Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

So... you fellows [drfrank, DSE, steenkh, et al] do NOT believe interspecies lateral gene transfer could happen? ...does happen?
I have no opinion on this, but I do not reject the possiblity. I certainly do not see how this could topple the theory of evolution or why it would involve a designer. It really only adds yet another mechanism that can cause mutations.
 
no - You look. I would be a 'believer' if Dawkins had pulled off a NON-TELEOLOGICAL demonstration of evolution. Even if he just had ONE. But the reason he DIDN'T is because he COULDN'T. If you pull out the teleology from the demonstrations, they deflate - Dawkins admitted it.
No.

You are saying that describing evolution without ascribing purpose is impossible. This is falsifiable; a single counter-example will dismiss it. Such a counter-example has been provided. Your claim is not true.

This is important to my point because I did not mean that one could not merely state identities without employing teleology (as chipmunk did). But to produce an explanation of substance, particularly like a demonstration, I challenge you to do that. Dawkins tried and his deus a machina was 'teleology'.
What substance did chipmunk's explanation lack?

There is genetic variation among living creatures. This makes some more likely to survive to produce offspring than others. Their offspring inherit these genes. The end.
 
There is genetic variation among living creatures. This makes some more likely to survive to produce offspring than others. Their offspring inherit these genes. The end.
Precisely. So the big question for anti-evolutionists is: what is it that prevents "microevolution" from becoming "macroevolution", given enough time?
 
no - You look. I would be a 'believer' if Dawkins had pulled off a NON-TELEOLOGICAL demonstration of evolution. Even if he just had ONE. But the reason he DIDN'T is because he COULDN'T. If you pull out the teleology from the demonstrations, they deflate - Dawkins admitted it.

Dawkins wasn't trying to. If you substitute pigeons for humans in the example then you have a non-teleological demonstration.
 
I also noted that Francis Crick thought there was insufficient evidence of life evolving here and that is why he postulated directed panspermia.

But wouldn't you expect the genetic makeup of related species to be much more different from one another if the differences came about from exposure to viruses ?

Since lateral (horizontal) gene transfer does not fit into the 'descent with modification' constraints of Darwinistic Evolution, I suppose many people still do not buy into it (?) - you don't?

I think it'd rather because darwinistic evolution has a lot going for it. "Milk ? Not so much." Sorry. Aero moment.

I think there is more plausibility in that this biosphere has been periodically upgraded with revisions, than that there is spontaneous generation of information here. Spontaneous adjustment of parameters? OK. But not new information [my subjective definition thereof]. And I still need to learn more about the nylonase - I have seen some rebuttal info out there on that subject.

Well since your premise is that there ISN'T new information, you'll have trouble accepting the fact that there IS. However, since we have ample evidence that some types of dinosaurs evolved into birds, and that dinosaurs didn't have wings, I'd say that, at least in appearance, information was added, not merely modified.

I think that all I said was I see relative plausibility in panspermia - not that I "believe" it. I did say I believe viruses can infect, maybe even inter-kingdom, to bring about sudden changes. How that can fit into the evolution model, I don't know, because it certainly seems to have to require some sort of higher level 'planning'.

It might, if it were true.
 
no - You look. I would be a 'believer' if Dawkins had pulled off a NON-TELEOLOGICAL demonstration of evolution. Even if he just had ONE. But the reason he DIDN'T is because he COULDN'T. If you pull out the teleology from the demonstrations, they deflate - Dawkins admitted it. .

Are you STILL hung up on that little "design" word ? Sheesh, I thought we had moved on from that ? Didn't you say so yourself ? If so, please drop this and let's get back on track, shall we ?
 
You are saying that describing evolution without ascribing purpose is impossible. This is falsifiable; a single counter-example will dismiss it. Such a counter-example has been provided. Your claim is not true.

Indeed. All it takes is more words to describe the process. Frankly, I'm a bit tired of arguing about this one. Von should just forget about this and move on to the actual subject : physical laws vs ID. Otherwise this thread is lost, and the kittens will start pouring in.
 
...

I do not know how to do this, without restricting the context. How much information is there in pi? pi=c/2r is only 7 bytes? What about the series? What about the infinitely long string of digits? What measure method is to be used? I did not understand how you can so quickly dismiss the 1K string analogy, I gave.

About the nylonase, I saw where someone was argueing about frame-shifts being known mechanisms in immune-systems for re-calibrating against a new threat. I didn't look very hard yet but I have not yet found how many base pairs are involved in the nylonase. How many base-pairs were coded in the precursor, and how many base-pairs in the resultant nylonase? If there are not new base-pairs, please explain to me under what measurement method there would be an increase in information.
Exactly my point - you have absolutely no consistent definition of information but you can firmly state that no information increase took place in the development of nylonase. You're back to using the SMI again ;)

Personally, I think that the only meaningful measure of information that can be made is in terms of the phenotype, not the genotype. An ability not previously expressed before indicates new information. At the genotype level, you could see the mutation that caused the frameshift as producing extra information, if that makes you happy.

If you like, examine the dynamics of the population of a whole. Over time, due to evolution, it will ascend to an optimum of the fitness distribution. When you use a Genetic Algorithm to find the optimum of some objective function, I don't think you would deny that you have more information than you started with afterwards. How does this differ with real populations?

That said, I would prefer not to talk about evolution in terms of information at all, as unless you have a rigorous definition (which you don't), there's not much point - `information' is an abstract concept with a lot of different meanings in different contexts. However, everyone who criticises evolution always uses the `no increase in information' argument anyway, because they can redefine the term`information' as they please throughout a discussion.

For example, consider your statement: How many base-pairs were coded in the precursor, and how many base-pairs in the resultant nylonase? If there are not new base-pairs, please explain to me under what measurement method there would be an increase in information. You say here that without base-pairs, there can be no new information. If I then gave you an example with increased base pairs forming a novel protein, you would still argue that no new information was produced and change your definition of information to fit.

And this discussion then carries on and on, with you still disagreeing as someone gives all the examples of plant speciation, gives all the genetic evidence between ourselves and apes until you, finally, say something along the lines of "show me a cat giving birth to a dog" Edit: perhaps that's a little harsh - I don't think you'd actually produce the dog/cat example, but it's the way this discussion almost always goes with Biblical Creationists/IDers
 
Last edited:
Or to put it another way:

If we can produce direct, indisputable, genetic evidence and the living creatures themselves, it's micro-evolution. Even if it's speciation by every accepted definition, it's still micro-evolution.

If we only have indirect evidence, such as fossils and genes of descendent species, it's macro-evolution. The distinction is not based on the amount of change, but on whether they can deny that it happened naturally without exposing themselves as complete fools to the entire world. (As opposed to just everyone who has the slightest undersanding of the subject.)
 
Or to put it another way:

If we can produce direct, indisputable, genetic evidence and the living creatures themselves, it's micro-evolution. Even if it's speciation by every accepted definition, it's still micro-evolution.

If we only have indirect evidence, such as fossils and genes of descendent species, it's macro-evolution. The distinction is not based on the amount of change, but on whether they can deny that it happened naturally without exposing themselves as complete fools to the entire world. (As opposed to just everyone who has the slightest undersanding of the subject.)

Yeh, distinguishing between aspects of a theory based on the amount and types of evidence available to support them, what a shocking thought, how skeptical!
 
drfrank, i really don't think you can summarize all that i've said, like that. Really, do you? You are making reference here to panspermia. I specifically referenced panspermia.org as a place you can go, and they BTW claim to be anti-ID.
Yes, I was being glib, but my version was certainly closer to your thinking than than the mistaken impression DSE had ;)

And, similarly, standard ID claims to be anti-Creationist :rolleyes:

I said that I believe viruses can and do spread lateral information, and that I thought of that idea myself, decades ago. It is finally catching on. When I thought of it, my idea was that it was merely a missing ingredient to evolution and that it would have a powerful effect in allowing 'good ideas' to spread. ...sort of how the patent system, and scientific publishing works.

I also noted that Francis Crick thought there was insufficient evidence of life evolving here and that is why he postulated directed panspermia.

Since lateral (horizontal) gene transfer does not fit into the 'descent with modification' constraints of Darwinistic Evolution, I suppose many people still do not buy into it (?) - you don't?
Horizontal gene transfer is an accepted theory in evolutionary theory, thanks, particularly during early life. It makes sense that before cell membranes and everything were formed, organisms would screw around with each other's DNA a lot more. Also, a few bacterial genes probably get transferred into animals on occasion.

Importantly, all the evidence points to a relatively small amount of it, nothing even remotely approaching the enormous upheavals you suggest. Under your hypothesis, there's no reason at all why we should observe any tree of development, rather a random mishmash of genes equally shared between all organisms. This does not even slightly resemble what we observe.

Find me just one human gene that's significantly more similar to that of any other animal than an ape to start to provide evidence against this. Yes, many of our genes have homologues in other animals (particularly the Hox genes and those specifying basic cellular functions), but the underlying DNA coding for them will always be most similar in apes.

There are only 20 amino acids, but 64 combinations of 3 codons, so most amino acids have several codon combinations. In this way, neutral mutation in DNA will build up even when the coded-for protein remains completely identical, allowing you to determine similarity between species.

I think there is more plausibility in that this biosphere has been periodically upgraded with revisions, than that there is spontaneous generation of information here. Spontaneous adjustment of parameters? OK. But not new information [my subjective definition thereof]. And I still need to learn more about the nylonase - I have seen some rebuttal info out there on that subject.
Well, let me know how the rebuttals define information too, or whether they start with the a priori assumption that information will never increase and work from there :)

I think that all I said was I see relative plausibility in panspermia - not that I "believe" it. I did say I believe viruses can infect, maybe even inter-kingdom, to bring about sudden changes. How that can fit into the evolution model, I don't know, because it certainly seems to have to require some sort of higher level 'planning'.
*smiles at the sound of back-peddling*
 
Last edited:
Yeh, distinguishing between aspects of a theory based on the amount and types of evidence available to support them, what a shocking thought, how skeptical!
Huh?

The point is, they claim that the distinction is based on the amount of change - within or between undefined "kinds". It isn't; it's based on whether they think they can get away with denying that it happens naturally.

Which is, of course, thoroughly dishonest, but that should not come as a surprise.
 
Last edited:
Huh?

The point is, they claim that the distinction is based on the amount of change - within or between undefined "kinds". It isn't; it's based on whether they think they can get away with denying that it happens naturally.

Which is, of course, thoroughly dishonest, but that should not come as a surprise.

People can define words any way they like. Two people who you lump together as 'they' may use the same word with two different definitions. An indivdual person may use two different meanings of a word in two different discussions. A person may use a word with two different meanings in a single discussion when disambiguation is not considered important. A person may accidently equivocate.

None of these is necessarily dishonest.
 
The point is, they claim that the distinction is based on the amount of change - within or between undefined "kinds". It isn't; it's based on whether they think they can get away with denying that it happens naturally.

I disagree. I think that many of them are being as honest as they know how, and are trying to
evaluate the evidence as reasonably as they can.

"Real" scientists do the same thing. Consider the issues involved in the definition of "species" -- the standard secondary school definition ("two different species cannot interbreed") simply doesn't work. Horses and donkeys are different species, but they can interbreed. Herring gulls and black-backed gulls can't interbreed, but are the same (ring) species. Chorthippus brunneus and C. biguttulus look so similar field entmologists can't tell them apart, but they don't naturally breed together-- however, by adjusting the temperatures in the cages, scientists can get them to interbreed artificially.

So the notion of "species" gets pummelled and mangled and twisted every time someone else finds some damn organism that does some damn fool thing that's probably illegal in most of the southern United States.

The notion of "kind" (and by extension, micro- and macro-evolution) is exactly the same -- it's an intuitively plausible concept that just keeps getting mangled by the evidence. Let's face it -- a frog turning into another kind of frog is still not that impressive. It's still "just a frog."
 
So the notion of "species" gets pummelled and mangled and twisted every time someone else finds some damn organism that does some damn fool thing that's probably illegal in most of the southern United States.

The notion of "kind" (and by extension, micro- and macro-evolution) is exactly the same -- it's an intuitively plausible concept that just keeps getting mangled by the evidence. Let's face it -- a frog turning into another kind of frog is still not that impressive. It's still "just a frog."

Yes. The term "species" is useful for classification and discourse, but in the end there is no such thing as a "species". Of course, IDers use that as some sort of "proof" against darwinism.
 
I think VN's answer is the same as the IDists': Because.
So far, yup. Same way the results we see around us and in the geol record of added genomic info are explained by neo-Darwinism.

Has 3 billion years actually been enough time without extraneous data input?

As to genomic similarities also apparent, what else does one expect based on the physics/chemistry of H-O-C, etc.
 
So far, yup. Same way the results we see around us and in the geol record of added genomic info are explained by neo-Darwinism.

Has 3 billion years actually been enough time without extraneous data input?

As to genomic similarities also apparent, what else does one expect based on the physics/chemistry of H-O-C, etc.

Was that supposed to mean something ?
 
Precisely. So the big question for anti-evolutionists is: what is it that prevents "microevolution" from becoming "macroevolution", given enough time?
Good question at this point so I can close the loop on this 'round and round'...
[mojo, i'm not picking on you so interpret the word "you" in the following in the collective sense.]

Dawkins tried to explain in Blind Watchmaker, using a computer program model, how small random changes add up to large changes. This was to contrast with the fact that the large change would be probablistically vanishingly small. In other words, he was trying to demonstrate the answer to the "big question" you asserted. When he did it, he said "see".... and then admitted he had to use teleology to show it.

So, what 'prevented' Dawkins from successfully demonstrating what you asked, is that he used teleology - which is verbotten if you are a hard-evolutionist.

Your 'given enough time' implies to me you think 10^20 years is a lot of time. Dawkins knows that there is not enough time unless random mutation/natural selection can create the steps along the way to speed it up. This seems to be taken on faith that rm/ns can do that. I do not take it on faith. Faith is what keeps you from doubting that micro yields macro. Your faith in micro yields macro is what makes you NOT a skeptic. Be MORE skeptical.

Anyone want to step up to the plate and re-do what Dawkins attempted WITHOUT TELEOLOGY this time?
 
Dawkins wasn't trying to. If you substitute pigeons for humans in the example then you have a non-teleological demonstration.
huh? There were no humans except for Dawkins' being the programmer. Pigeons can't program. If you don't know what I'm talking about then please go back to the link I posted a few posts back.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom