Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Well since your premise is that there ISN'T new information, you'll have trouble accepting the fact that there IS. However, since we have ample evidence that some types of dinosaurs evolved into birds, and that dinosaurs didn't have wings, I'd say that, at least in appearance, information was added, not merely modified..
That reminds me, while everyone was asking why I do not present counter-evidence, many posts back, I commented on the avian fingers. Hardly what I would call "ample evidence that ... dinosaurs evolved into birds." They may have but we still do not have a good precursor because of the I II III vs II III IV problem. You might go read the link and feel satisfied that the problem is solved - I think it is not. "Ample evidence" is the key phrase. What is ample - depends on your level of skepticism.
 
Are you STILL hung up on that little "design" word ? Sheesh, I thought we had moved on from that ? Didn't you say so yourself ? If so, please drop this and let's get back on track, shall we ?
I understand how, if you plop in and read a few posts, you lose context. The topic was actually 'teleology'.
 
Has 3 billion years actually been enough time without extraneous data input?

Yes, thank you. Any other questions?


As to genomic similarities also apparent, what else does one expect based on the physics/chemistry of H-O-C, etc.

A substantially lower degree of genomic similarity.

Why, for example, do all known life forms use the same base pairs instead of the nearly unlimited number of other organic compounds? Why do all known lifeforms use the same set of twenty amino acids instead of the nearly infinite variety of such acids? Why do they all use the same coding, so the same base pairs universally code for the same amino acid? Why do the degrees of genetic similarity so greatly exceed the 25% that would be expected by "chance"? Why do the same exact gene sequences appear in unrealated organisms -- and why is it that there is such a strong correlation between the fossil sequence of morphological change and the denetic changes, and in particular, the more distance the morphological speciation, the more drastic the genetic change?
 
Indeed. All it takes is more words to describe the process. Frankly, I'm a bit tired of arguing about this one. Von should just forget about this and move on to the actual subject : physical laws vs ID. Otherwise this thread is lost, and the kittens will start pouring in.
I tried to move on but others kept going on, saying I was wrong when I was willing to just drop it.

But now we are on "Methinks it like a woo-zil". Belz, why don't you re-do what Dawkins tried to do , but this time with no teleology.
 
Good question at this point so I can close the loop on this 'round and round'...
[mojo, i'm not picking on you so interpret the word "you" in the following in the collective sense.]

Dawkins tried to explain in Blind Watchmaker, using a computer program model, how small random changes add up to large changes. This was to contrast with the fact that the large change would be probablistically vanishingly small. In other words, he was trying to demonstrate the answer to the "big question" you asserted. When he did it, he said "see".... and then admitted he had to use teleology to show it.

So, what 'prevented' Dawkins from successfully demonstrating what you asked, is that he used teleology - which is verbotten if you are a hard-evolutionist.

Your 'given enough time' implies to me you think 10^20 years is a lot of time. Dawkins knows that there is not enough time unless random mutation/natural selection can create the steps along the way to speed it up. This seems to be taken on faith that rm/ns can do that. I do not take it on faith. Faith is what keeps you from doubting that micro yields macro. Your faith in micro yields macro is what makes you NOT a skeptic. Be MORE skeptical.

Anyone want to step up to the plate and re-do what Dawkins attempted WITHOUT TELEOLOGY this time?
In any simulation, a human has to make decisions about what constitutes selection pressure and survival. That's the nature of an artificial simulation. You can't simulate without design, which is what Dawkins admitted.

That in no way implies, though, that the event being simulated must also have been designed.
 
Your 'given enough time' implies to me you think 10^20 years is a lot of time. Dawkins knows that there is not enough time unless random mutation/natural selection can create the steps along the way to speed it up.

Could you provide evidence that this has been shown ? Considering how much variation there can be in a handful of generations, I'm skeptical of your claim, here.
 
That reminds me, while everyone was asking why I do not present counter-evidence, many posts back, I commented on the avian fingers. Hardly what I would call "ample evidence that ... dinosaurs evolved into birds." They may have but we still do not have a good precursor because of the I II III vs II III IV problem. You might go read the link and feel satisfied that the problem is solved - I think it is not. "Ample evidence" is the key phrase. What is ample - depends on your level of skepticism.

Now you're just trolling, Von. If not dinosaurs, then just look at other species. New functions are gained, and this constitutes new information. True or false ?

VonNeumann said:
I understand how, if you plop in and read a few posts, you lose context. The topic was actually 'teleology'.

No, read the OP.
 
I tried to move on but others kept going on, saying I was wrong when I was willing to just drop it.

But now we are on "Methinks it like a woo-zil". Belz, why don't you re-do what Dawkins tried to do , but this time with no teleology.

Because I DON'T CARE. I don't care about semantics. You're one post away from a kitten. Just stick to the damn subject. If, as it was said before, someone says his car didn't "want" to start, it doesn't mean a thing about the car's will. Let's move on, yes ?
 
Could you provide evidence that this has been shown ? Considering how much variation there can be in a handful of generations, I'm skeptical of your claim, here.

I think he's simply misreading the Blind Watchmaker. I don't have a copy to hand, so I'll summarize and paraphrase what I remember.

Dawkins points out, correctly, that the odds against a successful major mutation -- for example, a fox hatching out of a turtle egg -- are unbelievably huge. Leaving questions of embryonic viability and such aside, I could calculate the odds of such a thing happening as a set of simultaneous point mutations and I'd end up with essentially 0.00000.......000001 : a one followed by this whole vapor trail of zeros.

It's a low enough probability that even given five or so billion years of evolution, and even giving a population of several billion turtle eggs hatching each year, the expected number of such events that we would see is zero.

His point, of course, is that natural selection doesn't need to happen by a process of simultaneous point mutations. If you start with a turtle, you'll get stuff that looks very turtle-like in the next generation. Then you'll get something turtle-like after a few thousand generations. Then stuff that looks kinda turtle-ish but a little bit fox-ish after a few more thousand generations. And so on, through millions and milions of generations, until you have something that's fully fox-like and not at all chelonian.
 
Pixy, you can program can't you? Go re-do "Methinks it..." and do it without teleology.
What do you mean, "without teleology"? A program is a designed thing, with a specific purpose. What exactly would satisfy you?

Evolution has been explained to you without reference to design or purpose. Your claim is FALSE, VN. False. Wrong. Incorrect. Untrue. Counterfactual. A load of foetid dingo's kidneys.
 
Yes, thank you. Any other questions?
Certainly an opinion shared by neo-Darwinists.

A substantially lower degree of genomic similarity.

Why, for example, do all known life forms use the same base pairs instead of the nearly unlimited number of other organic compounds?
One answer is common ancestor; another is parallel evolution. Iff other pairs were actual possibilities, why don't we see them?

Why do all known lifeforms use the same set of twenty amino acids instead of the nearly infinite variety of such acids?
Feel free to build a new life form using others. That at least would be interesting. Otherwise, see above.

Why do they all use the same coding, so the same base pairs universally code for the same amino acid?
Ditto.

Why do the degrees of genetic similarity so greatly exceed the 25% that would be expected by "chance"?
We do agree "chance" doesn't seem to be the key, does it?

Why do the same exact gene sequences appear in unrealated organisms -- and why is it that there is such a strong correlation between the fossil sequence of morphological change and the denetic changes, and in particular, the more distance the morphological speciation, the more drastic the genetic change?
Er, yes, isn't it interesting that the genome defines the critter. However, we are discussing why the changes in the genome actually occur.
 
VonNeumann ,

Still nothing that has been said seems to be evidence for a designer. Sure, there are some questions with evolution, but these still doesn't seem to be anything that leads to a designer. To me, that's the fault of ID. Even if interspecies lateral gene transfer was possible, what does that have to do with a designer?
 
Certainly an opinion shared by neo-Darwinists.
What is a "neo-darwinist"?

Is it a pejorative form for "evolutionist"? Or is it a special kind of evolutionist who is seeking new inspiration from the scriptures of Darwin?
 
In any simulation, a human has to make decisions about what constitutes selection pressure and survival. That's the nature of an artificial simulation. You can't simulate without design, which is what Dawkins admitted.

That in no way implies, though, that the event being simulated must also have been designed.
While we cannot simulate without design, we can still design simulations that do not use such brute-force selection as did Dawkins. I think that the more pure form would be the randomly seeded cellular automatons (CA). Some interesting machines have 'evolved' in those toy universes. But there is a problem with demonstration there, too. There just isn't enough time to see if anything like 'life' would actually emerge there. I do not have a problem with that CA is designed - it would still convince me that non-teleological selection could evolve life if it demonstrated it. ...I even think that it COULD!!! Of course, we will not hold our breath for the 10^10^10^10... years it would take. But present theory limits the time to a mere blink of the eye ~10^10 years.

Please understand my only gripe with all that is merely that people claim that more has been explained that has actually been explained. To explain something and then have to disclaim it (sorry but my selector was brute-force), doesn't say that much. Likewise with the biology book explanations that use vague terms and don't say much. Having said more than enough on all this, perhaps we at least agree that we are learning about micro-bio and biochemistry at such a fast pace now that there should be more answers and more clarity as time goes on.
 
Evolution has been explained to you without reference to design or purpose. Your claim is FALSE, VN. False. Wrong. Incorrect. Untrue. Counterfactual. A load of foetid dingo's kidneys.
Yes, this is so good. It shows how you think that something that purportedly explains everything (it's both a floor wax and a dessert topping) can be explained in a few identity statements. Evolution is so simple.

"Foetid dingo.." ? Are you 'down under'?
 
VonNeumann doesn't believe in speciation (`macroevolution'), and instead thinks that the Designer steps in every so often, in the form of retroviruses sent from space, to upgrade the genome to Quadraped V1.4.3.

No, really :rolleyes:

I guess they get bored after making all those crop circles and doing anal probes.
 
Now you're just trolling, Von. If not dinosaurs, then just look at other species. New functions are gained, and this constitutes new information. True or false ?
New functions seem to appear over time. That does not force 'descent with modification' to be true. Something sufficiently complex can provide new function with mere parametric change. Think of a function with input parameters where the value of an input selects different functions - all while the amount of information defining the function and the amount of information defining the input parameters, is fixed. So my answer is: could be True, could be False. Add to that notion the fact that we do not know if the amount of genetic information on the earth 300MYA was not already sufficient to make an organism as complex as h.sapiens. I may be wrong, but I think that's what Francis Crick proposed (need to read his book). If so, then we would be faced with no increase in worldly genetic information over the span of 300MY while a definite increase in function occurred.

For you Belz and others who keep asking me why there is not enough time to create new information using the theoretical mechanism of random mutation and Natural selection, I ask that you go read what high profile people have published on this: Hoyle, Wickramasinghe, Crick ...

I cannot add much if anything at all to their arguments. I must have read some of that stuff many times over a couple decades and scoffed every time. Then one day, I decided to calculate for myself and realized what I was blind to, before. That was probably the wedge that produced the crack in my darwin-faith.
 
I guess they get bored after making all those crop circles and doing anal probes.
Make fun, that's cool.:cool:

Actually though, if you really want to make fun of me (since I don't subscribe to panspermia per se): don't forget that I believe we live in a simulation:jaw-dropp .
 
Last edited:
New functions seem to appear over time. That does not force 'descent with modification' to be true. Something sufficiently complex can provide new function with mere parametric change. Think of a function with input parameters where the value of an input selects different functions - all while the amount of information defining the function and the amount of information defining the input parameters, is fixed. So my answer is: could be True, could be False. Add to that notion the fact that we do not know if the amount of genetic information on the earth 300MYA was not already sufficient to make an organism as complex as h.sapiens. I may be wrong, but I think that's what Francis Crick proposed (need to read his book). If so, then we would be faced with no increase in worldly genetic information over the span of 300MY while a definite increase in function occurred.

For you Belz and others who keep asking me why there is not enough time to create new information using the theoretical mechanism of random mutation and Natural selection, I ask that you go read what high profile people have published on this: Hoyle, Wickramasinghe, Crick ...

I cannot add much if anything at all to their arguments. I must have read some of that stuff many times over a couple decades and scoffed every time. Then one day, I decided to calculate for myself and realized what I was blind to, before. That was probably the wedge that produced the crack in my darwin-faith.
Your argument still seems to be that there may or not be some flaws with some aspects of accepted theory of evolution, so therefore there must be a designer. How does any of this add up to there must be a designer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom