Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I suppose if you were Edison, in 1900, and you could see the future (say 1999) for a moment, you would claim humans incompetently designed the CD player because it skips when you bump it.

And yet, the design has been improved with cache memory specifically to prevent this.

The flaws would be enough for you to say ' if you were smart enough to do all that, why isn't it perfect?'

No one claims that humans are perfect designers.

Another argument might be that the designer designed physical laws and then wanted to see what would happen - an experiment if you will. Again, why do you expect perfection? I don't see that.

Must I understand that you now drop any and all arguments about the designer having anything to do with biological evolution ? Are you conceding that RM/NS work ? Or are you simply beign hypothetical ? Lest we are trolling, let's stick with your actual arguments.
 
That is astonishing. Not to mitigate it, but it is not an increase in information. That was why I was asking the multiple choice question in the first place, trying to get some insight on increase of information vs translocation. Have any links for 'increase of'?
I think all of us knew that'd be your answer long before you even read the page ;)

A base was inserted, causing a frameshift and leading to the formation of a completely new protein. Now that the bacteria, through exaptation, has developed a novel function, that function can be improved and specialised through mutations causing slight changes in the shape of the protein that may cause it to react more efficiently with nylon.

Claiming no new `information' was created here is akin to the following: take a billion letters and arrange them into the Complete Works of Shakespeare but, hey, no new information has been added as all the letters were already present :p
 
Last edited:
Then you're simply wrong. Language is limited, and we use it at best we can.
And in any case, the statement is false. Evolution can be, and is, explained without reference to intent or design or purpose or any such terms. And the explanation is perfectly meaningful. VN seems to be using the argumentum ad libri rego, or I don't care what you say, this book I read...
 
This new information that is ubiquitous is mostly, what?
1. base sequences that do not correlate at all to samples taken from presumed living examples of ancestors.
2. base sequences that correlate to samples from presumed living examples of ancestors, that can be best characterized by translocations, reversals, and other 'editing' of large chunks.
3. base sequences that correlate ....., that can be best characterized as having many scattered point mutations.
4. other?

What, exactly, do you think you mean by "new information"?

Depending upon the framework you use to measure "information," any or all of the above would be examples of "new information>'

The nylon-eating bacteria is a good example of "new information," and I don't understand your reasons for rejecting it. Another good example is the development of color vision in howler monkeys, where a single gene for a single opsin protein was duplicate, and then the two versions of the gene drifted via mutation to create two slightly different opsin proteins. From one function protein comes two proteins serving two different functions, which sure sounds like "new information" to me.

The various versions of hemoglobin, including the one used by unborn infants (fetal hemoglobin, or hemoglobin F) are another example; there are several differen versions serving different functions, and without these different versions, mammal-like reproduction would probably be impossible. (Fetal hemoglobin binds to oxygen more tightly than adult hemoglobin, giving the baby the ability to take oxygen from the mother's blood.)
 
I t seems pretty clear to me that you could show VN evolution occurring under controlled conditions in a lab and they would still say it wasnot happening or look for a designer.
 
I t seems pretty clear to me that you could show VN evolution occurring under controlled conditions in a lab and they would still say it wasnot happening or look for a designer.
 
OK, the designer may not have been perfect, so we cannot judge if it is design by looking for perfection, and in any case, we cannot define design. And you still claim that you can see signs of design in the world???
Some would say that a waterfall 'designs' a hole when the water pummels rock. So some take the word rather broadly. The kind of 'design' I think of in the context of this discussion is the same 'design' that we can do in our minds when we create something - say, when we write a program. Since we make conscious decisions to write programs and are aware of ourselves doing the design, and have in mind the reason why we are doing it, I will include all that in what I mean by 'design' - at least when I think about 'intelligent design'. I may have confused the issue when I was trying to see if others thought of evolution, in any conceivable way, doing design. That was merely because I was poking at it to try to understand what others believe and think.

Having said all that, I have not defined 'design', but I have put a bit of a boundary around it. If you notice, I included awareness of designing as part of the 'design' and so my idea of 'intelligent design' is something that has to take place in a 'mind'. I only know what a mind is because I have one, but have no idea how emerges from the mind, the self-awareness/consciousness quality. I have been skewered here for revealing that I believe mind is not mechanism.

I think if we could define 'design' we could program machines to: first, think about things to design, and secondly, design them. What I mean about not having a definition of design, you see, goes deeper than that. We understand each other when we say we will design something, but we cannot tell very deeply, what we actually do in thinking of what to design, and then when we go about doing it.

So now, how do I see 'signs of design in the world?' I know you didn't mean human design, but of course that at least proves for me that 'design' exists, and I suppose also for you. I am not proposing something that we are not sure exists since we at least have this one example - humans design. Ostensibly you are begging why I think there is any design other than human design.

We know that some complexity can emerge in relatively simple systems, like ripples in the sand, crystal structure, other non-linear dynamics examples, cellular automata, auto-catalytic sets, and others. I am waiting to see more on this. It may be a long wait.

If you have ruled out 'design' entirely, the only guess I can make as to how you can accept that the physical laws of the universe were 'just so' to make all this happen, is that you allow some sort of paradigm allowing essentially near infinite time for random processes to instantiate this universe [coin it: infinite crap shoot]. If so, then you take that on faith, since there is no evidence. It is taken by default. I'm not asking you repeatedly why you would believe that, because I understand why. But let me contrast the idea of the 'infinite crap shoot' to 'design': 'infinite crap shoot' is something we can conceive but not something we can point out an example to; 'design' is something we can conceive because we know it exists and in fact possess such faculty ourselves.d THAT'S why I lean toward design.
 
So... are we starting at the point where physical laws began behaving as they do now, or before it?

Is the assumption that the universe was created, in its entirety, for the existence of life, or that life was just a side effect of the small-scale imperfections of the universe - a "skip" in the CD, if you will?
Do you not subscribe to the theory that the physical laws are essentially static for all intents and purposes? Are you talking about during the big-bang transient? ...or are you presuming an era before the big-bang? ...i dunno what you mean. ...were you talking to me?:confused:
 
:confused: You're the only person I've ever met who's had difficulty with this.
to begin with I have trouble with defining consciousness. Can you program, 'munk, when you're not conscious? ..neither can I. So.... you have difficulty, too - or... you have your own definition of 'design'.
 
Then you're simply wrong. Language is limited, and we use it at best we can. Let's move on to the actual argument. I don't like it when people put the fact that I think or believe in doubt.
OK. Language is limited. So in explaining evolution, the language is limited to teleological terms. Without the teleological terms, the explaining says nearly nothing. So you have two choices: explain with teleological terms; or, say nearly nothing. Its because language is limited, not because there's no substance - got it.
 
OK. Language is limited. So in explaining evolution, the language is limited to teleological terms.
False.

Without the teleological terms, the explaining says nearly nothing.
False.

So you have two choices: explain with teleological terms; or, say nearly nothing.
False.

Its because language is limited, not because there's no substance - got it.
Correct.
 
Let's move on to the actual argument.
I understand, helz-belz, why it is frustrating to you that we seemingly steer off the argument. Frustrating, I see, to others as well.

Here is why: this discussion is more about 'what we think reality is' than it is about 'what reality is'. Much of what I am interested in here is what people think. Somebody already well pointed out that this discussion too easily turns into 'my daddy can beat up your daddy.' [to paraphrase]. I'm not here to cry 'uncle' or to think I am going to get anyone else to do so.
 
If you have ruled out 'design' entirely, the only guess I can make as to how you can accept that the physical laws of the universe were 'just so' to make all this happen, is that you allow some sort of paradigm allowing essentially near infinite time for random processes to instantiate this universe [coin it: infinite crap shoot]. If so, then you take that on faith, since there is no evidence. It is taken by default. I'm not asking you repeatedly why you would believe that, because I understand why. But let me contrast the idea of the 'infinite crap shoot' to 'design': 'infinite crap shoot' is something we can conceive but not something we can point out an example to; 'design' is something we can conceive because we know it exists and in fact possess such faculty ourselves.d THAT'S why I lean toward design.
That's Deism. We have no particular problem with Deism. We do have a problem with claims of evidence for Deism - but only because the claimants never actually have any.

Oh, by the way, your mention of "infinite time" is meaningless. Time is a property of our universe.
 
What, exactly, do you think you mean by "new information"?

Depending upon the framework you use to measure "information," any or all of the above would be examples of "new information>'

The nylon-eating bacteria is a good example of "new information," and I don't understand your reasons for rejecting it. Another good example is the development of color vision in howler monkeys, where a single gene for a single opsin protein was duplicate, and then the two versions of the gene drifted via mutation to create two slightly different opsin proteins. From one function protein comes two proteins serving two different functions, which sure sounds like "new information" to me.

The various versions of hemoglobin, including the one used by unborn infants (fetal hemoglobin, or hemoglobin F) are another example; there are several differen versions serving different functions, and without these different versions, mammal-like reproduction would probably be impossible. (Fetal hemoglobin binds to oxygen more tightly than adult hemoglobin, giving the baby the ability to take oxygen from the mother's blood.)
I didn't really decide yet. If you will look I responded only minutes after pixy's post so I had not enough time to research it yet. The link only gives a simplistic ascii example and so doesn't reveal much. My first reaction was it seemed to me that a frame shift, at first face, does not change the amount of symbols, so it seemed it would have the same amount of information. Please give me a chance to read more about it.
 
Oh, by the way, your mention of "infinite time" is meaningless. Time is a property of our universe.
How would you say it. The multi-verse or rebirthing universes and the anthropic illusion. Call it 'near infinite re-tries'. I'm too lazy to look up what it is called.
 
I didn't really decide yet. If you will look I responded only minutes after pixy's post so I had not enough time to research it yet. The link only gives a simplistic ascii example and so doesn't reveal much. My first reaction was it seemed to me that a frame shift, at first face, does not change the amount of symbols, so it seemed it would have the same amount of information. Please give me a chance to read more about it.
You don't need to change the amount of symbols, though there are certainly mutations that do so.

It's not complicated.

There is information here that was not present before. That means there is new information. It is not possible to coherently claim otherwise; you have to redefine either "information" or "new". Information is well-defined in science, so in doing that you would no longer be arguing the point, but arguing some point you made up. New is a perfectly simple temporal concept.

There is new information. It's not an open question, it's an established fact.
 
Last edited:
How would you say it. The multi-verse or rebirthing universes and the anthropic illusion. Call it 'near infinite re-tries'. I'm too lazy to look up what it is called.
Show me some evidence that any such thing has happened or could happen, and I'll give some thought to how we should describe it. At present, it would seem that not only is this purely speculative, it is something that must necessarily remain purely speculative forever.

It's equivalent to asking "Is there a God who doesn't interact with his creation in any way?" My answer is "Don't know. Don't care."
 
Do you not subscribe to the theory that the physical laws are essentially static for all intents and purposes? Are you talking about during the big-bang transient? ...or are you presuming an era before the big-bang? ...i dunno what you mean. ...were you talking to me?:confused:

I was talking to everyone in general. I was trying to find a place to slip into this conversation, but it looks like everything's already being said, and I have nothing new to add.

I do have a question, though. Is ID claiming that the Universe was designed purposely to support life, that it was designed imperfectly and life was a side-effect, or is the claim that something was designed, but what is not known?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom