Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I never thought it was plausible that we only use 10% of our brains, just because a surgeon can remove 90% of an evolutionist's brain and he can still argue for evolution :D
What a shame: VonNeumann followed about the only accurate statement he's made for this entire discussion with a personal insult :rolleyes:

Yes, the 10% thing is, and always has been, complete rubbish.
 
Last edited:
I find it kind of funny, since IDers always seem to base their hypothesis on their complete and utter lack of imagination. One wonders if it was surgically removed.
 
Strategy: when they disprove your mathematics, make your mathematics appear more complicated and hope...
Disprove? More complicated? You missed the drift. I made some mistakes but my point is still made even before I clarified. It is not complicated at all. The only beef PaulA' and Drfrank have, I believe, is that they think I proposed too long a sequence to have to spontaneously appear by chance.
 
What a shame: VonNeumann followed about the only accurate statement he's made for this entire discussion with a personal insult :rolleyes:

Yes, the 10% thing is, and always has been, complete rubbish.
...come on my friend. After all the sarcastic comments you make toward me, you have no sense of humor of your own? Sure you do.
 
But it seems like you are dismissing all evidence that points to 1, and choose to lean toward 2 without any evidence to support that decision. There is information to suggest that 1 is likely while there is no information to suggest 2.
DSE, you've totally lost me here. You say there is information to suggest #1 (origin of Physical laws from chance) is LIKELY?

Please tell me what it is. What is the information that indicates that the physical laws of this universe arose by chance - of course, I mean other than supernatural/metaphysical information. ...If all you are going to suggest is supernatural/metaphysical information for #1, then you have confirmed you understand and concede my point.
 
Von, I thought you backed off questioning evolution and limited your questions to origins. It's correct to say you support the theory of evolution, correct? You've made it clear that evolution does not address how life would originate, and people have agreed with you. But reading to your responses above, it seems like you're back to questioning evolution. Which is it? Origins, evolution, or both?
In my last post couple posts to you, I've tried to get from you what your mindset is with regard to origins of physical laws. Yes, it seems there has always been the primary de facto thread here - evolution.
 
In my defense, I asked, "What part of origins do you feel supports the idea that there is a designer?". I agree that I've asked several times, but I don't think you've given me a single direct answer yet.
Show us non-metaphysical evidence of origins of Physical Laws, and then I will understand WHY you say there is an alternative to non-metaphysical conjectures.
 
wrong--the latest scientific understanding seems pretty clear that all life originates from the simplest of life forms, and now scientists believe that viruses (DNA scraps) might be the our oldest "ancestors"--pre-life, if you will. Most of the DNA on the planet, it now appears, is in the form of viruses--many of which are found in the oceans...a true primordial soup--and no one needs to take anything on faith...the evidence is accumulating daily. Of course, the origins of these viruses (or the first DNA) might well have been a meteor...we don't know--yet. But I suspect we'll have a lot better understanding as the years go by--we are looking in the right direction--
You are free to read of all the evidence for yourself...check out this month's Scientific American--no faith is needed. But it's valuable to understand what is known before you accuse others of taking things on faith-- There is much evidence behind that which you are calling faith--even if you don't know about it. I haven't heard much evidence in support of your theories, Von.

Evolution is getting to the origin of life...and that is something those who have cherished supernatural beliefs will find untenable.

P.S. And yes there is a third choice--There's a "design"...the designer is Natural Selection. It works for bacteria, weeds, tumors, parasites, roaches, and humans...oh, and it works for viruses too. There is no plan...you just don't pass anything into the future if your vectors don't have what it takes to do so. With all the replication going on all the time, only one has to work--to get things started...and only one of an endless possiblity of mutations needs to be beneficial for life to evolve.
1. DSE and I are discussing ultimate origins, viz a viz this thread (Origin of Physical Laws).
2. "Evolution is getting to the origin of life..." - well, until it 'gets there' it is out of scope.
3. You say "the designer is Natural Selection":) . Where were you a few hundred posts back when I was trying to get one of you so-called-skeptics to admit that you think that natural selection "designs".

So, Art', what do you think about the origins of the 'just so' physical laws of this universe. How'd we get so lucky? Is there a scientific explanation?
 
Oh, absolutely.

3: happened because of an intelligent agent, but completely without purpose. Just for fun.
4: Happened after previous universe collapsed: deterministic but not intelligent.

Etc.
I thought #1, #2 were broad enough to encompass the two you added.

ie:
#3=#2
and
#4=#1

...that OK?

With that spirit in mind, please add some not already covered.
 
a quick dash of this, a dash of that, a little saltpetre and ooopps theres the universe there it was that easy all done in an afternoon for my next trick i will create the Giraffe
To get all that sex going on, must have gone soft on the saltpetre.
 
Yes, obviously. So why bother with all the math to show that a protein can't pop into existence as a discrete combinatorial object? Are you trying to make the same silly mistake that Dembski made in No Free Lunch?

Thyrotropin releasing hormone has only three amino acids. Many ribosomal proteins are very short. Simple life could have started with small proteins.

~~ Paul
Well good, then. So you can map out a path from simple 3-amino acid proteins, of that sort of magnitude, on up to something like a 100-amino acid protein then? Seriously, I am glad I finally found one of you fine specialists to be able to map out one example. Is there a white paper on this? Please direct us.
 
Given that there's no known mechanism to deliberately store information in DNA, this is at best a highly speculative (and unlikely) conjecture. The only way we know that information in DNA can be manipulated is slowly, at random, via mutation.

A scratch pad on which one cannot write is not especially useful.
reverse-trancriptase?
 
Yes, the 10% thing is, and always has been, complete rubbish.
an aside:
I paired with a brain surgeon in a ski lift line once, long ago. He was stuck with me next to him for 20 minutes:eek: I asked him about the 'we only use 10% of our brains..' thing, and he said 'I'm sure of it.' I asked how he could be so sure. He said he had removed 90% of the frontal lobe of a cattle rancher. The fellow recovered. Went back to cattle ranching. I asked if his wife ever said he changed, ..if he quit playing piano, writing poetry or whatever the fellow had been fond of doing. Surgeon said, "i dunno, never asked..."
 
an aside:
I paired with a brain surgeon in a ski lift line once, long ago. He was stuck with me next to him for 20 minutes:eek: I asked him about the 'we only use 10% of our brains..' thing, and he said 'I'm sure of it.' I asked how he could be so sure. He said he had removed 90% of the frontal lobe of a cattle rancher. The fellow recovered. Went back to cattle ranching. I asked if his wife ever said he changed, ..if he quit playing piano, writing poetry or whatever the fellow had been fond of doing. Surgeon said, "i dunno, never asked..."

Quick question. What's the difference between "10% of a brain" and "10% of the frontal lobe"?

I disbelieve that this story ever occurred. But if something like it did occur, then I chalk it up to miscommunication between you and the surgeon.
 
..if we are in the numbers game? You believe in a concept such as: democratic majority vote for science? Crap! I hope not. At least in the US, who do you think would 'win'? Have you seen the Gallup polls?

I'd prefer to go on evidence. What Darwin said that is still true today is the lack of intermediate forms - what Gould called punk eek - and that which is still a problem in using the fossil record to cite the gradualism for which there is no fossil evidence.

Wrong. Catch up. You use old quotes from people who were only describing missing pieces of the puzzle--many of those pieces have been filled in...and none match your "life came from aliens" theory--Though you may have been well read in the past, you are not well read in the current further evidence in support of evolution. Of course, science isn't about popularity--otherwise there would be "scientific proof" for god--since that's a popular paradigm. But it is about replication and adding to the evolving sphere of knowledge--and this is true in all scientific fields. And that is why the many scientists who do know the latest information on evolution and so forth are so compelling. The pieces of the puzzle fit. And to acknowledge that means having to bear the brunt of the ignoramuses on this planet who have a vested interest in believing that there must be an intelligent disigner. Truly, to me, the arguments against evolution are as primative as those who couldn't believe the earth was spherical and not even the center of the universe. By the way, Gould and Crick are dead--but neither believed in an intelligent designer...and I'm not sure Darwin did either (though he may have given lip service to one to avoid the anger atheism inspires.).

Gradualism is more than apparent in our genes...we can now "see" what sort of mutations ended up being fortuitous--

You have some sort of pet theory about a designer and we've learned that it has something to do with aliens, but your main arguments tend to be those of creationists--the old Haldane's dilemma--long resolved. You seem unaware of the latest understandings of both DNA and evolution and you also seem unwilling to offer any support for your pet theory. Your main evidence seems to be the gaps you perceive in our understanding of evolution--which is pretty much what ID proponents do. That being said, are you the VonNeumann cited in Sam Harris' book, End of Faith?--He is described as "mathematician, game theorist, savant of national defense, and agnostic--converting to Catholicism while in the throes of cancer..."

I think you have a good audience here if you were to present evidence, but it's the continual lack of evidence and your seeming failure to keep up on the latest info. in regards to evolution that makes your speculation so difficult to take seriously. You seem to have a desire to think you're smarter and have figured out some truth beyond what science has revealed...but you give no details as to what that truth really is or what the evidence is in support of these claims. You put scientists who have added to the growing embodiment of evidence in support of evolution down without offering a single piece of evidence in return for your "better" theory. You continually point to "flaws" in evolution...many of which have been addressed, but you don't ever acknowledge it.

And in a group of skeptics, of course evidence is important--it is the tool we use to separate truth from fiction...the tool we use to understand our world. It's the best there is, frankly--especially given the capacity human's have for fooling themselves. Science tends to weed out the fakery pretty quickly (hence the disgaced Korean cloners and Raelians...are you a Raelian?). You feel miffed when someone questions your beliefs (not backed by evidence) and yet you continually deride scientific understanding without seeming to grasp it fully. You point your skeptic lens at evolution which is fine--but you become disgruntled when people point to flaws in panspermia and the "aliens did it" theory you seem to espouse.
 
1. DSE and I are discussing ultimate origins, viz a viz this thread (Origin of Physical Laws).
2. "Evolution is getting to the origin of life..." - well, until it 'gets there' it is out of scope.
3. You say "the designer is Natural Selection":) . Where were you a few hundred posts back when I was trying to get one of you so-called-skeptics to admit that you think that natural selection "designs".

So, Art', what do you think about the origins of the 'just so' physical laws of this universe. How'd we get so lucky? Is there a scientific explanation?

Backwards thinking again...if we hadn't have been the "lucky" ones...we wouldn't have been here to ponder it. In the past, humans used god or gods or other stories to explain the "luck". We now have more information. And yes...it is fortuitous...but the same fortuitous events happen to tumors--you blast them with chemo, and it only takes one sell that has one mutation that makes it slightly resistant--to spread...the same happens for infections which is why antibiotics must continually be made anew...the same thing happens with roaches...which and other pests--one "fortuitous" mutation can mean survival when all else die. It happens again and again and again. It's what happens in flu viruses too--humans build resistances to viruses they've had before and viruses they are inoculated against, but one "lucky" mutation can make a human particularly unlucky. In fact, it appears that much of the story of humanity and who survived had to do with who brought germs that they were immune to into populations who didn't have that immunity. This world was populated by people lucky enough to have immunity to diseases that killed off their rivals. It is further populated by people lucky to be alive thanks to science, antibiotics, vaccinations, germ theory applications, and so forth...Lucky indeed. But not magic. And not designed except by natural (and human) selection.

I don't think it's just so...I think we evolved because we have adaptations that fit in this environment--just as other life forms on this planet do. Neanderthals did not. And one day, humans will be gone too, I'm sure. I don't think this world is designed for humans anymore than it's designed for cactus or ebola. Sure--consciousness, intelligence, adaptation, learning, memory, imitation, story telling and feelings are great--they certainly enhanced the success we humans have had when it comes to survival and reproduction--they are marvelous traits, no doubt--but many marvelous and fascinating traits can be found in life forms--even life forms we find unpleasant and "lesser"--. And they clearly came about by natural selection just as the grand canyon wasn't carved by an "intentional" artist--but natural forces. Nature is a fabulous "designer" even though seemingly cruel from a human perspective (actually uncaring from a scientific perspective). If there were some magical other designer, they forgot to leave any evidence or clues behind. Does the designer you believe in have a plan...does he/she/it plan ahead?--have a goal?
 
I really don't know what to tell you since you think you know so much. Viruses are dormant without cellular mechanisms. They cannot reproduce. They cannot metabolize. They are like software sitting on a memory medium - sans computer. ...surely, since you know so much, you know this. It is doubtful, to absurd proportions, that DNA could have somehow emerged without some extremely complex set of other bio-machines surrounding it to work with it. RNA is a relatively new discovery and was first thought might be a precursor for DNA (circa early '80s). I believe most everyone has thrown that out. Proteins are a more likely candidate IMO.....
4. I am simply MORE skeptical than you are.

You are, once again wrong-- http://www.discover.com/issues/mar-06/cover/
and, once again, behind. You may well be more skeptical than I am when it comes to evolution, but I'm not sure that skepticism is based on understanding. I think you fail to shine the skeptic light on your "intelligent design" theory. BTW, I am well aware that viruses are DNA scraps (or in computers--"code scraps") that need to exploit or hijack some other replicating mechanism-- I think religion does that...it exploits the human desire to understand cause and effect and deal with the knowledge that we will die...and exploits our communication vectors--to spread it's message. (Believe or you will suffer eternally!) Moreover, I think your "intelligent designer" is (to quote you) "doubtful, to absurd proportions"...and your evidence far less compelling than the above article and its sources.

To me, it seems you use your "skepticism" to stroke your ego and keep the light off your own faith based theory--and you use it to pretend that your conjecture is on par with reams of scientific data. You may have read Dawkins in the past, but I don't think you've read much in the area of current research from anyone on the forfront of DNA research--including Dawkins. The evidence shows quite clearly that Darwin was more profoundly correct than anyone could have imagined.
 
...come on my friend. After all the sarcastic comments you make toward me, you have no sense of humor of your own? Sure you do.
Hey, that was good natured ribbing on my part :)

Maybe being English generally makes my humour too subtle for some 'merkins :p

I'll try to slap my thigh more in future.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom