Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

...
My understanding is that you believe a designer was only involved in the origins of life, not any of the developments since then. Is that fair to say?

VonNeumann doesn't believe in speciation (`macroevolution'), and instead thinks that the Designer steps in every so often, in the form of retroviruses sent from space, to upgrade the genome to Quadraped V1.4.3.

No, really :rolleyes:
 
VonNeumann doesn't believe in speciation (`macroevolution'), and instead thinks that the Designer steps in every so often, in the form of retroviruses sent from space, to upgrade the genome to Quadraped V1.4.3.

No, really :rolleyes:
Say it ain't so.
 
Say it ain't so.
I wish I could :hit:

I do not think of the designer as perfect nor do I believe the designer is incompetent. I believe the way genes got distributed was through viral infection. I think of it this way. Free genes, having to do with eye design, are let go on the planet. The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves. In the installation process, there may be some self revision that is designed into the mechanism that may cause slight differences in implementation. Some people believe viruses are primarily diseases and maybe some sort of proto-life. I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.
 
Last edited:
VonNeumann doesn't believe in speciation (`macroevolution'), and instead thinks that the Designer steps in every so often, in the form of retroviruses sent from space, to upgrade the genome to Quadraped V1.4.3.

No, really :rolleyes:

I honestly don't know why Von thinks it's more likely this way. Even IF we didn't have overwhelming evidence for "macro" evolution (which we do,) it'd already be more likely than some extra-cosmic entity playing around with the laws of physics.
 
vonNeumann said:
I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.
The key here is the word believe. Which is actually all very well, but rather weak considering that we already have a good solid theory that explains speciation and with plenty of evidence, and that there is zero evidence for vonNeumann's belief. But of course, in time it may turn up.
 
I honestly don't know why Von thinks it's more likely this way. Even IF we didn't have overwhelming evidence for "macro" evolution (which we do,) it'd already be more likely than some extra-cosmic entity playing around with the laws of physics.
Exactly
 
But this discussion is not about interpretations but about logic: Just like you cannot determine that the winning lottery ticket was made specially for you, you also cannot determine that the world was specially for you.

What is illusory about that?
Yes, you are right. I admit I totally obfuscated what I meant - sorry. I meant that if one is strong toward anthropic principle then one thinks design is an illusion. I'll try not to coin new phrases in the future without explaining what I mean.
 
Yes, you are right. I admit I totally obfuscated what I meant - sorry. I meant that if one is strong toward anthropic principle then one thinks design is an illusion. I'll try not to coin new phrases in the future without explaining what I mean.
OK, apology accepted. In general terms, I agree with you that the anthropic principle can lead to believing that design - if you can see any signs of design (I cannot) - is an illusion. The anthropic principle only tells you that there is no reason to believe that the world was made for you, but it cannot rule out the possibility that it really is so. It merely removes a theist argument, but it does not rule out theism.

However, if you happen to be religious, it is possible for you to believe in your god, and at the same time accept evolution as your god's chosen way of evolving his design. There really only needs to be a conflict if you also believe that the world was created, say, 6000 years ago.

This is why so many scientists can profess themselves religious, and at the same time be proponents for evolution. It is only if they have beliefs that goes against facts that they have trouble combining the two.

Personally, I would have nothing against another theory than evolution, if it could offer a better explanation all the facts that we already know. I doubt that evolution will ever be counted out completely, because we have observed speciation in a number of genus, and we know that evolutionary pressure must exist. It will be difficult to explain away the fact that evolutionary pressure will not lead to speciation.

As it has often been stated, ID has no predictive power, and really just replaces evolution with an unknown, unprovable, and unpredictable entity. How some people believe that is an explanation of anything is beyond me.
 
That is why I wanted to know why some people, who have a zero-teleological view, seemingly cannot avoid using teleological terms.
But I demonstrated that this is not true. It resulted in overly-stuffy and self-conscious language, and in the end seemed totally unnecessary except to talk down to some dimwit who can't grasp the concept that words have contextual meanings.

I learned what I wanted to, for now.
I hope what you learned was that you were wrong.
 
vonneumann said:
I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.
The key here is the word believe. Which is actually all very well, but rather weak considering that we already have a good solid theory that explains speciation and with plenty of evidence, and that there is zero evidence for vonNeumann's belief. But of course, in time it may turn up.
So... you fellows [drfrank, DSE, steenkh, et al] do NOT believe interspecies lateral gene transfer could happen? ...does happen?
 
Proposed paranormal demonstration: levels of hope normally impossible to humans.

Demonstration successful? :checkmark

*Awards million dollar prize to Chipmunk*
NO! I am NOT wrong about the use of teleological terms by those who deny teleology. It is there to be seen if you go research it yourself. I just gave up on you guys because of your cognitive dissonance. I don't try to convert smokers, either.

Chipmunk showed that a few non-teleological statements can be produced that say something about evolution. OK. Give him a prize. While you do that, I still stand amazed at the lack of explanation in evolution and the overuse of those terms.

Now, I think Pixy is correct that this has been bantered "ad nauseum". ...only because those who will not see ...will not see.

Before I get sick... go see:

http://www.asa3.org/archive/evolution/199505-10/0202.html

..where the veritable Dawkins says he is going to demonstrate evolution, gives a 'telelogical' demonstration ...admits it...tries again... and does it AGAIN!

This is his flipping book! Couldn't he have just thrown that stuff in the trash before he decided to take it to publishing?

You wanna' know why he doesn't throw it in the trash? ...its because teleology IS THE BEST HE HAS.
 
Last edited:
Chipmunk showed that a few non-teleological statements can be produced that say something about evolution. OK. Give him a prize. While you do that, I still stand amazed at the lack of explanation in evolution and the overuse of those terms.
Yes.

And this is entirely your problem. Evolution can be explained without reference to design or cause or meaning; this has been demonstrated. You can't argue that it is necessary, because we have proved it is not.

Now, I think Pixy is correct that this has been bantered "ad nauseum". ...only because those who will not see ...will not see.
Exactly. None so blind as those who will not concede that their argument is entirely unsupported, and all that.

You wanna' know why he doesn't throw it in the trash? ...its because teleology IS THE BEST HE HAS.
No.
 
VonNeumann doesn't believe in speciation (`macroevolution'), and instead thinks that the Designer steps in every so often, in the form of retroviruses sent from space, to upgrade the genome to Quadraped V1.4.3.

No, really :rolleyes:
drfrank, i really don't think you can summarize all that i've said, like that. Really, do you? You are making reference here to panspermia. I specifically referenced panspermia.org as a place you can go, and they BTW claim to be anti-ID.

I said that I believe viruses can and do spread lateral information, and that I thought of that idea myself, decades ago. It is finally catching on. When I thought of it, my idea was that it was merely a missing ingredient to evolution and that it would have a powerful effect in allowing 'good ideas' to spread. ...sort of how the patent system, and scientific publishing works.

I also noted that Francis Crick thought there was insufficient evidence of life evolving here and that is why he postulated directed panspermia.

Since lateral (horizontal) gene transfer does not fit into the 'descent with modification' constraints of Darwinistic Evolution, I suppose many people still do not buy into it (?) - you don't?

I think there is more plausibility in that this biosphere has been periodically upgraded with revisions, than that there is spontaneous generation of information here. Spontaneous adjustment of parameters? OK. But not new information [my subjective definition thereof]. And I still need to learn more about the nylonase - I have seen some rebuttal info out there on that subject.

I think that all I said was I see relative plausibility in panspermia - not that I "believe" it. I did say I believe viruses can infect, maybe even inter-kingdom, to bring about sudden changes. How that can fit into the evolution model, I don't know, because it certainly seems to have to require some sort of higher level 'planning'.
 
No?:) You are in total denial.
No.

Look. Evolution can be and often is explained without reference to purpose. This has been demonstrated, right here in this thread. To claim otherwise means that you are in denial.

Is it because Dawkins is your priest that you do not wonder why he would give two teleological demonstrations for evolution - knowingly?
No. I have no priests. I have no faith.

Your "no" does not make it go away.
There is nothing there in the first place.
 
No, I mean you should stop using of your own accord in an attempt to stop pounding on your evolution strawman and contribute something meaningful ;)
I understand why you say that. I am basically lazy and try expressing from my own accord, as you say, rather than cite. So your point is well taken. As to whether I contribute anything meaningful ... I'll admit that I am here for me, not for you. I press buttons and I get responses. It is very interesting. It is amusing how people actually get angry, pompous, and punitive. Someone said I was boring, but even if I am totally wrong, the subjects may be untenable but I do not believe 'boring'.

OTOH, I think I contribute some input into the minds of any who read these posts: at least I hope it reminds that there are other ways to think about things. I observe here that there is a bit of a herd mentality - a locked in lexicon - that sounds to me like 'hatfield vs mccoy' type thinking[an american euphemism for a legendary hillbilly feud].

I expect you may have rather that we had had some debate via cite and counter -cite on evidence of evolution. That is a bit of work, and not what I feel like doing. But I did give an example of what I thought was typical of counter-evidence that is ignored through a weak explaining-away. No one came back on it. It was on the subject of the avian-phlanges.


That is completely separate from the fact that genomes are very different from standard computer algorithms, and therefore an algorithmic metaphor is invalid. Your 1k algorithmic string example remains pointless.

Well, mainly I was saying that a communications channel metaphor is completely inappropriate. Bully for you if you're not using one :)

However, if you were inclined to you could treat the mutated and non-mutated genomes as separate messages, in which case they would inevitably contain slightly different amounts of information. Mutations would not count as noise as, technically, they represent an alteration in the message rather than a corruption of it - the goal is not to perfectly reproduce on the other side what went in, unlike in comms.

If you weren't using Shannon's measure, then please describe exactly what measure you were using because, forgive me, but you seem to be using the Subjective Measure of Information (SMI) which gives exactly the answer you want in a given circumstance...

I guarantee that if you settle on a solid definition of information then there are trivial examples demonstrating increase in information from evolution.

So, of course, my prediction is that you'll never be pinned down on it.
I do not know how to do this, without restricting the context. How much information is there in pi? pi=c/2r is only 7 bytes? What about the series? What about the infinitely long string of digits? What measure method is to be used? I did not understand how you can so quickly dismiss the 1K string analogy, I gave.

About the nylonase, I saw where someone was argueing about frame-shifts being known mechanisms in immune-systems for re-calibrating against a new threat. I didn't look very hard yet but I have not yet found how many base pairs are involved in the nylonase. How many base-pairs were coded in the precursor, and how many base-pairs in the resultant nylonase? If there are not new base-pairs, please explain to me under what measurement method there would be an increase in information.
 
No.
Look. Evolution can be and often is explained without reference to purpose. This has been demonstrated, right here in this thread. To claim otherwise means that you are in denial.
There is nothing there in the first place.
no - You look. I would be a 'believer' if Dawkins had pulled off a NON-TELEOLOGICAL demonstration of evolution. Even if he just had ONE. But the reason he DIDN'T is because he COULDN'T. If you pull out the teleology from the demonstrations, they deflate - Dawkins admitted it.

It is like saying "I can make ice without using heat transport phenomenon. I'll demonstrate." Then in demonstration the perp uses a refrigerator. Then says, "well sorry - of course the refrigerator employs heat transport phenomenon - but still I made ice." Then he says, here I'll do it another way, and uses a peltier cell. Then he says, "sorry again - peltier uses heat transport, too. To summarize, I've shown how ice can be made, (albeit with the help of heat transport)."

This is important to my point because I did not mean that one could not merely state identities without employing teleology (as chipmunk did). But to produce an explanation of substance, particularly like a demonstration, I challenge you to do that. Dawkins tried and his deus a machina was 'teleology'.
 
So... you fellows [drfrank, DSE, steenkh, et al] do NOT believe interspecies lateral gene transfer could happen? ...does happen?
I can't speak for drfrank and steenkh, but I'm more interested in why you think there is a designer as opposed whether or not lateral gene transfer happens. Is there something about lateral gene transfer that, if it happens, you believe proves the existence of a designer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom