Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

I like to ask atheists here:

1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?


2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​


Yrreg

There's that old trick question: how many bites can you take from a whole sandwich? The answer is of coure just the one. After that it's not a whole sandwich any more.

If there is a maker of everything then depending upon its nature it may be possible to prove it.

The question of atheism only enters into it in as much as if it had been proven to a person's satisfaction that God exists, they would be hard pressed to call themselves an atheist. Whether the provee begins as an atheist, deist, theist or undecided makes very little difference. Those of us who are open to rational persuasion come in all stripes. Similarly it doesn't matter who does the proving. It may be the provee himself or another person.

However one thing is paramount. In order for it to be possible to prove that X is true, first X must be true.

If it is not true that there is a God who is the maker of everything then it follows that it will not be possible to prove such a thing.

As far as my extensive investigations have shown me, it has not been proven that there is a maker of everything, let alone that such a maker is the God of the bible. However the fallacy of argument from consequences prevents me from deduceing God's lack of existence from the absence of proof. That is to say that this lack of proof may be because one or both of these claims are untrue, or it may be that one or both of the claims are true but are either as yet unproven or unprovable.

I have however found many examples of chains of logic that have the semblance of being such proof. Yet all that I have encountered from the ontological argument for the existence of god, through pascal's wager to the cosmological argument (that your question appears to be leading on to) have serious flaws.

The main one here being that even if a first cause is established as being a logical necessity (it hasn't but that's another flaw) why then should we asscribe it the other trappings of Godhood. Argument ad absurdum posits that the universe was sneezed into existence by the Great Green Arkleseizure. Mockery asside establishing the identity of such a first cause by a priori definition as you've done here in your definition of God has no basis in logic or reason. Are you seriously telling me that if scholars proved beyond doubt that the universe was created by accident as part of a science fair project by some being from outside of space and time then that would truly fit your definition of God? I'm sorry to say this doesn't square with your claim elsewhere that you're a Christian.
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?


This comes back to a question I asked earlier: if someone who is "certain" of something can be wrong about it (as one of the groups of "reasonably certain" people in your above example must be), what is the use of certainty?

All it is likely to achieve is to encourage them to continue to be wrong in the face of contradictory evidence.
 
Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist.
Well, okay, if you insist.

1. Santa Claus - since Santa Claus does not exist, I can reasonably deny that Santa Claus can be reasonably certain that God does exist.

2. Harry Potter - see above for rationale.

3. Henry Dent - see above for rationale.

4. Mary Poppins - see above for rationale.

Is that enough, or do you need more examples?
 
I deny that anyone with access to the same data I have access to can be reasonably certain that any gods exist.
 
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?


Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist.




Yrreg

Could it be that Gerry is actually satirising his own posts?
 
Can people be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists?

Let us just ask ourselves:


Prescinding from ourselves,* can people be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists?​


Remember this thread is about the inquiry:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​

So, don't anymore go into useless directions to muddle up the issue.



Yrreg


*Prescinding from ourselves -- not considering ourselves.​
 
Prescinding from ourselves,* can people be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists?​

Yes. They can also be 'reasonably' (it doesn't mean what you think it means, despite your frequent use of obscure words) certain, or even completely certain, that they are Superman.
In either case, they would be utterly wrong.
 
That is the more about reasonable certainty, what is the less?

Yes. I can be reasonably certain that God doesn't exist - in fact I can be reasonably certain that no gods exist at all. You can be reasonably certain that God does exist.

All we have established is that reasonable certainty is more akin to belief, rather than knowledge.



To take you on your words, I ask you in return:


That is the more about reasonable certainty, what is the less?​


Does the more eviscerate or annihilate or neutralize or cancel the less in reasonable certainty according to your description:

...that reasonable certainty is more akin to belief, rather than knowledge.​

If you are more emotional and less logical, I suggest that you should instead be more logical and at the same time be less emotional at least in regard to your attachment to your own desires and conveniences, which can compromise your logic.






Yrreg
 
React to this post, please.

Does that mean you're ready to get to the point? I answered all your questions.


React to this post. please.

Let us just ask ourselves:


Prescinding from ourselves,* can people be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists?​


Remember this thread is about the inquiry:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​

So, don't anymore go into useless directions to muddle up the issue.



Yrreg


*Prescinding from ourselves -- not considering ourselves.​



Then we can proceed further in our exchange of thoughts still constructively and thus productively to arrive at the common conclusion to the inquiry:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​

Declare thus:

Yes, I agree that people can be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists.​




Yrreg
 
Then we can proceed further in our exchange of thoughts still constructively and thus productively to arrive at the common conclusion to the inquiry:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​

Declare thus:

Yes, I agree that people can be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists.​




Yrreg


Already asked and answered, but I'll say again:

Yes, I agree that people can be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists.

Happy?

Now, for the love of all you hold sacred, please move this discussion forward.
 
To take you on your words, I ask you in return:


That is the more about reasonable certainty, what is the less?​
Reasonable certainty is more akin (closer in meaning to) belief than it is to knowledge. It is less akin to everything to which it is not close in meaning. For example, it's not close in meaning to "interstellar flight", or "chocolate" or "anger".

If this is not what you are trying to get at, you are going to have to work on communicating more clearly.

Does the more eviscerate or annihilate or neutralize or cancel the less in reasonable certainty according to your description:

...that reasonable certainty is more akin to belief, rather than knowledge.​
No. Reasonable certainty doesn't become closer to knowledge by virtue of it not meaning something it doesn't mean.
If you are more emotional and less logical, I suggest that you should instead be more logical and at the same time be less emotional at least in regard to your attachment to your own desires and conveniences, which can compromise your logic.
I need an yrreg to English translator here. Are you suggesting:

1)My emotions are clouding my ability to think clearly?
2) I'm not being logical in my replies?
3) My desires and conveniences (whatever they may be) are causing me to type that which I don't believe?
4) Something else?

Whatever it is, when you explain what you mean here you might want to bear in mind the command in the MA to be "civil and polite".

ETA As several people have already posted, including me hours ago: Yes, I agree that people can be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists.

Now please move the discussion on to your next point.
 
Last edited:
Given Gerry's ardent amity for the thesaurus, perhaps he should inaugurate a matrimonial consanguinity with it.
 
Let us just ask ourselves:


Prescinding from ourselves,* can people be reasonably certain for themselves that God exists?​


Remember this thread is about the inquiry:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​

So, don't anymore go into useless directions to muddle up the issue.



Yrreg


*Prescinding from ourselves -- not considering ourselves.​

I don't think that anyone can claim to be reasonably certain of anything for which there is no available evidence. Can you sass* that?

* Sass: know, be aware of, meet, have sex with.
 
Summary to date:

We have broadly accepted Yrreg's three assumptions
We have stated we are reasonably* certain that god(s) do not exist
We have agreed that some people are reasonably certain that god does exist.

*we are aware that there is more than one meaning of the word "reasonable"

How has this taken 8 pages?
 
Last edited:
Can you reasonably deny other people can be reasonably certain God exists?

Even though you are reasonably certain for yourself that God does not exist?


Give some examples of people you are reasonably denying that they can be reasonably certain that God does exist.




Yrreg

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom