Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I do not need 'infinite crap shoot' to explain this universe. Your logic is the same backwards logic as when you have a winning number in a lottery and believe that there must be some higher meaning that gave you this particular number!

This universe is our winning number. As far as we know, we would not have been around to wonder about the universe if the universe had been different in any way. There is no way of looking backwards to determine if it was chance or design that gave us this universe.

And the lack of evidence for a designer, combined with all the evidence that a designer is not needed, makes ME lean away from design.
Yeh yeh yeh.. I know that. The infinite crap shoot WITH the anthropic illusion. It is still an infinite crap shoot. I merely said that I UNDERSTAND infinite crap shoot [with anthropic illusion]. It could happen. I totally agree. I can contemplate infinite crap shoot with anthropic illusion and go "wow - amen bros!" for an instant or two. We are in synch on this. THe only thing I see differently is your phrase "all the evidence that a designer is not needed" since I see RM/NS as so extremely thin on evidence. So I lean differently.
 
The religious people I have encountered have had no problem with this question: Either God created himself (!), or God is above logic, and accordingly you cannot apply logic reasoning to his being!
Did everything we have in the world bootstrap itself out of a singularity? Is that a way of summarizing the materialistic paradigm that many hold? We call things like that "emerging" or "emergence" or "self-organization" ? Stuff like that?

When it comes to origins, everybody sort of has an 'order from chaos' myth or some other 'spontaneous origin' thang...

I assume everyone has a problem with this question, don't they? Don't you? You are satisfied - totally satiated?
 
I was talking to everyone in general. I was trying to find a place to slip into this conversation, but it looks like everything's already being said, and I have nothing new to add.

I do have a question, though. Is ID claiming that the Universe was designed purposely to support life, that it was designed imperfectly and life was a side-effect, or is the claim that something was designed, but what is not known?
I dunno. I don't belong to any club. I'm a REAL skeptic.;)

I wouldn't lump together creationism with ID though. There are IDers who fully believe in modern synthesis of evolution, I've heard. I can buy into that too a little if and only if all the basic genes we have today were already here half a billion years ago.

To see what IDers say, there are some interesting forums on iscid.org.
 
Yeh yeh yeh.. I know that. The infinite crap shoot WITH the anthropic illusion.
Could you explain how the anthropic principle is an illusion? It does not state that we are not singular or that the world was not created especially to suit us. It merely states that we have no way of knowing just from the fact that we exist.
 
When it comes to origins, everybody sort of has an 'order from chaos' myth or some other 'spontaneous origin' thang...

I assume everyone has a problem with this question, don't they? Don't you? You are satisfied - totally satiated?
No, I am not satisfied. For every question in the world, I would like answers. The origin of Life, Universe, and Everything is not different. Theists are free to assume that their preferred deity did it. I can accept that theory, but on the other hand I would have expected the deity to be at least slightly detectable in the universe after the creation, so my own preferred theory is that there probably is no designer/deity, and presumably there is some other answer to this question.

But certain questions like this one are bound to be difficult or impossible to answer because of the impossiblity of testing theories and the lack of evidence, and I accept that the definitive answer will probably never be found. It still makes interesting stuff for theorising, though.

But this whole thread was, as far as I have understood, not about cosmogenisis and abiogenesis, but about evolution, and I believe that the theory of the evolution of life is rock-solid with lots and lots of evidence - thin as you may think - contra ID with no evidence at all.
 
I really should [not] get away with...? [you mean?]
No, I mean you should stop using of your own accord in an attempt to stop pounding on your evolution strawman and contribute something meaningful ;)
Why not? They are apples/oranges academically - yes. But I would think a materialist, as I presume you are, would see that evolution, being a reducible mechanistic process, reduces to the equivalent of what could be made into an algorithm (someday when we are sufficiently smart enough to do so).
That is completely separate from the fact that genomes are very different from standard computer algorithms, and therefore an algorithmic metaphor is invalid. Your 1k algorithmic string example remains pointless.
Shannon would call what you described (point mutation) as 'noise'. But I wasn't using a communications channel metaphor. What exactly prompted you to say "...measure of information is meaningless w.r.t. DNA"?:confused:
Well, mainly I was saying that a communications channel metaphor is completely inappropriate. Bully for you if you're not using one :)

However, if you were inclined to you could treat the mutated and non-mutated genomes as separate messages, in which case they would inevitably contain slightly different amounts of information. Mutations would not count as noise as, technically, they represent an alteration in the message rather than a corruption of it - the goal is not to perfectly reproduce on the other side what went in, unlike in comms.

If you weren't using Shannon's measure, then please describe exactly what measure you were using because, forgive me, but you seem to be using the Subjective Measure of Information (SMI) which gives exactly the answer you want in a given circumstance...

I guarantee that if you settle on a solid definition of information then there are trivial examples demonstrating increase in information from evolution.

So, of course, my prediction is that you'll never be pinned down on it.
 
Last edited:
Where did I accuse anybody of anything? Chill.

You wer basically arguing that, since people say "design", even if they claim it was not intelligent design, they, somehow, deep down really believe in ID. This is clearly not the case, and your mentionning it takes us away from the actual argument, which I'm sure suits you fine.
 
What is a 'mind'? The only 'mind' I know of is my own and, not being a solipsist, other humans' minds. Since I know 'minds' exist, I can hypothesize that something like that, a mind, did the designing of, minimally, the physical laws. Personally, I see this filling-in the gap less extreme than filling-in the gap with randomness. I'm not saying that to argue - its just my present take on what I see is very thin, evidence-wise - one way OR the other.

Yeah, that's because you're not thinking scientifically, because you've just posited an untestable hypothesis, and your basic misunderstanding of the current theory makes it unlikely to you.
 
I meant from the standpoint that if I do a shift of "LMN" to "MNO", its the same amount of bits: same amount of info. That was just at first glance, as I said. Is that invalid, in that context?

Yes, because the information theoretic definition of "bits" is different from the computer science defintion of "bits," which, in turn, is different from the teleological definition of "information" with regard to fitness of purpose.
 
You wer basically arguing that, since people say "design", even if they claim it was not intelligent design, they, somehow, deep down really believe in ID. This is clearly not the case, and your mentionning it takes us away from the actual argument, which I'm sure suits you fine.
No. It is quite to-the-point to understand what each other means when we say 'design'. That is why I wanted to know why some people, who have a zero-teleological view, seemingly cannot avoid using teleological terms. I learned what I wanted to, for now.
 
I know you did not really mean to make such a sweeping statement, as "they all oppose ... the simulation claim." Surely, you categorize me in the set of {IDers, Creationists, scientists}, somewhere?

Hmmm...

You're right, they do not all oppose simulation in that a League of the Faithful and Scientists has not stepped up to say, "Simulation is wrong, and we have tickety-thousand signatures against it." Instead, they're opposed in principle.

Any creation-event (be it the establishment of a firmament in Genesis, or some sort of Big Bang) leads to an existant universe that can be known, in part, either through Faith or science. The model stands in contrast to some sort of simulation/mass consentual hallucination/Aristotelean quintessential material/ etc. For both the Faithful and scientific, anything unknowable regarding physical reality is mere fantasy. Where they differ, is in the existence of anything outside of physical reality, such as Heaven/Hell, etc. but even those follow 'religious' rules.

So actually, on this particular issue, regardless of your profession, I classify you as none of: IDer, Creationist, nor Scientist, but some weird fourth way. Regardless of what philosophers say about God's influence on evolution (0<influence<complete), Intelligent Design as written, seems to be a political movement founded, at least in part, by the Discovery Institute. DI => ID? :D

You and I are back to square 1. I am somewhat interested in the simulation idea, but I believe the physical universe is complete unto itself. With that, I am somewhat consistent with the Faithful (when not considering aspects such as an after-life). How do you:
i) Justify the reality of our existence as simulation?
ii) Make neat machines and do neat stuff with that knowledge (esp. interesting to me)?
iii) Make predictions about future states of the simulation?
iv) Discover any simulation rules not directly analogous to the scientific rules currently being discovered?

Take me from here, man! :cool:
 
No. It is quite to-the-point to understand what each other means when we say 'design'. That is why I wanted to know why some people, who have a zero-teleological view, seemingly cannot avoid using teleological terms. I learned what I wanted to, for now.

Can I consider, then, that when we say "design" to describe biological and evolutive processes, you understand that we don't mean "design" in the intelligent sense ?
 
Could you explain how the anthropic principle is an illusion? It does not state that we are not singular or that the world was not created especially to suit us. It merely states that we have no way of knowing just from the fact that we exist.
There are multiple interpretations of 'anthropic principle'. Please just go plug in 'anthropic principle' for where I called it 'anthropic illusion'.
 
Can I consider, then, that when we say "design" to describe biological and evolutive processes, you understand that we don't mean "design" in the intelligent sense ?
I hear you. ...and can I consider then that when non-teleological people use teleological terms, then they don't really mean what they say?:confused:

Biologists have never had trouble making up new words when they needed them. Heck, that's most of what biology was until more recently: draw a picture of something and make up a big word for it.:) Its what Rutherford meant when he made reference to stamp collecting. Not to denigrate biology - it is the science about the most complex stuff in this universe that we can study. This century will be to biology what the 20th century was to physics.

So let them make up new words so they won't have to use the teleological ones so much.
 
How do you:
i) Justify the reality of our existence as simulation?
ii) Make neat machines and do neat stuff with that knowledge (esp. interesting to me)?
iii) Make predictions about future states of the simulation?
iv) Discover any simulation rules not directly analogous to the scientific rules currently being discovered?

Take me from here, man! :cool:
:) The fact that I can't begin to take you from here, man, is a fact I recognized long time ago. I had entered grad school to specialize in some facet of AI - only to drop out. I decided AI was not here yet - at least not where I wanted it to be at that time.
 
I hear you. ...and can I consider then that when non-teleological people use teleological terms, then they don't really mean what they say?:confused:

That's somewhat dishonest, since there is no way around this problem short of inventing new terms specifically for the purposes of this discussion. The term "design" can be used in a way distinct from what an architect would mean by it. Kinda like the word "marcher" (walk) in French can be used to mean "fonctionner" (work, as in function.) (sorry no other example comes to mind.)

Biologists have never had trouble making up new words when they needed them.

Ah, but there ARE scientific, technical terms that represent what we're describing here. They are: "random mutation" and "natural selection". When we need to define what they mean and how they work, we usually fall back to simpler layman terms, and so we're stuck with "design".

So let them make up new words so they won't have to use the teleological ones so much.

I still think this is a non-issue. Whether or not we use a term that you interpret as meaning ONE thing that it DOES mean under ONE definition does not mean that it doesn't mean what WE use it for under ANOTHER definition.
 
There are multiple interpretations of 'anthropic principle'. Please just go plug in 'anthropic principle' for where I called it 'anthropic illusion'.
But this discussion is not about interpretations but about logic: Just like you cannot determine that the winning lottery ticket was made specially for you, you also cannot determine that the world was specially for you.

What is illusory about that?
 
I suppose if you were Edison, in 1900, and you could see the future (say 1999) for a moment, you would claim humans incompetently designed the CD player because it skips when you bump it. The laser and embedded programs in the motor controllers and the digital signal processors would not impress you. The flaws would be enough for you to say ' if you were smart enough to do all that, why isn't it perfect?
Again, I don't think that is a fair analogy. What I'm trying to say is if the development of a CD Player was a designed process, I wouldn't expect to find a tiny non-functional analog record player inside when I cracked it open, or a wires that wrapped around the circuit board 6 times before making a connection 1cm away. But if it was a non-designed evolutionary process, I would expect to find all sorts of non-optimal attributes that don't have a huge negative effect on the whole.

But again, this argument is really focused on the idea that a designer not being continuously involved with the evolutionary process, which as I now understand your point of view, is not what you think.

My understanding is that you believe a designer was only involved in the origins of life, not any of the developments since then. Is that fair to say?
 
I can't believe this. All evolution is about is 'descent with modification'. ...Hardly anything to argue about since that does not say much. But that's on one hand. On the other hand, when evolution is used to explain everything, as so many people tend to do, and it gets into origins, then clearly, that is a faith issue. Whatever theory we each have on ORIGINS, we take on faith, because the evidence is lacking. YOU know this. Don't be so unilateral.
I think I understand where you're coming from. But, just because we don't have definitive answers on aspects how the first single celled organisms originated, I that doesn't make all explanations equally valid.

Your argument, as I understand it, is that life is too mathematically unlikely for it to have evolved from chemical processes as we understand them. I honestly don't agree, but for me that's besides the point. I still don't understand why you've picked a designer as the answer. For me, that feels like a huge leap. We have never seen any evidence of a designer. Yes, we have unexplained phenomena, but in itself is not evidence of anything supernatural. In fact, as our understanding grows, it's often the unexplained phenomena that people thought was caused by something supernatural forces that we are able to explain scientifically.

I agree we have more to study on the subject, but I don't understand how that supports your belief that it must be a supernatural force.

Supernatural forces have been disproved as the cause of explained phenomena countless times. After so many years of supernatural explanations being wrong, how can we trust them without explicit proof?

I'm a skeptic, an atheist, and a freethinker. But, giving strong evidence explicitly pointing to something supernatural, I could be convinced. I still do not understand, with the knowledge that we have today, and the number of times supernatural explanation have been proven wrong, how you logically get from "we don't have a complete understanding of how life was first formed" to "a designer was involved with the first creation of life".

What makes you think a designer has to be the only answer? Or even the most likely answer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom