Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

New functions seem to appear over time. That does not force 'descent with modification' to be true.

So you're just denying that NEW functions that weren't there before are new information. Is that correct ?

I still you're just been willfully "skeptical" of darwinism. It seems more and more obvious to me that you're just trying to justify a religious position.

This said... If new functions appear, then they probably are inherited unless your theoretical designer somehow sends new "updates", as you claimed, through viruses for example. Of course, this does not fit with the observed data.

Something sufficiently complex can provide new function with mere parametric change.

Yes but that IS new information. An exemple of this, using a simple word, has been provided to you in this very thread. I'll provide my own example:

The word DEAR can become READ rather easily. Obviously, this is NEW information. The READ word wasn't there before, but its components were.

Add to that notion the fact that we do not know if the amount of genetic information on the earth 300MYA was not already sufficient to make an organism as complex as h.sapiens. I may be wrong, but I think that's what Francis Crick proposed (need to read his book). If so, then we would be faced with no increase in worldly genetic information over the span of 300MY while a definite increase in function occurred.

Who cares ? "Information" is not merely added genes. It can be transformed ones. And yes, new genes and new chromosomes are added. In fact, there are a number of species with MORE chromosomes and genes than humans. And some with less. Obviously something's been added at one point, unless you contend that there were hundreds of chromosomes in the original life forms, and it's been decaying ever since...

For you Belz and others who keep asking me why there is not enough time to create new information using the theoretical mechanism of random mutation and Natural selection, I ask that you go read what high profile people have published on this: Hoyle, Wickramasinghe, Crick ...

No, YOU provide quotes, links and references. Your burden, not mine.

That was probably the wedge that produced the crack in my darwin-faith.

What is that ? An attack. How mature.
 
VonNeumann said:
I've heard many say that the reason they believe in evolution is because 'it is the best scientific theory we have'. In other words, they take it by default.

That's... not very smart, Von. Obviously, when it's the best you have, you pretty much DO pick that one by default. Besides, darwinism is supported by tons of evidence. God ? Not really. Milk ? Why not.

For me, I think it is too simple a theory and certainly cannot myself extrapolate it to time before the first organisms.

That's not what evolution's all about. It's about the origin OF SPECIES, not life.

I can stretch to accept evolution could explain descent with modification for the past ~300MY, iff there was sufficient complexity in the world store of genetic information to begin with, starting from that time

Yes, thanks to your skewed definition of information.

Still, that leaves no explanation for origins of the first life forms - not for me and not for you. Speculations and conjectures? Yes. But evolutionary theory is out of scope for those beginnings.

So... DESIGNER! Right ? Right ?? Wrong!

So why do you harp on me about why 'there must be a designer'? I take it by default much as many scientists take evolution by default.

No, no and no. Evidence, evidence, EVIDENCE. Repeat, please.

We all take origins on faith. So while it is unresolved, I find myself biased toward design. So I think that I have answered your question.

Well, well. "We all take origins on faith". Trying to justify your lack of scientific rigor ?

VonNeumann said:
Sorry but I've never seen such a clever thing as an elegant palindrome.

Who the hell cares ?

It is interesting to me that it appears like a great example of 'new information' to a believer (such as you)

I'm sure he needed that last part to understand who you were talking about.

while to me it appears like a great example of something that is cleverly designed.

You don't really want me to explain that, do you ?

Remember all the people on this thread who want to shove down my throat that a designer should be perfect and efficient? Man! How more efficient can you be than to design something that you merely need to shift fewer than 3 bases and get a whole new, and needed, enzyme? Where are all you guys now? Doesn't efficiency=design?:D

Ah, NOW the designer's perfect ?
 
VonNeumann said:
I'm not nitpicking - I mean that it is seriously incomplete.

Irrelevant, again. Relativity doesn't explain the origins of life, either.

How do you explain first life and the immense 'just so' complexity that came before it?

I think you mean "simplicity".

VonNeumann said:
What are the other theories? Lamarkism? Spontaneous generation? It seems to me that the only theories from which Darwinism was selected were all spontaneous generation theories - get something for nothing type theories.

You mean, like ID ?

Did I say "theory"? Evolution is conjecture - so is ID, conjecture.

You have no idea what a theory is, then.

You yourself allow for plausibility of a designer there, you just don't think she/it/he poked his fingers in anymore after that - right?

You're either completely unaware of what you're saying, or intellectually dishonest. You said that evolution was too simple a theory, and then you claim to believe in a theory that goes as such: "God did it". I guess you really meant "complex" when you said "simple". That'd explain that other blunder a few lines up.

I could mock it too and just say "what kind of theory is 'god did it'?". But OTOH, it is not simple at all: You design. I design. How in hell do we do it? We haven't the faintest! Is it simple, then? No. It's so fantastically complex, that we cannot even encapsulate it.

Argument from incredulity.

Back to the incompetent designer again. Which brings up another point: is the designer perfect, or not ?

That gets into consciousness. What the hell is that? We don't know.

So.... DESIGNER! Right ? Right ? Wrong!

So ID is not simple - it is exceedingly complex. Our idea of how design works is nearly vacant - but we know it can be done - we do it. To me, it is less of a leap that something similar to our own mental activity made the complexity we see, than the leap of faith that randomness can do it.

Of course. Anthropomorphism. It's easier to you to imagine something similar than something you don't understand. But the question remains: who made the designer ? I mean... it's exceedingly complex, right ? So...

As by this theory, innumerable transitional forms must have existed. Why do we not find them embedded in the crust of the earth? Why is not all nature in confusion [of halfway species] instead of being, as we see them, well-defined species?"—Charles Darwin,

Oh, no! Someone who lived almost two centuries ago said that our most recent theory is inadequate ! What ever shall we do ?

More quote mining.

Yeah, yeah. I'm sure I can get a quote from your mother saying you were built from mechanical parts, but that doesn't make it true.

ETA: Sorry for the long posts, people.
 
Not to mention, there *does* seem to be a lot of information and study on the origins of the first living cells. I honestly hadn't looked into in much before, but it seems like Sidney W. Fox and others have show that under certain conditions that are found on Earth (thermal vents in the oceans, geysers on land), how life came into being from nonlife.

Basically:

"Fox found that inanimate amino acids, when heated, reproducibly and non-randomly join to form thermal proteins. The amino acids determined their own arrangement in the proteins."

"Fox showed that these new thermal proteins, when placed in water, would self-organize, within minutes, into relatively uniform microspheres having virtually all the properties of a living cell: They displayed growth, metabolism, reproduction and response to stimuli -- thus meeting the basic criteria expected of living organisms."

This, of course, is not the only source of information on the topic. And doesn't answer all the questions. But there seems to be a lot more understanding of how the process can work than I knew about. It just seems like one more reason it doesn't makes sense to assume a designer had anything to do with it.
 
Evolution isn't intended to explain the origins of life, just like gravity isn't intended to explain why I don't fall through this solid floor. Quantum mechanics (specifically electron-electron repulsion), not gravity explains why I don't move through the floor. Abiogenesis, not evolution, is intended to explain the origins of life. Abiogenesis still needs a good bit of work (such as nailing down the Earth's original atmosphere), but that lack of knowledge does NOT mean that abiogenesis isn't possible. As far as we know, some guy out there might discover the most likely process (and there do seem to be plenty of other viable methods that could be occurring on other planets with different histories), rather than giving up and using his failure as "evidence" of design.

You can't put ignorance or lack of imagination into an evidence locker.
 
yeah, nice quote mining there, VonNeumann - everyone knows real scientists just spew enormous lists of quotes to prove their case. Including all the classic Darwin quotes in there was a nice, yet slightly embarrassing, touch.

I'd also like to know whether that Colin Patterson quote was completely fabricated or not. You can find a decent article examining Patteron's true opinions here, associated with a different misquote of him by Creationists.

Seriously, if you want to be taken as anything other than a joke, please don't resort to identical tactics to Creationists: it severely damages any credibility that you may be trying to achieve.
Yeh, OK. I had a point. One, that the Darwin quote is still valid TODAY. Also, that there are many non-creationists (non-IDers) who doubt evolution is a real scientific theory. You have to admit, I have been pummeled by questions of the sort that, why not just remind you all that there is a good amount of incredulity amongst many who claim to NOT be ID bent.

I'll also mention that I don't care if you or others think I am joking, or am a joke, or am insane. Embarrassing? You've got to be joshing. I am incognito, first off. Also, I am a freethinker so I am proud to be contrarian and relish being of irritation to those who have grooves worn in their neural networks.

I am here to see what YOU think and believe. I could not care less WHAT you think of me, however. I have told you about many of my ideas and thoughts and what I consider relatively plausible. So many of you think I do that to try to convert you. I'm smarter than that. The most I might expect is that some of you may have subconsciously started to consider some different views - but it may not hit you for years.

Drfrank, your response was most entertaining, thank you :) .
 
Yeh, OK. I had a point. One, that the Darwin quote is still valid TODAY.
Why is the Darwin quote still valid today?

Also, that there are many non-creationists (non-IDers) who doubt evolution is a real scientific theory.
How many Steves are there on your list? "Steve" or "Stephen" is the first name of approximately 1% of Americans. The NCSE Project Steve gives you a list of currently 725 scientist with first name Steve who support evolution. Just to show you that if we are in the numbers game, you are up against strong opposition!
 
Yeh, OK. I had a point. One, that the Darwin quote is still valid TODAY. Also, that there are many non-creationists (non-IDers) who doubt evolution is a real scientific theory. You have to admit, I have been pummeled by questions of the sort that, why not just remind you all that there is a good amount of incredulity amongst many who claim to NOT be ID bent.

I'll also mention that I don't care if you or others think I am joking, or am a joke, or am insane. Embarrassing? You've got to be joshing. I am incognito, first off. Also, I am a freethinker so I am proud to be contrarian and relish being of irritation to those who have grooves worn in their neural networks.

I am here to see what YOU think and believe. I could not care less WHAT you think of me, however. I have told you about many of my ideas and thoughts and what I consider relatively plausible. So many of you think I do that to try to convert you. I'm smarter than that. The most I might expect is that some of you may have subconsciously started to consider some different views - but it may not hit you for years.

Drfrank, your response was most entertaining, thank you :) .
I think you'd need to actually provide some evidence or reasoned arguments before any of us might start to seriously consider different views, even subconsciously :rolleyes:

I, for one, have certainly considered all the arguments and evidence of ID and Creationism, and have found them incorrect and, on many occasions, just plain dishonest. I also had a look at the strong panspermia stuff you linked to, and they were just stealing Creationist arguments, which immediately lumps them into the same category: telling flat out lies about current evidence and evolutionary theory. If their site was not just full of the same old demonstrable falsehoods, that shining hallmark of pseudoscientists, then I may not have immediately dismissed them as misguided fools.

Of course, I know that no matter now much evidence for evolution we present that you'll continue with your bizarre beliefs.

You originally `believed' in evolution, but you did not understand it. You then read some arguments against evolution which you couldn't answer due to your ignorance on the subject. This made you alter your beliefs, believing this was actual evidence of incorrectness in evolution, by assuming that if you could not answer those questions then no one could (quite pretentious, I have to say). And now, finally, you too argue based on no evidence and bring up decades-old lies.

The cycle is complete ;)

On the other hand, when I read Creationist/ID arguments and didn't have immediate answers to them, I searched scientific sources and determined that those arguments were wrong, and how the evidence had been fabricated or distorted. Moreover, I found that these people had been using the same discredited arguments for decades. I witnessed first hand how dishonest proponents of such theories can be, and how they never revise their ideas in light of new evidence. I now understand a hell of a lot more about the modern synthesis than I did then. I also understand why your viral DNA patching hypothesis simply would not produce the evidence that we see today: it's a shame that you do not, or are in denial.
 
Last edited:
One thing I noted is that it is easy to hit the hot button on some personalities around here. I use big words:confused: ? I only used the word 'obfuscate' to be humorous (see, it is a word not many people use and when you look it up you go - cool - I see - a self-referential irony.).

I do not wish to be impolite but, to respond in like: your post looked to me like sophmoric jibberish. What you had to say in this post looks mostly like emotionalism (probably because evolution is your religion) and you also stepped into the most obvious folly... You used a designed object (automobiles) to try to metaphorically illustrate something that I'm sure you will swear is not designed (organisms). What were you thinking?:boggled:

Let us try to talk about 'new information' in a realm that is less vague, shall we? Let's try this: How do you suppose that the new information of DNA, in the first place, emerged here? How did the structure emerge, with the amino acids, the codon mapping, the sugar structures... How did this emerge from, say, starting with atoms?

Well I don't think we need to start with atoms...I think you can start with DNA...and if you're up on the latest science, it looks like the first life forms (or rather pre-life forms) were just DNA segments (viruses)...There is lots and lots of information on the emergence of life, and I am not about to explain it to a person who hasn't even got some of the basics down. Why don't you read Dawkins book (An Ancestor's Tale) and then we'll talk. You've obviously read ID crap, because you bring up their old Haldane's Dilemma argument which has been answered for some time. If what I wrote sounds like jibberish, rest assured you can not yet understand the answers to the questions you ask--you seem to have a vested interest in your ignorance perhaps...or maybe you just want to keep sticking with your theory because it makes you feel good...but don't ask questions that you don't really want to know the answer too...nor do you have the slightest bit of capacity for understanding if your latest science comes from creationist texts. Check out a genomic website...DNA website...it is all there...but start you are way way behind...start with the basics...a little Darwin...a little Dawkins...Matt Ridley, Steve Jones...Scientific American...BBC radio 4--these questions have been answered. And in the places where the answers aren't clear...space aliens don't really fit--nor are they needed...we just got to get the next piece of the puzzle...and it's likely to be earth bound (though the first viruses may have, in fact, come from space--read this months Scientific American (I think)...it might give you a little more credence in discussing your space theory.
 
I'll also mention that I don't care if you or others think I am joking, or am a joke, or am insane. Embarrassing? You've got to be joshing. I am incognito, first off. Also, I am a freethinker so I am proud to be contrarian and relish being of irritation to those who have grooves worn in their neural networks.

Careful, now. That's the definition of a troll.

The most I might expect is that some of you may have subconsciously started to consider some different views - but it may not hit you for years.

Subconsciously ? You're not THAT type, too ?
 
Just to show you that if we are in the numbers game, you are up against strong opposition!
..if we are in the numbers game? You believe in a concept such as: democratic majority vote for science? Crap! I hope not. At least in the US, who do you think would 'win'? Have you seen the Gallup polls?

I'd prefer to go on evidence. What Darwin said that is still true today is the lack of intermediate forms - what Gould called punk eek - and that which is still a problem in using the fossil record to cite the gradualism for which there is no fossil evidence.
 
Careful, now. That's the definition of a troll.
Subconsciously ? You're not THAT type, too ?
What is a troll?
What is trolling?
What is woo?

I know I tried to look up woo, but never found a definition. I can guess at what you mean by the first two, but why don't you translate? Thanks.
 
Well I don't think we need to start with atoms...I think you can start with DNA...and if you're up on the latest science, it looks like the first life forms (or rather pre-life forms) were just DNA segments (viruses)...
I really don't know what to tell you since you think you know so much. Viruses are dormant without cellular mechanisms. They cannot reproduce. They cannot metabolize. They are like software sitting on a memory medium - sans computer. ...surely, since you know so much, you know this. It is doubtful, to absurd proportions, that DNA could have somehow emerged without some extremely complex set of other bio-machines surrounding it to work with it. RNA is a relatively new discovery and was first thought might be a precursor for DNA (circa early '80s). I believe most everyone has thrown that out. Proteins are a more likely candidate IMO.


There is lots and lots of information on the emergence of life, and I am not about to explain it to a person who hasn't even got some of the basics down.
Lots of information. Bits and pieces. Have you read Kauffman's "Origins of Order"? He wrote the book because there are no theories (ideas? yes. conjecture. yes) for pre-cellular origins. He postulated autocatalytic sets as a mechanism. Kauffman is a very smart dude and this book took him at least 10 years to write. Go read it and tell me if you received "lots of information" that help you bridge the gap.

Why don't you read Dawkins book (An Ancestor's Tale) and then we'll talk.
I've read all or almost all of Dawkins.

If what I wrote sounds like jibberish...
Please, calm down and absorb this:
1. I was a darwinist and amateur paleontologist at age 8. I hunted my own fossils. I read Simpson by age 12. I wanted to be a paleontologist but fell in love with math/physics at 12 years old.
2. I understand evolution. It is not difficult to understand. The basic principles were in fact simple enough for me to understand it at age 8 and I was not a child prodigy. I believed it and it was very much my mindset most of my life.
3. Stop presuming I have not already read every book you have read on evolution. My guess is that I've read considerably more than have you, on the subject.
4. I am simply MORE skeptical than you are.
 
...
1. I was a darwinist and amateur paleontologist at age 8. I hunted my own fossils. I read Simpson by age 12. I wanted to be a paleontologist but fell in love with math/physics at 12 years old.
2. I understand evolution. It is not difficult to understand. The basic principles were in fact simple enough for me to understand it at age 8 and I was not a child prodigy. I believed it and it was very much my mindset most of my life.
3. Stop presuming I have not already read every book you have read on evolution. My guess is that I've read considerably more than have you, on the subject.
4. I am simply MORE skeptical than you are.
Wow, you knew stuff about dinosaurs and liked paleontology when you were 8, and now you believe in an odd version of ID? That's it - I'll call all those misguided evolutionary biologists that think they're onto something and get them to halt one of the most productive research programs in human history :p

If 2 and/or 3 are true, then you either haven't understood the theory or simply select strawmen of evolution to beat on for fun. Which is it? If required, I can trawl back over this thread to find blatantly erroneous statements you have made, although it could take a fair while to collect all of them :rolleyes:

4 is certainly not true, as you have shown no regard for evidence in this matter. Positing the unfalsifiable hypothesis of a simulation, concurrently with designed viruses that have no resemblance to the currently observed genetic evidence, is about as skeptical as Uri Geller's groupie collection.
 
You originally `believed' in evolution, but you did not understand it.
What part of evolution is it, that you comfort yourself with, that I must not understand?

This is absurd. I can easily see through your simplistic thinking that only ignorant people or unintelligent people would not believe evolution. If they believed it and no longer believe it, they must have been really silly - must never had really understood it.

Let us not talk about me; instead, what mental deficiency did Hoyle have? Was he ignorant? Did he not understand? Was he dishonest or (as Dawkins might say) wicked?

It is only because of your bias that you believe the rubuttals so complete, when someone dissents. For the umpteenth time, you never said anything about the avian phlanges rebuttal

I also understand why your viral DNA patching hypothesis simply would not produce the evidence that we see today: it's a shame that you do not, or are in denial.
A shame? :) You want to shame me for rising above the balogna? Perhaps you should catch up with the times and see for yourself about how this is already known to work. Go read about the DuPont fiasco with their DNA horizontal transfer of their patented DNA. Why is horizontal DNA transfer hard for you to understand?
 
I can trawl back over this thread to find blatantly erroneous statements you have made, although it could take a fair while to collect all of them :rolleyes:
A while back, you said that there were no human fossil remains ever found with or in the same strata [I think you implied] with alleged precursors, such as with H. Habilis. That was in response to my putting forward the idea that H. Habilis may have made a nice dinner for H.Sapiens. This might be the kind of "erroneous statement" I have made? It is very consistent with evidence, that we cannot find fossils of some species for huge spans of times, yet we presume they existed over that time. In the case of H. Sapiens, you would presume they did not exist during H. Habilis. But if some reptile, such as Tuatara, has not left fossil evidence for 100 MY, he is assumed extinct. Then when we find he lives today, we presume it to have existed during that span where no fossil evidence supports it. That's what evolutionary science is riddled with - bias and evidence fitting. Presume one way for one species and the other way for the other species - to make it fit your paradigm.


4 is certainly not true, as you have shown no regard for evidence in this matter. Positing the unfalsifiable hypothesis of a simulation, concurrently with designed viruses that have no resemblance to the currently observed genetic evidence, is about as skeptical as Uri Geller's groupie collection.
You do not feel comfortable outside of the safety in numbers of the huge crowd who subscribe to the evolution paradigm. I think you well fit the groupie definition. If I am a groupie, who is my leader? I am a contrarian, not a follower. Most of what I invent as contrary ideas, I believe I thought of myself at some level, and then searched and found there exist others who also have had the same ideas. I find that I am left with nearly nothing, that someone else has not already thought of, themselves.

I think many of us will live to see that 'simulation' and 'digital physics' will finally move into the mainstream. When eyes finally open to it, many will wonder how it was missed for so long. You may scoff from your comfortable perch :) .

BTW, philosopher Karl Popper said that evolution was 'unfalsifiable' and therefore not a scientific theory. Of course, I'm sure you read the rebuttal and it fit your groupie mindset - so you buy that.
 
VonNeumann - still trolling, I see. You've already publically admitted to lying.

Why, exactly, are you posting in this forum?

Why do you care what skeptics think?

What could you possibly hope to accomplish by continuing to post drivel?
 
..if we are in the numbers game? You believe in a concept such as: democratic majority vote for science? Crap! I hope not. At least in the US, who do you think would 'win'? Have you seen the Gallup polls?
Well, you started posting a long list of quotes that were supposed to seem intimidating, so I thought you were in the numbers game! Both lists were at least of scientists. You are quite right that evolution - and cosmology, plate tectonics, relativity, and lots of other scientific theories would get voted down if science was determined by a democratic vote in the US.

I'd prefer to go on evidence. What Darwin said that is still true today is the lack of intermediate forms - what Gould called punk eek - and that which is still a problem in using the fossil record to cite the gradualism for which there is no fossil evidence.
What is the definition of an intermediate form? How would you recognise when you have one? If you have a population of type A species, and a part of it develop a new trait and becomes type B species, and a part of that develops into type C series, would it be possible to nail down a transition form?

Today, we see lots and lots of variation ("races") in existing species depending on geographic location. When sufficiently separated, for instance because they develop mating habits that prevent them from mating with other races, it is difficult to see how this can prevent two different races to become different species over time. Which would indicate that we see transition forms right here right now.
 
BTW, philosopher Karl Popper said that evolution was 'unfalsifiable' and therefore not a scientific theory. Of course, I'm sure you read the rebuttal and it fit your groupie mindset - so you buy that.
One characteristic of a groupie is that they use a lot of arguments from authority.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom