Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

NO.
The Dogma speaks only of the direction of information flow. It says nothing of coding. Researchers thought there would be a one-to-one coding from genes to proteins, but this does not follow from the Dogma at all. It was a hypothesis formed on the basis of the best evidence available at the time.
The dogma has history preceding 1952 (DNA).

http://www.emc.maricopa.edu/faculty/farabee/BIOBK/BioBookPROTSYn.html

The 1 gene : 1 protein idea goes back to a 1940s dogma: 1 gene : 1 enzyme.

Certainly, it was more than just evolutionary guidance that induced the one gene one protein dogma - probably it just came from an occam's razor approach to heredity theory, pre-DNA.

Its there in the dogma, but I'll go with you Pixy on focusing on direction of information flow, which was Crick's main contribution. I believe I am on firmer ground in my argument there. To have reverse flow would be Lamarkian - god forbid. It was a pro-darwin anti-lamarkian view that probably set it up. On this point, US congress was sold a bill of goods on this false notion, and thus permitted some genetic engineering allowances. I haven't drawn conclusions yet myself on whether there has been major damage due to genetic engineering in our food supply. Maybe some of you have inside knowledge one way or the other?
 
No. ...You have nothing but an untestable conjecture.
Pixy, you are NOT following here. You are too hasty. There is a meta-layer in between here. The EVIDENCE I am arguing is about cognition about ID, NOT ABOUT ID ITSELF.

Instead of terse protest, would you humor me with answering whether you rule out the possibility that humans may evolve to some future entity that has sufficient design ability to design a new universe in which there could be intelligent entities?
A. Rule Out
B. Could be.
 
VonNeumann, I don't think the point is whether or not a universe (or at least the simulation of a universe) could be designed by a powerful creator. I think the point is why you seem to think that powerful creator is required. Science has be able to explain countless phenomena that people used to belief only be caused by god. And the evidence points to the fact that a creator isn't required. Sure, some aspects of the theory have not been completely defined, but why does that mean there has to be a creator?

I have read your posts. And I believe that you feel that you are approaching this problem from an unbiased point-of-view. But I wonder, what exactly would it take for you to accept evolution? What would it take to convince you a creator or designer wasn't required?

Also, I think I have been fair, but please excuse me if I have misinterpreted your position.
Sure, that's fair. What would it take to convince me? Most of my life I was convinced. I was a fossil hunter at an early age. I read George Gaylord Simpson's most popular book ("Natural Selection"??) at age 12! My 9th grade biology teacher had me go in front of all her 10th grade biology classes to teach evolution from my own fossil collection I had collected myself from ages 8 through 11. Crap! Could I be more self-indoctrinated? Obviously, and I didn't figure out till years later, my biology teacher knew she could only teach evolution by getting a student to do it for her!

What would it take for me to return to darwin-faith? EVIDENCE!

If you read my posts as you've said you'll see I can allow for quite a bit of [evolutionism]:
1. that everything from t=0 to t=4MYA could have unfolded from "just so" physical laws.
2 that all flora/fauna could have unfolded from a sufficiently rich supply of genetic information at the cellular level, say ~500MYA.

But in both cases that is an "unfolding" of a predestined set of information - not creation of new information.

I would have to see some new augmentation to THE THEORY, and not just RM/NS because I finally figured it out on my own what Hoyle et al were saying for a long time. There is not enough time for randomness to generate the immense information that is represented by life.

BTW, it was after reading Simpson in 7th grade that I dropped paleontology as my main interest and switched to physics/math. Even though I adhered to evolution for decades, I became more of an isotropic skeptic than the one-flavored skeptic-style I see here.

Show me the meat: show the math model that RM/NS can write programs. Kauffman is pretty smart. He wrote a big book. I did not find in there what I need - I'm still waiting. But I also invented the idea of a "the universe is a computer" idea - I thought. I probably just absorbed it from reading lots of von Neumann and the other early cyberneticists' writings when I was a teen. I think many of these early pioneers secretly believed that cellular automata is more than a toy. It may be an accurate model of reality. I have many other ideas bent in that direction, and unless there is some ~infinite computational power embedded the fabric of what is, I doubt complexity can self-organize here in <10^10 Years.

Oh, and SURE I'm biased. Just not unilaterally biased toward evolution as I used to be. Try isotropic skepticism yourself. Maybe just one day a week - its good for you.
 
Pixy, you are NOT following here. You are too hasty. There is a meta-layer in between here. The EVIDENCE I am arguing is about cognition about ID, NOT ABOUT ID ITSELF.
You don't have any evidence. Of anything.

Instead of terse protest, would you humor me with answering whether you rule out the possibility that humans may evolve to some future entity that has sufficient design ability to design a new universe in which there could be intelligent entities?
A. Rule Out
B. Could be.
Huh? We can do this right now.
 
Instead of terse protest, would you humor me with answering whether you rule out the possibility that humans may evolve to some future entity that has sufficient design ability to design a new universe in which there could be intelligent entities?
A. Rule Out
B. Could be.

I think I know where your argument is going, but I'll wait until you make your own case. Assuming that B is true (for now I'll just stick to idea of a simulated universe), what would your argument be?
 
But in both cases that is an "unfolding" of a predestined set of information - not creation of new information.

"predestined set of information" seems like a pretty strong claim. Are you saying that once things were set in motion that there was no other possible outcome?
 
You don't have any evidence. Of anything.

Huh? We can do this right now.
Well then you are easy. Though I'm not sure you mean that we can already build a universe with intelligent entities within it. I wonder what criterion you lay for "intelligence". What I meant was: intelligent to the equivalent level of our own: self-aware, conscious, etc.

OK, so if you believe that we can evolve to that point...

My proposition is that you believe intelligent design is inevitable of a new universe in which are intelligent entities that could wonder about their own origins? You say yes? How do you know that we are not already a product of such - that this has not already happened? You say, because there is no evidence of it - right? BUT YOU HAVE ALREADY ACCEPTED THAT IT COULD HAPPEN IN THE FUTURE WITH/WITHOUT EVIDENCE.

OK. But my point is that it is evident that you believe it COULD happen, which is indistinguishable (given my previously posted logical argument) from that it COULD HAVE ALREADY HAPPENED. This is evidence of how you think , not evidence about WHAT IS.

It is evidence that you hold plausibility of ID and deny it in the same mindset.
 
"predestined set of information" seems like a pretty strong claim. Are you saying that once things were set in motion that there was no other possible outcome?
You pulled this out of the context where I was revealing to what extent I can allow in my own mind, the likelihood of evolution being true. I was not saying that it is what I normally take stock in. It is a stretch.

But in that scenario, NO: not limited to one outcome set. I meant to suggest that IF there was sufficient information in the genomes (where they come from I dunno) of ~500MYA that they could be randomly shuffled and adapt into, for example, all that we see today. Both living and extinct, including humans. Predestined? Only maybe to the extent that there was enough premordial functions, and ingredients, to build even something so strange as human beings. This is about the closest I can come to believing evolution and you might notice it is quite Darwinian. Darwin did not answer where the first cells came from and as far as I can tell, the natural selection worked on variation on big chunks of information already in existence.
 
Last edited:
I think I know where your argument is going, but I'll wait until you make your own case. Assuming that B is true (for now I'll just stick to idea of a simulated universe), what would your argument be?
I could dance with you to if you wish but maybe I've typed 4000 words already on this. Please follow my thread with chipmunk and give me your feedback - I'd much appreciate it.

Pixy thinks, as best I can tell, I'm purporting this as some kind of evidence for a simulated universe here. I am NOT. Its easier than that, because I think [collective you] already accept with or without evidence that synthesis of a future universe as grand as our own is an inevitable consequence of evolution with ourselves being common ancestors to that next universe.

What it is evidence of is: a paradox in your mindset, where you accept ID and deny it all at once. If you accept the premise, why do you insist you are to the left, instead of to the right, on a time-line you already accept?
 
My proposition is that you believe intelligent design is inevitable of a new universe in which are intelligent entities that could wonder about their own origins? You say yes? How do you know that we are not already a product of such - that this has not already happened? You say, because there is no evidence of it - right? BUT YOU HAVE ALREADY ACCEPTED THAT IT COULD HAPPEN IN THE FUTURE WITH/WITHOUT EVIDENCE.

OK. But my point is that it is evident that you believe it COULD happen, which is indistinguishable (given my previously posted logical argument) from that it COULD HAVE ALREADY HAPPENED. This is evidence of how you think , not evidence about WHAT IS.

It is evidence that you hold plausibility of ID and deny it in the same mindset.

I understand where you are coming from. But I'm concerned about how arguments like this have the potential to lead people away from useful information. There are lots of things that cannot be proved wrong. The world could be a simulation, an all-powerful god could be testing us by giving us false evidence, or we could simply be dreaming. But without evidence to indicate that one of these things is true, I don't see the value in believing them.

I just made a similar argument in the Can a Skeptic Believe in God? thread (sorry to double post, but I'm new and the system won't let me post URLs yet):
For me the supernatural argument was always comes down to the "brain in a jar" argument. Sure, we may all be brains in a jar hooked up to computer simulations. And if the simulation is perfect, there is no way to tell. A perfect simulation would be completely undetectable and have no measurable influence on the world. But that's the point, if it really has no measurable influence whatsoever then there is no way to study it, no way to test it, and no way to learn from it.

If the simulation isn't perfect that's a different story. What if it *does* affect the world in tiny ways. In that case it would be rational for a small number of skeptics to question the idea that we are not brains in jars. They should try and find evidence and, if found, they should try to convince the scientific community. But just because there is a small chance doesn't mean that it makes sense for most people to believe it. Until there is some convincing evidence, the vast majority of skeptics should not believe it.

If supernatural forces exist they either have influence on the world or not. If they do, they there should be ways to test to see if they exist, and without evidence it doesn't make sense to believe in them. If they don't have influence on the world, then they don't matter and are essentially distractions what we can study and learn about.

So, can skeptics be believers? Sure, but probably the vast majority shouldn't be. I'm not saying that people can't silo their beliefs and choose not to be skeptical about certain things. Or that people that believe supernatural things can't be very skeptical when dealing with certain topics. These people are and have been invaluable to skeptical arguments and the world in general. But, I don't think you can be wholly a skeptic if you believe in supernatural things that don't have evidence to support them.


I don't agree with your statements that:
There is not enough time for randomness to generate the immense information that is represented by life.
or
But in both cases that is an "unfolding" of a predestined set of information - not creation of new information.

But these are real arguments that can be tested and discussed. If you believe that evolution could not have happened without a creator, that's one thing. And we can discuss that. But unless you think it could not possibly have happened without a designer, I don't think there is any evidence to support that the system is anything but undersigned.
 
You don't have any evidence. Of anything.
Huh? We can do this right now.
:boxedin: Brother, your neural network has some deeply worn grooves in it. Loosen up. Remap some synapses. Go back to being a curious boy again. Replace your yagi with a vertical dipole. Change your crystal to a variable oscillator. Learn to juggle. Take up hip-hop. Pull your panties out of your crack. Ask your loved ones for forgiveness.
 
Well then you are easy. Though I'm not sure you mean that we can already build a universe with intelligent entities within it.
That's not what you said. You asked if we might have "sufficient design ability to design a new universe in which there could be intelligent entities". The answer is yes, we do, right now.

My proposition is that you believe intelligent design is inevitable of a new universe in which are intelligent entities that could wonder about their own origins?
No.

You say yes?
No.

How do you know that we are not already a product of such - that this has not already happened?
I don't know any such thing. But I ignore it as idle and valueless speculation.

You say, because there is no evidence of it - right?
No.

BUT YOU HAVE ALREADY ACCEPTED THAT IT COULD HAPPEN IN THE FUTURE WITH/WITHOUT EVIDENCE.
It could happen. That is not evidence.


OK. But my point is that it is evident that you believe it COULD happen, which is indistinguishable (given my previously posted logical argument) from that it COULD HAVE ALREADY HAPPENED.
No.

This is evidence of how you think , not evidence about WHAT IS.
No.

It is evidence that you hold plausibility of ID and deny it in the same mindset.
Your argument has nothing whatsoever to do with Intelligent Design as it is proposed by, for example, the Design Institute. All it is, is a worthless circular argument on prime causes.

As I said: It is not testable, it is not useful, and it is not supported by any evidence whatsoever. Furthermore, it does not support your arguments regarding evolution in any way. So what's the point?
 
:boxedin: Brother, your neural network has some deeply worn grooves in it. Loosen up. Remap some synapses. Go back to being a curious boy again. Replace your yagi with a vertical dipole. Change your crystal to a variable oscillator. Learn to juggle. Take up hip-hop. Pull your panties out of your crack. Ask your loved ones for forgiveness.
No.
 
I understand where you are coming from. But I'm concerned about how arguments like this have the potential to lead people away from useful information. .
I have a lot more faith in people than that. You just hit upon an irritating thing about what seems to be going on in society. That is that science has gotten the microphone and has a tendency to censor. Let people read all ideas and judge for themselves. Make sure that the government schools do not teach dogma without identifying it as such.

There are lots of things that cannot be proved wrong. The world could be a simulation, an all-powerful god could be testing us by giving us false evidence, or we could simply be dreaming. But without evidence to indicate that one of these things is true, I don't see the value in believing them. .
No, I'm dreaming that you exist, but you don't :)

But these are real arguments that can be tested and discussed. If you believe that evolution could not have happened without a creator, that's one thing. And we can discuss that. But unless you think it could not possibly have happened without a designer, I don't think there is any evidence to support that the system is anything but undersigned.
What you do not agree with: that RM/NS cannot produce significant amounts of new information, is not easily tested. I would think it would not be empirically possible to test because it requires falsificaton. But if only we could find ONE example where it works!

If I already knew of one example where RM/NS produces say a 1000 base sequence that builds a new structure (definitions totally lacking here - its pretty subjective for me at this point) then I would have finally found what I've been looking for.

Have you ever done some calculations on the amount of permutations there are for modest amounts of DNA information?

In the early days of microprocessors, one of my technicians asked me, why do we have to erase the EPROMS and program them, can't they manufacture one each of each possible kind and you just order the one you want? At the time the EPROMs were 1KB. I said incredulously, don't you realize that would be 2^8096 different parts? Thats ~10^2048 different parts. There are only 10^70 atoms in the universe!

That's when I realized it was easy to ignore how awesome the amount of randomness you'd have to go through, to even find a simple little program. Then I remembered that I had read that many times and dismissed it, coming from the likes of Fred Hoyle.

Another war story was when I worked for a gov agency contractor decades ago. I was on a committee writing a paper on 'future of mass memory'. We had lots of satellite data and such and were running out of warehouse space to store it all. I joined the committee late but already the paper centered around an optical memory, already working in the lab purportedly, that could store 10^40 bits. That jerked my head around. Smelling a rat, I found that the papers cited via two other gov publications both pointed to the same April article in an Optics journal. I wish I could find that, now. Obviously, it was an april fools joke and three gov agencies were taking the bait. Some of these were scientists! Couldn't they do the siimple arithmetic that if one bit were stored per atom, this memory would be the size of the moon? You couldn't dump all the data at 1Gbps in the whole lifetime of the universe? Scientists can be pretty gullible. BTW, my discovery was not well accepted because now they were going to have to re-write the paper.
 
But unless you think it could not possibly have happened without a designer, I don't think there is any evidence to support that the system is anything but undersigned.
Huh? "undersigned"? Cannot parse.
I did not rush to the designer conclusion. Back away from evolution for a moment and consider consciousness. It is ordinary in that its always with us but it is the deepest mystery imaginable. If one can argue [if there be a designer he is incompetent] I can argue that if there is no purpose to evolution, why did it make consciousness.

So, it isn't just that I find RM/NS a doubtful generator of new information, bootstrapping its way from atoms to amino acids to proteins to reverse-transcriptase to DNA/RNA or something like that... It is that I find the idea that we think we know so much when we actually know so little [vis a vis our inability to define intelligence or define consciousness], preposterous.

I just read Pixy's post where he reveals he thinks we have already built the substrate on which intelligence could evolve [my paraphrase]. Maybe Marvin Minsky would agree with him, so he is not in shabby company. I do not understand anymore that idealist viewpoint. Isn't that a small school? Extremely-strong-AI? I wonder how many on this thread subscribe to that.
 
VonNeumann, I don't think ideas should be censored. But I also don't think all ideas are equally valid. I want people to question the established doctrine. I want people to try and disprove it. My point is that giving god, or a designer, or computer simulation, as an explanation for the unknown *without evidence* is a cop-out.

Why muddle your argument with a jump to the designer? You feel you've found a problem with evolution. Great. Lets discuss it, maybe improve the theory. But what I don't get is why just because you feel one part of the theory is incorrect, that you feel confident to say that a designer is involved. Are you saying that there is no possible explanation other than a designer? That there is no conceivable way the universe could have ended up as it has without a designer?

I understand what led you to doubt aspects of evolution. What made you decide that a designer was involved?
 
If one can argue [if there be a designer he is incompetent] I can argue that if there is no purpose to evolution, why did it make consciousness.
I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, I just want to clarify. Are you arguing that if there is no purpose to evolution it would not have created consciousness? And to follow that, since it did create consciousness then there must be a purpose?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom