Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

...
BTW, philosopher Karl Popper said that evolution was 'unfalsifiable' and therefore not a scientific theory. Of course, I'm sure you read the rebuttal and it fit your groupie mindset - so you buy that.
When a theory has as much support as evolution, it is difficult for a single piece of evidence to show it wrong - new evidence we get today allows us to revise estimates of when species existed. However, if that picture strayed too far from common ancestry e.g. a pre-cambrian fossil rabbit, then evolution would be effectively falsified.

So, your alternate theory for no fossil record (coelacanth, for example) is that an entire population just poofed into existence in a Goddidit kind of way? That's a pretty extraordinary claim - you'd need strong evidence for that. What do you have? No evidence! :)
 
BTW, philosopher Karl Popper said that evolution was 'unfalsifiable' and therefore not a scientific theory.
Why isn't evolution falsifiable? You just need to point to any species that apeared out of nowhere and you would have your falsification.

So Karl Popper was wrong. But he was probably right that evolution will never be falsified.
 
What part of evolution is it, that you comfort yourself with, that I must not understand?

I think now would be a good point to refer back to an earlier post of VN's...

1. Cambridge explosion. Darwin-faith-speak fills the gap with the explanation that the fossil record is lacking because the precursors' body parts were too soft to be preserved (explain away lack of evidence).
Bravo :clap:
 
What is a troll?
What is trolling?
What is woo?

I know I tried to look up woo, but never found a definition. I can guess at what you mean by the first two, but why don't you translate? Thanks.

Basically, a troll is someone that says things that are deliberately contrary to the beliefs or opinions of people on the forum. Like a teenager coming over here and saying : "God will save you all" and waiting for the reaction. What they say isn't what they think. They just want to set people off.
 
But if some reptile, such as Tuatara, has not left fossil evidence for 100 MY, he is assumed extinct. Then when we find he lives today, we presume it to have existed during that span where no fossil evidence supports it. That's what evolutionary science is riddled with - bias and evidence fitting. Presume one way for one species and the other way for the other species - to make it fit your paradigm.

Actually, the fact that it is found live today IS evidence that it lived through that period.

You do not feel comfortable outside of the safety in numbers of the huge crowd who subscribe to the evolution paradigm. I think you well fit the groupie definition.

...says the man who doesn't know what evidence is.

If I am a groupie, who is my leader? I am a contrarian, not a follower. Most of what I invent as contrary ideas, I believe I thought of myself at some level, and then searched and found there exist others who also have had the same ideas.

Yeah, that's the right word: ideas. Now prove them, and we'll talk.
 
Oh wait, more blatantly erroneous statements that show a misunderstanding of evolutionary theory. :eek:
drfrank, are you unaware of recent discovery that all mammals/birds are genetically equidistant from fish? Darwinism would predict a taxonomical relationship instead of equidistance. Why do we have some genes that are incredibly similar to those in the fly? The common ancestor of anthropods and vertabrates were cambrian and so simple that the need for those genes in that common ancestor is unthinkable.
Sentences 1 & 2: Blatant misunderstanding of evolutionary theory
Sentence 3 & 4: Really should find the answer to this blindingly obvious in light of body plans (e.g. hox genes) and proteins coding for basic cellular mechanisms.

ding ding ding! We have a winner! :footinmou

Edit: Oh, and two bonus marks for spelling both arthropod and vertebrate incorrectly. Your spelling is usually fine, so this seems to indicate unfamiliarity with the terms.
 
Last edited:
This is one of my favorites. This is VonNeumann's misinterpretation of the Neutral Theory:
I have no problem with so-called micro-evolution. I can see that there is already a huge variability in the genome of canines and adaptation within the given variability is pretty obvious. I imagine you could isolate some dogs and within a million years they may not be able to cross breed. If this is micro-evolution then I believe in micro-evolution. But I could also believe that apes could have evolved from humans That would also be micro-evolution. One ingredient of micro-evolution is it results in variability already in the genetic data. Another added ingredient would allow for some translocations or other small scrambling of the information that was already there. Enough said about the RM side of the RM/NS model of micro-e. Now for the NS side. The natural selection side of the model is pretty simplistic, in my thinking, and also there is nothing to argue here. Not if there is already a sufficient amount of biological systems present and competing and all that. I see NS as simple 'negative feedback' that 'deletes' products of RM that are not selected because they are not well adapted .

Macro-e is hard to define. One definition could be 'that which is NOT micro-e' but evolutionists believe macro-e is simply an extrapolation of micro-e. I am astonished at that simplistic thinking because it is not very critical thinking to simply say that a bunch of micro-e over enough time produces macro-e. There are two points I would introduce for my scope of macro-e:
1. macro-e must result in significantly sizeable new information
2. natural selection must stay neutral during the micro-e process, only to become a stabilizer at the end of the macro-e process.

So item#1, that macro produces sizeable increases in the genome, representing new information, is based on my belief that there are no intermediate steps for some structures. Take as an example chlorophyll, even though it may not be a good enough example. If there are no light-to-energy conversion molecules lesser than chlorophyll, there are no precursors. So chlorophyll had to be coded for completely at once. This would be macro evolution unless there was already a similar molecule for some other purpose, that could be changed by a micro-e process. The test for macro-e is that a new sequence of significant size appears that RM would have to work on for too long a period of time in order to get in one fell swoop. It is not all that many nucleotides of a specific sequence that it would take more than 20 billion years to occur by chance. ...Even if the primordial soup filled the whole universe volume. Macro evolution is where 'there's not enough time' because the intermediate steps are too large to be micro-e. Natural selection must remain neutral during the intermediate steps that do not express some advantage. So in macro-e, it would be best if natural selection would look the other way for a while. Natural selection can not do anything but stay neutral to help along the intermediate steps. That is another characterisitic of macro-evolution - being where NS must be neutral while new information is forming.
[my emphasis]

VonNeumann revealed in a later post that he was referring to the Neutral Theory. What he didn't understand was that the Neutral Theory has to do simply with the idea that some percentage of alleles in a given genome are more affected by genetic drift than by natural selection, and that the theory in no way suggests that natural selection "looks the other way" at any point in an organism's evolution.
 
:) Surely you are joking. Don't we all 'stand on the shoulders of giants', when we can? I agree with you if one always uses ONE source.
You're like a contrarian groupie. You have a bias towards the opinions of those who doubt evolution. And standing on the shoulders of giants is quite different from arguments from authority. For instance, referencing Karl Popper's opinion that evolution is unfalsifiable, rather than outlining the reasons with which you agree, in your own words. Not only is it lazy, it's fallacious.
 
Basically, a troll is someone that says things that are deliberately contrary to the beliefs or opinions of people on the forum. Like a teenager coming over here and saying : "God will save you all" and waiting for the reaction. What they say isn't what they think. They just want to set people off.
I do want to get reactions. But unless I poke, I do not know to what extent some of the ideas are contrary. I'm sure a forum of skeptics is not entirely homogeneous. I want to see what the different flavors are.

You forgot to tell me, what is 'woo'?
 
You're like a contrarian groupie. You have a bias towards the opinions of those who doubt evolution. And standing on the shoulders of giants is quite different from arguments from authority. For instance, referencing Karl Popper's opinion that evolution is unfalsifiable, rather than outlining the reasons with which you agree, in your own words. Not only is it lazy, it's fallacious.
For whatever reason, this thread has turned into 90% VN bashing. About 1/3 of the verbage here is mine and most of the rest of it is a small group of skeptics who have some desire to engage me on this or that point - or want to just throw shots at me.

So, who are the groupies here? Even Complexity can't help but bite my ankle every once in a while. But don't take me wrong. I know it is a negative sort of attraction that pulls people in, not a positive one. ...and I respect every person who joins in, even if they are rude to me. Some just scoff, and others give kind suggestions, and others seem to be sort of mean.

But I think all of you are a little curious, and there's nothing wrong with that.
 
This is one of my favorites. This is VonNeumann's misinterpretation of the Neutral Theory:
[my emphasis]

VonNeumann revealed in a later post that he was referring to the Neutral Theory. What he didn't understand was that the Neutral Theory has to do simply with the idea that some percentage of alleles in a given genome are more affected by genetic drift than by natural selection, and that the theory in no way suggests that natural selection "looks the other way" at any point in an organism's evolution.
You suggest I do not understand something. To me, it appears you have not applied a sufficient amount of critical thinking. You fault me for thinking beyond the weak explanations and lack of explanations. That is not a matter of my misunderstanding nor lack thereof, it is a matter of what level of explanation I will accept as plausible.

Follow this:
1. the amount of combinations of 100 neucleotides (a moderately small sized protein) is on the order of about 10^160. ...Too big a jump to happen in this universe.
2. Because of #1, in order for RM/NS to work, RM must come up with a gradual series of smaller mutations, one at one time, than something as large as #1.
3. Notwithstanding that most (understatement) mutations are deleterious, it is even less likely that a small mutation will add advantage and thus, if not deleted by natural selection, the best we can hope for is that natural selection is neutral to it.
4. the conjecture is that many of these small changes, could lead up to the appearance of a new function, even one that would require 100 nucleotides of new code (where #1 stated it would be impossible as one single jump).

What I understand very well is that one has to have a big helping of 'faith' to believe that a bunch of small gradualistic changes can lead to such a high level of complexity. What is the explanation for how this can happen. The neutral theory only offers why natural selection may be considered to not get in the way while these gradualistic changes, which offer no advantage, need to persist through more generations.

Remember, when Dawkins tried to illustrate how gradualism works, he used the "Methinks it.." program he wrote. When the correct letter popped into the right location, his program artificially selected it and kept it there. That artifact was a teleological 'neutral' mechanism. That is: the programmed function of 'selection' was constructed to stay neutral once the right code fell into place.

See? There IS no explanation for how natural selection can pull along the piecemeal path toward some new function, unless.... Unless evolution works more like Dawkins program than we think it does.
 
No, I meant PRATT fall: Point Refuted A Thousand Times.

Besides, if you can come up with a falsification method, it means its falsifiable, and therefore testable. Isn't that what Popper and other evolutionary scientists do?
 
You forgot to tell me, what is 'woo'?
Sometimes alternately referred to as a 'creduloid'. Someone who exhibits a penchant for pseudoscientific and/or paranormal ideas and faulty or absent critical thinking. Someone who supports these ideas with conjecture, speculation, anecdote, and fallacious arguments.

That's the general idea, anyway.
 
VonNeumann said:
Follow this:
1. the amount of combinations of 100 neucleotides (a moderately small sized protein) is on the order of about 10^160. ...Too big a jump to happen in this universe.
2. Because of #1, in order for RM/NS to work, RM must come up with a gradual series of smaller mutations, one at one time, than something as large as #1.
3. Notwithstanding that most (understatement) mutations are deleterious, it is even less likely that a small mutation will add advantage and thus, if not deleted by natural selection, the best we can hope for is that natural selection is neutral to it.
4. the conjecture is that many of these small changes, could lead up to the appearance of a new function, even one that would require 100 nucleotides of new code (where #1 stated it would be impossible as one single jump).
...
See? There IS no explanation for how natural selection can pull along the piecemeal path toward some new function, unless.... Unless evolution works more like Dawkins program than we think it does.
Here, run the Evj program and then explain to me how it could possibly work:

http://www.lecb.ncifcrf.gov/~toms/papers/ev/evj/

You appear to have no idea of the power of huge populations and deep time. Also, proteins aren't made up of neucleotides.

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom