Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, I just want to clarify. Are you arguing that if there is no purpose to evolution it would not have created consciousness? And to follow that, since it did create consciousness then there must be a purpose?
Kind of. Consciousness, which is pretty well undefined, seems an unnecessary ingredient for survival - an astonishing result from mere RM/NS. Doesn't prove anything - just my observation from my view.
 
VonNeumann, I don't think ideas should be censored. But I also don't think all ideas are equally valid. I want people to question the established doctrine. I want people to try and disprove it. My point is that giving god, or a designer, or computer simulation, as an explanation for the unknown *without evidence* is a cop-out.

Why muddle your argument with a jump to the designer? You feel you've found a problem with evolution. Great. Lets discuss it, maybe improve the theory. But what I don't get is why just because you feel one part of the theory is incorrect, that you feel confident to say that a designer is involved. Are you saying that there is no possible explanation other than a designer? That there is no conceivable way the universe could have ended up as it has without a designer?

I understand what led you to doubt aspects of evolution. What made you decide that a designer was involved?
If evolution plugs your hole, then it plugs your hole. I have educated myself sufficiently on the subject that I have shifted my paradigm so that I doubt. It started with the hope of finding the right missing ingredient to evolution. But why did I go to "designer"? I'll have to think about that. I'll get back with you on that.
 
Suggesting? No.

Stating forthrightly? Yes.

No compenent philosopher takes either Lucas or Penrose seriously in this regard;

Sounds like a no true Scotsman fallacy.

I would have thought that it was a question for mathematicians rather than philosophers though.

for a quick demonstration, read Dennet and Hofstadter.

No I will not. I will not ever read a word of what Dennett says, no matter how much people implore me to do so on here. He's a raving lunatic who has admitted that he thinks he's a p-zombie.
 
Accept ID in the future but not in the past. My point is if it is likely ID will evolve in the future, it may have already evolved. Paradox: simultaneous acceptance/denial.
No.

The possibility of something is meaningless without evidence for it actually happening. There is no evidence for ID. We reject it because there is no evidence for it; because it is not a scientific theory (or even a well-formed hypothesis); because it has no value; because it teaches us nothing.

That it is conceptually possible is completely irrelevant. Conceptually, the moon could be made of green cheese. But it isn't.

And once again, the idea that the Universe may be a simulation has nothing to do with Intelligent Design as it is actually proposed.
 
No I will not. I will not ever read a word of what Dennett says, no matter how much people implore me to do so on here. He's a raving lunatic who has admitted that he thinks he's a p-zombie.
I have already proved that you are a p-zombie, Ian, so you must be a raving lunatic too.
 
I have already proved that you are a p-zombie, Ian, so you must be a raving lunatic too.

Any proof is necessarily flawed since I cannot possible be in error in my conviction I am conscious.

I advise you and Dr Kitten to read some Searle (and don't worry, he's a materialist -- or so he claims).

PS Not about the Chinese room, rather read his attacks on Dennett.
 
I grew up around A C Clarke type of mindset. Space Odysses 2001, etc. HAL9000. I was strong AI, total reductionist .. all that. But I really never thought of this paradox when I believed we could evolve to a "Creator" level. So I cannot tell you how i would have grappled with it. Probably would have answered exactly as you just did. But now, I don't accept IU even for n=0. The reason is I believe we live in a universe that, within it, it is computationally constrained (if you will) such that we cannot grow AI here, and neither can nature (self-organization is limited, I believe). The thought experiment was designed for people who have the mindset that accepts evolution and strong AI ... and that no longer describes me.
Do you believe that our complexity and intelligence is evidence of design? If so, you still have to grapple with the paradox.
 
Any proof is necessarily flawed since I cannot possible be in error in my conviction I am conscious.
Yep. That means you're a p-zombie.

I advise you and Dr Kitten to read some Searle (and don't worry, he's a materialist -- or so he claims).
I've read Searle. He's hopeless.

PS Not about the Chinese room, rather read his attacks on Dennett.
Such as?
 
But now, I don't accept IU even for n=0. The reason is I believe we live in a universe that, within it, it is computationally constrained (if you will) such that we cannot grow AI here, and neither can nature (self-organization is limited, I believe).
This is obvious nonsense.

We are intelligent, therefore the universe is not computationally constrained, therefore AI is possible. Even if you don't believe it can arise from evolution (a belief that is nonsense, but not obvious nonsense), you have to accept that it is possible by design, and therefore AI is necessarily possible.
 
P-Zombies Are Conscious

Here's my proof that Ian is a p-zombie:

A p-zombie is exactly like a human in all ways except that it isn't consciously aware, right?

So if you ask a p-zombie if it is consciously aware, it will say that it is - because otherwise it would be trivially distinguishable from a real human and contradict the very definition of the term.

And if you ask a p-zombie what it is thinking or feeling, it will be able to report on those internal processes exactly as a human would. It can detail feeling happy or sad or lost or exalted, it can describe its experience of redness or blueness or greenness. It can describe its internal experiences in a way that exactly match the way a conscious human would describe their internal experiences.

In other words, it is under the illusion that it is conscious. But that illusion acts exactly the same as consciousness itself. To an external observer, the p-zombie exhibits all the signs of consciousness. The p-zombie itself knows perfectly well that it is conscious, just as you and I do.

Therefore p-zombies are conscious, and we are p-zombies.
P-zombies exhibit all the external and internal properties of consciousness, so there are conscious. The distinction between p-zombies and consciousness is a distinction without meaning.
 
Your arrogance is breathtaking.
No. It's pretty straightforward. Lucas and Penrose are hopelessly lost on the subject of consciousness, and very few researchers or philosophers take them seriously at all. As I said in the case of Penrose, his proposed mechanism for consciousness (magic fairies) is impossible, being something like 17 orders of magnitude too short-lived to have the effects he claims.

As I said, my non-existent cat has a better understanding of consciousness than they do.
 
A p-zombie is exactly like a human in all ways except that it isn't consciously aware, right?

So if you ask a p-zombie if it is consciously aware, it will say that it is - because otherwise it would be trivially distinguishable from a real human and contradict the very definition of the term.

And if you ask a p-zombie what it is thinking or feeling, it will be able to report on those internal processes exactly as a human would.

Internal processes? Not conscious processes it doesn't since by definition it is not conscious.

It can detail feeling happy or sad or lost or exalted, it can describe its experience of redness or blueness or greenness. It can describe its internal experiences in a way that exactly match the way a conscious human would describe their internal experiences.

In other words, it is under the illusion that it is conscious.

No.

Since it is not conscious then by definition it cannot be under the illusion about anything.

The rest of your "proof" follows from you begging the question here.
 
I have noticed that some of you speak of science and then give philisophical arguments as though they are scientific arguments.

Philosphy is nothing more than speculation using logic. It is the first step in science not the last.

I can imagine numerous theories that would explain a phenomena like planetary motion, but the one we accept as scientific is the one that works best when tested in reality. The one that actually allows us to launch a space vehicle and have it hit the target millions of miles away.

That theory becomes the current accepted scientific theory until it is replaced by one that works even better.

Evolution is hardly the strongest scientific theory we have, but it does explain most of the evidence and it is the best working theory we have.

Intelligent Design explains nothing at all. It is a purely speculation. What intelligent design says is..."gee is sure feels unlikely that all this complicated stuff happened by accident. My gut reaction is that someone must have designed all this."

I understand why people FEEL that way, but we are not supposed to think with our gut.
 
Internal processes? Not conscious processes it doesn't since by definition it is not conscious.
They act in every way, both to the p-zombie and to external observers, as though they are conscious processes. That follows necessarily from the definition of the term. The p-zombie acts exactly like humans in all ways. Humans act conscious, therefore the p-zombie acts conscious. Humans believe they are conscious, therefore the p-zombie professes that same belief, and acts on it.

No.

Since it is not conscious then by definition it cannot be under the illusion about anything.
Try asking it. It will tell you that you are wrong, and that it definitely is conscious. And it can report in detail exactly what being conscious feels like. Either this is an illusion, or the p-zombie really is conscious.

The rest of your "proof" follows from you begging the question here.
The problem is that the concept of p-zombies is logically incoherent.
 
Asked or Answered

Perhaps responding to a question is not a sign of consciousness but asking a question is.

Before you say we can program a computer to ask a question, thats not the same thing. That is the computer performing a function and in that instance we are still the conciousness behind the computer.

And it doesn't matter how far removed we are from that, ie if we program it to program another computer etc.
 
Perhaps responding to a question is not a sign of consciousness but asking a question is.
Both can be.

Before you say we can program a computer to ask a question, thats not the same thing. That is the computer performing a function and in that instance we are still the conciousness behind the computer.
Not if we don't know what the question is.
 
Ok I meant proof of conciousness not a sign of.

And as to "Not if we don't know what the question is" I can only say...Huh?
 
Ok I meant proof of conciousness not a sign of.
Then asking questions isn't proof of consciousness either.

And as to "Not if we don't know what the question is" I can only say...Huh?
It is perfectly possible to program a computer so that it will formulate questions based on its experience, rather than merely parroting questions that have been programmed directly. Where, then, would you place the consciousness?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom