Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

Wow, it's not often that he actually announces he's leaving a thread. Is that new?

I'm just sad that he didn't provide this watertight reasoning that led two hard-core atheists to a human certainty of god.

But this is yrreg and even his examples (such as mothers loving their children) are flawed. This one:
If a woman is being suspected of sterility instead of her husband, the fact that she had a baby from a previous husband is proof that she is fertile, not sterile.
actually makes an argument, just not the one he had in mind. A baby of a previous husband is proof of a woman's past fertility and has no bearing on her current fertility. Things can change, including god beliefs.
 
This is a duplicate as now I am totally confused as where it belongs...I am going to leave it here for reference Fiona because in the thread you gave me there was a member suggesting it belonged back here ; (>

Of course a moderator could decide!


Hey Yrreg if you like rational, logical ontological arguments what do you think about Kurt Godels ontological argument for the existence of God? I am happy that one of the greatest mathematical minds of history believed in God and expressed it in a logical expression. ; {>

Or the KCA (being a rational logical argument for the existence of God)

ie

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
 
Last edited:
This thread is entitled:

Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.​


There is no need further to argue on and on and on and on, I have produced two previous atheists of great renown, Antony Flew a philosopher previously writing against God, and Francis Collins a scientist who was an atheist in his younger years, they have come to the certainty, humanly reasonable certainty, of God's existence.

Obviously, notwithstanding all the sour-grapes griping or sore-loser screeching of their former colleague atheists, they are the evidence that it is possible to prove the existence of God maker of everything.

They have proven it to themselves with certainty to their own satisfaction, that God exists, and have written about their proofs to others who are sincere seekers of the truth and do not imprison their reason in a dungeon.


P1: Most people don't believe in fairies for lack of evidence.

P2: Some people have come to believe in fairies and claim evidence supports their conclusions.

C: Therefore, most people who don't believe in fairies simply haven't found the evidence that is out there to be found.*

*For said evidence, google 'Cottingley fairies' and 'Sir Arthur Conan Doyle'.


Since Sir Arthur Conan Doyle proved to himself, with certainty, that fairies live at the bottom of the garden, do you, yrreg, now accept that fairies live at the bottom of the garden?
 
Last edited:
Do we need to start up a "Stalkers of yrreG" social group? We could post links to the latest yrreg thread so that everyone can keep up.
 
1. Well, prove to me praying helps, and then let me hear the voice of God, or maybe see him. Then give me some certainty on what to do to get to heaven, meaning, tell me which religions are "wrong" and take me to hell, if being a nice guy just doesn't make God satisfied enough. Maybe Jesus should come back one more time to remind people on what to do, as people have pretty much messed the bible up from it's original form.. I actually have no idea on how to convince me into believing. You should try me, and please, personally.

I remember being laughed at by my 1st grade teacher and the rest of my class when she told us the story of Jesus (Yeshua, isn't that his real name?) giving the final piece of bread to Judas, showing Judas that he will betray Jesus.

I told the teacher that isn't that a bit insinuating of Jesus to give the bread to someone and accuse him of betrayal, then Judas ends up hanging himself of guilt after fulfilling this "profecy". I told her, that didn't Jesus give the last piece of bread to Judas to tell Judas to betray him, that it was more like a request (or order coming from a religious leader).

I can still remember the laughter, and the mockery that followed. Me trying to logically investigate the bible, how mad of me.

Then years later they found the Gospel of Judas, and I still remembered this event from my first year ever in school. In the Gospel it seemed to say, that Judas was infact not an evil person, and that he was the most special of the desciples (for some reason I can't recall now. Maybe it was as he got this special task of non-directly killing Jesus, or then he was always held higher by Jesus, can't remember.). That he was given the task to fulfill the profecy.

It never made sense to me until now. And what I mean by that is, I've always liked Jesus' teachings, to find the logic in them, and I find the tale of the bible to be enjoyable. And didn't Jesus himself say (the character jesus in the bible. Damn, gotta be real careful typing on these threads :), that he sticks to metaphores when teaching people, because they wouldn't understand what he was talking about if he didn't, and that the disciples were the only ones to hear the real words. So is it too illogical to assume that the entire bible is metaphore, or at least to some extent?

I'll attempt to simplify; Maybe the bible has gone through so much that the "magical" event's might have been explained in the other removed parts of the bible, and that the bible wasn't intended to be a "magical" book at all, but the Romans removed all the humane stuff from in there and left all the belief stuff in it. To some extent of course.

And that trusting the bible to be 100% true can't be logical in any way, as people, without the intrusion of God, have removed a lot of crusial things from it, as if it was written by God, then the bible we have now is nowhere near the word of God. And using this logic, couldn't we all agree on never knowing what God thinks, or what God want's, or that you are right, and you neighbour is wrong about his perception of God. And with this conflict in one religion (different person, same *******) ccan't religious people even agree on not knowing God, as they are as certain of their God as their neighbours are of their special version of God. Using this logic, it is impossible to actually know what God want's unless he talks to you himself. And then people claim God talks to them personally, and he says different things to idifferent people, so my question is;

How on earth could any one person know what's going on?!?! And who to listen? What to do? Who to listen to as religious leaders are stating different opinions?!?!

It just all comes down to youself, believe in what you wish, discuss your beliefs with other people if you wish, but keep all the fuss inside your head, and only answer questions. Don't force beliefs which could very well be as wrong as the next guys you dispise.

I'm not religious, but I enjoy reading the bible as I'm interested in history, and it is a part of it no matter how much people wish it isn't. Not saying that the bible is true of course, but saying it has made a huge difference in the world since it's creation. Or since Rome took it as an official religion.

Here's my banter. Hope it made some sense to someone, as I sort of just let it all out :p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom