Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

No dilly-dallying here, please, my words are simple and plain enough.

Posted by Yrreg

The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

​


I have not seen EventHorizon coming back to this thread; that is the sorrow I always encounter in this JREF forum, that when I have come to someone willing to discuss seriously, constructively, and thus productively, he will disappear, and I get the impression that he is afraid to continue the discussion with me, afraid to have a really serious, constructive, and thus productive discussion.

I could be mistaken, maybe he has come already but I did not see him here, or he just has not come back -- yet.

In which case my apologies, but I have not read up to except to the post below from godless dave.

So, addressing EventHorizon, I hope to meet you again here and with your sincere desire to truly have a serious, constructive, and thus productive discussion or exchange of thoughts with me.

For the guidance of folks who come late, here is the post from EventHorizon and my reply to him:


[My earlier post]

OK, I'll bite. I cannot accept assumption three until you define 'human certainty' and explain how it is different from just plain old certainty.

[My post in reply]

See: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4966919&postcount=206


Now addressing those of you who have replied in regard to my three assumptions, thank you so much, and I am sure that readers are thinking over your replies.

My wording of the three assumptions is simple enough, there is really no need to nitpick over the meanings of words there.



I will now attend to godless dave.

We cannot arrive at certainty using reason by itself. Reason needs data to work with.


You are the one who suggest that what I call human certainty should instead be called reasonable certainty.

Are you now having second thoughts about calling reasonable certainty what I call human certainty.

See: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4966996#post4966996


Anyway, I like to ask you, godless dave, is absolute certainty possible with man?

And please for the sake of being serious and sincere in this exchange between you and me, please don't now react with the question whether by man I exclude women, etc., etc. etc. etc.

Why do atheists to my recurring and regrettable impression always want to make things so unnecessarily wasteful of time and resources by bringing in things and questions which are just dilly-dallying the issue, muddling up the issue?




Okay, godless dave, please just tell me if you agree with me that absolute certainty is not possible with humans.



In the meantime, yes, I must reply to your present question:

We cannot arrive at certainty using reason by itself. Reason needs data to work with.


As I said in the present post earlier that you are the one who told me that reasonable certainty could be a better term instead of human certainty.

Now you are abandoning your previous position.


You now tell me that reason needs data to work on.

That is all perfectly acceptable to me.


There, we have an agreement that reason needs data to work on.


As we proceed further we will come to the need to classify data, but until then please don't now clutter the discussion with all kinds of obstructing issues about data, okay?


Did you get my previous reply to you about my preference for my term human certainty in place of your suggestion of reasonable certainty? See here.


I will just add now that the term reasonable certainty will provoke some naughty minds who have nothing else to employ their faculty of reasoning but to abuse it in order to infect everything that people consider to be certain with doubts, and that by all kinds of what I call the abuse of reason.

But in their abuse of reason they wilfully do not want to see that they themselves by their abuse of reason render reason inutile -- so it's like slaying the goose that lays the golden eggs.


Now, I would still suggest that human certainty is a good and useful term in place of reasonable certainty, and it is within the big umbrella of human certainty where we can distinguish different kinds and degrees of human certainty, like physical certainty, artistic certainty, statistical certainty, psychological certainty, etc.





Yrreg
 
Now, I would still suggest that human certainty is a good and useful term in place of reasonable certainty, and it is within the big umbrella of human certainty where we can distinguish different kinds and degrees of human certainty, like physical certainty, artistic certainty, statistical certainty, psychological certainty, etc.

Yrreg

You forgot faith based religious certainty.

Theists are certain that god(s) exist.
 
Why do atheists to my recurring and regrettable impression always want to make things so unnecessarily wasteful of time and resources by bringing in things and questions which are just dilly-dallying the issue, muddling up the issue?
Yes, how frivolous of us to ask for evidence to back up your claims. I mean if someone says "I have a dragon in my garage" it would be evading the issue to ask him to open his garage door.

As we proceed further we will come to the need to classify data, but until then please don't now clutter the discussion with all kinds of obstructing issues about data, okay?
You've been telling us that you will get to the data for months now.
 
Having observed Yrreg's actions over a series of threads, I think the essential problem is that he is rooted in a theist behaviour pattern to such an extent that he is incapable of dialectic reasoning. All his threads are thus attempts to emulate this reasoning, which he considers a tool to convince us, but inevitably fail, because he can't grasp the way the system works.

Well, according to himself, he used to be an atheist.

Anyway, I am an academic atheist or nontheist or secularist or infidel myself.

http://www.freeratio.org//showthread.php?p=1961716#post1961716

Or at least, an 'ultra liberal Christian', 'practically an atheist'.

Yours truly was brought up a Catholic from the cradle to college. But I am now a postgraduate Catholic, meaning more in a cultural sense, actually an ultra liberal Christian, and practically an academic atheist or secularist or infidel or an ecumenist, that can live with all kinds of peoples with a religion or without a religion, provided they are not violent in their religious enthusiasm or ir-religious fervor or when engaged in anti-theist objections or recriminations.

http://www.freeratio.org//showthread.php?p=1961716#post1961716

What happened, Yrreg? When did you rediscover your faith?
 
And Shinto are certain that kami as numerous as objects in the univese are better than one god.

Hey, this game is kinda fun!

And Buddhists are certain about nothing.

Hey, I understand why Yrreg hates them now! :D

For Yrreg: This post was made in jest.
 
Once again, please understand, Atheists are NOT angry at god. They simply do not believe that god exists at all. Are you angry at Allah? Thor? Zeus? It is the same rationale.

Now you just prove that atheists have no brains, because it's quite obvious only a brainless idiot would believe in those other gods.

;)
 
I will now attend to godless dave.

You are the one who suggest that what I call human certainty should instead be called reasonable certainty.

Are you now having second thoughts about calling reasonable certainty what I call human certainty.

No.

Anyway, I like to ask you, godless dave, is absolute certainty possible with man?

No.


As I said in the present post earlier that you are the one who told me that reasonable certainty could be a better term instead of human certainty.

Now you are abandoning your previous position.

No, I'm not.

You now tell me that reason needs data to work on.

That is all perfectly acceptable to me.


There, we have an agreement that reason needs data to work on.

This in no way conflicts with my use of the term "reasonable certainty".
 
Reasonable certainty is a kind of human certainty, yes? no?

Addressing godless dave:

I will not argue with you endlessly over which is a better phrase to call the certainty that man has in terms of his acquaintance with reality and ultimately with the whole totality of existence, which includes the physical universe or the empirical universe if you will of some scientists, whether reasonable certainty from you or human certainty from me.


The way I see it, reasonable certainty is one kind of certainty within the big umbrella of human certainty.


You will ask if there is any certainty that is human which is not reasonable certainty.


I stand to be corrected by you, but right away I will say even before I reason out very carefully my words here, namely:


Yes, there are kinds of certainty that is not reasonable but are certain for mankind to live peaceably together and productively.​

I can see clearly that want to understand by reasonable certainty which I think you understand it so, namely, it is the certainty arrived at by reasoning, i.e., arguing at least within yourself by the use of your reason in its function of ratiocination.

But reason is not only for ratiocination, it is also for all kinds and manners of being certain about anything even without ratiocination.


For example, I gave earlier the fact that mothers love their children, that is certainly certain on the basis of human reason, but it is not necessary to arrive at its certainty by reasoning over it, i.e., by ratiocination or arguing at least within yourself.


Anyway if you want to insist that the only certainty you can admit is what you call reasonable certainty, and you mean the certainty arrived at by ratiocination, then I have to tell you that you don't need to reason out over so many things that you are immediately certain about, like for example when you are thirsty you are certain you are thirsty, when you have to go to the bathroom you are certain that you have to go, when you are sexually excited you know for certain that you are sexually excited.



The way I see it, you seem to be engaged in an attempt to prepare a venue or an approach in this discussion whereby you can and will keep on arguing forever: that there is no certainty on whatever you want to insist there is no certainty because you can use your reasoning capability to abuse reason interminably, as in keeping on and on and on about the absence of sufficient evidence for this or that piece of knowledge mankind has always lived by, for example, mothers love their children.

Is that your attitude? in wanting to set as the right kind of term for the certainty available to mankind to be what you want to call "reasonable certainty"?





Yrreg
 
Addressing godless dave:

I will not argue with you endlessly over which is a better phrase to call the certainty that man has in terms of his acquaintance with reality and ultimately with the whole totality of existence, which includes the physical universe or the empirical universe if you will of some scientists, whether reasonable certainty from you or human certainty from me.


The way I see it, reasonable certainty is one kind of certainty within the big umbrella of human certainty.


You will ask if there is any certainty that is human which is not reasonable certainty.


I stand to be corrected by you, but right away I will say even before I reason out very carefully my words here, namely:

Yes, there are kinds of certainty that is not reasonable but are certain for mankind to live peaceably together and productively.
​
I can see clearly that want to understand by reasonable certainty which I think you understand it so, namely, it is the certainty arrived at by reasoning, i.e., arguing at least within yourself by the use of your reason in its function of ratiocination.

But reason is not only for ratiocination, it is also for all kinds and manners of being certain about anything even without ratiocination.


For example, I gave earlier the fact that mothers love their children, that is certainly certain on the basis of human reason, but it is not necessary to arrive at its certainty by reasoning over it, i.e., by ratiocination or arguing at least within yourself.


Anyway if you want to insist that the only certainty you can admit is what you call reasonable certainty, and you mean the certainty arrived at by ratiocination, then I have to tell you that you don't need to reason out over so many things that you are immediately certain about, like for example when you are thirsty you are certain you are thirsty, when you have to go to the bathroom you are certain that you have to go, when you are sexually excited you know for certain that you are sexually excited.



The way I see it, you seem to be engaged in an attempt to prepare a venue or an approach in this discussion whereby you can and will keep on arguing forever: that there is no certainty on whatever you want to insist there is no certainty because you can use your reasoning capability to abuse reason interminably, as in keeping on and on and on about the absence of sufficient evidence for this or that piece of knowledge mankind has always lived by, for example, mothers love their children.

Is that your attitude? in wanting to set as the right kind of term for the certainty available to mankind to be what you want to call "reasonable certainty"?



Yrreg
The way I see it, your post is certainly rambling. Of this, I am certainly certain.
 
Addressing godless dave:

I will not argue with you endlessly over which is a better phrase to call the certainty that man has in terms of his acquaintance with reality and ultimately with the whole totality of existence, which includes the physical universe or the empirical universe if you will of some scientists, whether reasonable certainty from you or human certainty from me.


The way I see it, reasonable certainty is one kind of certainty within the big umbrella of human certainty.

By reasonable certainty, I meant certain as much as you can be with the limitations of our senses and what evidence we can gather. I can be reasonably certain that the sun will rise tomorrow. Absolutely certain? No. But reasonably certain.


You will ask if there is any certainty that is human which is not reasonable certainty.


I stand to be corrected by you, but right away I will say even before I reason out very carefully my words here, namely:


Yes, there are kinds of certainty that is not reasonable but are certain for mankind to live peaceably together and productively.​

That's not certainty at all. Certainty is about what the facts are, not about the implications of those facts.


For example, I gave earlier the fact that mothers love their children, that is certainly certain on the basis of human reason, but it is not necessary to arrive at its certainty by reasoning over it, i.e., by ratiocination or arguing at least within yourself.

This is an example of the dangers of arriving at certainty without examining all the data. All you have to do is pick up a newspaper or visit a shelter for abused children to discover that there are lots of mothers who do not love their children.

After having examined the available data, I think I can be reasonably certain that a majority of mothers love their children, but a sizeable minority do not.

Anyway if you want to insist that the only certainty you can admit is what you call reasonable certainty, and you mean the certainty arrived at by ratiocination, then I have to tell you that you don't need to reason out over so many things that you are immediately certain about, like for example when you are thirsty you are certain you are thirsty, when you have to go to the bathroom you are certain that you have to go, when you are sexually excited you know for certain that you are sexually excited.

You're misunderstanding what I meant by "reasonable". I did not mean "arrived at by reason". That's not what reasonable means in American English. I'm sorry if my usage was confusing.


The way I see it, you seem to be engaged in an attempt to prepare a venue or an approach in this discussion whereby you can and will keep on arguing forever: that there is no certainty on whatever you want to insist there is no certainty because you can use your reasoning capability to abuse reason interminably, as in keeping on and on and on about the absence of sufficient evidence for this or that piece of knowledge mankind has always lived by, for example, mothers love their children.

Is that your attitude? in wanting to set as the right kind of term for the certainty available to mankind to be what you want to call "reasonable certainty"?

No, that is not my attitude. I merely wanted to illustrate that humans are very capable of feeling certain about things that are not true at all. As another poster pointed out, many humans used to be certain that the sun revolved around the earth. They felt certain, but they were wrong.
 
Looks like Yrreg is attempting one of his many Equivocation Fallacy tactics.
"Reasonable Certainty is the same for evidence based science and faith-based magic religious thinking. It's all the same therefore God exist!!! Hallejujah praise Jesus."

Of course everyone can see this tactic and no one is willing to agree with his wishy-washy definition. Expected next are insults and calling atheist close-minded or stupid.
 
Looks like Yrreg is attempting one of his many Equivocation Fallacy tactics.
"Reasonable Certainty is the same for evidence based science and faith-based magic religious thinking. It's all the same therefore God exist!!! Hallejujah praise Jesus."
I am not sure what he is attempting, but I wish he would hurry up and come to the point. He is whining about atheists being wasteful of time, but it is like watching grass grow waiting for him to actually say something.
 
I am not sure what he is attempting, but I wish he would hurry up and come to the point. He is whining about atheists being wasteful of time, but it is like watching grass grow waiting for him to actually say something.

I think that's part of his tactics, wear you down until you say, "Agree with him so he will just get to the point, fer cryin out loud." Then it's "HA HA GOTCHA!"

Where it falls down is the getting to the point part.
 
I think that's part of his tactics, wear you down until you say, "Agree with him so he will just get to the point, fer cryin out loud." Then it's "HA HA GOTCHA!"

Where it falls down is the getting to the point part.
It sure does. It seems to me that if I thought I could prove something I could simply just present my argument.

I accepted his premisses without demur over a day ago. Since then he has given us two very long posts saying we shouldn't dilly dally.

So stop dilly dallying already Yrreg.
 
You know, I can see better and better in the course of writing in web forums why people are afraid of the truths in everything, of course understanding by truths, the truths men live by and live together peaceably and productively, even though mankind can never achieve absolute truths.

Why can mankind never achieve absolute certainty and absolute truth? Because man is a limited being, only God is unlimited in contrast to man being limited.
I have to respond to this (particularly the next quoted section), even though I'm certain (there's that word) that someone will provide a much more thorough answer before I do.

It is a fundamental aspect of the human psyche to be afraid of that which we do not understand; critical thought and scientific thinking help to reduce the number of things we don't understand. The claim you're making here seems to be that everyone who does not believe in God must therefore be afraid of the knowledge of him. Speaking only for myself, I can say that is so far from the reality of the situation that it is laughable. I am not afraid of knowledge of God--I just haven't seen or heard anything that convinces me of his existence. One man is unlikely to achieve absolute certainty, but the common experiences of many who investigate what happens, question why things happen, and reproduce those events bring us all closer to complete understanding. A man is limited, but, if we pool our resources, there is no limit to what mankind can achieve.

That is why I always believe and get more an more certain, humanly certain that is, that the only for the present productive in terms of human knowledge of human behavior in the study of atheists, mind you I say atheists not atheism, is the psychology of atheists as atheists, in particular their anger at God.

There you are, accusing us all of being angry at God. I am not angry at God--it is very difficult to be angry at something you do not believe exists. I do, occasionally, get angry at some of the things that some people do in the name of God, but that is not what you believe. You see only two options--either you worship God or you are angry at him. What's funny to me is that most of the time when I hear someone talk about how angry they are at God, it's someone who actually believes in his existence. Most who don't believe, in my experience, have varying degrees of ambivalence towards the concept of God--some closer to anger, some closer to amusement, some closer to awe, and any of those subject to change depending upon circumstances and evidence. And that's what it all boils down to--evidence. There is no compelling evidence of the existence of any supernatural entity. While conclusive evidence of ghosts or Santa Claus would not, for obvious reasons, prove the existence of God, they would at least open the door to the existence of other things. But no evidence exists for any of them--and it's a much smaller leap to posit the existence of something like a ghost to something that has unlimited power and knowledge who created existence itself.
 
Last edited:
I can see clearly that want to understand by reasonable certainty which I think you understand it so, namely, it is the certainty arrived at by reasoning, i.e., arguing at least within yourself by the use of your reason in its function of ratiocination.


Reasonable certainty is not certainty arrived at by reasoning. It is the degree of certainty we can arrive at.

Reasonable certainty is the level of certainty at which point it is logical to provisionally accept something as being true. As godless dave put it, we can be very, very certain that the sun will rise tomorrow, but we cannot be absolutely (i.e. 100%) certain.
 
You see only two options--either you worship God or you are angry at him. What's funny to me is that most of the time when I hear someone talk about how angry they are at God, it's someone who actually believes in his existence.
C.S. Lewis was the most famous person to make this claim, that when he was an atheist he was angry at God for not existing. To me that puts quite a lot of doubt on whether he was really an atheist, or whether he had given it much thought.
Most who don't believe, in my experience, have varying degrees of ambivalence towards the concept of God--some closer to anger, some closer to amusement, some closer to awe, and any of those subject to change depending upon circumstances and evidence.
And of course it depends upon which particular concept is being mentioned.

The idea of a God who would sentence people to eternal torture for failing to worship him is of course laughable.

On the other hand if there really was a being who was the embodiment of perfect love I would totally be on his/her/it's corner

I have of course pointed this out in Yrreg's threads before when he has made this "angry at God" claim, however he has a habit of not seeing stuff that does not suit his own prejudices.
And that's what it all boils down to--evidence. There is no compelling evidence of the existence of any supernatural entity.
That is it in a nutshell.
 
I have not seen EventHorizon coming back to this thread; that is the sorrow I always encounter in this JREF forum, that when I have come to someone willing to discuss seriously, constructively, and thus productively, he will disappear, and I get the impression that he is afraid to continue the discussion with me, afraid to have a really serious, constructive, and thus productive discussion.

I'm here, I've just been busy. I can accept them as long as you understand that being certain does not mean that you are right.
 
Is reasonable certainty a certainty attainable by man or not?

Well, godless dave, you have had your say on what you mean by reasonable certainty.

And I have had my say about what is human certainty.


Now I ask you, Is reasonable certainty a certainty attainable by man or not?

If it is attainable by man, can you give some examples of reasonable certainty which everyone accepts to be certainty accepted by mankind?





Oslove
 
I have not seen EventHorizon coming back to this thread; that is the sorrow I always encounter in this JREF forum, that when I have come to someone willing to discuss seriously, constructively, and thus productively, he will disappear.

And I repeat, if you ask yourself why this might be so, you could come to an important understanding.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom