Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I just read Pixy's post where he reveals he thinks we have already built the substrate on which intelligence could evolve [my paraphrase]. Maybe Marvin Minsky would agree with him, so he is not in shabby company. I do not understand anymore that idealist viewpoint. Isn't that a small school? Extremely-strong-AI? I wonder how many on this thread subscribe to that.
Hell's donkeys, it's your own freaking argument! If it's not possible, your argument would mean we are not possible!
 
Huh? "undersigned"? Cannot parse.
I did not rush to the designer conclusion. Back away from evolution for a moment and consider consciousness. It is ordinary in that its always with us but it is the deepest mystery imaginable. If one can argue [if there be a designer he is incompetent] I can argue that if there is no purpose to evolution, why did it make consciousness.
No.
 
Back away from evolution for a moment and consider consciousness. It is ordinary in that its always with us but it is the deepest mystery imaginable.
Why?

In nature it seems to exist in all shades from barely conscious to fully conscious, and it seems to be advantageous to have, especially for social species. On the other hand, nothing indicates that consciousness is necessary, or that it represents a higher stage than anything else. We cannot conclude backwards and say that there must be something behind the fact that we are fully conscious. As far as I know, we are not even the most succesful species on Earth (I have heard that if we count bio-mass, there are bacteria with more mass then humans).
 
My cat knows more about this than Penrose and Lucas, because it doesn't have its head stuffed full of counterfactual assumptions.

And I don't even have a cat.

Given what other ideas you find convincing, that is hardly a recommendation.

What counterfactual assumptions?
 
What counterfactual assumptions?
That consciousness is mysterious; that human beings are more than systems of matter; that (taking Penrose's case) quantum gravity could be the proximate cause of consciousness (not physically possible; the numbers are out by about 17 orders of magnitude); that (taking Lucas's case) humans are not subject to the strictures of Godel's Incompleteness Theorem to precisely the degree to which it is applicable.

I can come up with some more if you like. Or I can ask my cat.
 
Pixy,
I'll start a thread about this in the philosophy forum (or maybe science forum) either later on today or tomorrow. I don't want to hijack this thread.
 
Literally the term evolution means 'unfold'. If that is the meaning of your sentence then i agree that everything pre-biotic COULD have been an unfolding of a set of laws. I can also find plausible that all life on earth could have unfolded from a set of information in some original cells. There are minimally two gaps: origin of the laws; origin of the first cells.

I suspect you mean that there is no intelligent design in the laws nor in the first cells, but we could agree on the unfolding from at least two origin points: physical laws; first cells/quasi-cells. Then we are merely saying we don't have evidence for how these two origin points began, so you can believe what you want and I can in what I want.

I don't believe what I WANT. I believe what I interpret as true from the evidence.

I would only point out that the mutual-coupling of RM/NS is doubtful as a mechanism of [I'll say 'creating'] the physical laws, and it is doubtful as a mechanism of 'creating' DNA.

Why is it doubtful ?

It may be that the physical laws themselves indeed were formed in such a manner from a chaotic, lawless burgeoning cosmos.

At least we are missing a huge ingredient to how RM/NS alone could go from, say amino acids, to DNA. But, unfolding a pre-designed plan is not within the spirit of a non-teleological mindset.

Having said all that, how could you say " creation of the physical laws themselves followed a similar process [of evolution]", and say it within the constrants of science. I think you are just speculating as I am fond of doing myself.

Didn't I say "could have", or something ?
 
OK: conjecture. But what is evident to me is that the conjecture is plausible within the paradigm of some (most?) here, that opens the door for ID if you merely displace yourself to the right on the time-line. The evidence is not about nature, it is about how skeptics deny what they actually accept (given displacement on the time-line).

So, what do I accept ? Pray tell.
 
:confused: Chipmunk, to me you appear as slippery as a bar of soap.

OK, then I am to understand that you withdraw the tentative hypothesis that humans could ever evolve to something that would design a new universe? I am to understand you completely rule that out?
I thought I've been very clear that I completely rule it out unless and until compelling evidence comes along. I don't regard the fact of complex, intelligent life as evidence, given the paradox above.
 
I don't think another theory is allowed by science.

So you don't have one. Got it.

I'm not following how such fundamental things are judged by you as "inefficient". Lets go with how are stars inefficient?

As I said, there is at least one much better way to convert matter into energy. Why aren't the stars vast matter-antimatter reactors ? Fusion isn't nearly as efficient.
 
I thought I've been very clear that I completely rule it out unless and until compelling evidence comes along. I don't regard the fact of complex, intelligent life as evidence, given the paradox above.
Speaking of which, how do you, VonNeumann, grapple with said paradox?
 
Last edited:
I read this paper by Lucas on the Net somewhere. It seemed pretty convincing to me.

You're seriously suggesting that you understand more about this than Penrose and Lucas?

Suggesting? No.

Stating forthrightly? Yes.

No compenent philosopher takes either Lucas or Penrose seriously in this regard; for a quick demonstration, read Dennet and Hofstadter.
 
1. Technology is increasing
2. Someday AI
3. AI smarter than humans
4. Bio-machine blends
5. Immortality
6. progression toward something that is god-like
7. god-like progeny create new universes in which unfold new 'life'
8. Unfolding from that 'new life' are intelligent creatures
9. In this new universe, the new intelligent creatures invent technology
10. Their technology increases.

Wow, this discussion has moved along quite a bit since I last checked - I've been out celebrating all weekend after getting minor corrections in my Viva :)

Let me get this straight: because you have a notion that humans may be able to create some kind of separate Universe in the future, we have to accept that we are probably in a created Universe ourselves.

There is also a vaguely conceivable possibility that I'll build a time machine sometime in the future, and therefore you should all worship me as God right now for pouring all the amino acids into the primordial soup, and then stirring it with a tea spoon (sterling silver).

Something being conceivable, or imaginable, does not mean something is possible: being able to conceive that event X will happen in future does not mean that p(X)>0. Time travel, Universe creation, Faster-than-light travel all come under this sort of banner.

Therefore, our ability to conceive that humans may have the ability to create Universes certainly does not mean that it is at all possible. Your argument is therefore flawed. Points 3 through 7 are pure unfounded speculation, and so in order for your argument to gain credence you would need to present evidence.

For example, evidence is required that you could either
a) make another Universe similar to our's (using some cunning electro-gravity tachyon inversion ray etc. etc.)
b) simulate a Universe within our's of suitable complexity.

If you're going with the computer simulation type (which I believe you are), you'd need to demonstrate how you could store all the information needed for a Universe in our Universe. My hypothesis is that, even if you used all the matter in the Universe, you could not even store a miniscule portion of the information required to generate a similar Universe, never mind process it.

Therefore, I think it is inevitable that an embedded simulated Universe could only contain a stupidly negligible fraction of the complexity of the previous one, leading to an unavoidable iterative decrease in complexity.

For my money, it would be impossible to simulate a Universe in our's whereby intelligent life of our level could form, both in terms of storage and also processing time.

Plus, what on Earth would it achieve for us?
 
Wow, this discussion has moved along quite a bit since I last checked - I've been out celebrating all weekend after getting minor corrections in my Viva :)

Let me get this straight: because you have a notion that humans may be able to create some kind of separate Universe in the future, we have to accept that we are probably in a created Universe ourselves.

There is also a vaguely conceivable possibility that I'll build a time machine sometime in the future, and therefore you should all worship me as God right now for pouring all the amino acids into the primordial soup, and then stirring it with a tea spoon (sterling silver).

Something being conceivable, or imaginable, does not mean something is possible: being able to conceive that event X will happen in future does not mean that p(X)>0. Time travel, Universe creation, Faster-than-light travel all come under this sort of banner.

Therefore, our ability to conceive that humans may have the ability to create Universes certainly does not mean that it is at all possible. Your argument is therefore flawed. Points 3 through 7 are pure unfounded speculation, and so in order for your argument to gain credence you would need to present evidence.

For example, evidence is required that you could either
a) make another Universe similar to our's (using some cunning electro-gravity tachyon inversion ray etc. etc.)
b) simulate a Universe within our's of suitable complexity.

If you're going with the computer simulation type (which I believe you are), you'd need to demonstrate how you could store all the information needed for a Universe in our Universe. My hypothesis is that, even if you used all the matter in the Universe, you could not even store a miniscule portion of the information required to generate a similar Universe, never mind process it.

Therefore, I think it is inevitable that an embedded simulated Universe could only contain a stupidly negligible fraction of the complexity of the previous one, leading to an unavoidable iterative decrease in complexity.

For my money, it would be impossible to simulate a Universe in our's whereby intelligent life of our level could form, both in terms of storage and also processing time.

Plus, what on Earth would it achieve for us?
I agree - but you miss my point. I'm repeating myself. The idea is not to prove it could happen but merely to point out to those who believe without evidence that it could happen (having spoken with many skeptics, you may be surprised that many skeptics believe it is inevitable that humans will evolve to this omega level), but also say ID is false, hold contradictory thinking in their believe system on this point.
 
Speaking of which, how do you, VonNeumann, grapple with said paradox?
I grew up around A C Clarke type of mindset. Space Odysses 2001, etc. HAL9000. I was strong AI, total reductionist .. all that. But I really never thought of this paradox when I believed we could evolve to a "Creator" level. So I cannot tell you how i would have grappled with it. Probably would have answered exactly as you just did. But now, I don't accept IU even for n=0. The reason is I believe we live in a universe that, within it, it is computationally constrained (if you will) such that we cannot grow AI here, and neither can nature (self-organization is limited, I believe). The thought experiment was designed for people who have the mindset that accepts evolution and strong AI ... and that no longer describes me.
 
As I said, there is at least one much better way to convert matter into energy. Why aren't the stars vast matter-antimatter reactors ? Fusion isn't nearly as efficient.
I'm no cosmologist but ... stars don't convert matter to energy (only), they convert matter to other matter, with an energy byproduct. How would you build a machine that could make beryllium and carbon and say uranium? Do you know the most efficient way to do it? How many different stellar systems does it take in cascade to make uranium? I have no idea but I don't think one stellar structure can do it. It takes a series of steps through different systems to go through the process to make all the elements. It takes fission and fusion. The EM output, gravitational output, etc are byproducts but also part of the whole system, in order for it to work. So I wonder how you be so bold as to think you know if a star is efficient - but all I got from you so far is you seemingly think stars are just EM emitters. Where do you think all our elements came from? It took billions of years and an assortment of "just so" stellar structures. Its really quite weird, or 'lucky'.
 
I agree - but you miss my point. I'm repeating myself. The idea is not to prove it could happen but merely to point out to those who believe without evidence that it could happen (having spoken with many skeptics, you may be surprised that many skeptics believe it is inevitable that humans will evolve to this omega level), but also say ID is false, hold contradictory thinking in their believe system on this point.
No.

It has nothing to do with Intelligent Design. It has similarities - lack of evidence, lack of logical rigour, special pleading, circular reasoning - but is otherwise unconnected.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom