Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Von, is it fair to say that you believe in a designer not because of evidence, but because of faith, and leave it at that?
 
Here, run the Evj program and then explain to me how it could possibly work:

http://www.lecb.ncifcrf.gov/~toms/papers/ev/evj/

You appear to have no idea of the power of huge populations and deep time. Also, proteins aren't made up of neucleotides.

~~ Paul
...I meant a protein expressed from 100 nucleotides of DNA - why quibble ? I just threw out an example for consideration of its order of magnitude.

You appear not to, actually. Huge populations? Deep time? I assume you mean populations that can fit in this universe and in 10-20 billion years, or is that not deep or huge enough?

There are only theorized to be 10^80 atoms in the universe. ...only theorized to be 10^18 seconds. If you had a machine at every atom site (a generous offer), assembling different codes each picosecond (another generous suggestion), what is the mean time to synthesize a particular 100 amino acid protein?
Never mind that we used up all the atoms in the universe, and then some, to make these protein sequencing machines, and that there are no amino acides to assemble with - I'll give an unending supply of those for free, too.

Would you suppose it takes longer than 10^18 seconds? Get out your pencil.

That sure is a lot of primordial soup, wouldn't you say?

I'll go check on that link and get back with you.
 
Von, is it fair to say that you believe in a designer not because of evidence, but because of faith, and leave it at that?
DSE, you challenge my memory cuz I'm really getting deja vu all over all over again again.

Didn't we already leave it at this: "we all take origins on faith - there are NO scientific theories for origins."

So, yes I would agree that it is fair for all of us to say that whatever we believe, we take on faith. Evolution is out of scope on origin of life, of course.

What do YOU take on faith for pre-biotic origins? ...iss it fair to ask.
 
You sure about this?

~~ Paul
Sure about that most mutations are deleterious? Perhaps you are speaking of single point mutations and giving the cell a chance to correct it? I thought this was pretty much a consensus that most mutations in the gamete are deleterious.

Here, this fellow says that mutations more than likely are deadly:

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/01/060126194000.htm

..but I was getting ready to post this link because of what he says about doubting 'gradualism', which was an issue raised in some recent posts.
 
Most mutations are in junk DNA, because most of our DNA no longer codes for anything--it's junk...filler... Most mutations in genes are deleterious--but we seldom know of them because they often don't survive long enough for anyone to be aware that they ever existed...but it only takes one beneficial mutation to change a lot...the most common for of Dwarfism is caused by a mutation in a collagen gene--microscopic genomic change--large phenotypic change. There is that little kid in Germany who has super muscles because of a genetic quirk...sometimes mutations end up enhancing an individuals survival and reproductive success-- Old genes can get turned on two via translocations...but there are lots of ways that mutations and recombinations happen--uniparental disomy, nondisjunction, sattlelite attachment, siamese twinning...
 
For whatever reason, this thread has turned into 90% VN bashing. About 1/3 of the verbage here is mine and most of the rest of it is a small group of skeptics who have some desire to engage me on this or that point - or want to just throw shots at me.
You are posting in a skeptic forum. What did you expect?
 
Most mutations are in junk DNA, because most of our DNA no longer codes for anything--it's junk...filler...
Newer research has found several functions for "junk" DNA. It is obvious that it is not junk at all, but it just does not code for proteines.
 
Newer research has found several functions for "junk" DNA. It is obvious that it is not junk at all, but it just does not code for proteins.
I think it's still pretty much beyond doubt that most of it is junk. I direct you to CB130, and also PubMed.
 
I think it's still pretty much beyond doubt that most of it is junk. I direct you to CB130, and also PubMed.
CB130: "Creationist Claim 130"? What on earth has the function or non-function of "junk" DNA to do with creationism? The theory of evolution will not be shaken if "junk" DNA turns out not to be junk, or if it turns out that there are other factors than DNA that determines inheritance. And these facts, be they true or not, cannot support creationism.

I am not convinced that you can conclude that some DNA is junk because you can cut it out and not noticing a difference. These animals are laboratory animals and are not exposed to the same kind of challenges as wild animals.

I do not doubt that some DNA is real junk, but I doubt that the real junk constitutes such a large part of our genome as is now assumed. I refer to recent articles in Scientific American: Nov 2003 "The Unseen Genome: Gems among the Junk", and Oct 2004 "The Hidden Genetic Program of Complex organisms".
 
You suggest I do not understand something. To me, it appears you have not applied a sufficient amount of critical thinking. You fault me for thinking beyond the weak explanations and lack of explanations. That is not a matter of my misunderstanding nor lack thereof, it is a matter of what level of explanation I will accept as plausible.

Follow this:
1. the amount of combinations of 100 neucleotides (a moderately small sized protein) is on the order of about 10^160. ...Too big a jump to happen in this universe.
2. Because of #1, in order for RM/NS to work, RM must come up with a gradual series of smaller mutations, one at one time, than something as large as #1.
3. Notwithstanding that most (understatement) mutations are deleterious, it is even less likely that a small mutation will add advantage and thus, if not deleted by natural selection, the best we can hope for is that natural selection is neutral to it.
4. the conjecture is that many of these small changes, could lead up to the appearance of a new function, even one that would require 100 nucleotides of new code (where #1 stated it would be impossible as one single jump).

What I understand very well is that one has to have a big helping of 'faith' to believe that a bunch of small gradualistic changes can lead to such a high level of complexity. What is the explanation for how this can happen. The neutral theory only offers why natural selection may be considered to not get in the way while these gradualistic changes, which offer no advantage, need to persist through more generations.

Remember, when Dawkins tried to illustrate how gradualism works, he used the "Methinks it.." program he wrote. When the correct letter popped into the right location, his program artificially selected it and kept it there. That artifact was a teleological 'neutral' mechanism. That is: the programmed function of 'selection' was constructed to stay neutral once the right code fell into place.

See? There IS no explanation for how natural selection can pull along the piecemeal path toward some new function, unless.... Unless evolution works more like Dawkins program than we think it does.

Point a: 4^100 = 1.6*10^60. I hope the extra one was just a typo, as an error of one hundred orders of magnitude out is a little much, even for you.

As I've explained before, proteins can be quite robust to mutation - altering several amino acids may not result in any functional change or, in some cases, altering a single amino acid will result in a large change. For a given protein coded for by 100 nucleotides, a given function will be far from unique in terms of the amino acid chain required. Also, while there are 64 combinations of DNA triplets, only 20 amino acids are coded for. This reduces the number of possible amino acid sequences to 20^33 = 8.6*10^42.

Therefore, in your example of using every atom in the universe you'd expect over 10^37 of every possible protein in the first picosecond.
So, that argument has obviously been crushed to dust :rolleyes:

Furthermore, given that current research suggests that only a minority of amino acids in a protein actually defines the folds and therefore its function, the number of possible effective proteins would be many orders of magnitude less than that.

Also, you are assuming an end goal, or function, that is advantageous that the protein is `aiming' towards. In this way, I agree that Dawkins' example is not fantastic as it assumes only one acceptable end sequence. There may be an enormous number of different functions that the protein could have which would improve fitness.

Furthermore, due to gene duplication you can have extra copies of redundant genes that will mutate neutrally to explore the space. As nylonase demonstrates, frameshifts can also radically alter the protein, resulting in novel ones.

Care to revise your estimates?
 
CB130: "Creationist Claim 130"? What on earth has the function or non-function of "junk" DNA to do with creationism? The theory of evolution will not be shaken if "junk" DNA turns out not to be junk, or if it turns out that there are other factors than DNA that determines inheritance. And these facts, be they true or not, cannot support creationism.

I am not convinced that you can conclude that some DNA is junk because you can cut it out and not noticing a difference. These animals are laboratory animals and are not exposed to the same kind of challenges as wild animals.

I do not doubt that some DNA is real junk, but I doubt that the real junk constitutes such a large part of our genome as is now assumed. I refer to recent articles in Scientific American: Nov 2003 "The Unseen Genome: Gems among the Junk", and Oct 2004 "The Hidden Genetic Program of Complex organisms".

Well, the junk DNA argument is related to incompetent design, in that if God is so perfect etc. why is a good proportion of our genome pointless crap? Therefore, Creationists always say that all DNA must have purpose.

I read a good article arguing why the majority of `junk' DNA almost certainly is junk due to the mechanisms of how it forms (something to do with retroposons, iirc) - I'll have a look for it :)
 
I do want to get reactions. But unless I poke, I do not know to what extent some of the ideas are contrary. I'm sure a forum of skeptics is not entirely homogeneous. I want to see what the different flavors are.

You forgot to tell me, what is 'woo'?

I didn't forget. I abstained. I simply don't have a clear definition. Someone else might be more suited to answer you on that one.
 
Von said:
...I meant a protein expressed from 100 nucleotides of DNA - why quibble ? I just threw out an example for consideration of its order of magnitude.
Ah, sorry, that wasn't obvious. 100 bases encodes a protein with about 31 amino acids, for which there are [latex]$20^{31}=2 \times 10^{40}$[/latex] combinations.

You appear not to, actually. Huge populations? Deep time? I assume you mean populations that can fit in this universe and in 10-20 billion years, or is that not deep or huge enough?
A mere trillion organisms replicating once per hour can conduct [latex]$10^{24}$[/latex] evolution experiments in a billion years.

Why do you insist that nature has to enumerate all possible 33-residue proteins in order to come up with something useful? How about starting with a few residues that do something useful and then slowly evolving that protein? In that billion years we can easily enumerate all possible 10-residue proteins.

~~ Paul
 
1. the amount of combinations of 100 neucleotides (a moderately small sized protein) is on the order of about 10^160. ...Too big a jump to happen in this universe.

That's because you think it should rearrange itself randomly on the spot. That's not what happens.

3. Notwithstanding that most (understatement) mutations are deleterious, it is even less likely that a small mutation will add advantage and thus, if not deleted by natural selection, the best we can hope for is that natural selection is neutral to it.

Not bloody likely. The organism just dies off if it's not fit. There is no need for neutrality at all.

What I understand very well is that one has to have a big helping of 'faith' to believe that a bunch of small gradualistic changes can lead to such a high level of complexity.

Sorry, but that's inane. Obviously, adding more and more small changes leads to a big change.

What is the explanation for how this can happen. The neutral theory only offers why natural selection may be considered to not get in the way while these gradualistic changes, which offer no advantage, need to persist through more generations.

Yeah, but it's a strawman.

See? There IS no explanation for how natural selection can pull along the piecemeal path toward some new function, unless.... Unless evolution works more like Dawkins program than we think it does.

So... you're again using your appeal to Dawkins' program. Drop it. It's a computer program. It may not duplicate how evolution really works. So ?
 
There are only theorized to be 10^80 atoms in the universe. ...only theorized to be 10^18 seconds. If you had a machine at every atom site (a generous offer), assembling different codes each picosecond (another generous suggestion), what is the mean time to synthesize a particular 100 amino acid protein?
Never mind that we used up all the atoms in the universe, and then some, to make these protein sequencing machines, and that there are no amino acides to assemble with - I'll give an unending supply of those for free, too.

Would you suppose it takes longer than 10^18 seconds? Get out your pencil.

That sure is a lot of primordial soup, wouldn't you say?

I'll go check on that link and get back with you.

Again, you assume too much. The way I see it, there are a limited number of ways that life could have evolved, or that amino acids could have formed, etc. So the number of possible combinations that would occur "by chance" and be carried on from one generation to the next might be much fewer than you believe. If so, the time needed to reach this point would be shortened immensly.

Of course, I'm no biologist.
 
Last edited:
Ah, sorry, that wasn't obvious. 100 bases encodes a protein with about 31 amino acids, for which there are [latex]$20^{31}=2 \times 10^{40}$[/latex] combinations.


A mere trillion organisms replicating once per hour can conduct [latex]$10^{24}$[/latex] evolution experiments in a billion years.

Why do you insist that nature has to enumerate all possible 33-residue proteins in order to come up with something useful? How about starting with a few residues that do something useful and then slowly evolving that protein? In that billion years we can easily enumerate all possible 10-residue proteins.

~~ Paul

Ooh, I keep forgetting to use the swanky LaTeX capabilities:

[latex]$f_{\text{cs}}^{\prime}(c_i,\alpha,\beta) = \alpha(2-\beta) - 2c_i(2\alpha-\beta)$[/latex]

Sorry, just a random equation I copied from my Thesis (I'm in the middle of doing corrections at the moment) :blush:

Well, it's nice to see someone else gets numbers that agree ;) Of course, you included the start and stop codons as part of the coding, whereas I assumed 33 coded amino acids, but the effect is more or less identical.

Belz is also right: the examples myself and Paul are giving are still effectively strawmen of how evolution works, but it's useful to demonstrate that even if this were the case the probabilities are nowhere near as unlikely as VonNeumann was asserting.

Of course, in reality the more complex amino acids would be variations on existing ones, and not just pop into existence - adding a few more amino acids to a protein will probably not cause much of a change in function, if at all.
 
Last edited:
DSE, you challenge my memory cuz I'm really getting deja vu all over all over again again.

Didn't we already leave it at this: "we all take origins on faith - there are NO scientific theories for origins."

So, yes I would agree that it is fair for all of us to say that whatever we believe, we take on faith. Evolution is out of scope on origin of life, of course.

What do YOU take on faith for pre-biotic origins? ...iss it fair to ask.
Sorry if it seems repetitive, just trying to be clear. But, glad to hear evolution is officially off the table. I can't say that I agree that we all take origins on faith. I think there are ideas that have more evidence to support them than others. That's different than faith. Either way, like I said, I thought Sidney W. Fox and others have shown convincing data on how non-living amino acids would move toward becoming living organisms under the right conditions. What part of origins do feel supports the idea that there is a designer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom