Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

We know RM/NS
Evolution.
works, given complexity to begin with, but we only know for certain that it can preserve the status quo or allow devolution.
Completely false. Evolutionary processes have been demonstrated many times to create new information that wasn't present before.

The rest is taken on faith.
False.

Seems to me from your argument that assuming too much for RM/NS
Evolution.

is a religion.
No.
 
We know what design is - we possess the design faculty. One thing I have done for $ is write algorithms. Even a small algorithm of 1K bytes is a rarity in a random set.
No. All 1k strings are algorithms.

I could either write the 1KB algorithm, with a few days of mental work, or I could start a Pseudorandomnumber generator and test each 1KB to see if it performed the needed function. I think I calculated there are about 10^2000 different 1KB programs. I hope no one has to tell you how huge a number that is. Even though I can design such an algorithm, I don't know how I really do it. But design is infinitely more efficient than randomness, as a creator of new information. I don't know HOW it works, but I know it exists and that it DOES work.
None of which is relevant to anything being discussed.

Randomness needs infinite time to work
False.

and needs a major piece, not mentioned yet.
Then why not mention it?

What is the criterion of delete vs keep?
Reality.

The selection mechanism is missing.
No.

Is the selection mechanism a bootstrapped result out of randomness itself?
No.

In Dawkins "methinks it is... like a weasle" the deux-a-machina was a preprogrammed selector that Dawkins designed into the program (what a fraud!).
No.

I would rather take "design" even if merely on faith, because I know it has existence (at least because I have it myself), than take on faith something that has never been demonstrated.
It has been demonstrated.
 
That's like saying, 'since Microsoft is smart enough to write XP, they are smart enough to make it much better than it obviously is - therefore I doubt Microsoft wrote XP.'

ID = Perfect ID is your own arbitrary bias. You know you can design something that is not perfect but certainly useable (viable). So you understand the concept. Why cannot that be universally applied? You just don't believe in Santy Claus. OK. I'm not talking about Santy Claus - I'm talking about an intelligent designer. I'm sorry but it seems so arrogant that we mere worms think we know what would and what would not represent the level of quality that said intelligent designer would employ.
I don't really think the Microsoft analogy is valid. I think it's closer to saying that PHD in Mathematics would be able to do basic addition. But my point is, you'd have to be pretty damn skilled to set up the system. And if we're assuming that the system was supposed to create life. Then I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that such as skilled designer would create life that was relatively unflawed. But with evolution, you *would* expect to find all sorts of minor flaws and redundancies.

I'm not trying to claim definitive proof, but it does support evolution while raising the question, if an amazingly skilled designer created the universe and life, why do we see flaws?

All I am saying is, evolution answers and incredible number of questions. Its predictions have been supported by immense amounts of evidence. Now you say you have found a flaw with part of the theory. Fine. Even if you have found a flaw, why a designer? Why have you skipped the entire process of examining all possibilities?

I think the designer argument brings up a lot of unanswered questions. That's all I was trying to say. But either way, why have you ruled out every possibility other than a designer?
 
We know what design is - we possess the design faculty. One thing I have done for $ is write algorithms. Even a small algorithm of 1K bytes is a rarity in a random set. I could either write the 1KB algorithm, with a few days of mental work, or I could start a Pseudorandomnumber generator and test each 1KB to see if it performed the needed function. I think I calculated there are about 10^2000 different 1KB programs. I hope no one has to tell you how huge a number that is. Even though I can design such an algorithm, I don't know how I really do it. But design is infinitely more efficient than randomness, as a creator of new information. I don't know HOW it works, but I know it exists and that it DOES work. Randomness needs infinite time to work and needs a major piece, not mentioned yet. What is the criterion of delete vs keep? The selection mechanism is missing. Is the selection mechanism a bootstrapped result out of randomness itself? In Dawkins "methinks it is... like a weasle" the deux-a-machina was a preprogrammed selector that Dawkins designed into the program (what a fraud!).
I assuming that you bring all this up because you question how evolution was involved with the *initial* creation of life (i.e., you accept it's role in the development from single-celled organisms to complex life).

And if I am understanding correctly, you feel that the initial creation of life is too mathematically unlikely to have occurred by known processes. I disagree, but that's not the main issue right now.

Even if known processes couldn't possibly demonstrate how life was initially created. It still seems to me that it doesn't make sense to just jump to the conclusion that it was a designer without first ruling out every other possibility.

You said above:
I would rather take "design" even if merely on faith, because I know it has existence (at least because I have it myself), than take on faith something that has never been demonstrated.
It's hard for me to parse this any way other than that you choose to believe in a designer for reasons of faith. Am I understanding correctly?
 
I think evolution and ID may be very similar to each other when you look to see that they both do something that we humans would call: "design". Not to get into that anthropormphic lexicon thing again, I think if an evolutionist started talking about how evolution designed a flagellum, you probably wouldn't stop him. (but if I did, you would). In other words, if design meant "to make something new", we could probably agree that both evolution and ID are somebody's explanation on how "to make something new". Where we part is the "teleology".

The difference, of course, is that design need not be intelligent. So, random mutations and natural selection "design" things. But they don't have a goal. they just happen because they must. Physical laws and all that.

Now, if you want to take this discussion down to the "design" of physical laws themselves, I'm sure someone can provide a link to theories about how symmetry breaking occured in the early universe.
 
AH. maybe I'm starting to get your drift finally. Tell me if I'm right. While I think that the design of something that can self-organize and self-manufacture is elegant, you think is incompetent. Do you think a competent designer would design each little thing individually ad hoc, and that would be what you would expect her/it/him to do? Do you think 'poof: there's a carbon atom; poof: there's a gold atom' is more realistic than 'poof: there are the physical laws that will result in big machines that manufacture a bunch of different elements?

I'm not saying that self-organisation is incompetent. I'm saying that's EXPECTED from randomness. I'm saying that things that are exceedingly complex or inneficient are expected from natural causes but not from "intelligent" design.

As an aside, I "created" three distinct fantasy "universes", all with their own laws, and they're all much simpler and "efficient", specifically because _I_ designed them. They're not random at all, and anyone who looks at how they're constructed can tell they're designed.
 
ID = Perfect ID is your own arbitrary bias. You know you can design something that is not perfect but certainly useable (viable). So you understand the concept. Why cannot that be universally applied? You just don't believe in Santy Claus. OK. I'm not talking about Santy Claus - I'm talking about an intelligent designer. I'm sorry but it seems so arrogant that we mere worms think we know what would and what would not represent the level of quality that said intelligent designer would employ.

I don't think we're talking about perfection, here. We're merely saying that the RESULT of the natural processes are exactly what would be expected from random events, while the assumption that intelligence is involved raises a great number of unanswerable questions; even contradictions.
 
While I think that the design of something that can self-organize and self-manufacture is elegant, you think is incompetent. Do you think a competent designer would design each little thing individually ad hoc, and that would be what you would expect her/it/him to do?

I'll first state that the context VonNeumann said this in was related to the formation of the Universe, not biology (no accusations of quote-mining, please ;) ). However, it does seem to betray VonnNeumann's contradictory views on the Designer at the Universe creation level compared to the biological creation level.

a) Designer elegantly designed Universe so that galaxies/stars/planets would form using appropriate physical laws he generated. Stupendously intricate self-organisation abounds.
b) Designer is completely stuck with being able to make matter self-organise and self-replicate using laws of Universe, and therefore is forced to poof virii into existence to patch the genome on a regular basis.

What happened? Did they subcontract for the biological life or something?

Oh, and I believe you're abusing people's open-mindedness, to some extent, with your comments about contradictory beliefs. When you ask a skeptic whether humans could ever become advanced enough to create Universes, most (I believe) will answer "Almost certainly not, but there's a possibility". You've then take this vague head-nod at the fact that there isn't enough evidence to decisively state that it's impossible (and also trying to prove a negative) as a contradictory worldview, when it is not.
 
Faith is a Girl's Name

I would rather take "design" even if merely on faith, because I know it has existence (at least because I have it myself), than take on faith something that has never been demonstrated.

Well, that certainly is not the way a rational scientific mind should work.

One's existence only proves that one was born, but not that one was 'designed', unless it's a robot.

It's scientifically foolish to take anything 100% on faith. Scientific 'faith' should be tempered by critically thinking about what is being believed and why.

It is possible to be correct in a conclusion, but for all the wrong reasons.

Ancient religious writings or beliefs should never be invoked in defense of a scientific concept. There's no valid need for that.
 
Oh, and I believe you're abusing people's open-mindedness, to some extent, with your comments about contradictory beliefs. When you ask a skeptic whether humans could ever become advanced enough to create Universes, most (I believe) will answer "Almost certainly not, but there's a possibility". You've then take this vague head-nod at the fact that there isn't enough evidence to decisively state that it's impossible (and also trying to prove a negative) as a contradictory worldview, when it is not.
Not intending to "abuse" as you say, but I did not realize very quickly what was the problem when I tried it on chipmunk. The experiment had previously worked so well with others I didn't realize what had gone wrong. The difference, it turns out, the previous 'victims' were almost religious about the inevitability of the ACClarke-style 'evolution of god'.
 
The squawks would be just as loud against the likes of "Planned evolution" as it is against "ID".
Not so. You've heard of theistic evolution, I assume? Basically that evolutionary theory is basically accurate, but God guided it in some mysterious way. This is a reasonable compromise for a religious person to make.

ID proponents, on the other hand, assert tinkering, deny common ancestry and "macro-ev". Very different.
 
I'd have to go look to see if I ever said anything about "evidence of design". It seems evidence is a pretty subjective thing in the field of 'origins'.
If it's really evidence, it's not subjective.

Reflecting back on previous posts, I think I understand "the paradox generated by this belief" that you reference is [my paraphrase: that intelligent designer has to have a beginning and that must be another intelligent designer who designed him, ad nauseum]. I don't see it so simple as that: that evolution lacks this paradox and ID does, as I think you are saying here.
How would you characterize this paradox in evolution?

I think evolution and ID may be very similar to each other when you look to see that they both do something that we humans would call: "design". Not to get into that anthropormphic lexicon thing again, I think if an evolutionist started talking about how evolution designed a flagellum, you probably wouldn't stop him. (but if I did, you would). In other words, if design meant "to make something new", we could probably agree that both evolution and ID are somebody's explanation on how "to make something new". Where we part is the "teleology".
That's a pretty loose definition of "design". I think you're in pretty rare company with this definition. To most people, "design" implies a plan or goal, a mapped-out solution to a specific problem. That you can't see how this does not apply to evolution reveals a deep misunderstanding of the theory.

So, in origins, there is always the problem of "beginning", it is not a unique question only for ID. The difference is whether there was "purpose" or "no purpose" to the design.

So I can take your protest to prove "purpose" but I cannot take your protest that I should not accept ID because it has a paradox that evolution does not have - both ideas have the "bootstrap" or "beginning" problem.
The paradox has nothing to do with beginnings--that's a separate paradox. It has to do with whether or not complexity and intelligence are possible without design aid. If not, then existence isn't possible at all.
 
Last edited:
Not intending to "abuse" as you say, but I did not realize very quickly what was the problem when I tried it on chipmunk. The experiment had previously worked so well with others I didn't realize what had gone wrong. The difference, it turns out, the previous 'victims' were almost religious about the inevitability of the ACClarke-style 'evolution of god'.
I'm not convinced that's the reason. Even if I accept the possibility that humanity will have the power to create at least simulated universes, I still see no evidence that a designer was involved with this universe.

Again, from what you stated earlier (unless I misunderstood), it seems like you choose to believe in a designer for this universe for reasons of faith. I think that is the main reason people reacted so strong.
 
I'm not convinced that's the reason. Even if I accept the possibility that humanity will have the power to create at least simulated universes, I still see no evidence that a designer was involved with this universe.

Again, from what you stated earlier (unless I misunderstood), it seems like you choose to believe in a designer for this universe for reasons of faith. I think that is the main reason people reacted so strong.
Well, no. The reason for the reaction is that he accepted this on faith, claimed that he had evidence, and accused the people who actually have evidence of accepting things on faith. In other words, he has been throroughly dishonest.
 
Well, no. The reason for the reaction is that he accepted this on faith, claimed that he had evidence, and accused the people who actually have evidence of accepting things on faith. In other words, he has been throroughly dishonest.
Well, sure. But I'll give the benefit of the doubt that it was not intentional. (I am new here after all...) Just like psychics who really believe their powers, I think a lot of IDers really are convinced that they are being rational and fair-minded.
 
I'm a confused as to your stance. Again, I apologize if I taking things out of context. In the first quote I thought you were saying that evolutionists would say evolution *designs* new organisms. But in the second quote it seems to me that you're saying to opposite; that evolutionists would consider a "designed" evolution process the same as ID, and *not* evolution. Aren't these opposing ideas?
It is understandable that it seems self-contradictory. I should have given up on this argument before. Many posts back I tried to make a point about this. I'll paraphrase it as a question: if biology/evolution is non-teleological, why are the papers/books filled with teleological terms in the explanations about biological systems? I suggested it was because the same minds who deny teleology, actually hold both teleology and non-teleology, simultaneously: congitive dissonance. The counter was that I was mistaken, because the teleological terms are mere anthropomorphisms. My counter-counter was that mere anthropomorphisms such as 'my car did not want to start' can be restated easily with 'my car would not start'. But, in the case of describing and explaining biology, if you expunged all teleological terms (such as 'design', 'purpose' 'strategy' etc) the biological explanation would be reduced to empty say-nothing phrases. This is what I alleged.

So, the reason you thought I was contradicting myself was because I was revisiting this thing that looks like cognitive dissonance amongst those who espouse non-teleology.
 
Evolutionary processes have been demonstrated many times to create new information that wasn't present before.
This new information that is ubiquitous is mostly, what?
1. base sequences that do not correlate at all to samples taken from presumed living examples of ancestors.
2. base sequences that correlate to samples from presumed living examples of ancestors, that can be best characterized by translocations, reversals, and other 'editing' of large chunks.
3. base sequences that correlate ....., that can be best characterized as having many scattered point mutations.
4. other?
I know we do not have enough genome data yet, but perhaps some generalities can be drawn from the human vs the nematode genomes, that are the more completely mapped ones.
 
Then why not mention it?
Why don't I mention the 'missing piece' of evolution? We've been round and round on this.

Let me ask you: On Dawkins "Methinks it is like a weasle"... Do you believe that to be a valid analogy to evolution in any way?
 
I don't really think the Microsoft analogy is valid. I think it's closer to saying that PHD in Mathematics would be able to do basic addition. But my point is, you'd have to be pretty damn skilled to set up the system. And if we're assuming that the system was supposed to create life. Then I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that such as skilled designer would create life that was relatively unflawed. But with evolution, you *would* expect to find all sorts of minor flaws and redundancies.

I'm not trying to claim definitive proof, but it does support evolution while raising the question, if an amazingly skilled designer created the universe and life, why do we see flaws?

All I am saying is, evolution answers and incredible number of questions. Its predictions have been supported by immense amounts of evidence. Now you say you have found a flaw with part of the theory. Fine. Even if you have found a flaw, why a designer? Why have you skipped the entire process of examining all possibilities?

I think the designer argument brings up a lot of unanswered questions. That's all I was trying to say. But either way, why have you ruled out every possibility other than a designer?
I guess we are mutually incredulous at each other's viewpoint.

I suppose if you were Edison, in 1900, and you could see the future (say 1999) for a moment, you would claim humans incompetently designed the CD player because it skips when you bump it. The laser and embedded programs in the motor controllers and the digital signal processors would not impress you. The flaws would be enough for you to say ' if you were smart enough to do all that, why isn't it perfect?'

Another argument might be that the designer designed physical laws and then wanted to see what would happen - an experiment if you will. Again, why do you expect perfection? I don't see that.

But of course "designer" brings unanswered questions. There are always unanswered questions. Like I said before - we can barely define the word "design". If we knew what we do when we conceive of something we want to do, then plan, then design, we could program machines to do it and we would all be redundant already. But we cannot define design.

Do you have some other ideas that are alternates to consider besides just design or evolution? The only other idea off the top of my head is that the information has always been here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom