VonNeumann, I don't think the point is whether or not a universe (or at least the simulation of a universe) could be designed by a powerful creator. I think the point is why you seem to think that powerful creator is required. Science has be able to explain countless phenomena that people used to belief only be caused by god. And the evidence points to the fact that a creator isn't required. Sure, some aspects of the theory have not been completely defined, but why does that mean there has to be a creator?
I have read your posts. And I believe that you feel that you are approaching this problem from an unbiased point-of-view. But I wonder, what exactly would it take for you to accept evolution? What would it take to convince you a creator or designer wasn't required?
Also, I think I have been fair, but please excuse me if I have misinterpreted your position.
Sure, that's fair. What would it take to convince me? Most of my life I was convinced. I was a fossil hunter at an early age. I read George Gaylord Simpson's most popular book ("Natural Selection"??) at age 12! My 9th grade biology teacher had me go in front of all her 10th grade biology classes to teach evolution from my own fossil collection I had collected myself from ages 8 through 11. Crap! Could I be more self-indoctrinated? Obviously, and I didn't figure out till years later, my biology teacher knew she could only teach evolution by getting a student to do it for her!
What would it take for me to return to darwin-faith? EVIDENCE!
If you read my posts as you've said you'll see I can allow for quite a bit of [evolutionism]:
1. that everything from t=0 to t=4MYA could have unfolded from "just so" physical laws.
2 that all flora/fauna could have unfolded from a sufficiently rich supply of genetic information at the cellular level, say ~500MYA.
But in both cases that is an "unfolding" of a predestined set of information - not creation of new information.
I would have to see some new augmentation to THE THEORY, and not just RM/NS because I finally figured it out on my own what Hoyle et al were saying for a long time. There is not enough time for randomness to generate the immense information that is represented by life.
BTW, it was after reading Simpson in 7th grade that I dropped paleontology as my main interest and switched to physics/math. Even though I adhered to evolution for decades, I became more of an isotropic skeptic than the one-flavored skeptic-style I see here.
Show me the meat: show the math model that RM/NS can write programs. Kauffman is pretty smart. He wrote a big book. I did not find in there what I need - I'm still waiting. But I also invented the idea of a "the universe is a computer" idea - I thought. I probably just absorbed it from reading lots of von Neumann and the other early cyberneticists' writings when I was a teen. I think many of these early pioneers secretly believed that cellular automata is more than a toy. It may be an accurate model of reality. I have many other ideas bent in that direction, and unless there is some ~infinite computational power embedded the fabric of
what is, I doubt complexity can self-organize here in <10^10 Years.
Oh, and SURE I'm biased. Just not unilaterally biased toward evolution as I used to be. Try isotropic skepticism yourself. Maybe just one day a week - its good for you.