The Circle of ID
The logical flaw, as I see it, is this paradox: "Complex, intelligent life is impossible without the design aid of complex, intelligent life." This is what the ID argument (whatever its form) boils down to.
That's a good way to put it.
Who created the complex intelligent life that was needed to originate the complex life that the ID people so obsess over?
The ID argument is clearly a circular argument if ever I saw one. There is no logical starting or ending point. No matter where you start, you end up eventually back where you started without a single viable answer no matter how many times you repeat the loop. No answers, but usually more questions.
Evidence has no influence on ID beliefs which are already cast in stone.
Valid scientific conjectures usually come from somewhere specific and lead in some specific direction.
We must simply accept the fact that some people only feel secure hiding behind beliefs that they fully know or desperately hope cannot EVER be proved one way or another. Religions and other superstitions provide that kind of placebo of false hope they need for security. Perhaps they feel that false hope is better than no hope at all. In fact, for people that shallow in terms of rationality, it is.
But many ID supporters I've seen insist on Earth being less than 10,000 years old and man and dinosaurs living side by side and other things that sound more like the 'Twilight Zone' than any reality attested to by scientific inquiry ... gimme a break !
ID supporters cannot be reasoned with and any argument with such is a lost cause from the onset.
"The earth is flat, and anyone who
disputes this claim is an atheist who
deserves to be punished."
Sheik Abdel-Aziz Ibn Baaz,
Supreme religious authority,
Saudi Arabia, 1993 (AD not BC)
NOTE: To be fair: Ibn Baaz has since recanted his position on a flat earth, but the ID people will never change regardless of any evidence.