No dilly-dallying here, please, my words are simple and plain enough.
I have not seen EventHorizon coming back to this thread; that is the sorrow I always encounter in this JREF forum, that when I have come to someone willing to discuss seriously, constructively, and thus productively, he will disappear, and I get the impression that he is afraid to continue the discussion with me, afraid to have a really serious, constructive, and thus productive discussion.
I could be mistaken, maybe he has come already but I did not see him here, or he just has not come back -- yet.
In which case my apologies, but I have not read up to except to the post below from godless dave.
So, addressing EventHorizon, I hope to meet you again here and with your sincere desire to truly have a serious, constructive, and thus productive discussion or exchange of thoughts with me.
For the guidance of folks who come late, here is the post from EventHorizon and my reply to him:
Now addressing those of you who have replied in regard to my three assumptions, thank you so much, and I am sure that readers are thinking over your replies.
My wording of the three assumptions is simple enough, there is really no need to nitpick over the meanings of words there.
I will now attend to godless dave.
You are the one who suggest that what I call human certainty should instead be called reasonable certainty.
Are you now having second thoughts about calling reasonable certainty what I call human certainty.
See: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4966996#post4966996
Anyway, I like to ask you, godless dave, is absolute certainty possible with man?
And please for the sake of being serious and sincere in this exchange between you and me, please don't now react with the question whether by man I exclude women, etc., etc. etc. etc.
Why do atheists to my recurring and regrettable impression always want to make things so unnecessarily wasteful of time and resources by bringing in things and questions which are just dilly-dallying the issue, muddling up the issue?
Okay, godless dave, please just tell me if you agree with me that absolute certainty is not possible with humans.
In the meantime, yes, I must reply to your present question:
As I said in the present post earlier that you are the one who told me that reasonable certainty could be a better term instead of human certainty.
Now you are abandoning your previous position.
You now tell me that reason needs data to work on.
That is all perfectly acceptable to me.
There, we have an agreement that reason needs data to work on.
As we proceed further we will come to the need to classify data, but until then please don't now clutter the discussion with all kinds of obstructing issues about data, okay?
Did you get my previous reply to you about my preference for my term human certainty in place of your suggestion of reasonable certainty? See here.
I will just add now that the term reasonable certainty will provoke some naughty minds who have nothing else to employ their faculty of reasoning but to abuse it in order to infect everything that people consider to be certain with doubts, and that by all kinds of what I call the abuse of reason.
But in their abuse of reason they wilfully do not want to see that they themselves by their abuse of reason render reason inutile -- so it's like slaying the goose that lays the golden eggs.
Now, I would still suggest that human certainty is a good and useful term in place of reasonable certainty, and it is within the big umbrella of human certainty where we can distinguish different kinds and degrees of human certainty, like physical certainty, artistic certainty, statistical certainty, psychological certainty, etc.
Yrreg
Posted by Yrreg
The first assumption is that we exist as humans.
The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.
The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.
The first assumption is that we exist as humans.
The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.
The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.
I have not seen EventHorizon coming back to this thread; that is the sorrow I always encounter in this JREF forum, that when I have come to someone willing to discuss seriously, constructively, and thus productively, he will disappear, and I get the impression that he is afraid to continue the discussion with me, afraid to have a really serious, constructive, and thus productive discussion.
I could be mistaken, maybe he has come already but I did not see him here, or he just has not come back -- yet.
In which case my apologies, but I have not read up to except to the post below from godless dave.
So, addressing EventHorizon, I hope to meet you again here and with your sincere desire to truly have a serious, constructive, and thus productive discussion or exchange of thoughts with me.
For the guidance of folks who come late, here is the post from EventHorizon and my reply to him:
[My earlier post]
OK, I'll bite. I cannot accept assumption three until you define 'human certainty' and explain how it is different from just plain old certainty.
[My post in reply]
See: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4966919&postcount=206
Now addressing those of you who have replied in regard to my three assumptions, thank you so much, and I am sure that readers are thinking over your replies.
My wording of the three assumptions is simple enough, there is really no need to nitpick over the meanings of words there.
I will now attend to godless dave.
We cannot arrive at certainty using reason by itself. Reason needs data to work with.
You are the one who suggest that what I call human certainty should instead be called reasonable certainty.
Are you now having second thoughts about calling reasonable certainty what I call human certainty.
See: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4966996#post4966996
Anyway, I like to ask you, godless dave, is absolute certainty possible with man?
And please for the sake of being serious and sincere in this exchange between you and me, please don't now react with the question whether by man I exclude women, etc., etc. etc. etc.
Why do atheists to my recurring and regrettable impression always want to make things so unnecessarily wasteful of time and resources by bringing in things and questions which are just dilly-dallying the issue, muddling up the issue?
Okay, godless dave, please just tell me if you agree with me that absolute certainty is not possible with humans.
In the meantime, yes, I must reply to your present question:
We cannot arrive at certainty using reason by itself. Reason needs data to work with.
As I said in the present post earlier that you are the one who told me that reasonable certainty could be a better term instead of human certainty.
Now you are abandoning your previous position.
You now tell me that reason needs data to work on.
That is all perfectly acceptable to me.
There, we have an agreement that reason needs data to work on.
As we proceed further we will come to the need to classify data, but until then please don't now clutter the discussion with all kinds of obstructing issues about data, okay?
Did you get my previous reply to you about my preference for my term human certainty in place of your suggestion of reasonable certainty? See here.
I will just add now that the term reasonable certainty will provoke some naughty minds who have nothing else to employ their faculty of reasoning but to abuse it in order to infect everything that people consider to be certain with doubts, and that by all kinds of what I call the abuse of reason.
But in their abuse of reason they wilfully do not want to see that they themselves by their abuse of reason render reason inutile -- so it's like slaying the goose that lays the golden eggs.
Now, I would still suggest that human certainty is a good and useful term in place of reasonable certainty, and it is within the big umbrella of human certainty where we can distinguish different kinds and degrees of human certainty, like physical certainty, artistic certainty, statistical certainty, psychological certainty, etc.
Yrreg