Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Actually, the term "evolution" could be applied to MORE than just biology. In fact, it's even possible that the creation of the physical laws themselves followed a similar process during the universe's formation.
Literally the term evolution means 'unfold'. If that is the meaning of your sentence then i agree that everything pre-biotic COULD have been an unfolding of a set of laws. I can also find plausible that all life on earth could have unfolded from a set of information in some original cells. There are minimally two gaps: origin of the laws; origin of the first cells.

I suspect you mean that there is no intelligent design in the laws nor in the first cells, but we could agree on the unfolding from at least two origin points: physical laws; first cells/quasi-cells. Then we are merely saying we don't have evidence for how these two origin points began, so you can believe what you want and I can in what I want.

I would only point out that the mutual-coupling of RM/NS is doubtful as a mechanism of [I'll say 'creating'] the physical laws, and it is doubtful as a mechanism of 'creating' DNA. At least we are missing a huge ingredient to how RM/NS alone could go from, say amino acids, to DNA. But, unfolding a pre-designed plan is not within the spirit of a non-teleological mindset.

Having said all that, how could you say " creation of the physical laws themselves followed a similar process [of evolution]", and say it within the constrants of science. I think you are just speculating as I am fond of doing myself.
 
So to me it would seem somewhat more plausible that we're at #1/#10 on the nth iteration of a version of your re-birth loop scenario that has a definite first iteration than that we're at the same point on an infinite version. But since it's impossible to know (at least given the evidence on hand) if we're in this loop at all or where we are in it, then I have to assume (unless evidence suggesting otherwise arises) that if we're in it at all, then we're in the first iteration.

My take on any other somewhat plausible but impossible to prove scenarios would be similar.
I could paraphrase that you believe it COULD be true that we be in an Iterative Universe (IU) but are biased toward believing we are at n=0. If I turned on an oscilloscope that is connected to some signal and capture my first trace, and it shows a few periods of a sinewave, I would assume that there were preceding periods that were there before I turned on the oscilloscope, unless I had contrary evidence. It would be quite arbitrary of me to assume that the first period on the screen was the very first one that signal produced. If you would find plausible (even if you give it a very small likelihood) that IU is true, but be biased toward n=0, wouldn't that be arbitrary?
 
That's not evidence. That's conjecture.
Because we will point out that you don't, in fact, have any evidence?
The reason I do not want to post all my ideas here is because I have not gone public with some of them before, and if I do, HERE is not where I should do it.

No it wouldn't.
I think when most people think of design, they think of something that did not appear until it was designed and therefore had a beginning. What is your reason for this statement "no, it wouldn't [have a beginning]"?
 
I could paraphrase that you believe it COULD be true that we be in an Iterative Universe (IU) but are biased toward believing we are at n=0. If I turned on an oscilloscope that is connected to some signal and capture my first trace, and it shows a few periods of a sinewave, I would assume that there were preceding periods that were there before I turned on the oscilloscope, unless I had contrary evidence. It would be quite arbitrary of me to assume that the first period on the screen was the very first one that signal produced. If you would find plausible (even if you give it a very small likelihood) that IU is true, but be biased toward n=0, wouldn't that be arbitrary?
Not arbitrary. Unless and until there's some evidence of IU, it's the best default assumption. Show me an IU sinewave, then maybe I'll shift my assumptions.
 
Still, every form is an intermediate form. There is no "end" result. This is just an after-the-fact assumption.
OK, every form that exists, or that we have fossil evidence of, is an intermediate form. For gradualists, there must exist forms that have left no evidence (at least undiscovered).
 
Not arbitrary. Unless and until there's some evidence of IU, it's the best default assumption. Show me an IU sinewave, then maybe I'll shift my assumptions.
Let me just clarify something. The "IU" that we've been talking about is dependent on intelligent design, or at least intelligent beginnings.

There is another Iterative Universe (to borrow your coinage) model I've thought about (and subsequently discovered I was far from alone) that seems slightly more plausible, and that's the idea of "baby universes" that branch off from other, older ones. In this idea, there still would seem to be either an infinity of causes/effects or an ultimate beginning. But since it isn't complicated by the seemingly insoluble requirement that intelligence must be planned for intelligently, either case can be grappled with. When entertaining this idea, then, it doesn't make a difference which iteration is taken as the default.
 
Not arbitrary. Unless and until there's some evidence of IU, it's the best default assumption. Show me an IU sinewave, then maybe I'll shift my assumptions.
We went in a circle.
I say: IU= true
U say: maybe
I say: n =N N>0
U say: n=0
I say: P approaches 0 for n=0
U say: for IU, P approaches 0, therefore n=0

See, I thought you accepted for sake of argument that IU is true. Then you seemed to say that n=0 because IU=false.

The probability we are in the first iteration is 100% if there is no iteration, but if iteration is 100% then the probability of n=N, N>0, approaches 100%. That seems logical to me.

Is it that you are just too reluctant to accept the premise because you don't like the result N>0? Did you retract the premise? ...or did I make a logical error?
 
Big deal. The Steelers' recent victory in the SuperBowl was not predicted by the central dogma, either. That doesn't invalidate either the Steelers' victor or the dogma, since the dogma is silent on the issue.
The dogma is similarly silent on the issue of how many genes humans -- or any given organism -- are supposed to have.
The central was NOT silent on that issue. Iit was not silent on number of genes because we knew since the 60s we had atleast 100,000 proteins; therefore Dogma predicted at least 100,000 genes. (Didn't you know that?). I conclude that a darwin-mind-set idea Central Dogma of DNA, was not only a poor predictor, it may have slowed discovery down. (no researcher dare dis' the dogma).
 
Last edited:
That's what I said.

Yes it is. In exactly the same way that biology is chemistry.

You mean biochemistry, right? Because if you're talking biology, your claim is wrong rather than merely unsupported.

But that's the point. They don't need to refer to evolution, because they are not talking specifically about evolution. Your evidence is evidence only for the obvious fact that we compartmentalise scientific research. It remains that evolution is the theory that ties all of biology together into a single system.

That again proves my point. You just don't know what you are talking about.

Evolution is atomic physics. And anthropology is quantum mechanics. Evolution necessarily does work at the atomic level, because if it didn't, it wouldn't work at all.

Which has nothing to do with the origin of atoms.
No, because that's not what evolution is about.
You are not conveying any information except you are relating the concept of reductionism by example. I thought that was already clear we mutually understood that when you responded "that's what I said". I used to be JUST like you with that mindset. And still am, only with a few important exceptions. Unless randomness has had time approaching infinity, so I'll call it infinite time, I doubt it could be responsible for the 'natural laws' tuned so exceedingly well. But neither you nor I can prove infinite time. ....but it could happen!
 
VonNeumann - Why are you posting on this forum?
Oh, now I get it. You should have referenced my post to Belz where I asked why he is here if he wants to avoid the central topic of this thread.

Is that what you mean?
 
Last edited:
I'm just saying that simulation/ID is already in the plausibility domain in the paradigm of self-proclaimed skeptics - the argument is merely where we are on the time-line.
It's exactly as plausible as idealistic pantheism and other such nonsense. In other words, unless you have evidence, it's not plausible at all.

Your conjecture is not evidence.
 
I think when most people think of design, they think of something that did not appear until it was designed and therefore had a beginning. What is your reason for this statement "no, it wouldn't [have a beginning]"?
I didn't say that. I contradicted your point, which was that "designed simulation would predict a starting point". It doesn't. It doesn't predict anything. That's one of the problems with the idea; it is completely unfalsifiable; it agrees with all possible sets of observations.
 
The central was NOT silent on that issue. Iit was not silent on number of genes because we knew since the 60s we had atleast 100,000 proteins; therefore Dogma predicted at least 100,000 genes.
The Dogma made no such prediction. It can't make any such prediction. All it speaks about is the direction of information flow, not about coding.
 
Is it that you are just too reluctant to accept the premise because you don't like the result N>0? Did you retract the premise? ...or did I make a logical error?
It's because (a) you have no evidence, and (b) the idea is useless anyway.

That's why we reject idealistic pantheism and panpsychism and Platonic and Berkelian idealism - which all amount to the same thing as your simulation concept. They can never be shown to be true, and even if true, they are not of any use.
 
You are not conveying any information except you are relating the concept of reductionism by example.
Yes. All of science is reductionist.

I thought that was already clear we mutually understood that when you responded "that's what I said". I used to be JUST like you with that mindset. And still am, only with a few important exceptions.
In other words, you are rational except when you dislike the results.

Unless randomness has had time approaching infinity, so I'll call it infinite time, I doubt it could be responsible for the 'natural laws' tuned so exceedingly well.
Back to the argument from anthropic principle. How exactly are the laws of nature tuned well?

But neither you nor I can prove infinite time. ....but it could happen!
Not in this universe, which is all we can speak of.
 
It's exactly as plausible as idealistic pantheism and other such nonsense. In other words, unless you have evidence, it's not plausible at all.

Your conjecture is not evidence.
OK: conjecture. But what is evident to me is that the conjecture is plausible within the paradigm of some (most?) here, that opens the door for ID if you merely displace yourself to the right on the time-line. The evidence is not about nature, it is about how skeptics deny what they actually accept (given displacement on the time-line). I am patient. If you still don't understand, I'll explain it in a different way, friend. I'm not being sarcastic, I mean that I understand that we may perceive each other as too far away from our respective paradigms - please help me out and see if you can see that there is some interesting intersection here. ...all that notwithstanding that Science will not open the door to ID without the kind of evidence you are talking about - that is the character of Science - we are out of scope of Science in this particular discussion, I concede (is that what you needed to hear from me?).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom