Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Well, no. The reason for the reaction is that he accepted this on faith, claimed that he had evidence, and accused the people who actually have evidence of accepting things on faith. In other words, he has been throroughly dishonest.
Baloney. I have always said that we all have to take origins on faith - all of us.
It comes down to falsifibility and you are well aware of that.
 
It's hard for me to parse this any way other than that you choose to believe in a designer for reasons of faith. Am I understanding correctly?
I can't believe this. All evolution is about is 'descent with modification'. ...Hardly anything to argue about since that does not say much. But that's on one hand. On the other hand, when evolution is used to explain everything, as so many people tend to do, and it gets into origins, then clearly, that is a faith issue. Whatever theory we each have on ORIGINS, we take on faith, because the evidence is lacking. YOU know this. Don't be so unilateral.
 
I'm not convinced that's the reason. Even if I accept the possibility that humanity will have the power to create at least simulated universes, I still see no evidence that a designer was involved with this universe.
Again, from what you stated earlier (unless I misunderstood), it seems like you choose to believe in a designer for this universe for reasons of faith. I think that is the main reason people reacted so strong.

This thread was started on [origins of physical laws]. Do you have a pet idea of what that origin is? If you do, you take it on FAITH. In case you didn't notice, there is no evidence. ...or do you have a news bulletin for us?
 
Why don't I mention the 'missing piece' of evolution? We've been round and round on this.

Let me ask you: On Dawkins "Methinks it is like a weasle"... Do you believe that to be a valid analogy to evolution in any way?

Wow, look a spontaneous inversion mutation. :)
 
I would like to jump into the conversation somewhere. I'd like the definition of "origin" that we're using.

Are we defining the "origins" of physical laws as the point when they first acted as they do now, or "origins" as to the process that led to physical laws acting the way they do now?
 
Last edited:
I suppose if you were Edison, in 1900, and you could see the future (say 1999) for a moment, you would claim humans incompetently designed the CD player because it skips when you bump it. The laser and embedded programs in the motor controllers and the digital signal processors would not impress you. The flaws would be enough for you to say ' if you were smart enough to do all that, why isn't it perfect?'

Another argument might be that the designer designed physical laws and then wanted to see what would happen - an experiment if you will. Again, why do you expect perfection? I don't see that.

But of course "designer" brings unanswered questions. There are always unanswered questions. Like I said before - we can barely define the word "design". If we knew what we do when we conceive of something we want to do, then plan, then design, we could program machines to do it and we would all be redundant already. But we cannot define design.
OK, the designer may not have been perfect, so we cannot judge if it is design by looking for perfection, and in any case, we cannot define design. And you still claim that you can see signs of design in the world???
 
So... are we starting at the point where physical laws began behaving as they do now, or before it?

Is the assumption that the universe was created, in its entirety, for the existence of life, or that life was just a side effect of the small-scale imperfections of the universe - a "skip" in the CD, if you will?
 
Like I said before - we can barely define the word "design". If we knew what we do when we conceive of something we want to do, then plan, then design, we could program machines to do it and we would all be redundant already. But we cannot define design.
:confused: You're the only person I've ever met who's had difficulty with this.
 
It is understandable that it seems self-contradictory. I should have given up on this argument before. Many posts back I tried to make a point about this. I'll paraphrase it as a question: if biology/evolution is non-teleological, why are the papers/books filled with teleological terms in the explanations about biological systems? I suggested it was because the same minds who deny teleology, actually hold both teleology and non-teleology, simultaneously: congitive dissonance. The counter was that I was mistaken, because the teleological terms are mere anthropomorphisms. My counter-counter was that mere anthropomorphisms such as 'my car did not want to start' can be restated easily with 'my car would not start'. But, in the case of describing and explaining biology, if you expunged all teleological terms (such as 'design', 'purpose' 'strategy' etc) the biological explanation would be reduced to empty say-nothing phrases.

Then you're simply wrong. Language is limited, and we use it at best we can. Let's move on to the actual argument. I don't like it when people put the fact that I think or believe in doubt.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom