Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Indeed, the power to redefine the meaning of words is god-like, is it not? :)
I don't understand this line. If Huntsman had said "we have observed speciation for (just one/a few/most/all but one) of the currently accepted definitions of speciation." I'd see your point. Is there a particular definition of "speciation" which you prefer and is currently accepted, which has not been observed?
 
It's because (a) you have no evidence, and (b) the idea is useless anyway.

That's why we reject idealistic pantheism and panpsychism and Platonic and Berkelian idealism - which all amount to the same thing as your simulation concept. They can never be shown to be true, and even if true, they are not of any use.
Your stubborn adherances to your understandings are commendable. They are required for you to be a good scientist. I have no quibble at all with that's what you should do. I understand the scientific rejection: point noted (again).
 
The Dogma made no such prediction. It can't make any such prediction. All it speaks about is the direction of information flow, not about coding.
Why do you think the HGP was looking for the 100,000 genes in the human genome? Why did they think they knew it was 100,000 genes? It was because researchers predicted (of course, people predict; dogmas don't. but I didn't think this required careful wording for the intelligent people here - including you) with what the Dogma teaches,that there should be a one-to-one correspondence.

There was MORE to the dogma than direction of flow, it is: one-to-one gene-to-protein.
 
You read wrongly.



How about doubling the amount of chromosomes in a single generation? That's been observed in plants. A single-generational jump to a new species, capable of reproducing with its own generation but not plants of its parents generation.

If that's not "sizeable new information", I don't know what is.

Also, it doesn't have to be a single large jump. What process stops the small changes from continuing to grow? That's what you haven't explained. There's no reason for the small changes not to continue to occur, and add up to something larger. Look up ring species, seriously. Ring species giove an excellent example of how small changes can add up without discontinuity. If you don't know, a ring species is where there are several different populations spread out geographically. Each population can interbreed with the populations near it. However, the populations say, on the two ends, can't interbreed. This can occur in time as well as geography, a species makes small changes, and those add up to a completely new species.

First, I think I posted previously the link for the 10,000s proteins from one gene. So I DID read it. Sometimes I write a post and get bumped out and come back in and the post vanished (anybody know why?) so I'll have to go look if that post is here somewhere.

Secondly, I don't know about the doubling of chromosomes. I'll have to go read about it. Do the new chromosomes contain entirely new sequences or are they copies of pre-existing chromosomes (perhaps slightly modified)?

Also, the ring species sounds like it could accelerate evolution (time always seems to be the enemy of evolution, to me), but I'll have to read about it, too.
 
For those who doubted that I read somewhere that one gene can produce 10,000s proteins, I found that I posted a link at post #420. For what it is worth, it appears to be a speculation of possible result from alternative splicing during DNA to mRNA transcription. I don't know if it is actually observed that so many proteins can result from one gene.
 
As I said, if you think another theory fits the facts better or that darwinism is inadequate, then stop making vague claims or personnal attacks and be specific.
I don't think another theory is allowed by science. In answer to my "vague claims", I posted the kind of 'evidence' that should have a skeptic be critical, many posts ago. It has to do with with avian phalanges. No one has responded to that post. Why don't you read it and give it a shot, Belz? ...and please cite for me a personal attack by me.

How is it inefficient ? It allows us to do precisely what it was designed to do. It wasn't designed so much for speed and stability as it was for versatility. And that it is.
You say Windows is inefficient because it was designed to be? OK. Of course it is. Who would spend an extra $M on R&D for a product that is already commercially viable. As long as a design is viable, why does it have to be perfect? I do not understand how design requires perfection, which is what I think you are saying (?).


Still waiting..
You are still waiting for the neutral theory I mentioned? Here 'tis:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutral_theory_of_molecular_evolution

You're the one who asked about the carbon atom being badly designed or not. I'm simply pointing out that the nuclear fusion process is inneficient compared to, not the fusion bomb, as you clearly didn't understand my post, but a total energy conversion, however THAT might be done. I'm saying that stars are inneficient and AGAIN this points to an incompetent designer. Your Microsoft example is inadequate, because Bill Gates did NOT create the LAWS OF PHYSICS themselves.
I'm not following how such fundamental things are judged by you as "inefficient". Lets go with how are stars inefficient?
 
Last edited:
There was MORE to the dogma than direction of flow, it is: one-to-one gene-to-protein.
As I have understood the dogma, there is no mentioning of one-to-one gene-to-protein.

But even if there was, even if the dogma is wrong, the theory of evolution is not shaken just because the mechanism for evolution is more comlex than the dogma stated.
 
If you really think that the consequences of Godel's second proof should be spread beyond the mathematical community -- what actual consequences does it have? As far as I can tell, the only serious philosophical implications of Godel's proofs are the Kolmogorov-Chaitin definition of information complexity (which is still "mathematics"), Turing's proof that the halting problem is unsolvable (which is still "mathematics" broadly definedand largely of interest only to computing specialists), and the Lucas-Penrose argument about artificial intelligence (which has been proven to be fallacious).

I read this paper by Lucas on the Net somewhere. It seemed pretty convincing to me.

You're seriously suggesting that you understand more about this than Penrose and Lucas? When a person who has only done CSE maths (i.e myself) has already proved you wrong on another mathematical issue??

You really truly are a complete arsehole.
 
Last edited:
You are still waiting for the neutral theory I mentioned? Here 'tis:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutral_theory_of_molecular_evolution
But it sounded in your argument like you were saying that "macro-e" would require "neutrality" where "micro-e" would not, as though natural selection switches off while transitioning between "macro" forms, based on the false assumption that intermediate forms would be non-viable otherwise.

The Neutral Theory is about genetic drift. It basically says, even if you remove selection pressures, forms may still branch off and speciation can still occur. Ring species, which you'd probably classify under "micro-e", would appear to support this idea, which on its own falsifies your implication that this is a "macro-e" "problem".

But the main point is that the theory never suggests that natural selection takes a holiday at any point. It just proposes that there is some percentage of alleles in any given genome that are affected more by genetic drift than by selection.

This is not a controversial idea. The only real controversy has been about relative percentages. From your link, on "the 'neutralist-selectionist' debate":
A heated debate arose on the initial publication of Kimura's theory, in which discussion largely revolved around the relative percentages of alleles that are "neutral" versus "non-neutral" in any given genome. Contrary to the perception of many onlookers, the debate was not about whether or not natural selection acts at all.
There is no "neutral problem", for "macro-e" or otherwise. In fact, if genetic drift occurs despite natural selection, what mechanism is there that would prevent "macro-e" from occurring as a simple extrapolation of "micro-e"?
 
Last edited:
We went in a circle.
I say: IU= true
U say: maybe
I say: n =N N>0
U say: n=0
I say: P approaches 0 for n=0
U say: for IU, P approaches 0, therefore n=0

See, I thought you accepted for sake of argument that IU is true. Then you seemed to say that n=0 because IU=false.

The probability we are in the first iteration is 100% if there is no iteration, but if iteration is 100% then the probability of n=N, N>0, approaches 100%. That seems logical to me.

Is it that you are just too reluctant to accept the premise because you don't like the result N>0? Did you retract the premise? ...or did I make a logical error?
I only ever accepted the premise on a tentative basis in order to follow it to its logical conclusion, which resulted in an insoluble paradox, at which point I rejected the premise as a non-starter unless and until some compelling evidence comes along.

The logical flaw, as I see it, is this paradox: "Complex, intelligent life is impossible without the design aid of complex, intelligent life." This is what the ID argument (whatever its form) boils down to.
 
OK: conjecture. But what is evident to me is that the conjecture is plausible within the paradigm of some (most?) here, that opens the door for ID if you merely displace yourself to the right on the time-line.
No. It is not plausible (given that no evidence for it exists), and even if it were true, it would not not make ID plausible, because ID is contrary to the evidence.

The evidence is not about nature, it is about how skeptics deny what they actually accept (given displacement on the time-line).
That's not evidence.

I am patient. If you still don't understand, I'll explain it in a different way, friend.
I understand. You have nothing but an untestable conjecture.
 
Why do you think the HGP was looking for the 100,000 genes in the human genome? Why did they think they knew it was 100,000 genes? It was because researchers predicted (of course, people predict; dogmas don't. but I didn't think this required careful wording for the intelligent people here - including you) with what the Dogma teaches,that there should be a one-to-one correspondence.
NO.

The Dogma speaks only of the direction of information flow. It says nothing of coding. Researchers thought there would be a one-to-one coding from genes to proteins, but this does not follow from the Dogma at all. It was a hypothesis formed on the basis of the best evidence available at the time.
 
The Circle of ID

The logical flaw, as I see it, is this paradox: "Complex, intelligent life is impossible without the design aid of complex, intelligent life." This is what the ID argument (whatever its form) boils down to.



That's a good way to put it.

Who created the complex intelligent life that was needed to originate the complex life that the ID people so obsess over?



The ID argument is clearly a circular argument if ever I saw one. There is no logical starting or ending point. No matter where you start, you end up eventually back where you started without a single viable answer no matter how many times you repeat the loop. No answers, but usually more questions.

Evidence has no influence on ID beliefs which are already cast in stone.

Valid scientific conjectures usually come from somewhere specific and lead in some specific direction.

We must simply accept the fact that some people only feel secure hiding behind beliefs that they fully know or desperately hope cannot EVER be proved one way or another. Religions and other superstitions provide that kind of placebo of false hope they need for security. Perhaps they feel that false hope is better than no hope at all. In fact, for people that shallow in terms of rationality, it is.

But many ID supporters I've seen insist on Earth being less than 10,000 years old and man and dinosaurs living side by side and other things that sound more like the 'Twilight Zone' than any reality attested to by scientific inquiry ... gimme a break !

ID supporters cannot be reasoned with and any argument with such is a lost cause from the onset.






"The earth is flat, and anyone who
disputes this claim is an atheist who
deserves to be punished."

Sheik Abdel-Aziz Ibn Baaz,
Supreme religious authority,
Saudi Arabia, 1993 (AD not BC)



NOTE: To be fair: Ibn Baaz has since recanted his position on a flat earth, but the ID people will never change regardless of any evidence.
 
As I have understood the dogma, there is no mentioning of one-to-one gene-to-protein.

But even if there was, even if the dogma is wrong, the theory of evolution is not shaken just because the mechanism for evolution is more comlex than the dogma stated.
I'm sorry if my focus was lost on this point. Specifically:
1. Evolutionists say that the field of study encompassed by biology is guided by the evolution paradigm [my summary]
2. Others [including I] say that there are times, The Central Dogma of Molecular Biology [aka of DNA] is the example here, where that guidance was negative.

I challenge that evolution is such a guiding light as it is sold to be. Here is a case where it was not.

If I could give numerous accounts such as this one right now, perhaps some of you might concede that "the theory of evolution is not shaken" is questionable. It would depend upon how strong you are toward your bias.
 
As I have understood the dogma, there is no mentioning of one-to-one gene-to-protein.

But even if there was, even if the dogma is wrong, the theory of evolution is not shaken just because the mechanism for evolution is more comlex than the dogma stated.
Do you want me to google it for you, that the dogma includes 1gene:1protein?
 
I only ever accepted the premise on a tentative basis in order to follow it to its logical conclusion, which resulted in an insoluble paradox, at which point I rejected the premise as a non-starter unless and until some compelling evidence comes along.

The logical flaw, as I see it, is this paradox: "Complex, intelligent life is impossible without the design aid of complex, intelligent life." This is what the ID argument (whatever its form) boils down to.
:confused: Chipmunk, to me you appear as slippery as a bar of soap.

OK, then I am to understand that you withdraw the tentative hypothesis that humans could ever evolve to something that would design a new universe? I am to understand you completely rule that out?
 
That's a good way to put it.

Who created the complex intelligent life that was needed to originate the complex life that the ID people so obsess over?



The ID argument is clearly a circular argument if ever I saw one. There is no logical starting or ending point. No matter where you start, you end up eventually back where you started without a single viable answer no matter how many times you repeat the loop. No answers, but usually more questions.

Evidence has no influence on ID beliefs which are already cast in stone.

Valid scientific conjectures usually come from somewhere specific and lead in some specific direction.

We must simply accept the fact that some people only feel secure hiding behind beliefs that they fully know or desperately hope cannot EVER be proved one way or another. Religions and other superstitions provide that kind of placebo of false hope they need for security. Perhaps they feel that false hope is better than no hope at all. In fact, for people that shallow in terms of rationality, it is.

But many ID supporters I've seen insist on Earth being less than 10,000 years old and man and dinosaurs living side by side and other things that sound more like the 'Twilight Zone' than any reality attested to by scientific inquiry ... gimme a break !

ID supporters cannot be reasoned with and any argument with such is a lost cause from the onset.






"The earth is flat, and anyone who
disputes this claim is an atheist who
deserves to be punished."

Sheik Abdel-Aziz Ibn Baaz,
Supreme religious authority,
Saudi Arabia, 1993 (AD not BC)



NOTE: To be fair: Ibn Baaz has since recanted his position on a flat earth, but the ID people will never change regardless of any evidence.

Man, you walked in way too late. Nobody in this entire thread has talked about the stupid stuff like young earth - except those poking at me to see what I thought. You are so completely biased that you cannot see that "descent with modification" must start with cellular life. Science does not address with "theory" [only hypothesis] on origins OUTSIDE OF THAT SCOPE.

Now that you got your condemnation of church-lady out of the way, do you believe that humans can evolve to some level in the far future that can design the likes of new universes, in which intelligent entities could evolve?
 
Now that you got your condemnation of church-lady out of the way, do you believe that humans can evolve to some level in the far future that can design the likes of new universes, in which intelligent entities could evolve?

VonNeumann, I don't think the point is whether or not a universe (or at least the simulation of a universe) could be designed by a powerful creator. I think the point is why you seem to think that powerful creator is required. Science has be able to explain countless phenomena that people used to belief only be caused by god. And the evidence points to the fact that a creator isn't required. Sure, some aspects of the theory have not been completely defined, but why does that mean there has to be a creator?

I have read your posts. And I believe that you feel that you are approaching this problem from an unbiased point-of-view. But I wonder, what exactly would it take for you to accept evolution? What would it take to convince you a creator or designer wasn't required?

Also, I think I have been fair, but please excuse me if I have misinterpreted your position.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom