I know you did not really mean to make such a sweeping statement, as "they all oppose ... the simulation claim." Surely, you categorize me in the set of {IDers, Creationists, scientists}, somewhere?
Hmmm...
You're right, they do not all
oppose simulation in that a League of the Faithful and Scientists has not stepped up to say, "Simulation is wrong, and we have tickety-thousand signatures against it." Instead, they're opposed in principle.
Any creation-event (be it the establishment of a firmament in Genesis, or some sort of Big Bang) leads to an existant universe that can be known, in part, either through Faith or science. The model stands in contrast to some sort of simulation/mass consentual hallucination/Aristotelean quintessential material/ etc. For both the Faithful and scientific, anything unknowable regarding physical reality is mere fantasy.
Where they differ, is in the existence of anything outside of physical reality, such as Heaven/Hell, etc. but even those follow 'religious' rules.
So actually, on this particular issue, regardless of your profession, I classify you as none of: IDer, Creationist, nor Scientist, but some weird fourth way. Regardless of what philosophers say about God's influence on evolution (0<influence<complete),
Intelligent Design as written, seems to be a political movement founded, at least in part, by the Discovery Institute. DI => ID?
You and I are back to square 1. I am somewhat interested in the simulation idea, but I believe the physical universe is complete unto itself. With that, I am somewhat consistent with the Faithful (when not considering aspects such as an after-life). How do you:
i) Justify the reality of our existence as simulation?
ii) Make neat machines and do neat stuff with that knowledge (esp. interesting to me)?
iii) Make predictions about future states of the simulation?
iv) Discover any simulation rules not directly analogous to the scientific rules currently being discovered?
Take me from here, man!
