Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Problem is, females are seldom if ever in a position to resist their communities. Strict laws, as you mention are a valid alternative, however a situation exists where rejecting the act of wearing it pulls the eject lever, to say nothing of the rug, out from under the only way of life someone has ever known. This isn't likely to be common.

This has the effect of gradually reconditioning communities to accept a hijab, rather than the reverse.
What's with the righteous wardrobe fetish? Next we should ban high-heeled shoes in free countries because most sex slave trade victims are forced to wear high-heeled shoes.

High-heeled shoes are offensive to some of us so let's punish women with fines whenever they choose or are forced to wear them. ... We'll only get rid of sex crime when women have to pay a penalty for wearing these offensive shoes.

... That's SP's silly argument.
 
Or quite literally, a suitcase nuke. Hey, now both have to be banned. Checkmate.

best lets ban suitcases too. your trolling is showing.

Literally, if you leave Islam you have a situation similar to an act of treason in The Godfather, except it isn't the horse that gets decapitated. Hijabs are far more common among moderates, a burqa is usually indictative of a particularly strict community.

can you say that generaly for Islam?
source?

Problem is, females are seldom if ever in a position to resist their communities. Strict laws, as you mention are a valid alternative, however a situation exists where rejecting the act of wearing it pulls the eject lever, to say nothing of the rug, out from under the only way of life someone has ever known. This isn't likely to be common.

Not according the Muslim woman that do fight for their rights.
How do you think woman in th western countrys were able to reach equal rights? (and still have not reached it completly)
The question whether a ban would result in domestic instability is uncertain, as the blame is shifted to an external entity (a government), not focused on the woman. This has the effect of gradually reconditioning communities to accept a hijab, rather than the reverse. The case with the French is they just don't want to look at it and consider it demoralizing. I can't agree more.

the question is very easy, how would you punish people that still wear a Burka?
who would you punish and how would you punish them?

I think a woman must be able to take the kids go to the police station and demand protection, she then gets brought to a refuge for battered women and Police is protecting her and her kids. And there will be a trial against the man who forces his wife to wear a burka. Just like we do it with western Woman that get beaten by her husband.
 
Nuclear Nuns & Other Puns

best lets ban suitcases too. your trolling is showing.
That was in jest, pay attention now.

..can you say that generaly for Islam?
Among moderates, no. Among strict communities which mandate the constant wearing of things like burqas, yes to varying degrees.

..western countrys were able to reach equal rights? (and still have not reached it completly)
The problem is ostracism, not rights. They already have that, you should know, if they live outside a theocracy. That means they can say and do what they wish already. That doesn't stop Sharia law from being a enormous emerging problem in the U.K, though. Do you see any women daring to protest this? No. Why would they, when they have little idea how to act in a manner independent from their cultural group.

...the question is very easy, how would you punish people that still wear a Burka?
Obviously, what would occur is public indecency or fines in that situation, and to add to your alternative, very very strict laws on domestic violence as a result. That is, if the woman is beaten or psychologically mistreated, the husband is looking at a serious felony.

I think a woman must be able to take the kids go to the police station and demand protection, she then gets brought to a refuge for battered women and Police is protecting her and her kids. And there will be a trial against the man who forces his wife to wear a burka. Just like we do it with western Woman that get beaten by her husband.
It could work. A ban just works a lot better and is better principle. The bottom line is nobody should accept what it represents.
 
Sir Philip
what punishment do you envisage for a woman who is coerced by family into wearing a burqa?
what punishement do you envisage for a woman who chooses to wear a burqa?
 
We'll only get rid of sex crime when women have to pay a penalty for wearing these offensive shoes.
The only crime discussed here is the burqa, which signifies neither love nor sex but their absolute absence in a wearer's daily life. :duel
 
That was in jest, pay attention now.

Among moderates, no. Among strict communities which mandate the constant wearing of things like burqas, yes to varying degrees.

The problem is ostracism, not rights. They already have that, you should know, if they live outside a theocracy. That means they can say and do what they wish already. That doesn't stop Sharia law from being a enormous emerging problem in the U.K, though. Do you see any women daring to protest this? No. Why would they, when they have little idea how to act in a manner independent from their cultural group.

Obviously, what would occur is public indecency or fines in that situation, and to add to your alternative, very very strict laws on domestic violence as a result. That is, if the woman is beaten or psychologically mistreated, the husband is looking at a serious felony.

It could work. A ban just works a lot better and is better principle. The bottom line is nobody should accept what it represents.

why do you think, Muslim woman cannot reach what european woman reached in case of equal rights? they fought for it by themself.

i see no good in banning the burka. it doesnt change the problem, it just removes it from our sight, away from the street, home to the supressed woman.
If you want to help those woman, help them, and dont punish them.
 
Sir Philip
what punishment do you envisage for a woman who is coerced by family into wearing a burqa?
what punishment do you envisage for a woman who chooses to wear a burqa?
 
Sir Philip
what punishment do you envisage for a woman who is coerced by family into wearing a burqa?
what punishement do you envisage for a woman who chooses to wear a burqa?
The same obviously, as for public indecency. As Cheney mentioned, I agree that strict laws are also required to protect anybody who seeks refuge in authorities if mistreated. You can't, um, figure that one out?
 
and what exactly is your problem with Sharialaws in the UK. i find it a strange system you have, but to me it makes somehow sence that you can agree on rules that arent in place for others.
the problem i have with sharia law is its punishment, wich in my eyes violate human rights extremly. but that isnt the case in the UK.
 
The same obviously, as for public indecency. As Cheney mentioned, I agree that strict laws are also required to protect anybody who seeks refuge in authorities if mistreated. You can't, um, figure that one out?

What I can't figure out is what punishments you envisage.
You can't, um, just give a direct answer.
Are you a politician?
Do you wish to punish women who are forced to wear a burqa? If so, how?
If I choose to wear a burqa for whatever reason, do you wish to punish me? If so, how?
 
why do you think, Muslim woman cannot reach what european woman reached in case of equal rights? they fought for it by themself.
Because you literally have a situation where they are brought up, in all respects, inside a apocalyptic cult. If they publicly resist, they will have to live under assumed identities, irregardless of community. Self interest.

i see no good in banning the burka. it doesnt change the problem, it just removes it from our sight, away from the street, home to the supressed woman. If you want to help those woman, help them, and dont punish them.
Unfortunately, like everything in regards to Islam, forcefulness or outright force is required - that means collateral damage. It has defined the rift between Conservatives and Liberals. So we probably have a fundamental disagreement on approach here.
 
What I can't figure out is what punishments you envisage.
You can't, um, just give a direct answer.
Are you a politician?
Do you wish to punish women who are forced to wear a burqa? If so, how?
If I choose to wear a burqa for whatever reason, do you wish to punish me? If so, how?
 
and what exactly is your problem with Sharialaws in the UK. i find it a strange system you have, but to me it makes somehow sence that you can agree on rules that arent in place for others.
the problem i have with sharia law is its punishment, wich in my eyes violate human rights extremly. but that isnt the case in the UK.
The problem with Sharia law is the same as with a malignant infection - the characteristic of growth. Sharia is divine law, man made law is therefore inferior, and efforts will be made to overthrow "man made" laws in the host country. There is no actual diplomacy possible as Islam is completely at odds in the first place with everything unislamic.
 
Because you literally have a situation where they are brought up, in all respects, inside a apocalyptic cult. If they publicly resist, they will have to live under assumed identities, irregardless of community. Self interest.

Unfortunately, like everything in regards to Islam, forcefulness or outright force is required - that means collateral damage. It has defined the rift between Conservatives and Liberals. So we probably have a fundamental disagreement on approach here.

slowely i get the impression you are a so called Islamophobe.

why would everything in regard to Islam have to be forcefull or outright force?


And do you think our grandmothers wastn teached since child on that theyr place it at home to cook and take care for the kids, and that they cannot tal about politics as they have no clue about it anyway? And imagen our grandmothers havning kids without beeing married, or divorced and she goes to work and feed the kids all by herself? that didnt earn them respect in the community, in contrary, those woman had a hard hard time finding acceptance, some still have to fight for it up to today.
They did it, and so can Muslim woman. they dont need your punishment for it.
they could need your help in protecting them. but that seems not to be a priority.
 
The problem with Sharia law is the same as with a malignant infection - the characteristic of growth. Sharia is divine law, man made law is therefore inferior, and efforts will be made to overthrow "man made" laws in the host country. There is no actual diplomacy possible as Islam is completely at odds in the first place with everything unislamic.

what a load of nonsence.
 
Not only is it not nonsense, it already is increasingly the defining global issue in the 21'st century outside energy.

and outside Global Warming
and outside Financial Crisis
and so on.

nonsense, total nonsense.

what do you mean you cannot have diplomacy with Islam?
who is representing Islam? who is an Islamic diplomat?

do you also fear they make to much babys and will outnumber you in the UK in a few centurys?
 
..why would everything in regard to Islam have to be forcefull or outright force?
Because, adherence is ultimately recognized as not volitional, Islam is identical to a secular dictatorship or personality cult, except it exists inside host nations. It surprises me after what happened during the 20'th century, the correlation isn't widely recognized.



..they could need your help in protecting them. but that seems not to be a priority.
A rare few certainly will, publicly, at the cost of their safety.
 
..what do you mean you cannot have diplomacy with Islam?
Muslims consider anything outside Islam wrong, as their ritualistic lifestyle is prescribed by God and not man made. Everything that is must eventually be brought under Islam. In other words, they all think you should act likewise for your own good to avoid being tortured for eternity by a dictator that created the universe, similar to what neoconservatives believe. That is in fact what a Muslim is. That is why they dress, act, and behave that way: out of fear (submission).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom