Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

You are posting in a skeptic forum. What did you expect?
Yes, of course. But I was defending against chipmunk's allegation that I am a groupie. My point is that I am not protected by numbers of my own kind here - hardly what a groupie would expose himself to.
 
Newer research has found several functions for "junk" DNA. It is obvious that it is not junk at all, but it just does not code for proteines.
Yes. And this is more of the result from the simplistic evolution-slanted interpretation as I have already brought here for discussion (and many were ostensibly unfamiliar with): The Central Dogma of DNA. By definition, codes that did not express into proteins were erroneously labeled "junk".
 
Care to revise your estimates?
It is a bad habit I have of trying to shoot from memory. I did this 10 years ago and mixed up a couple of gedanken experiments together accidently. Even with my previous errors, it points out the ludicrosity of thinking, if anyone indeed does think so, that evolution relies on mutations of this magnitude.

Try this: What are the combinations of all possible proteins of 100 amino acid length (my first mistake was that I DID mean amino acids, not nucleotides)?

Given a 100 amino acid protein: 20^100 ~ 10^130 combinations.
How far will 10^80 machines get through all the combinations, in the life of the universe if they can assemble a new string each picoS? 10^80 * 10^12 * 10^18 = 10^110 combinations out of 10^130. The whole universe, with the generous infinite supply of amino acides and a machine at each particle (before I said at each atom, but this is at each particle) in the universe, each one working and not overlapping its work with any of the other machines, producing one new string each millionth-millionth of a second (picosecond), can only get through 10^-20 of all the combinations of this protein. Stated another way, it would take 10^20 times the life of the universe to get through all the combinations.

It seems more obvious this is a problem at the beginning of life because where does that first protein come from? I think insulin is like 51 amino acids, which is exceedingly better but still not something that is likely to pop into existence. A primordial soup the size of all the oceans on earth, say 10^32 atoms, again with the fictional machines working on the problem, one string each picosecond yields 10^32*10^12= 10^44 and there are 10^66 combinations, so that is 10^22 seconds. As 10^22 >> 10^18, and all the other generous "givens", it wouldn't pop into this universe.

This is the kind of thing that bothers me, that useful proteins are so exceedingly unlikely to result from chance. There must be a gradualistic explanation.

I hear you say nylonase. You are not suggesting that frame-shifts are common are you? Like, if you find the code for something useful, say, chlorophyll, all you need to do is play with some frame-shifting and you get all kinds of other neat useful stuff? If frame-shifting could do such magic, I think it would have been discovered by now.
 
It is a bad habit I have of trying to shoot from memory. I did this 10 years ago and mixed up a couple of gedanken experiments together accidently. Even with my previous errors, it points out the ludicrosity of thinking, if anyone indeed does think so, that evolution relies on mutations of this magnitude.

Try this: What are the combinations of all possible proteins of 100 amino acid length (my first mistake was that I DID mean amino acids, not nucleotides)?

Given a 100 amino acid protein: 20^100 ~ 10^130 combinations.
How far will 10^80 machines get through all the combinations, in the life of the universe if they can assemble a new string each picoS? 10^80 * 10^12 * 10^18 = 10^110 combinations out of 10^130. The whole universe, with the generous infinite supply of amino acides and a machine at each particle (before I said at each atom, but this is at each particle) in the universe, each one working and not overlapping its work with any of the other machines, producing one new string each millionth-millionth of a second (picosecond), can only get through 10^-20 of all the combinations of this protein. Stated another way, it would take 10^20 times the life of the universe to get through all the combinations.

It seems more obvious this is a problem at the beginning of life because where does that first protein come from? I think insulin is like 51 amino acids, which is exceedingly better but still not something that is likely to pop into existence. A primordial soup the size of all the oceans on earth, say 10^32 atoms, again with the fictional machines working on the problem, one string each picosecond yields 10^32*10^12= 10^44 and there are 10^66 combinations, so that is 10^22 seconds. As 10^22 >> 10^18, and all the other generous "givens", it wouldn't pop into this universe.

This is the kind of thing that bothers me, that useful proteins are so exceedingly unlikely to result from chance. There must be a gradualistic explanation.

I hear you say nylonase. You are not suggesting that frame-shifts are common are you? Like, if you find the code for something useful, say, chlorophyll, all you need to do is play with some frame-shifting and you get all kinds of other neat useful stuff? If frame-shifting could do such magic, I think it would have been discovered by now.

Strategy: when they disprove your mathematics, make your mathematics appear more complicated and hope...
 
Sorry if it seems repetitive, just trying to be clear. But, glad to hear evolution is officially off the table. I can't say that I agree that we all take origins on faith. I think there are ideas that have more evidence to support them than others. That's different than faith. Either way, like I said, I thought Sidney W. Fox and others have shown convincing data on how non-living amino acids would move toward becoming living organisms under the right conditions. What part of origins do [you]feel supports the idea that there is a designer?
This seems like the Nth time... anywise:
This thread is the best proposition, "Physical Laws - best case for ID", to couch the argument. What is your best pet conjecture, of origins of those laws?
I don't know of any hypothesis other than:
1. Happened by chance and with absolutely no plan/purpose/design.
2. Happened due to plan/purpose/design.
3. ..do you know of some others?

Can you tell me what you do, in the privacy of your own mind but might share with us here, with answering this basic origins question? I've already told you I lean toward #2.
 
Well, the junk DNA argument is related to incompetent design, in that if God is so perfect etc. why is a good proportion of our genome pointless crap? Therefore, Creationists always say that all DNA must have purpose.

I read a good article arguing why the majority of `junk' DNA almost certainly is junk due to the mechanisms of how it forms (something to do with retroposons, iirc) - I'll have a look for it :)
If an alien who was technically astute enough to analyze our computers, but somehow not smart enough to draw proper conclusions as to WHY they are built the way they are, may look at the code store as the good data and the so-called RAM store as 'junk'.

Could some of the DNA be 'scratch pad' or some substrate that serves as a sort of workbench? Spare parts inventory?

I don't think that all of DNA has to have a purpose any more than all my hard disk drives and RAM have to be full. I never thought it was plausible that we only use 10% of our brains, just because a surgeon can remove 90% of an evolutionist's brain and he can still argue for evolution :D. Perhaps there is more of a holographic viewpoint we should have when considering these things.
 
This seems like the Nth time... anywise:
This thread is the best proposition, "Physical Laws - best case for ID", to couch the argument. What is your best pet conjecture, of origins of those laws?
I don't know of any hypothesis other than:
1. Happened by chance and with absolutely no plan/purpose/design.
2. Happened due to plan/purpose/design.
3. ..do you know of some others?

Can you tell me what you do, in the privacy of your own mind but might share with us here, with answering this basic origins question? I've already told you I lean toward #2.
But it seems like you are dismissing all evidence that points to 1, and choose to lean toward 2 without any evidence to support that decision. There is information to suggest that 1 is likely while there is no information to suggest 2.
 
Didn't we already leave it at this: "we all take origins on faith - there are NO scientific theories for origins."

So, yes I would agree that it is fair for all of us to say that whatever we believe, we take on faith. Evolution is out of scope on origin of life, of course.

What do YOU take on faith for pre-biotic origins? ...iss it fair to ask.
Von, I thought you backed off questioning evolution and limited your questions to origins. It's correct to say you support the theory of evolution, correct? You've made it clear that evolution does not address how life would originate, and people have agreed with you. But reading to your responses above, it seems like you're back to questioning evolution. Which is it? Origins, evolution, or both?
 
This seems like the Nth time... anywise
In my defense, I asked, "What part of origins do you feel supports the idea that there is a designer?". I agree that I've asked several times, but I don't think you've given me a single direct answer yet.
 
Newer research has found several functions for "junk" DNA. It is obvious that it is not junk at all, but it just does not code for proteines.

Well, it's useful for paternity tests and forensic analysis because individuals vary more in this "filler'" DNA-- It also acts as a spacer and humans use it as markers when mapping the genome--but it doesn't code for proteins which is what "genes" do. Sometimes an old (or primitive) gene will get turned on...

My point is, that mutations can and do happen a lot of the time--most of it is in this part of the DNA, because it can be passed on without being problematic. If you're packing a box for shipment, you can use all kinds of filler and do all kinds of things with it without affecting the contents being shipped...If you mess with the items you're shipping, you're likely to screw things up--but there is a chance that you could inadverdantly enhance the product. Serendipity.
 
DSE, you challenge my memory cuz I'm really getting deja vu all over all over again again.

Didn't we already leave it at this: "we all take origins on faith - there are NO scientific theories for origins."

So, yes I would agree that it is fair for all of us to say that whatever we believe, we take on faith. Evolution is out of scope on origin of life, of course.

What do YOU take on faith for pre-biotic origins? ...iss it fair to ask.

wrong--the latest scientific understanding seems pretty clear that all life originates from the simplest of life forms, and now scientists believe that viruses (DNA scraps) might be the our oldest "ancestors"--pre-life, if you will. Most of the DNA on the planet, it now appears, is in the form of viruses--many of which are found in the oceans...a true primordial soup--and no one needs to take anything on faith...the evidence is accumulating daily. Of course, the origins of these viruses (or the first DNA) might well have been a meteor...we don't know--yet. But I suspect we'll have a lot better understanding as the years go by--we are looking in the right direction--
You are free to read of all the evidence for yourself...check out this month's Scientific American--no faith is needed. But it's valuable to understand what is known before you accuse others of taking things on faith-- There is much evidence behind that which you are calling faith--even if you don't know about it. I haven't heard much evidence in support of your theories, Von.

Evolution is getting to the origin of life...and that is something those who have cherished supernatural beliefs will find untenable.

P.S. And yes there is a third choice--There's a "design"...the designer is Natural Selection. It works for bacteria, weeds, tumors, parasites, roaches, and humans...oh, and it works for viruses too. There is no plan...you just don't pass anything into the future if your vectors don't have what it takes to do so. With all the replication going on all the time, only one has to work--to get things started...and only one of an endless possiblity of mutations needs to be beneficial for life to evolve.
 
Last edited:
1. Happened by chance and with absolutely no plan/purpose/design.
2. Happened due to plan/purpose/design.
3. ..do you know of some others?

Oh, absolutely.

3: happened because of an intelligent agent, but completely without purpose. Just for fun.
4: Happened after previous universe collapsed: deterministic but not intelligent.

Etc.
 
If an alien who was technically astute enough to analyze our computers, but somehow not smart enough to draw proper conclusions as to WHY they are built the way they are, may look at the code store as the good data and the so-called RAM store as 'junk'.

Then that alien is just as incompetent as the designer you posit.
 
a quick dash of this, a dash of that, a little saltpetre and ooopps theres the universe there it was that easy all done in an afternoon for my next trick i will create the Giraffe
 
Last edited:
Von said:
This is the kind of thing that bothers me, that useful proteins are so exceedingly unlikely to result from chance. There must be a gradualistic explanation.
Yes, obviously. So why bother with all the math to show that a protein can't pop into existence as a discrete combinatorial object? Are you trying to make the same silly mistake that Dembski made in No Free Lunch?

Thyrotropin releasing hormone has only three amino acids. Many ribosomal proteins are very short. Simple life could have started with small proteins.

~~ Paul
 
If an alien who was technically astute enough to analyze our computers, but somehow not smart enough to draw proper conclusions as to WHY they are built the way they are, may look at the code store as the good data and the so-called RAM store as 'junk'.

Could some of the DNA be 'scratch pad' or some substrate that serves as a sort of workbench? Spare parts inventory?

Given that there's no known mechanism to deliberately store information in DNA, this is at best a highly speculative (and unlikely) conjecture. The only way we know that information in DNA can be manipulated is slowly, at random, via mutation.

A scratch pad on which one cannot write is not especially useful.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom