Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

I like to continue on the assumptions put forward by be myself...

So far I have had two posters here who appeared at the start of my renewed presence here to be constructive and thus productive.


But I am losing them, I am sorry to notice.



So, if you two are still around, please resume our exchange of thoughts on the need to take for granted as a working platform for our discussion the three assumptions I put forth for your concurrence, so that we can the three of us continue forward to the discussion ultimately of the possibility of proving the existence of God.


Here again are the there assumptions:

The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

​


Those of you who have something to say about the three assumptions, to accept them in toto or to reject and why, please do so, and say it right away at the start of your messages.



I will be back later in the late afternoon.





Yrreg
 
Dear Godless Dave, why do you have to adopt that name, godless dave? Is it any really useful way for you to arrive at human certainty in everything that counts for anything that is good and noble and uplifting to mankind starting with yourself?
Were you being good and noble and uplifting to mankind when you suggested that atheists should commit suicide?
 
Please define human certainty.

So far I have had two posters here who appeared at the start of my renewed presence here to be constructive and thus productive.


But I am losing them, I am sorry to notice.



So, if you two are still around, please resume our exchange of thoughts on the need to take for granted as a working platform for our discussion the three assumptions I put forth for your concurrence, so that we can the three of us continue forward to the discussion ultimately of the possibility of proving the existence of God.


Here again are the there assumptions:

The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

​


Those of you who have something to say about the three assumptions, to accept them in toto or to reject and why, please do so, and say it right away at the start of your messages.



I will be back later in the late afternoon.





Yrreg

The titular bandage frocks the purple canary to which it blogs with inhuman certainty.
 
Those of you who have something to say about the three assumptions, to accept them in toto or to reject and why, please do so, and say it right away at the start of your messages.


Here is what I have to say about your assumptions:

The problem with your second and third assumptions is that being certain does not mean that you are right.

People used to be certain that the sun orbited the earth.

They were certainly wrong.
 
Ok I will play

Yrreg said:
The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

Since I do not believe in reincarnation I can accept that.

The second assumption is that we have reason

As it happens I do accept that we have reason. But I am not being difficult when I say that I have no grounds at all to suppose that you mean the same thing by that word as I mean. So before I can accept your assumption you need to define reason. Once you have done that I will tell you whether I can adopt this part of your assumption

and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

No I don't think I can accept that. Reason is one of several abilities we have. It is extremely useful for certain kinds of task but the achievement of certainty is not one of them. I tend to think that instinct is much better for arriving at certainty. We act on instinct very quickly and if we do not do so on the basis of certainty it will do till certainty comes along. I must also disagree that reason is dependable. I have often seen people who genuinely believe they are acting on the basis of their reason when it is clear to all and sundry that they are doing no such thing. In fact I have seen this quite recently and not a million miles away from this thread.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

I do not think this is a good way to phrase what you say you mean; I prefer

"The third assumption is that we are subject to error even when we are certain: and it is helpful to remember that in all except the most extreme circumstances"
 
That is why I always believe that the only productive study of atheists is their psychology of being angry at God because they are afraid of God


Please explain why you are angry at Ganesh, because the only productive study of Christians is their psychology of being angry at Ganesh, because they are afraid of Ganesh.


whereas there is no need to fear God whatever if you guys will just face God and live with God.


So, all that talk in the Bible about facing the wrath of God if you follow other gods isn't true? Does a Muslim or Jew have anything to fear from God? What about a Hindu or a Sikh? What about all those Egyptians who believed in gods? God didn't seem too happy about that.

What if you are the one that has chosen poorly? What if the Jews are right and Jesus was a false prophet? What if the Muslims are right and Jesus was not the son of man and Mohammed was God's last and greatest prophet? What will you say to Allah when you face him in the afterlife?


Okay, tell me if you are not accepting any of these three assumptions, and why?




The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

​


Let me see if someone among you have the courage to either accept these the assumptions or to point out which assumption(s) you cannot accept and why.


First assumption: Yes, I accept that we indeed exist as humans.

Second assumption: Reason without evidence is dependable to arrive at certainty about very simple things. For example, we can know that all squares have four sides, because squares have four sides by definition. This is known as a priori knowledge. However, reason alone (i.e. without supporting evidence) is not enough to arrive at certainty about most things including the existence of gods. If you have come to such a conclusion in the absence of supporting evidence, please provide the reason and logic here and we can discuss it.

Third assumption: I'm not quite sure what you mean by this. It sounds like gibberish. But I suppose it follows:

P1: We are human.
P2: We have certainty about a very few things.
C: The certainty is human certainty.

However, see my response to your second assumption in regards to arriving at certainty.
 
Why are you always afraid?
I am not. Why are you always afraid?
That is why I always believe that the only productive study of atheists is their psychology of being angry at God because they are afraid of God whereas there is no need to fear God whatever if you guys will just face God and live with God.
Here is an example of your fear. Why are you afraid to admit that Atheists just don't believe in God?

Why are you always desparately inventing fanciful motivations like this?
Okay, tell me if you are not accepting any of these three assumptions, and why?




The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

​
I am happy to accept these assumptions.
 
But we need to fix that definition of God - "Maker of everything" is meaningless.

I would not accept any definition that did not stipulate a purposeful intelligence.

yrreg, do you continue to deny that purposeful intelligence is a necessary criterion to define God?

If so then you are still an atheist in denial.
 
Last edited:
But we need to fix that definition of God - "Maker of everything" is meaningless.

I would not accept any definition that did not stipulate a purposeful intelligence.

yrreg, do you continue to deny that purposeful intelligence is a necessary criterion to define God?

If so then you are still an atheist in denial.


I've been trying to get yrreg to acknowledge this on multiple threads for weeks now.

I would even suggest that 'intelligence' isn't enough for yrreg's definition of God.

'Maker of everything' would allow for the dead, unconscious universe to be God, which yrreg would reject.

'Intelligent maker of everything' would allow for an alien or time-traveller to be God, which yrreg would also reject.

yrreg's definition must, therefore, be 'supernatural, intelligent maker of everything'.
 
Is it possible to prove the existence of God maker of everything?


There are several questions which must be settled first in order an answer in the affirmative can be made to that question.


First of course is, what is it to prove the existence of something?


Next what is certainty for humans?



Other questions will come up as we go about with the topic of this thread in the quest for an answer to the inquiry on the possibility of proving the existence of God maker of everything.


Any ideas from you guys, atheists here, on what is it to prove the existence of something?

And any ideas from you guys, atheists here, on what is certainty for humans?




Yrreg


It is possible to know the mind of God?

Stephen Hawking asked exactly the same question in his legendary book, dare i repeat it for boredom. However, from my perspective, i doubt it greately.

For instance, how can we even reconcile the variables of the universe, and inexorably see past its complexities? I don't even think something as vast as the universe would even allow us to reduce it's complexities so easily, nor could we ever define the existence of a God mathematically, simply because of continuous strings of variables yet again. A God, a creator or maker of everything, would know the ultimate plan, if indeed there is one. The universe to have a proper meaning however would need to come in the form of a single equation which could possibly describe everything. The equation would be simple by contrast, and some have even hoped it being as simple as [latex]E=Mc^2[/latex].

Even if we had the ability to know everything about the past, its complimentary partner, the future, would still hold complexities, one off the top of my head would be chaos theory (something by the way i have no mathematical grasp of :) ). To know the rules of everything, you would need to know the future, whether it had an end or not. An infinite future will eventually leave the universe drained in black holes and a soft background temperature, colder than today. Ultimate knowledge would be to know the initial statistics of the beginning and how they might play in a predictable or non-predictable role in the future. If we knew this, we might at least know Gods plan in this universe.
 
I tend to believe that citizens of our little blue planet get ahead of themselves when stating that something is for certain, without considering any of "Neighbors" opinions. :gasp:
 
Assumptions without evidence just lead to chopped logic

I am asking you guys to agree on the assumptions I present before you, because unless we adhere to the assumptions human discourse of any worth is impossible.

So you say. I say otherwise. Since all we have to back us up is what we say, why should you be right and I wrong?

But as usual you guys keep avoiding what is crucially necessary to have any constructive and thus productive discourse on the issue at hand.

So you say. I say otherwise. Since all we have to back us up is what we say, why should you be right and I wrong?

Why are you always afraid?

I'm not. The only thing I'm afraid of is vampires. They are relatively rare. And I like garlic.

That is why I always believe that the only productive study of atheists is their psychology of being angry at God because they are afraid of God whereas there is no need to fear God whatever if you guys will just face God and live with God.

That is why I always believe that the only productive study of Christians is their psychology of being angry at Astarte, because they are afraid of Astarte, whereas there is no need to fear Astarte, whatever if you guys will just face Astarte and live with Astarte.

Okay, tell me if you are not accepting any of these three assumptions, and why?

Because if you just start off with assumptions and no evidence, all you can do is chop logic.

So far I have had two posters here who appeared at the start of my renewed presence here to be constructive and thus productive.

But I am losing them, I am sorry to notice.

If you ask yourself why that is, you might arrive at some truly useful knowledge.
 
I've been trying to get yrreg to acknowledge this on multiple threads for weeks now.

I would even suggest that 'intelligence' isn't enough for yrreg's definition of God.

'Maker of everything' would allow for the dead, unconscious universe to be God, which yrreg would reject.

'Intelligent maker of everything' would allow for an alien or time-traveller to be God, which yrreg would also reject.

yrreg's definition must, therefore, be 'supernatural, intelligent maker of everything'.
Probably not enough for his personal idea of what God is, and probably too much for the proof he has in mind, I would say.

I have always preferred "a purposeful, creative intelligence that encompasses, and is fundamental to, all existence".
 
yrreg said:
What is God for myself?

God is the maker of everything and the author of order and intelligence in the whole universe of existence, this whole universe of existence includes the physical universe.
From your other thread.

In essence here you are claiming that God existed before there was any order whatsoever? Yes?

And that God existed before there was any intelligence? Yes?
 
May I just say that I use the word human in order that the word certainty will be under a big enough umbrella as to include all and every certainty that mankind live with and under and no man will challenge except that he must live by himself alone in the jungle or in the forest or in the desert, or better put himself in a dungeon away from all human presence.

You should proof read your stuff Gerry. Sometimes you really go wandering to who knows where when you write.

You know, I can see better and better in the course of writing in web forums why people are afraid of the truths in everything, of course understanding by truths, the truths men live by and live together peaceably and productively, even though mankind can never achieve absolute truths.

Once again it's obvious where you go with this;

Why can mankind never achieve absolute certainty and absolute truth? Because man is a limited being, only God is unlimited in contrast to man being limited.

Provided that there is proof of God. Do you have any of that Gerry?

Can God create a being just like Himself? He can but He is not silly, because two Gods are not better than one, that is also a human certainty for myself and a human truth for myself.

The only certainty in that comment is your belief in God.


That is why I always believe and get more an more certain, humanly certain that is, that the only for the present productive in terms of human knowledge of human behavior in the study of atheists, mind you I say atheists not atheism, is the psychology of atheists as atheists, in particular their anger at God.

Again, proof read your stuff Gerry and answer what it is that makes you believe Atheists are mad at God.
 
Last edited:
May I just say that I use the word human in order that the word certainty will be under a big enough umbrella as to include all and every certainty that mankind live with and under and no man will challenge except that he must live by himself alone in the jungle or in the forest or in the desert, or better put himself in a dungeon away from all human presence.


How would you differentiate between, for example, the certainty some people have that there is no god but Allah, and Jesus was one of his prophets, and the certainty that others have that Jesus was the son of God? Both of these are certainties that people live under. Since these "certainties" are contradictory, at least one of them must be wrong.

If "certainties" can be wrong, what value do they have?
 
Why are you always afraid?

When I was a believer, I was afraid of the dark.
As I moved to atheist, that fear faded away*.
Go, as they say, figure.

* with the possible exception of walking through parts of Staines late at night. ;)
 
1. Theoretically, yes
2. Я не понимаю ваш инглиш, сэр!

S.

[derail]
And I don't understand that Russian. :) But I think you are right. Yrregs English is quite his own.
[/derail]
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom