Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

Number 1: Those examples are not examples of reasonable certainty in the contemplation of godless dave, but what I would call automatic certainty.

Well you would be wrong then, wouldn't you?


Number 2: Please read the title and topic of the thread, here I will reproduce it for you:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​

Yes, We are aware if the nature of your enterprise.


That is what I have seen time and again in exchange of thoughts with atheists here, they don't seem to know what the topic is all about, but instead they keep bringing in their pet peeves against God as though by thus doing God will go away.

Please point to a "peeve against god" which has been introduced in this thread.

Do you understand that you cannot assume the outcome and use it as a premise to demonstrate that outcome?

What you have to do, Yrreg, is define relevant terms and assumptions: and agree them. So you started well, but then you began to fail when you were not prepared to modify your definitions in order to reach agreement, And you fail further by introducing new and undefined terms (automatic certainty) as it suits you.

Once you have agreed on definitions you then have to show, using those definitions and the logical implications of them, that a particular conclusion is arrived at. See I am not even asking for evidence: just a straight logical argument would be welcome.

At this stage in your argument god is neither a defined term, nor does it follow logically from the implications of the terms you have defined and their interaction with each other. God is in fact entirely irrelevant to anything you have done so far. It may be that you can make it relevant but so far you have not even attempted to do so.

You are wasting our time (again)

Can you please get on with it
 
Last edited:
Unlike you, can other people be reasonably certain God does exist?

Originally Posted by yrreg
Can you, godless dave, be reasonably certain about God's existence?

​


Well, I, SumDood, can be reasonably certain about God's existence. I'm reasonably certain he does not exist.



Well, I can only give it to you to be reasonably certain about God not existing for your own part.

Now, tell me, are you also reasonably certain that other people cannot be reasonably certain that God does not exist, or can be reasonably certain that God does exist for their own part, as you are reasonably certain for your own part that God does not exist?


In brief, unlike you, can other people be reasonably certain God does exist?




Yrreg


------------

Wrong [ original title of post ] Unlike you, can other people be reaonably certain God does not exist,?

Corrected title of post: Unlike you, can other people be reasonably certain God does exist?​
 
Last edited:
Yes. I can be reasonably certain that God doesn't exist - in fact I can be reasonably certain that no gods exist at all. You can be reasonably certain that God does exist.

All we have established is that reasonable certainty is more akin to belief, rather than knowledge.
 
Those examples are not examples of reasonable certainty in the contemplation of godless dave, but what I would call automatic certainty.
That is because you don't understand the scientific method. There is no absolute certainty in science. Every conclusion is accepted provisionally, pending further evidence, even if the chances of further evidence overturning a conclusion seem exceedingly remote the possibility is never dismissed.
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?


Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist.




Yrreg
 
Well, I can only give it to you to be reasonably certain about God not existing for your own part.

Agreed. If I implied other wise, I apologize. But is it not impossible to be certain about other’s certainties?

Now, tell me, are you also reasonably certain that other people cannot be reasonably certain that God does not exist,…

Not really. I may be over analyzing this, but I believe that some people ARE not reasonably certain that god does not exist, not that it is impossible for others to be reasonably certain god does not exist. You, yrreg, are NOT reasonably certain that God does NOT exist. Another example would be an Atheist who begins to question his/her beliefs and is no longer reasonably certain that god does not exist. And I am reasonably certain that there are others that share my point of view and are also reasonably certain that god does not exist.

…or can be reasonably certain that God does exist for their own part, as you are reasonably certain for your own part that God does not exist?

Sure.

In brief, unlike you, can other people be reasonably certain God does exist?

Absolutely.

Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?
Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?
No, I do not deny others' points of view, no matter how they might differ from my own.

Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist. Yrreg
See previous answer.
 
Gerry, do you remember that post in which you described your frustration in trying to reason with your kitchen help? Now you know how we feel.
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?
No. They can be reasonably certain that god exists...and they can still be completely wrong. Which makes all your following question irrelevant.

Still waiting for a point. Any point at all would be nice.
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?
I don't think anyone is denying (reasonably or otherwise) that some people are reasonably certain that God exists. The posts above yours were people saying yes, that they accept that some people are reasonably certain that god exists.

Which makes this:
Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist.
an extremely puzzling question, since nobody, as far as I can see, has taken the position you suggest here.
 
Which makes this: an extremely puzzling question, since nobody, as far as I can see, has taken the position you suggest here.
It's not puzzling at all. Like I mentioned a page back, this is Yrreg's very clumsy attempt at Equivocating belief based on evidence and belief based on faith.
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?

Since I'm reasonably certain that God does not exist, I'm not sure I agree that someone who is certain God does exist is being reasonable.
 
Since I'm reasonably certain that God does not exist, I'm not sure I agree that someone who is certain God does exist is being reasonable.
He is using "reasonable" different from you. He is using it as a measure of strength of belief.
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?


Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist.




Yrreg

yrreG, are you reasonably certain that children reasonably believe in Santa Claus?
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?


Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist.




Yrreg

I believe the proper response is:

Inigo Montoya said:
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
 
Number 1: Those examples are not examples of reasonable certainty in the contemplation of godless dave, but what I would call automatic certainty.

No, those examples were what I meant by reasonable certainty.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom