Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

If you have ruled out 'design' entirely, the only guess I can make as to how you can accept that the physical laws of the universe were 'just so' to make all this happen, is that you allow some sort of paradigm allowing essentially near infinite time for random processes to instantiate this universe [coin it: infinite crap shoot]. If so, then you take that on faith, since there is no evidence. It is taken by default. I'm not asking you repeatedly why you would believe that, because I understand why. But let me contrast the idea of the 'infinite crap shoot' to 'design': 'infinite crap shoot' is something we can conceive but not something we can point out an example to; 'design' is something we can conceive because we know it exists and in fact possess such faculty ourselves.d THAT'S why I lean toward design.
I do not need 'infinite crap shoot' to explain this universe. Your logic is the same backwards logic as when you have a winning number in a lottery and believe that there must be some higher meaning that gave you this particular number!

This universe is our winning number. As far as we know, we would not have been around to wonder about the universe if the universe had been different in any way. There is no way of looking backwards to determine if it was chance or design that gave us this universe.

And the lack of evidence for a designer, combined with all the evidence that a designer is not needed, makes ME lean away from design.
 
Science vs ID

And the lack of evidence for a designer, combined with all the evidence that a designer is not needed, makes ME lean away from design.


This seems related to one of my previous arguments.

Whether deliberately designed by an intelligent entity or derived from random processes, we have no possible way to differentiate without the kind of outside knowledge that science has no access to. So, from a strictly logical standpoint, the argument is a draw, since neither argument can progress.

Science can't prove a designer or justify simply assuming one and ID can't disprove science or provide a sound reason for attempting to do so.

Basing my decision as to which is more probable on religious beliefs is not a valid scientific argument in defence of that decision.

Theories of how everything originated can be extended into infinity without resolution.


Consider: Who designed the designer?

According the the same ID 'logic', the designer is obviously so fantastic, he/she/it must have been designed too! The classic endless circular argument.

*
*
 
OK sphenisc, now that you have your arms around 'design', go write programs that think of neat things to design. What goes on in your mind when you 'design'? That's what i mean by 'define design'.

Next time, try 'simulate creativity'.
 
Consider: Who designed the designer?
The religious people I have encountered have had no problem with this question: Either God created himself (!), or God is above logic, and accordingly you cannot apply logic reasoning to his being!
 
I understand, helz-belz, why it is frustrating to you that we seemingly steer off the argument. Frustrating, I see, to others as well.

Here is why: this discussion is more about 'what we think reality is' than it is about 'what reality is'. Much of what I am interested in here is what people think. Somebody already well pointed out that this discussion too easily turns into 'my daddy can beat up your daddy.' [to paraphrase]. I'm not here to cry 'uncle' or to think I am going to get anyone else to do so.

If you continue accusing people of thinking something different than they claim, then you're not adressing the actual issue and you're antagonizing people all around you. Please stick to the subject.
 
VonNeumann said:
How would you say it. The multi-verse or rebirthing universes and the anthropic illusion. Call it 'near infinite re-tries'. I'm too lazy to look up what it is called.

We have no evidence of other universes. What's more, there is no reason to believe that other universes would have time, or that this time would be in any way similar to our own.
 
VonNeumann, I really think you should get away from computing metaphors when talking about evolution. Apples and oranges, see?

Computer programs are not redundant - change one byte and there's a good chance they'll fail utterly, or at least perform no useful task.

In biology, changing one amino acid in a protein is unlikely to vastly change the shape, and thus function, of the protein. Even if it does, the protein is likely to do something, even if it isn't useful in the current environment.

* Space of algorithms: only a miniscule proportion of the space contains useful algorithms.
* Space of proteins: a large proportion will have some function, and the space will contain gradients that may be scaled.

There's the difference - it's a big difference.

Talking about symbols in terms of information in DNA seems like you're using Shannon's definition. In which case, any point mutation will, by definition, either cause a small increase or decrease in the information present within the DNA. However, I'd say that this measure of information is meaningless with relation to DNA.
 
to begin with I have trouble with defining consciousness. Can you program, 'munk, when you're not conscious? ..neither can I. So.... you have difficulty, too - or... you have your own definition of 'design'.
Okay, consciousness, creativity, and abstraction are prerequisites to design. You're asking for cookbook definitions of consciousness, creativity, and abstraction, not design.

How does the fact that the only creature we know of that can design has never been able to design a machine that can design further your argument?

This whole line of calling the definition of design into question has really confused your position.
 
I didn't really decide yet. If you will look I responded only minutes after pixy's post so I had not enough time to research it yet.

With respect,.... no, strike that, without respect,.... you were pretty insistant in your dismissal that the nylon-eating bacteria were not "new information."

A person from a smarter religion might have done the research before he came up with the answer.
 
With respect,.... no, strike that, without respect,.... you were pretty insistant in your dismissal that the nylon-eating bacteria were not "new information."

A person from a smarter religion might have done the research before he came up with the answer.

With all respect, though - and really, respectfully - we have all been insistent about certain things, then later proven wrong and changed our position. I understand he should have researched a bit more before he chimed, but that previous response isn't important now. What is important is the position he is now taking.
 
Either God created himself (!), or God is above logic, and accordingly you cannot apply logic reasoning to his being!

This is the only kind of interesting IDesigner. If the IDesigner does not require a first cause then things are summed up. Also, since science tells us certain things about the universe, only something that is a strict violation of science (logic) is important enough to fall outside its domain.

I believe that OOOC CAN design a rock that OOOC can't lift and that OOOC CAN lift the unliftable rock that OOOC designed so that OOOC couldn't lift it.

Otherwise... who cares? We may as well believe OOOC doesn't exist.

errr... wait... ;)

BTW, IDers, Creationists and scientists DO share 1 very important aspect of their worldview. They believe that there is somelthing called the universe and that it is somehow knowable (either through faith or study). They all oppose (or at least find irrelevant) the simulation claim.
 
With all respect, though - and really, respectfully - we have all been insistent about certain things, then later proven wrong and changed our position. I understand he should have researched a bit more before he chimed, but that previous response isn't important now. What is important is the position he is now taking.

Yes, I think "VonNeumann" (it's funny to call him that) is a smart guy to talk with, unlike many ID people I have seen in this forum. But then I am a computer scientist, so I may be biased :P
 
If you continue accusing people of thinking something different than they claim, then you're not adressing the actual issue and you're antagonizing people all around you. Please stick to the subject.
Where did I accuse anybody of anything? Chill.

Subject (singular)?
 
With respect,.... no, strike that, without respect,.... you were pretty insistant in your dismissal that the nylon-eating bacteria were not "new information."

A person from a smarter religion might have done the research before he came up with the answer.
I meant from the standpoint that if I do a shift of "LMN" to "MNO", its the same amount of bits: same amount of info. That was just at first glance, as I said. Is that invalid, in that context?
 
'VonNeumann' claims to be related to Johnny. He would have been so disappointed.

VonNeumann - You do the deranged pseudointellectual rather badly.

Please go off and read several good books before you post more inanity.

I'm sure several of us would be happy to suggest some to you.

Your topics bore me and your intellect, such as it is, is wasted on the nonsense that you wallow in.

You are neither amusing nor interesting. You appear to have nothing to offer.

If I am mistaken about your having nothing to offer, please provide evidence to the contrary at your earliest convenience, for you grow tedius and life is short.
 
Okay, consciousness, creativity, and abstraction are prerequisites to design. You're asking for cookbook definitions of consciousness, creativity, and abstraction, not design.

How does the fact that the only creature we know of that can design has never been able to design a machine that can design further your argument?

This whole line of calling the definition of design into question has really confused your position.
Again, I'm here to see what people think... why they believe as they do.

Confused my position? I think it is interesting that, around here, there is a more specific idea about "what is design" than what I hold.

To me, this is the "design" we are talking about:
1. Takes place in a 'mind'
2. the parametrics "efficiency" or "perfection" or similar values, are moot to the definition.

What is a 'mind'? The only 'mind' I know of is my own and, not being a solipsist, other humans' minds. Since I know 'minds' exist, I can hypothesize that something like that, a mind, did the designing of, minimally, the physical laws. Personally, I see this filling-in the gap less extreme than filling-in the gap with randomness. I'm not saying that to argue - its just my present take on what I see is very thin, evidence-wise - one way OR the other.
 
'VonNeumann' claims to be related to Johnny. He would have been so disappointed.

VonNeumann - You do the deranged pseudointellectual rather badly.

Please go off and read several good books before you post more inanity.

I'm sure several of us would be happy to suggest some to you.

Your topics bore me and your intellect, such as it is, is wasted on the nonsense that you wallow in.

You are neither amusing nor interesting. You appear to have nothing to offer.

If I am mistaken about your having nothing to offer, please provide evidence to the contrary at your earliest convenience, for you grow tedius and life is short.
I thought it was a good comeback to the sassy posts about my login to suggest John von was my great uncle. I didn't think anyone would take it seriously and I doubt that you did.

Deranged? Inane? It is not required that you be friendly, but your vehemence is astonishing.

BTW, you may not know this but the 'von' was purchased, as you might purchase a dba at your local courthouse, in Austria, by Johnny's Daddy.

Complexity, you are obviously wrong about the entertainment value of my presence here. All you have to do is ignore me - which is what I had already thought you had decided to do (couldn't help it could you?).

My purpose here is to see what people think. I've noted what you think.
 
BTW, IDers, Creationists and scientists DO share 1 very important aspect of their worldview. They believe that there is somelthing called the universe and that it is somehow knowable (either through faith or study). They all oppose (or at least find irrelevant) the simulation claim.
I know you did not really mean to make such a sweeping statement, as "they all oppose ... the simulation claim." Surely, you categorize me in the set of {IDers, Creationists, scientists}, somewhere?

BUT... I do not disagree with you're point, entirely. The simulation claim as you called it, is not something I've ever noted anyone BUT a materialist favor. In other words, I agree it is probably antithetical to most Creationist-types and even most IDer types. Frankly, I thought more of you here would give it more plausibility.
 
VonNeumann, I really think you should get away from computing metaphors when talking about evolution. Apples and oranges, see?
I really should [not] get away with...? [you mean?]

Why not? They are apples/oranges academically - yes. But I would think a materialist, as I presume you are, would see that evolution, being a reducible mechanistic process, reduces to the equivalent of what could be made into an algorithm (someday when we are sufficiently smart enough to do so).

Talking about symbols in terms of information in DNA seems like you're using Shannon's definition. In which case, any point mutation will, by definition, either cause a small increase or decrease in the information present within the DNA. However, I'd say that this measure of information is meaningless with relation to DNA.
Shannon would call what you described (point mutation) as 'noise'. But I wasn't using a communications channel metaphor. What exactly prompted you to say "...measure of information is meaningless w.r.t. DNA"?:confused:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom