Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

How is this discussion of an "Intelligent Designer" of the Universe any different than a discussion of whether or not the Earth is controlled by a living sentient being by the name of "Gaia"?

Isn't it the exact same debate, just moved to a scale that we don't have the ability to explore completely?
It's different to be specific than to be general. Gaia is specific. Intelligent design is general. All the specific terms like "perfect", like "god" as in some pre-existing religious concept, serve to narrow down the concept of "intelligent design", and therefore serve to mislead. I suppose the words "intelligent" and "sentient" are not sufficiently defined for us to have any real argument anyway. Even "design" is not well defined. There are some forums at www.iscid.org about complexity and ID if you want to see what the likes of Dembski and fellows have to say in their own den.
 
It's different to be specific than to be general. Gaia is specific. Intelligent design is general. All the specific terms like "perfect", like "god" as in some pre-existing religious concept, serve to narrow down the concept of "intelligent design", and therefore serve to mislead. I suppose the words "intelligent" and "sentient" are not sufficiently defined for us to have any real argument anyway. Even "design" is not well defined. There are some forums at www.iscid.org about complexity and ID if you want to see what the likes of Dembski and fellows have to say in their own den.
"intelligent design" may be general, but "Intelligent Design" makes specific claims. [edit: e.g. not "perfection" or "god" but rather "irreducible complexity", "specified complexity" and "fine-tuned universe"]

In any case, I still don't understand how you can regard the fact of complexity and/or intelligence as evidence of design. Given the paradox generated by this belief, it defies logic to regard it as such. If there's evidence of design, the fact of complexity and/or intelligence is not it.

For such an extraordinary claim (design), an argument from incredulity that results in a logical paradox doesn't quite meet the requirement of extraordinary evidence.
 
Last edited:
It's different to be specific than to be general. Gaia is specific. Intelligent design is general. All the specific terms like "perfect", like "god" as in some pre-existing religious concept, serve to narrow down the concept of "intelligent design", and therefore serve to mislead. I suppose the words "intelligent" and "sentient" are not sufficiently defined for us to have any real argument anyway. Even "design" is not well defined. There are some forums at www.iscid.org about complexity and ID if you want to see what the likes of Dembski and fellows have to say in their own den.

That's the problem - you can't trace ID without delving into religion, because you are making assumptions about what the "designer" is capable of, without any idea of whether there is an actual designer.
 
That's the problem - you can't trace ID without delving into religion, because you are making assumptions about what the "designer" is capable of, without any idea of whether there is an actual designer.
One cannot trace RM/NS being the seminal source of complexity either. What you said, "you are making assumptions about what the "designer" is capable of", can also be applied to RM/NS as a seminal source of information. We know RM/NS works, given complexity to begin with, but we only know for certain that it can preserve the status quo or allow devolution. The rest is taken on faith. Seems to me from your argument that assuming too much for RM/NS is a religion.
 
One cannot trace RM/NS being the seminal source of complexity either. What you said, "you are making assumptions about what the "designer" is capable of", can also be applied to RM/NS as a seminal source of information. We know RM/NS works, given complexity to begin with, but we only know for certain that it can preserve the status quo or allow devolution. The rest is taken on faith. Seems to me from your argument that assuming too much for RM/NS is a religion.

We are not assuming it religiously, because we are not assuming that there is an intelligent, sentient "higher power" influencing the situation.
 
"intelligent design" may be general, but "Intelligent Design" makes specific claims. [edit: e.g. not "perfection" or "god" but rather "irreducible complexity", "specified complexity" and "fine-tuned universe"]

In any case, I still don't understand how you can regard the fact of complexity and/or intelligence as evidence of design. Given the paradox generated by this belief, it defies logic to regard it as such. If there's evidence of design, the fact of complexity and/or intelligence is not it.

For such an extraordinary claim (design), an argument from incredulity that results in a logical paradox doesn't quite meet the requirement of extraordinary evidence.
I'd have to go look to see if I ever said anything about "evidence of design". It seems evidence is a pretty subjective thing in the field of 'origins'.

Reflecting back on previous posts, I think I understand "the paradox generated by this belief" that you reference is [my paraphrase: that intelligent designer has to have a beginning and that must be another intelligent designer who designed him, ad nauseum]. I don't see it so simple as that: that evolution lacks this paradox and ID does, as I think you are saying here.

I think evolution and ID may be very similar to each other when you look to see that they both do something that we humans would call: "design". Not to get into that anthropormphic lexicon thing again, I think if an evolutionist started talking about how evolution designed a flagellum, you probably wouldn't stop him. (but if I did, you would). In other words, if design meant "to make something new", we could probably agree that both evolution and ID are somebody's explanation on how "to make something new". Where we part is the "teleology".

So, in origins, there is always the problem of "beginning", it is not a unique question only for ID. The difference is whether there was "purpose" or "no purpose" to the design.

So I can take your protest to prove "purpose" but I cannot take your protest that I should not accept ID because it has a paradox that evolution does not have - both ideas have the "bootstrap" or "beginning" problem.
 
OK, but you take too much on faith that cannot be empirically shown.

You got me wrong! LOL If that's how it is, and it is possible to be shown, it will be shown.

However, not only is there no evidence (other than interpretive imagination) that the Universe was created by an intelligent, sentient being, there is no necessity for it being done so.

If evidence comes to the contrary, I will take it into consideration. Until that time, I do not think it should be taught in an academic institution (such as grade school), as it cannot do so without delving into religion.
 
So, let me get this straight. The designer made hydrogen so it would condense into stars... stars so massive that they would collapse under their own weight and produce carbon, oxygen et al through type II supernovae, and THEN would form planetary systems on which life MAY evolve in some very specific, extremely-rare conditions ? He's incompetent, allright. Any way you look at it.
AH. maybe I'm starting to get your drift finally. Tell me if I'm right. While I think that the design of something that can self-organize and self-manufacture is elegant, you think is incompetent. Do you think a competent designer would design each little thing individually ad hoc, and that would be what you would expect her/it/him to do? Do you think 'poof: there's a carbon atom; poof: there's a gold atom' is more realistic than 'poof: there are the physical laws that will result in big machines that manufacture a bunch of different elements?

That's rather idiotic. We KNOW that creative creatures exist. It's not a maybe. I just don't think we can have it both ways: if we can create a universe with random laws, chances are no life will be found there. If the laws are not random, chances are whoever evolves in that universe is going to pick that up. OUR universe seems to be the result of randomness. There doesn't seem to be any design in it.
I know you think you understand what you thought I said, you just don't realize that what you think you read is not what I meant:) Lets drop this and I'll just see what you say to my question about elegance vs incompetence, above.
 
You got me wrong! LOL If that's how it is, and it is possible to be shown, it will be shown.

However, not only is there no evidence (other than interpretive imagination) that the Universe was created by an intelligent, sentient being, there is no necessity for it being done so.

If evidence comes to the contrary, I will take it into consideration. Until that time, I do not think it should be taught in an academic institution (such as grade school), as it cannot do so without delving into religion.
You mean government school, right? You don't mean to have the police raid the nuns?:)

Philip Johnson's book "Darwin on Trial" is pretty encompassing with what I believe to be an objective look at this subject of how the theory of evolution is sold as something it is not.
 
While I think that the design of something that can self-organize and self-manufacture is elegant, you think is incompetent. Do you think a competent designer would design each little thing individually ad hoc, and that would be what you would expect her/it/him to do? Do you think 'poof: there's a carbon atom; poof: there's a gold atom' is more realistic than 'poof: there are the physical laws that will result in big machines that manufacture a bunch of different elements?

I like the idea itself, however, again we're assuming what the ID'er is capable of doing.

Since there are uninterrupted laws of physics that govern our Universe, then the ID'er cannot be identified, since any actions taken must follow the laws and are assumed to be natural. On that token, the ID'er cannot interact with the Universe, as he/she would have no influence regarding the rules of the Universe without throwing the "design" off balance. Therefore, your ID'er can only follow the set guidelines that nature itself must follow anyway, so there is no need for "intelligence" or "sentience". So your ID'er is the Big Bang, or some other theory not involving another life form.

You mean government school, right? You don't mean to have the police raid the nuns?:)

Philip Johnson's book "Darwin on Trial" is pretty encompassing with what I believe to be an objective look at this subject of how the theory of evolution is sold as something it is not.

LOL I don't want ANY school to be overrun with police!!!

I think the concept of ID is at too early of a stage to be taught in an educational conext, relgious school or not.
 
Last edited:
So, in origins, there is always the problem of "beginning", it is not a unique question only for ID. The difference is whether there was "purpose" or "no purpose" to the design.
So I can take your protest to prove "purpose" but I cannot take your protest that I should not accept ID because it has a paradox that evolution does not have - both ideas have the "bootstrap" or "beginning" problem.

I still don't understand how you get from feeling like you've found flaws in evolution theory to there must be a designer. Even if there are faults with current theory, why does that make you think there is a designer?
 
I think evolution and ID may be very similar to each other when you look to see that they both do something that we humans would call: "design". Not to get into that anthropormphic lexicon thing again, I think if an evolutionist started talking about how evolution designed a flagellum, you probably wouldn't stop him. (but if I did, you would). In other words, if design meant "to make something new", we could probably agree that both evolution and ID are somebody's explanation on how "to make something new". Where we part is the "teleology".
I don't agree with that. I think design implies intention. I don't think it's correct to say evolution designed anything.
 
AH. maybe I'm starting to get your drift finally. Tell me if I'm right. While I think that the design of something that can self-organize and self-manufacture is elegant, you think is incompetent. Do you think a competent designer would design each little thing individually ad hoc, and that would be what you would expect her/it/him to do? Do you think 'poof: there's a carbon atom; poof: there's a gold atom' is more realistic than 'poof: there are the physical laws that will result in big machines that manufacture a bunch of different elements?
I can't speak for Belz, but one of the arguments against design is that to setting up a system at the big bang that lead to where we are now, or even just lead to life on earth, is incredibly complicated. And if something had they ability to create that system, it must have an outstanding ability to understand of how huge numbers of tiny factors affect each other. If that were the case, especially if this design included affecting the development of life on earth you would expect to find a world where everything was designed as well as it could be - not just good enough. You wouldn't expect to find squid eyes to have advantages over mammal eyes. Or redundancies in any system at all. Not to mention stronger bodies, or other advantages like lack of need to sleep, etc...

But you *would* expect to find these types of things in an evolutionary non-designed process. It seems to me that not only is there no evidence to support a designer, but that there is evidence that points to the fact that there isn't one.

Again, flaws with evolution theory or not, I still see no evidence that points to a designer.
 
Thanks. For me that's the main issue. It's good for people to question the theory, but I've never understood why when people feel they've find a problem, it can lead otherwise critical thinkers to a designer. Any insight?
We know what design is - we possess the design faculty. One thing I have done for $ is write algorithms. Even a small algorithm of 1K bytes is a rarity in a random set. I could either write the 1KB algorithm, with a few days of mental work, or I could start a Pseudorandomnumber generator and test each 1KB to see if it performed the needed function. I think I calculated there are about 10^2000 different 1KB programs. I hope no one has to tell you how huge a number that is. Even though I can design such an algorithm, I don't know how I really do it. But design is infinitely more efficient than randomness, as a creator of new information. I don't know HOW it works, but I know it exists and that it DOES work. Randomness needs infinite time to work and needs a major piece, not mentioned yet. What is the criterion of delete vs keep? The selection mechanism is missing. Is the selection mechanism a bootstrapped result out of randomness itself? In Dawkins "methinks it is... like a weasle" the deux-a-machina was a preprogrammed selector that Dawkins designed into the program (what a fraud!).

I would rather take "design" even if merely on faith, because I know it has existence (at least because I have it myself), than take on faith something that has never been demonstrated.
 
I can't speak for Belz, but one of the arguments against design is that to setting up a system at the big bang that lead to where we are now, or even just lead to life on earth, is incredibly complicated. And if something had they ability to create that system, it must have an outstanding ability to understand of how huge numbers of tiny factors affect each other. If that were the case, especially if this design included affecting the development of life on earth you would expect to find a world where everything was designed as well as it could be - not just good enough. You wouldn't expect to find squid eyes to have advantages over mammal eyes. Or redundancies in any system at all. Not to mention stronger bodies, or other advantages like lack of need to sleep, etc...

But you *would* expect to find these types of things in an evolutionary non-designed process. It seems to me that not only is there no evidence to support a designer, but that there is evidence that points to the fact that there isn't one.

Again, flaws with evolution theory or not, I still see no evidence that points to a designer.
That's like saying, 'since Microsoft is smart enough to write XP, they are smart enough to make it much better than it obviously is - therefore I doubt Microsoft wrote XP.'

ID = Perfect ID is your own arbitrary bias. You know you can design something that is not perfect but certainly useable (viable). So you understand the concept. Why cannot that be universally applied? You just don't believe in Santy Claus. OK. I'm not talking about Santy Claus - I'm talking about an intelligent designer. I'm sorry but it seems so arrogant that we mere worms think we know what would and what would not represent the level of quality that said intelligent designer would employ.
 
I don't agree with that. I think design implies intention. I don't think it's correct to say evolution designed anything.
Intention: purpose .... Purpose: intention .......... same thing in this context. My point is that since "design" is not well defined, it can be vaguely used in either case because we do not really KNOW what design means EXCEPT for that it is purposeful/intentional. THerefore the whole argument is about ONLY THAT: Purpose/intention. Let me try this. Instead of ID vs Evolution, call it Intentional Evolution or Planned Evolution versus random-nonpurposeful-Evolution. The squawks would be just as loud against the likes of "Planned evolution" as it is against "ID".
 
I like the idea itself, however, again we're assuming what the ID'er is capable of doing.

Since there are uninterrupted laws of physics that govern our Universe, then the ID'er cannot be identified, since any actions taken must follow the laws and are assumed to be natural. On that token, the ID'er cannot interact with the Universe, as he/she would have no influence regarding the rules of the Universe without throwing the "design" off balance.
I don't know about that. Until quantum physics came along 70 years ago, a la Heisenberg et al, I would have agreed with you (well not really cuz we weren't around then :) ).

Let's just say I think the universe is much much stranger than we think and science has not nearly caught up yet.
 
I'm a confused as to your stance. I was replying to:
I think evolution and ID may be very similar to each other when you look to see that they both do something that we humans would call: "design". Not to get into that anthropormphic lexicon thing again, I think if an evolutionist started talking about how evolution designed a flagellum, you probably wouldn't stop him. (but if I did, you would).
But in your reply you wrote:
Intention: purpose .... Purpose: intention .......... same thing in this context. My point is that since "design" is not well defined, it can be vaguely used in either case because we do not really KNOW what design means EXCEPT for that it is purposeful/intentional. THerefore the whole argument is about ONLY THAT: Purpose/intention. Let me try this. Instead of ID vs Evolution, call it Intentional Evolution or Planned Evolution versus random-nonpurposeful-Evolution. The squawks would be just as loud against the likes of "Planned evolution" as it is against "ID".
Again, I apologize if I taking things out of context. In the first quote I thought you were saying that evolutionists would say evolution *designs* new organisms. But in the second quote it seems to me that you're saying to opposite; that evolutionists would consider a "designed" evolution process the same as ID, and *not* evolution. Aren't these opposing ideas?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom