Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

You are confused about "adding to the genome". Just as adding words to a book or a recipe don't necessarily make it more "suitable"--nor does "adding info." to the genome. Most of the stuff in our genome is junk--filler--stuff that gets passed on because it causes no harm (and it's useful in forensic and paternity analysis)--Genes of more primative ancestors are in us too, but most are not expressed-- With one alphabet, you can write all sorts of stuff--from the simple to the complex...DNA is sort of like that. And some mutations or new arrangements or inversions or nondisjunction or point mutation etc. happen to be beneficial to the vectors that carry it--most aren't--but since the vectors don't live to reproduce over successive generations we are not aware of mind boggling number of "failures"--it's only the successes that we see...only the successes live to create new mutations and new genetic combinations (via sexual reproduction).

Von--why do you reach for such unlikely explanations when the more mundane do a far better job. Remember, UFO's just mean "unidentified flying object"--and they are only unidentified until someone takes the time to study and identify them. That's a long long stretch from presuming such objects are craft driven by aliens.

Life is a simulation for what? Of what? I guess I concur that it's a huge unfolding experiment, but I think the only observers of said experiment are we humans--just like we, humans, are the only observers of the internet (also complex and seemingly "designed"--though no designer--just an evolution of technology and ingenuity and ideas that work.) Of course I guess aliens could have planted the idea of the internet into collective human consciousness while inserting anal probes...
 
Yes, this is so good.
Thanks.

It shows how you think that something that purportedly explains everything (it's both a floor wax and a dessert topping) can be explained in a few identity statements.
What "identity statements"? I just explained the entire process of evolution.

Evolution is so simple.
Yes, it is. And your claim is false.
 
New functions seem to appear over time. That does not force 'descent with modification' to be true. Something sufficiently complex can provide new function with mere parametric change. Think of a function with input parameters where the value of an input selects different functions - all while the amount of information defining the function and the amount of information defining the input parameters, is fixed.
That is not how DNA works. Mutations change the program.

So my answer is: could be True, could be False.
But either way, is worthless nonsense.

Add to that notion the fact that we do not know if the amount of genetic information on the earth 300MYA was not already sufficient to make an organism as complex as h.sapiens.
VN, that doesn't mean anything.

I may be wrong
You're wrong.

If so, then we would be faced with no increase in worldly genetic information over the span of 300MY while a definite increase in function occurred.
We have demonstrated to you already that new information is constantly being created by mutations.

Then one day, I decided to calculate for myself and realized what I was blind to, before. That was probably the wedge that produced the crack in my darwin-faith.
VN, your statements in this thread have proved beyond a doubt that you don't have the faintest idea how to apply your calculations. You can add and multiply all you like, but since you start from false assumptions, your results will be meaningless.

Case in point: The nylonase mutation. You asserted that no new information had been created. Yet there it is, indisputably: Information that was not present before. New information was created. You are wrong, VN. Simple as that. You are wrong.
 
Last edited:
Von,
we can add no more letters to the alphabet and no more words to our vocabulary--and yet we can create endlessly complex compilations of these words and letters...and endless jibberish as you've proved. You are so misguided in your understanding that it's as if you are saying, "the world can't be spherical because my careful calculations show that the water in the oceans will spill out." More information is not necessarily better information--case in point--Down Syndrome--caused by non disjunction of chromosome #21 in the egg or sperm--gives a person 47 chromosomes. Chimps have 48. Humans have 46. A single deletion or mutation in a particular gene can have huge effects--example: Dwarfism (point mutation in collagen gene)--junk DNA can contain inactive genes which become active due to translocation--

Look,-- All of the atoms that will make all cars (present and future) exist right on our planet--right now--but the cars that will exist are only potential at this point--The same could be said for everything that will ever exist on this planet--(although assembly and life will require energy from the sun--this energy exists already too, however)

Whatever amazing technology will come in the future the ancestors of that technology is already here...as are all the elements that will make technology.
Nothing new needs to be added to the universe and no god needs to participate and no designer needs to have a plan for all such technology that will occur.

No new brain matter needs to be added to your brain for your thinking to evolve. Your big words are causing obfsucation and your steadfast misunderstanding as to the term " adding information" is helping prop up a false notion that you wish to believe. If your goal is to convince people other than yourself, you might want to brush up on some of the latest information on genetics before spouting your ignorance to those more educated than you on the subject. Otherwise, you seem like a blustery woo trying to convince himself by convincing others. (pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.)
 
Your argument still seems to be that there may or not be some flaws with some aspects of accepted theory of evolution, so therefore there must be a designer. How does any of this add up to there must be a designer?
I've heard many say that the reason they believe in evolution is because 'it is the best scientific theory we have'. In other words, they take it by default.

For me, I think it is too simple a theory and certainly cannot myself extrapolate it to time before the first organisms. I can stretch to accept evolution could explain descent with modification for the past ~300MY, iff there was sufficient complexity in the world store of genetic information to begin with, starting from that time

Still, that leaves no explanation for origins of the first life forms - not for me and not for you. Speculations and conjectures? Yes. But evolutionary theory is out of scope for those beginnings.

So why do you harp on me about why 'there must be a designer'? I take it by default much as many scientists take evolution by default. The only other non-designer answer I entertain is the anthropic principle , which is an OK conjecture that is logical to me, but it is a non-scientific conjecture as well.

We all take origins on faith. So while it is unresolved, I find myself biased toward design. So I think that I have answered your question.
 
Von,
we can add no more letters to the alphabet and no more words to our vocabulary--and yet we can create endlessly complex compilations of these words and letters...and endless jibberish as you've proved. You are so misguided in your understanding that it's as if you are saying, "the world can't be spherical because my careful calculations show that the water in the oceans will spill out." More information is not necessarily better information--case in point--Down Syndrome--caused by non disjunction of chromosome #21 in the egg or sperm--gives a person 47 chromosomes. Chimps have 48. Humans have 46. A single deletion or mutation in a particular gene can have huge effects--example: Dwarfism (point mutation in collagen gene)--junk DNA can contain inactive genes which become active due to translocation--

Look,-- All of the atoms that will make all cars (present and future) exist right on our planet--right now--but the cars that will exist are only potential at this point--The same could be said for everything that will ever exist on this planet--(although assembly and life will require energy from the sun--this energy exists already too, however)

Whatever amazing technology will come in the future the ancestors of that technology is already here...as are all the elements that will make technology.
Nothing new needs to be added to the universe and no god needs to participate and no designer needs to have a plan for all such technology that will occur.

No new brain matter needs to be added to your brain for your thinking to evolve. Your big words are causing obfsucation and your steadfast misunderstanding as to the term " adding information" is helping prop up a false notion that you wish to believe. If your goal is to convince people other than yourself, you might want to brush up on some of the latest information on genetics before spouting your ignorance to those more educated than you on the subject. Otherwise, you seem like a blustery woo trying to convince himself by convincing others. (pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.)
One thing I noted is that it is easy to hit the hot button on some personalities around here. I use big words:confused: ? I only used the word 'obfuscate' to be humorous (see, it is a word not many people use and when you look it up you go - cool - I see - a self-referential irony.).

I do not wish to be impolite but, to respond in like: your post looked to me like sophmoric jibberish. What you had to say in this post looks mostly like emotionalism (probably because evolution is your religion) and you also stepped into the most obvious folly... You used a designed object (automobiles) to try to metaphorically illustrate something that I'm sure you will swear is not designed (organisms). What were you thinking?:boggled:

Let us try to talk about 'new information' in a realm that is less vague, shall we? Let's try this: How do you suppose that the new information of DNA, in the first place, emerged here? How did the structure emerge, with the amino acids, the codon mapping, the sugar structures... How did this emerge from, say, starting with atoms?
 
VN, that doesn't mean anything.
Well, go argue with Francis Crick. He thought it meant something.

VN, your statements in this thread have proved beyond a doubt that you don't have the faintest idea how to apply your calculations. You can add and multiply all you like, but since you start from false assumptions, your results will be meaningless.
Well, go argue with Hoyle, et al.

Case in point: The nylonase mutation. You asserted that no new information had been created. Yet there it is, indisputably: Information that was not present before. New information was created. You are wrong, VN. Simple as that. You are wrong.
Nylonase mutation is a frame-shift. You probably would never think of it this way, Pix, but let me try something here.

Suppose you read something such as a poem that had some unusual feature.

"Are we not drawn onward,
we few,
drawn onward to new era?"

You notice that the poem reads the same, forward or backward. Now this is a particularly poor poem since it was conjured merely for its palindromic characteristic, but what if it were elegant, too? Sorry but I've never seen such a clever thing as an elegant palindrome.

Or what if you opened up the instruction book for your new gadget and the instruction book consisted of one sentence, but if you frame shifted it one letter, you would get the 2nd instruction. Frame shift it one letter again, you would get the 3rd instruction, etc.

In either case, I would certainly have to credit the author for being clever in the design of his literary work. Wouldn't you?

In the case of genetic information that can be frame-shifted to bring about new and needed function, this seems very strange to me. Is it common or unusual? From what I have read, it is not real common as far as we know, but not unique either. The immune system uses such clever tricks as this, however.

It is interesting to me that it appears like a great example of 'new information' to a believer (such as you), while to me it appears like a great example of something that is cleverly designed. Remember all the people on this thread who want to shove down my throat that a designer should be perfect and efficient? Man! How more efficient can you be than to design something that you merely need to shift fewer than 3 bases and get a whole new, and needed, enzyme? Where are all you guys now? Doesn't efficiency=design?:D
 
Last edited:
I've heard many say that the reason they believe in evolution is because 'it is the best scientific theory we have'. In other words, they take it by default.

For me, I think it is too simple a theory and certainly cannot myself extrapolate it to time before the first organisms. I can stretch to accept evolution could explain descent with modification for the past ~300MY, iff there was sufficient complexity in the world store of genetic information to begin with, starting from that time

Still, that leaves no explanation for origins of the first life forms - not for me and not for you. Speculations and conjectures? Yes. But evolutionary theory is out of scope for those beginnings.

So why do you harp on me about why 'there must be a designer'? I take it by default much as many scientists take evolution by default. The only other non-designer answer I entertain is the anthropic principle , which is an OK conjecture that is logical to me, but it is a non-scientific conjecture as well.

We all take origins on faith. So while it is unresolved, I find myself biased toward design. So I think that I have answered your question.
VonNeumann,

I know this must feel like a valid answer to you. And I respect that. Saying scientist take evolution by default is not the same as anyone taking a designer by default. Evolution has come observable and predictable evidence. They "take it by default" because after years of rigorous study and review it has matched best with the evidence. It comes from evidence.

You say you have found some fault in it. Fine. I don't agree, but it's good for people to look into it. But even if you have, even if you convinced every scientist on the planet that you have found a major flaw with evolutionary theory, and they all came public saying evolutionary theory was flawed, they wouldn't all stand up and say that the only possibility left is a designer. That's not how it works. These scientists are open to new ideas, but you need to provide evidence to believe them.

I ask why a designer because even if your theory were right and took down all of the pillars of evolutionary theory, I still don't see how that leads you to a designer.

I am not trying to attack your ideas, I honestly still don't understand how your conclusion matches the evidence you believe you've found.
 
I've heard many say that the reason they believe in evolution is because 'it is the best scientific theory we have'. In other words, they take it by default.
Strange way of thinking. I would say that 'the best theory we have' is a statement that says we have evaluated the theories, and this one was the best. That is not the same as a default theory.

You say that you take ID as a default theory, and by doing that, you are actually saying that a theory that does not explain anything, and is not supported by any facts, is preferable to all other theories!

For me, I think it is too simple a theory and certainly cannot myself extrapolate it to time before the first organisms.
Why should you stretch it before the first organisms? Evolution has nothing say about what came before the first organisms! You can have your designer or panspermia there, and evolution would not be affected.

Again, it is strange that you regard evolution as 'too simple', compared to ID that is so simple that it has lost all predictive power![/QUOTE]
 
How do you suppose that the new information of DNA, in the first place, emerged here? How did the structure emerge, with the amino acids, the codon mapping, the sugar structures... How did this emerge from, say, starting with atoms?
What is the relevance of this to the discussion of evolution?
 
In the case of genetic information that can be frame-shifted to bring about new and needed function, this seems very strange to me. Is it common or unusual? From what I have read, it is not real common as far as we know, but not unique either. The immune system uses such clever tricks as this, however.

It is interesting to me that it appears like a great example of 'new information' to a believer (such as you), while to me it appears like a great example of something that is cleverly designed. Remember all the people on this thread who want to shove down my throat that a designer should be perfect and efficient? Man! How more efficient can you be than to design something that you merely need to shift fewer than 3 bases and get a whole new, and needed, enzyme? Where are all you guys now? Doesn't efficiency=design?:D
Funny that you would use this example as a support for your argument, when I would have thought that this was an argument for evolution! Frame shifting seems a relatively simple thing to cause with a mutation, and it would be expected to happen. How many times has a mutation caused a frame shift that merely did not work, and the mutated organism perished? And how many times did it happen with no effect at all, thus adding a new valueless gene that future mutations could work on to create new functions?

Your argument seem much like the anthroposofic principle that we discussed: You have a winning lottery ticket, and it has to be designed specially for you, or what? Here we have a frame shift that created a new function. Elegance or luck? Contrary to the case of the universes, we know that the mutations happens all the time, and it would difficult to imagine that frame shifting does not also happen all the time, so here the verdict clearly goes down on the side of luck.
 
VonNeumann,

I know this must feel like a valid answer to you. And I respect that. Saying scientist take evolution by default is not the same as anyone taking a designer by default. Evolution has come observable and predictable evidence. They "take it by default" because after years of rigorous study and review it has matched best with the evidence. It comes from evidence.

You say you have found some fault in it. Fine. I don't agree, but it's good for people to look into it. But even if you have, even if you convinced every scientist on the planet that you have found a major flaw with evolutionary theory, and they all came public saying evolutionary theory was flawed, they wouldn't all stand up and say that the only possibility left is a designer. That's not how it works. These scientists are open to new ideas, but you need to provide evidence to believe them.

I ask why a designer because even if your theory were right and took down all of the pillars of evolutionary theory, I still don't see how that leads you to a designer.

I am not trying to attack your ideas, I honestly still don't understand how your conclusion matches the evidence you believe you've found.
:) Thank you for your patient expression of your thoughts. I am less perplexed by what you think than you are of what I think - merely because I used to subscribe.

You brought up that I see evolutionary theory as being flawed. Limiting the theory to the scope to which science agrees it is constrained, namely that it is applicable since the first organisms but not applicable before that time, the flaw I see could be summarized as it is incomplete. I'm not nitpicking - I mean that it is seriously incomplete. As an example, see the link I gave about avian fingers and how the problem is explained away. To you that may be OK but to me, it appears typical. But we could go round and round.

To try to answer your question better, lets limit ourselves to this thread about Physical Laws Best Case for ID. Lets start there and see if I can relate to you by seeing where your thinking focuses. How do you explain first life and the immense 'just so' complexity that came before it? Is the strong Anthropic Principle plausible or do you have some other idea?
 
Strange way of thinking. I would say that 'the best theory we have' is a statement that says we have evaluated the theories, and this one was the best. That is not the same as a default theory.
What are the other theories? Lamarkism? Spontaneous generation? It seems to me that the only theories from which Darwinism was selected were all spontaneous generation theories - get something for nothing type theories.

You say that you take ID as a default theory, and by doing that, you are actually saying that a theory that does not explain anything, and is not supported by any facts, is preferable to all other theories!
Did I say "theory"? Evolution is conjecture - so is ID, conjecture.

Why should you stretch it before the first organisms? Evolution has nothing say about what came before the first organisms! You can have your designer or panspermia there, and evolution would not be affected.
What is this thread - evolution? I try to come back to the thread "Physical Laws best case for ID?". Before first organism is more toward the topic.

You yourself allow for plausibility of a designer there, you just don't think she/it/he poked his fingers in anymore after that - right?

Again, it is strange that you regard evolution as 'too simple', compared to ID that is so simple that it has lost all predictive power!
You say ID is too simple. Of course - if you were to say it is a theory. I could mock it too and just say "what kind of theory is 'god did it'?". But OTOH, it is not simple at all: You design. I design. How in hell do we do it? We haven't the faintest! Is it simple, then? No. It's so fantastically complex, that we cannot even encapsulate it. Of course some of the tedium of some kinds of design have been automated, but that's not what I am talking about. How do we know what we want to design? That gets into consciousness. What the hell is that? We don't know.

So ID is not simple - it is exceedingly complex. Our idea of how design works is nearly vacant - but we know it can be done - we do it. To me, it is less of a leap that something similar to our own mental activity made the complexity we see, than the leap of faith that randomness can do it. So I agree that ID is a conjecture with little to ride on - but so is evolution.

Oh, and just in case you want me to tell you again why I don't think there is sufficient theory in "the theory of evolution", instead let other non-creationists tell you:

"As by this theory, innumerable transitional forms must have existed. Why do we not find them embedded in the crust of the earth? Why is not all nature in confusion [of halfway species] instead of being, as we see them, well-defined species?"—Charles Darwin,

"I am quite conscious that my speculations run quite beyond the bounds of true science." - From a letter to Asa Gray, Harvard biology professor, cited in Charles Darwin and the Problem of Creation, N.C. Gillespie, p.2)

"The Darwinian theory of descent has not a single fact to confirm it in the realm of nature. It is not the result of scientific research, but purely the product of imagination."—Dr. Fleischman [Erlangen zoologist].

"I am not satisfied that Darwin proved his point or that his influence in scientific and public thinking has been beneficial . . the success of Darwinism was accomplished by a decline in scientific integrity."—*W.R. Thompson. Introduction to Charles Darwin's, Origin of the Species [Canadian scientist].

"Evolutionism is a fairy tale for grown-ups. This theory has helped nothing in the progress of science. It is useless."—Bounoure, Le Monde Et La Vie (October 1963) [Director of Research at the National center of Scientific Research in France]

"Scientists have no proof that life was not the result of an act of creation."—Robert Jastrow, The Enchanted Loom: Mind in the Universe (1981), p. 19.

"In fact, evolution became in a sense a scientific religion; almost all scientists have accepted it and many are prepared to `bend' their observations to fit in with it."—H. Lipson, "A Physicist Looks at Evolution," Physics Bulletin, 31 (1980), p. 138.

"It is therefore of immediate concern to both biologists and layman that Darwinism is under attack. The theory of life that undermined nineteenth-century religion has virtually become a religion itself and, in its turn, is being threatened by fresh ideas. The attacks are certainly not limited to those of the creationists and religious fundamentalists who deny Darwinism for political and moral reason. The main thrust of the criticism comes from within science itself. The doubts about Darwinism represent a political revolt from within rather than a siege from without."—B. Leith, The Descent of Darwin: A Handbook of Doubts about Darwinism (1982), p. 11.

"What is it [evolution] based upon? Upon nothing whatever but faith, upon belief in the reality of the unseen—belief in the fossils that cannot be produced, belief in the embryological experiments that refuse to come off. It is faith unjustified by works."—Arthur N. Field.


"Just as pre-Darwinian biology was carried out by people whose faith was in the Creator and His plan, post-Darwinian biology is being carried out by people whose faith is in, almost, the deity of Darwin. They've seen their task as to elaborate his theory and to fill the gaps in it, to fill the trunk and twigs of the tree. But it seems to me that the theoretical framework has very little impact on the actual progress of the work in biological research. In a way some aspects of Darwinism and of neo-Darwinism seem to me to have held back the progress of science."—Colin Patterson, The Listener [senior paleontologist at the British Museum of Natural History, London].

"The problem of the origin of species has not advanced in the last 150 years. One hundred and fifty years have already passed during which it has been said that the evolution of the species is a fact but, without giving real proofs of it and without even a principle of explaining it. During the last one hundred and fifty years of research that has been carried out along this line [in order to prove the theory], there has been no discovery of anything. It is simply a repetition in different ways of what Darwin said in 1859. This lack of results is unforgivable in a day when molecular biology has really opened the veil covering the mystery of reproduction and heredity . . "Finally, there is only one attitude which is possible as I have just shown: It consists in affirming that intelligence comes before life. Many people will say this is not science, it is philosophy. The only thing I am interested in is fact, and this conclusion comes out of an analysis and observation of the facts."—G. Salet, Hasard et Certitude: Le Transformisme devant la Biologie Actuelle (1973), p. 331.

"The hold of the evolutionary paradigm [theoretical system] is so powerful that an idea which is more like a principle of medieval astrology than a serious twentieth century scientific theory has become a reality for evolutionary biologists."—Michael Denton, Evolution: A Theory in Crisis (1985), p. 306 [Australian molecular biologist].

"The theory of evolution suffers from grave defects, which are more and more apparent as time advances. It can no longer square with practical scientific knowledge."—Albert Fleishmann, Zoologist.

"In fact, evolution became in a sense a scientific religion; almost all scientists have accepted it and many are prepared to `bend' their observations to fit in with it."—H. Lipson, "A Physicist Looks at Evolution," Physics Bulletin, 31 (1980), p. 138.

"The creation account in Genesis and the theory of evolution could not be reconciled. One must be right and the other wrong. The story of the fossils agreed with the account of Genesis. In the oldest rocks we did not find a series of fossils covering the gradual changes from the most primitive creatures to developed forms, but rather in the oldest rocks developed species suddenly appeared. Between every species there was a complete absence of intermediate fossils."—*D.B. Gower, "Scientist Rejects Evolution," Kentish Times, England, December 11, 1975, p. 4 [biochemist].

"Evolution is baseless and quite incredible."—John Ambrose Fleming, President, British Association for Advancement of Science, in The Unleashing of Evolutionary Thought.

" `Scientists who go about teaching that evolution is a fact of life are great con men, and the story they are telling may be the greatest hoax ever. In explaining evolution we do not have one iota of fact.' A tangled mishmash of guessing games and figure juggling [Tahmisian called it]."—The Fresno Bee, August 20, 1959, p. 1-B [quoting T.N. Tahmisian, physiologist for the Atomic Energy Commission].

" `The theory [of evolution] is a scientific mistake.' "—Louis Agassiz, quoted in H. Enoch, Evolution or Creation, (1966), p. 139. [Agassiz was a Harvard University professor and the pioneer in glaciation.]

"[In Darwin's writings] possibilities were assumed to add up to probability, and probabilities then were promoted to certitudes."—Agassiz, op. cit., p. 335.

"It has been estimated that no fewer than 800 phrases in the subjunctive mood (such as `Let us assume,' or `We may well suppose,' etc.) are to be found between the covers of Darwin's Origin of Species alone."—L. Merson Davies [British scientist], Modern Science (1953), p. 7.

"In accepting evolution as fact, how many biologists pause to reflect that science is built upon theories that have been proved by experiment to be correct or remember that the theory of animal evolution has never been thus approved."—L.H. Matthews, "Introduction," Origin of Species, Charles Darwin (1971 edition).

"Present-day ultra-Darwinism, which is so sure of itself, impresses incompletely informed biologists, misleads them, and inspires fallacious interpretations . . . Through use and abuse of hidden postulates, of bold, often ill-founded extrapolations, a pseudoscience has been created. It is taking root in the very heart of biology and is leading astray many biochemists and biologists, who sincerely believe that the accuracy of fundamental concepts has been demonstrated, which is not the case."—Pierre P. de Grasse, The Evolution of Living Organisms (1977), p. 202.

[In a letter to Asa Gray, a Harvard professor of biology, Darwin wrote:] "I am quite conscious that my speculations run quite beyond the bounds of true science."—*Charles Darwin, quoted in N.C. Gillespie, Charles Darwin and the Problem of Creation (1979), p. 2 [University of Chicago book].

"The fact is that the evidence was so patchy one hundred years ago that even Darwin himself had increasing doubts as to the validity of his views, and the only aspect of his theory which has received any support over the past century is where it applies to microevolutionary phenomena. His general theory, that all life on earth had originated and evolved by a gradual successive accumulation of fortuitous mutations, is still, as it was in Darwin's time, a highly speculative hypothesis entirely without direct factual support and very far from that self-evident axiom some of its more aggressive advocates would have us believe."—Michael Denton, Evolution: A Theory in Crisis (1986), p. 77.
 
Funny that you would use this example as a support for your argument, when I would have thought that this was an argument for evolution! Frame shifting seems a relatively simple thing to cause with a mutation, and it would be expected to happen. How many times has a mutation caused a frame shift that merely did not work, and the mutated organism perished? And how many times did it happen with no effect at all, thus adding a new valueless gene that future mutations could work on to create new functions?

Your argument seem much like the anthroposofic principle that we discussed: You have a winning lottery ticket, and it has to be designed specially for you, or what? Here we have a frame shift that created a new function. Elegance or luck? Contrary to the case of the universes, we know that the mutations happens all the time, and it would difficult to imagine that frame shifting does not also happen all the time, so here the verdict clearly goes down on the side of luck.
Funny? Its incredible. Your paradigm for the darwin-thang is so strong you can't see it my way at all. I bet if Seti decoded some stream of pulses from some far off star, and we decoded it to find out that it reveals proofs to many known mathematical problems, but frame shifted, it gives proofs to many more mathematical problems, you would conclude that those were some pretty smart aliens out there. ...or would you think you won the lottery?


..."anthroposofic"? Slip of the keybroad:) ? (you must have spent time in those homeopathic medicine forums...)
 
Here we have a frame shift that created a new function. Elegance or luck? Contrary to the case of the universes, we know that the mutations happens all the time, and it would difficult to imagine that frame shifting does not also happen all the time, so here the verdict clearly goes down on the side of luck.
BTW, I guess I should try to look it up again. I think I read that frame-shifting is a 'technique' used in immune systems to sythesize defence against attack. So these nylon eating bacteria were not so unique (or lucky?) in their use of frame shifting.
 
:) Thank you for your patient expression of your thoughts. I am less perplexed by what you think than you are of what I think - merely because I used to subscribe.

You brought up that I see evolutionary theory as being flawed. Limiting the theory to the scope to which science agrees it is constrained, namely that it is applicable since the first organisms but not applicable before that time, the flaw I see could be summarized as it is incomplete. I'm not nitpicking - I mean that it is seriously incomplete. As an example, see the link I gave about avian fingers and how the problem is explained away. To you that may be OK but to me, it appears typical. But we could go round and round.

To try to answer your question better, lets limit ourselves to this thread about Physical Laws Best Case for ID. Lets start there and see if I can relate to you by seeing where your thinking focuses. How do you explain first life and the immense 'just so' complexity that came before it? Is the strong Anthropic Principle plausible or do you have some other idea?
For me, not knowing the details for how life began means just that; that we don't know. The less evidence we have, the less convinced we should be that our theories are correct. I feel there is enough evidence to support the idea that life came from non-living chemical reactions. But, I'll admit, there is still a lot to be learned on the topic. And when new evidence comes up, I am more open to ideas than when people question things that already have reams of evidence to support them. But even if there was no evidence to give us any idea of how life first began, I sill don't see how that leads to a designer. People have used god or a designer to explain away anything the didn't understand for centuries. And as science learns more, they are proven wrong again and again. After being proven to be the wrong answer over and over again, I'm wary to accept a designer without clear evidence. In other words, lack of understanding isn't enough to merit a designer. We would need clear evidence that lead directly to a designer before it makes sense to believe.

Just because we don't know how something happened, it doesn't mean that it was a designer. Maybe we don't know. Maybe there is no evidence to explain any of the existing theories. But saying a designer did it is a major claim. And goes against hundreds of years of scientific study. The designer answer also brings up many more questions than it solves. To me it's seems similar to making an astronomical observation that can't be fully explained and then saying that there must be a god and he must move certain astral bodies in unexpected ways. It just seems like a huge leap of faith. And it seems like it's a jump to conclusions before the data can even be collected.

Why not just say, that evolution doesn't answer how life first began, and focus on pulling together evidence to find out how it could have happened?

Why not forget about the designer argument unless there is some specific evidence to back it up?
 
Did I say "theory"? Evolution is conjecture - so is ID, conjecture.
Not all conjecture is equal. There is a difference between "conjecture" that hundreds of people have studied, found evidence to support, refined and reviewed and something a small group of people decide on their own without evidence to support it or peer review.
 
What are the other theories? Lamarkism? Spontaneous generation? It seems to me that the only theories from which Darwinism was selected were all spontaneous generation theories - get something for nothing type theories.
You can include ID as one of those 'get something for nothing' type theories.

What is this thread - evolution? I try to come back to the thread "Physical Laws best case for ID?". Before first organism is more toward the topic.
Sorry if I have misunderstood that. Why are we discussing evolution all the time?

You yourself allow for plausibility of a designer there, you just don't think she/it/he poked his fingers in anymore after that - right?
If he were poking around, we would notice. And we would also be able to finally find out which one out of myriads of religions holds the 'truth'.

You say ID is too simple. Of course - if you were to say it is a theory. I could mock it too and just say "what kind of theory is 'god did it'?". But OTOH, it is not simple at all: You design. I design. How in hell do we do it? We haven't the faintest! Is it simple, then? No. It's so fantastically complex, that we cannot even encapsulate it. Of course some of the tedium of some kinds of design have been automated, but that's not what I am talking about. How do we know what we want to design? That gets into consciousness. What the hell is that? We don't know.
But since the designer is just a black box where all knowledge ends, it is a simple theory. God flicked his fingers, and there was the universe! Or he chose a more complicated way, or whatever. There is no way to know, and there is only unverifiable speculation left.

Well, we could wonder why the designer has taken such pains to litter our world with evidence for evolution ...

So I agree that ID is a conjecture with little to ride on - but so is evolution.
But that is imply not true! Evolution is supported evidence everywhere, notwithstanding your list of partly outdated quotes.
 
...
Quote Mine
...

yeah, nice quote mining there, VonNeumann - everyone knows real scientists just spew enormous lists of quotes to prove their case. Including all the classic Darwin quotes in there was a nice, yet slightly embarrassing, touch.

I'd also like to know whether that Colin Patterson quote was completely fabricated or not. You can find a decent article examining Patteron's true opinions here, associated with a different misquote of him by Creationists.

Seriously, if you want to be taken as anything other than a joke, please don't resort to identical tactics to Creationists: it severely damages any credibility that you may be trying to achieve.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom