Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Let me think about that. No, and you don't make any sense as it is already a punishment, and those that actually choose to are, on plausible assumption virtually nonexistent.

plausible assumption there are quite a few that do it becuase they belive their god wants em to. i guess its about 15% of the woman wearing a burka actually do it out of free will religious dogma.

so another madeup statistic. very helpfull, isnt it?
 
You seemed to be saying that the burqa should be banned because no sane person would choose to wear it. The nun's habit fits that perfectly.
Out of the Christian population the number who prefer to dress as nuns is what, less than 1%? Only those raised as them, and rarely, those that join monastic orders. A nun however, isn't forced from birth to dress that way out of acute fear of personal destruction. Muslim women are tasked with conducting daily life behind one.
 
SirPhilip, who would you punish for wearing a Burka when it is forbidden, the Woman wearing it, or her Husband? Her parents, the whole family?What about her Imam= also punishment?


btw the picture you posted of woman with Burka and those almost naked, where was that taken? seems like Burka is not obligatory and still a woman wears it.
 
Let me think about that. No, and you don't make any sense as it is already a punishment, and those that actually choose to are, on plausible assumption virtually nonexistent.

I make perfect sense.
I ask if you want to punish
a) women who are forced to wear a burqa. Why avoid the question by stating it is already a punishment? That is just plain silly.
b) women who choose to wear a burqa. To say they are virtually non-existent is again just plain silly. You assert they are virtually non-existent with absolutely nothing to back it up. And even if they are totally non-existent you can still answer the question.
 
Out of the Christian population the number who prefer to dress as nuns is what, less than 1%? Only those raised as them, and rarely, those that join monastic orders. A nun however, isn't forced from birth to dress that way out of acute fear of personal destruction. Muslim women are tasked with conducting daily life behind one.

LOL those raised as Nuns?

They do it because they belive Jesus or God wants them to. why can force God nuns to wear such stuff? But Allah is not allowed to force its folowers to wear a Burka?

we dont need no ban on Burkas, we need a system, where a woman that is forced to wear that crap Burka, can report the case, she gets protected and her husband gets punished.

your bukra ban is crap. its lazyness. just bann it and let those fwoman fight it out with their husband.
 
those woman that wear this, are not even allowed to marry. they dont have a husband. No one forces them to wera that crap and hide their hear. oh wait a minute, yes there is, Jesus or God, their Faith demands it from them. they choose to go that way. out of free will. or not so much as it is religous dogma.
And what percentage of the volume of Christians would you guess plausibly they number?

i cant understand how you could do that, but still, hundrets of woman every ear choose exactly that. we should not alowe them to. no sane person would wear that crap.
The nun is actually a good example as it illustrates who would actually dress like that under non mandated circumstances. The last time I ever saw a nun face to face must have been in the 1980's.
 
I make perfect sense.
I ask if you want to punish
a) women who are forced to wear a burqa. Why avoid the question by stating it is already a punishment? That is just plain silly.
b) women who choose to wear a burqa. To say they are virtually non-existent is again just plain silly. You assert they are virtually non-existent with absolutely nothing to back it up. And even if they are totally non-existent you can still answer the question.

You missed answering this SirPhilip
 
we dont need no ban on Burkas, we need a system, where a woman that is forced to wear that crap Burka, can report the case, she gets protected and her husband gets punished.

Wouldn't disagree.

your bukra ban is crap. its lazyness. just bann it and let those fwoman fight it out with their husband.
In all fairness, a battle rifle could be concealed under that thing.
 
And what percentage of the volume of Christians would you guess plausibly they number?

The nun is actually a good example as it illustrates who would actually dress like that under non mandated circumstances. The last time I ever saw a nun face to face must have been in the 1980's.

you only need to go to a Hospital, they are there to help. or in schools, some give music lessons, there are quite a few around here.

and even if its only a tiny percentage, and it is, they are complaining not having enough new nuns.

even with that tiny percentage, they are still alowed to wear it. noone is baning their stuff around here.
why are those few woman that want to wear the nun dress allowed to while the few woman that want to wear the burka are not allowed to?
 
I like where this is heading. A burqa you must admit however, could conceal Level III tactical headgear with a retractable face shield.

a borg could perfectly hide his borginess under a nun's dress and assimilate us all.

but interesting that you suddenly jump to the , they could hide weappons "argument".

I am against the Burka, afaik the Koran doesnt want them to hide their face and hands. I think it is sick, i think most are indeed "forced" to wear it in one or the other way.

But banning the burka is not the way to go. those woman that are forced to wear a burka have almost no freedom and mostly cannot leave the house without their husband or someone watching them. and a Burka ban will make their situation even worse.

and why cant you answer the Punishment question ?
what would you plan there?
 
Fine, I admit it. I want to punish them both for existing at all.
Do you answer like this because you realise your stance is insupportable?
why do you find it so difficult to say whether or not you want to punish women for wearing a burqa?
It is the whole essence of the thread.
 
Yes. Mainly, that only somebody with the IQ of a turnip would require them to understand why nobody actually chooses to wear as unnatural as a burqa for the rest of their life except out of social conditioning or fear.

Now I get it: SP fails to understand the basic difference between an opinion and a fact. Or DC is right and it's just flagrant lying.

SP can spout this emotionally-laden grizzle all s/he wants and I definitely agree: s/he should take this woo and enter the Challenge.
 
Blasting The Burqa

a borg could perfectly hide his borginess under a nun's dress and assimilate us all.
Or quite literally, a suitcase nuke. Hey, now both have to be banned. Checkmate.

but interesting that you suddenly jump to the , they could hide weappons "argument".
Literally, if you leave Islam you have a situation similar to an act of treason in The Godfather, except it isn't the horse that gets decapitated. Hijabs are far more common among moderates, a burqa is usually indictative of a particularly strict community.

But banning the burka is not the way to go. those woman that are forced to wear a burka have almost no freedom and mostly cannot leave the house without their husband or someone watching them. and a Burka ban will make their situation even worse.
Problem is, females are seldom if ever in a position to resist their communities. Strict laws, as you mention are a valid alternative, however a situation exists where rejecting the act of wearing it pulls the eject lever, to say nothing of the rug, out from under the only way of life someone has ever known. This isn't likely to be common.

..and why cant you answer the Punishment question?
The question whether a ban would result in domestic instability is uncertain, as the blame is shifted to an external entity (a government), not focused on the woman. This has the effect of gradually reconditioning communities to accept a hijab, rather than the reverse. The case with the French is they just don't want to look at it and consider it demoralizing. I can't agree more.
 
Do you answer like this because you realise your stance is insupportable?
why do you find it so difficult to say whether or not you want to punish women for wearing a burqa?
It is the whole essence of the thread.

Come on SP. try to be honest and answer the two simple questions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom