...
I do not know how to do this, without restricting the context. How much information is there in pi? pi=c/2r is only 7 bytes? What about the series? What about the infinitely long string of digits? What measure method is to be used? I did not understand how you can so quickly dismiss the 1K string analogy, I gave.
About the nylonase, I saw where someone was argueing about frame-shifts being known mechanisms in immune-systems for re-calibrating against a new threat. I didn't look very hard yet but I have not yet found how many base pairs are involved in the nylonase. How many base-pairs were coded in the precursor, and how many base-pairs in the resultant nylonase? If there are not new base-pairs, please explain to me under what measurement method there would be an increase in information.
Exactly my point - you have absolutely no consistent definition of information but you can firmly state that no information increase took place in the development of nylonase. You're back to using the SMI again
Personally, I think that the only meaningful measure of information that can be made is in terms of the phenotype, not the genotype. An ability not previously expressed before indicates new information. At the genotype level, you could see the mutation that caused the frameshift as producing extra information, if that makes you happy.
If you like, examine the dynamics of the population of a whole. Over time, due to evolution, it will ascend to an optimum of the fitness distribution. When you use a Genetic Algorithm to find the optimum of some objective function, I don't think you would deny that you have more information than you started with afterwards. How does this differ with real populations?
That said, I would prefer not to talk about evolution in terms of information at all, as unless you have a rigorous definition (which you don't), there's not much point - `information' is an abstract concept with a lot of different meanings in different contexts. However, everyone who criticises evolution always uses the `no increase in information' argument anyway, because they can redefine the term`information' as they please throughout a discussion.
For example, consider your statement:
How many base-pairs were coded in the precursor, and how many base-pairs in the resultant nylonase? If there are not new base-pairs, please explain to me under what measurement method there would be an increase in information. You say here that without base-pairs, there can be no new information. If I then gave you an example
with increased base pairs forming a novel protein, you would
still argue that no new information was produced and change your definition of information to fit.
And this discussion then carries on and on, with you still disagreeing as someone gives all the examples of plant speciation, gives all the genetic evidence between ourselves and apes until you, finally, say something along the lines of "show me a cat giving birth to a dog"
Edit: perhaps that's a little harsh - I don't think you'd actually produce the dog/cat example, but it's the way this discussion almost always goes with Biblical Creationists/IDers