Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

...For example, I gave earlier the fact that mothers love their children, that is certainly certain on the basis of human reason, but it is not necessary to arrive at its certainty by reasoning over it, i.e., by ratiocination or arguing at least within yourself...
Fact? My wife works for Child Protective Services. Your generalization only works if "love" includes murder by strangulation and other acts that I could enumerate.
 
No dilly-dallying here, please, my words are simple and plain enough.

No dilly-dallying here, please, my words are simple and plain enough.

Simple and plain does not describe your posts, Gerry.
 
yrreg said:
For example, I gave earlier the fact that mothers love their children, that is certainly certain on the basis of human reason, but it is not necessary to arrive at its certainty by reasoning over it, i.e., by ratiocination or arguing at least within yourself.

Your 'fact' is not a fact, as was earlier pointed out.
It is not certainly certain, and even if it were it would not be on the basis of reason. It is not only not necessary to arrive at its (lack of ) certainty by reasoning, it is not possible
Some mothers demonstrably do not love their children.
 
... can you give some examples of reasonable certainty which everyone accepts to be certainty accepted by mankind?

Rain falls from the sky. Water is wet. People eat things.


Now, stop rambling and tell us one or two attributes of the god you believe in.
 
Yes, reasonable certainty can be attained by mankind.

Can you please get to the point, yrreg?
 
Well, godless dave, you have had your say on what you mean by reasonable certainty.

And I have had my say about what is human certainty.


Now I ask you, Is reasonable certainty a certainty attainable by man or not?

Yes, I believe I already said that.

If it is attainable by man, can you give some examples of reasonable certainty which everyone accepts to be certainty accepted by mankind?

The example I already gave is that the sun will rise tomorrow. We are reasonably certain about the schedule of the ocean's tides, and about what causes them. We are reasonably certain that if you drive southwest from New York City, eventually you will get to Los Angeles.
 
I thought we agreed that we could reasonably agree with a reasonable certainty but not certainly agree with a certainty.

There is one certainty about Gerry; He is going to argue with Atheists about the existence of god and try to control the arguments, but will take a LONG way around toward getting to the point.

Meanwhile, he will write very meandering paragraphs of useless drivel while attempting to impress with his "intellect."

That is a certainty about how Gerry operates.
 
Last edited:
There is one certainty about Gerry; He is going to argue with Atheists about the existence of god and try to control the arguments, but will take a LONG way around toward getting to the point.

Meanwhile, he will write very meandering paragraphs of useless drivel while attempting to impress with his "intellect."

That is a certainty about Gerry that I agree with.


Gerry seems to be obsessed with the Socratic method, but he needs to realise the Socratic method is only useful if the conclusion logically follows from the questions being asked. You can't use the Socratic method to force an admission of belief in fairy tales.
 
Reasonable certainty is not certainty arrived at by reasoning. It is the degree of certainty we can arrive at.

Reasonable certainty is the level of certainty at which point it is logical to provisionally accept something as being true. As godless dave put it, we can be very, very certain that the sun will rise tomorrow, but we cannot be absolutely (i.e. 100%) certain.

If you've done any work in the metrology field (and I pray for your sake that you haven't) and have had to generate uncertainty budgets for your measurements, then it is generally accepted that the level of "reasonable certainty" for scientific endeavours is 95%.

It might be different in other fields, but I'm not in other fields. I'm not even in that field anymore. There is no grass where I am, although the coffee is much better.
 
...bringing in their pet peeves against God as though by thus doing God will go away.

Originally Posted by yrreg
... can you give some examples of reasonable certainty which everyone accepts to be certainty accepted by mankind?

​


Rain falls from the sky. Water is wet. People eat things.


Now, stop rambling and tell us one or two attributes of the god you believe in.


Number 1: Those examples are not examples of reasonable certainty in the contemplation of godless dave, but what I would call automatic certainty.


Number 2: Please read the title and topic of the thread, here I will reproduce it for you:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​


That is what I have seen time and again in exchange of thoughts with atheists here, they don't seem to know what the topic is all about, but instead they keep bringing in their pet peeves against God as though by thus doing God will go away.




Yrreg
 
Number 1: Those examples are not examples of reasonable certainty in the contemplation of godless dave, but what I would call automatic certainty.
No. You continue to have no idea what you are talking about.

Number 2: Please read the title and topic of the thread, here I will reproduce it for you:
Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.
​
That is what I have seen time and again in exchange of thoughts with atheists here, they don't seem to know what the topic is all about, but instead they keep bringing in their pet peeves against God as though by thus doing God will go away.
Unless you provide some defined characteristics or atributes of your god, it is impossible to prove anything. Your inability to do so will not magic your god in existance.

Kindly provide some of go away. Please do so in less than ten words.
 
Number 1: Those examples are not examples of reasonable certainty in the contemplation of godless dave, but what I would call automatic certainty.


Number 2: Please read the title and topic of the thread, here I will reproduce it for you:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​


That is what I have seen time and again in exchange of thoughts with atheists here, they don't seem to know what the topic is all about, but instead they keep bringing in their pet peeves against God as though by thus doing God will go away.




Yrreg

1. Theists believe in god(s)
2. Children believe in Santa Claus

Both could be said to be reasonably certain.
 
Can you, godless dave, be reasonably certain about God's existence?

Originally Posted by yrreg

Well, godless dave, you have had your say on what you mean by reasonable certainty.

And I have had my say about what is human certainty.


Now I ask you, Is reasonable certainty a certainty attainable by man or not?

​


Yes, I believe I already said that.


[...]



Can you, godless dave, be reasonably certain about God's existence?



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom