This is one of my favorites. This is VonNeumann's misinterpretation of the
Neutral Theory:
[my emphasis]
VonNeumann revealed in a later post that he was referring to the Neutral Theory. What he didn't understand was that the Neutral Theory has to do simply with the idea that some percentage of alleles in a given genome are more affected by genetic drift than by natural selection, and that the theory in no way suggests that natural selection "looks the other way" at any point in an organism's evolution.
You suggest I do not understand something. To me, it appears you have not applied a sufficient amount of critical thinking. You fault me for thinking
beyond the weak explanations and lack of explanations. That is not a matter of my misunderstanding nor lack thereof, it is a matter of what level of explanation I will accept as plausible.
Follow this:
1. the amount of combinations of 100 neucleotides (a moderately small sized protein) is on the order of about 10^160. ...Too big a jump to happen in this universe.
2. Because of #1, in order for RM/NS to work, RM must come up with a gradual series of smaller mutations, one at one time, than something as large as #1.
3. Notwithstanding that most (understatement) mutations are deleterious, it is even less likely that a small mutation will add advantage and thus, if not deleted by natural selection, the best we can hope for is that natural selection is neutral to it.
4. the conjecture is that many of these small changes, could lead up to the appearance of a new function, even one that would require 100 nucleotides of new code (where #1 stated it would be impossible as one single jump).
What I understand very well is that one has to have a big helping of 'faith' to believe that a bunch of small gradualistic changes can lead to such a high level of complexity. What is the explanation for how this can happen. The neutral theory only offers why natural selection may be considered to not get in the way while these gradualistic changes, which offer no advantage, need to persist through more generations.
Remember, when Dawkins tried to illustrate how gradualism works, he used the "Methinks it.." program he wrote. When the correct letter popped into the right location, his program artificially selected it and kept it there. That artifact was a teleological 'neutral' mechanism. That is: the programmed function of 'selection' was constructed to stay neutral once the right code fell into place.
See? There IS no explanation for how natural selection can pull along the piecemeal path toward some new function, unless.... Unless evolution works more like Dawkins program than we think it does.