Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Chipmunk's non-telological statement: "the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce."
You had a problem with the term "survival strategy". I rephrased the term with that mouthful.

Did chipmunk mean: "[Natural Selection selects based upon] the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce." ?
No, I meant it as a rephrasing of the teleological-sounding term "survival strategy".

For expediency I attempted to help your quote be a complete sentence. Not having been able to think of anything better, I had added the stuff in brackets. Is my addition satisfactory?
For the sake of argument, let's use "Natural Selection selects based upon the relative likelihoods of reproduction among groups of organisms." In this context, where is the teleology in the word "select"? There is no intent, no goal. "Selection" in this context is a description of consequences of the interplay of relative likelihoods of reproduction--one organism survives where another does not. We could call it Natural Consequences of Relative Likelihoods of Reproduction if you like, but it just doesn't have the same ring. And most people don't have a problem understanding that the shorthand "Selection" doesn't imply conscious, intentional selection.
 
Oh, now I see - please understand that I am doing the same thing that I recognize everyone tends to do here: I say 'you' when I would do better to say 'one'. I am not speaking necessarily specifically to you when I say 'you' being that I recognize there is an audience. Take it as a broadcast. Please do not take it personally.

Your 'short hand' should be avoided if it always leads you to appear to attribute purpose when your creed is 'there is no purpose'.
Sure sounded like you were attributing that creed to me. My mistake, I guess.
 
He has been specific. He thinks programmers working somewhere outside the known laws of this simulation send viruses to earth on comets, viruses that carry genetic upgrades and are designed to find their way into specific genomes and install themselves. Or something. :cs:
You blended two things here. I don't mind - I'm not going to impune you for doing what you claim I do (you have repeatedly said I misquote you).

My proposition of our being in a simulation, with programmers having designed it, is one proposition. I have some evidence of simulation I have never seen anyone else produce and have only revealed this to a few scientists, none of whom scoffed as you seem to. Albeit, I had not added the ID ingredient yet at that time.

My second proposition was to go visit panspermia.org. Horizontal gene transfer is something that I have believed for decades. The panspermia guys are diverse, including Francis Crick being one (Crick flavor: directed panspermia). Panspermia.org is a flavor, and already appears to have its own dogma: no big-bang; genes have been here as long as atoms (forever). I did not say that I join this dogma but I can relate to why Crick doubted that genes evolved here. The genetic information, according to Crick is that they may have been intentionally projected here by some super-intelligent race.

I also mentioned that some people believe the designers are time-travellers. Our time-travelling progeny could be our own creators, according to some - I don't buy that either.

The only idea that I will claim is plausible to me today is designed simulation. Panspermia.org is interesting to me and more plausible to me than RM/NS being attributable to macro-evolution.

In a much earlier post, I tried to present the following:
1. Technology is increasing
2. Someday AI
3. AI smarter than humans
4. Bio-machine blends
5. Immortality
6. progression toward something that is god-like
7. god-like progeny create new universes in which unfold new 'life'
8. Unfolding from that 'new life' are intelligent creatures
9. In this new universe, the new intelligent creatures invent technology
10. Their technology increases.

Now, I ask you. Where are we? Are we at #1 or are we at #10? ..or some multiple interation thereof?

If simulation is inevitable, then P=1 at some t = T
If the domain t is infinite, then the probability of t>T approaches 1. So , it is almost certain we already have simulation.

This does not represent what I believe, it is only a way I can relate to the kinds of minds I presume frequent here, that it is plausible within your own paradigm that: we live in a designed simulation.
 
Last edited:
Naming disciplines of academia are only human fields of study: biology, chemistry, physics are only separate because of human limitations - human specialities. Nature doesn't care what we call it.
That's what I said.

Evolution is NOT biology.
Yes it is. In exactly the same way that biology is chemistry.

Nature doesn't care what we call it but they are not equal. Your identity Evolution=biology is not supported at all by fact. Again I reference the noted LACK of evolutionary explanation in 99% of biological studies.
You mean biochemistry, right? Because if you're talking biology, your claim is wrong rather than merely unsupported.

But that's the point. They don't need to refer to evolution, because they are not talking specifically about evolution. Your evidence is evidence only for the obvious fact that we compartmentalise scientific research. It remains that evolution is the theory that ties all of biology together into a single system.

I don't know what you mean but -evolution does not work at the atomic level means to me that RM/NS did not work in the "origin of atoms".
That again proves my point. You just don't know what you are talking about.

Evolution is atomic physics. And anthropology is quantum mechanics. Evolution necessarily does work at the atomic level, because if it didn't, it wouldn't work at all.

Which has nothing to do with the origin of atoms.
The scope of evolution is to living things and apparently only has credibility where there already existed huge volumes of DNA to begin work with. Evolution has NO theory about origin of DNA. Previous mumblings about clays are brief sentences of speculation. Self-catalyzing sets are mathematical models (Kauffman) and are not (yet?) part of the evolutionary theory.
No, because that's not what evolution is about.
 
Last edited:
You blended two things here. I don't mind - I'm not going to impune you for doing what you claim I do (you have repeatedly said I misquote you).
Except it was a paraphrase, not a quote. Important difference if you've ever gotten nailed for it when it counts.
 
How is it inefficient ? It allows us to do precisely what it was designed to do. It wasn't designed so much for speed and stability as it was for versatility. And that it is.
The memory management algorithms in XP are designed for machines with 16MB of memory. They suck for modern hardware. Off-topic, but I needed to say that.
 
I have some evidence of simulation I have never seen anyone else produce and have only revealed this to a few scientists, none of whom scoffed as you seem to.
What is this evidence?

My second proposition was to go visit panspermia.org. Horizontal gene transfer is something that I have believed for decades. The panspermia guys are diverse, including Francis Crick being one (Crick flavor: directed panspermia). Panspermia.org is a flavor, and already appears to have its own dogma: no big-bang; genes have been here as long as atoms (forever).
Well, if it claims that, it's wrong. The big bang is an straightforward deduction from atronomical observation. The universe has not been around forever.

The only idea that I will claim is plausible to me today is designed simulation. Panspermia.org is interesting to me and more plausible to me than RM/NS being attributable to macro-evolution.
But as has been pointed out, you have no understanding of evolution, and therefore no basis for reaching that conclusion.

If simulation is inevitable, then P=1 at some t = T
If the domain t is infinite, then the probability of t>T approaches 1. So , it is almost certain we already have simulation.

This does not represent what I believe, it is only a way I can relate to the kinds of minds I presume frequent here, that it is plausible within your own paradigm that: we live in a designed simulation.
This is no more plausible than pantheistic idealism or any such nonsense. No less plausible, but certainly no more plausible.

On the other hand, if you have actual evidence?
 
Except it was a paraphrase, not a quote. Important difference if you've ever gotten nailed for it when it counts.
I think I have a habit of putting things in quotes when I'm meaning to say "paraphrasing here: 'this is the paraphrase' ". I can see why one could think I was actually quoting the other person. I wasn't aware of that but I see now why it may have been irritating. Thanks for pointing it out. Probably a better convention would be to put my paraphrasing in brackets.
 
What is this evidence?

Well, if it claims that, it's wrong. The big bang is an straightforward deduction from atronomical observation. The universe has not been around forever.

On the other hand, if you have actual evidence?
I have what I think is evidence in that the premise predicts some observations. I have my own reasons why I do not want to reveal those here at this time.

Have you read in panspermia.org what evidence they have for big-bang is false? If you are interested, go look. I don't know enough about it to know how strong their case is. Admittedly I am biased against their case: designed simulation would predict a starting point - so their dogma is antithetical to designed simulation.
 
In a much earlier post, I tried to present the following:
1. Technology is increasing
2. Someday AI
3. AI smarter than humans
4. Bio-machine blends
5. Immortality
6. progression toward something that is god-like
7. god-like progeny create new universes in which unfold new 'life'
8. Unfolding from that 'new life' are intelligent creatures
9. In this new universe, the new intelligent creatures invent technology
10. Their technology increases.

Now, I ask you. Where are we? Are we at #1 or are we at #10? ..or some multiple interation thereof?
Let's say you're right, and we're at #1/#10 in the nth iteration of this cycle.

This then becomes a chicken and egg problem. You're stuck either with a pattern that stretches backwards (in a cause/effect chain, though not necessarily restricted by time) by infinity cycles, or with explaining how (if design is a fundamental necessity) the first cycle began.

If design is a fundamental necessity of intelligent life, explain the existence of the original designer.
 
Last edited:
I have what I think is evidence in that the premise predicts some observations.
That's not evidence. That's conjecture.

I have my own reasons why I do not want to reveal those here at this time.
Because we will point out that you don't, in fact, have any evidence?

Have you read in panspermia.org what evidence they have for big-bang is false? If you are interested, go look.
I'm not interested, but I looked anyway. As far as I can see, they don't have any evidence for anything, least of all that the big bang theory is false.

I don't know enough about it to know how strong their case is.
I do. It's rubbish.

Admittedly I am biased against their case: designed simulation would predict a starting point - so their dogma is antithetical to designed simulation.
No it wouldn't.
 
Last edited:
No, not your mistake. Admittedly, I was addressing you in a stereotypical way. So are you saying that you think there IS purpose?
No. I believe fairly strongly that there's a lack of evidence of purpose. I believe somewhat less strongly that there is in fact no ultimate purpose. I will always, though, keep my mind open a crack to be swayed in the other direction if actual evidence of purpose should be discovered.
 
Evolution is NOT biology. Nature doesn't care what we call it but they are not equal. Your identity Evolution=biology is not supported at all by fact. Again I reference the noted LACK of evolutionary explanation in 99% of biological studies.

Actually, the term "evolution" could be applied to MORE than just biology. In fact, it's even possible that the creation of the physical laws themselves followed a similar process during the universe's formation.
 
VonNeumann said:
I am commenting on what I understand some evolutionists interpretation is with regard to how large changes can happen. I can see why they think it is necessary. Every mutation that passes down may not add advantage at that time but may contribute later. So NS must be neutral toward some of the intermediate changes. Someone help me - does someone know what I'm referring to - this isn't MY stuff. I don't think I should be called to defend it.

Neutral isn't exactly the best term, here. Environmental pressures still exist even if the "intermediary" step doesn't change anything in the organism. However, it's hard to say what DID and what DIDN'T change anything in past lifeforms for which we have no genetic sample. In current lifeforms, however, we can see that much of the DNA is IN a transitional form, as much of it is either useless, duplicated or otherwise not strictly functional.

If when speaking of evolution, which is a priori non-teleological, you cannot cast it in terms of teleology (which I have not proven is true - merely what I think I keep observing), then I ask "why is that?" Perhaps you can now proceed to define the internal workings of function NS() without using teleological terms?[Disclaimer: "You" means "one" -not specifically chipmunk]

We simply don't have the time to invent new terms to define what we want to say. Just accept that we assume, and have evidence to the face that there is NO intelligence behind the universe. The terms we use are for clarity and expediency. So let's stop arguing semantics and continue our discussion, shall we ?


As far as your #1 to #10 example goes, it's possible, I guess, and I've thought about this before. However, the evidence we have points to a completely random cosmic formation, and it's likely that, if SOMEONE triggered this, there is no scientific way to know unless we could look beyond the universe. If this is true, your hypothesis would be non-falsifiable and therefore not very useful to our discussion.
 
Let's say you're right, and we're at #1/#10 in the nth iteration of this cycle.

This then becomes a chicken and egg problem. You're stuck either with a pattern that stretches backwards (in a cause/effect chain, though not necessarily restricted by time) by infinity cycles, or with explaining how (if design is a fundamental necessity) the first cycle began.

If design is a fundamental necessity of intelligent life, explain the existence of the original designer.
Evolution doesn't explain origin either, only "descent with modification".

I presented this scenario merely to prompt thought from those who have what I see as the mindset of so-called-skeptics.

Can you follow me on:
1. it is true that "skeptics" enjoy SF stories that entertain progression typified by #1 through say #8 or so, correct?
2. Beyond being SF story entertainment, it is in the minds of some that this is plausible?
If so, do you see that it might be interesting to me that those who proclaim non-existence of designers, do render plausibility in designers-just-not-yet? ...and so I point this out for your [not specifically chipmunk's] contemplation.

I'm just saying that simulation/ID is already in the plausibility domain in the paradigm of self-proclaimed skeptics - the argument is merely where we are on the time-line.

Please understand I was not presenting infinite loops of re-births as something I believe and therefore am not here to answer questions how that can be. Remember? ...it was only to make a point about mind-sets. You implied with your bouncy slobbering smilie that I was nuts [to paraphrase] and so I say it isn't any crazier than what some of you already find plausible. Gimme some feedback on if this post is or is not clear chipmunk. I've repeated this before and don't know if it is my explanation skills that are lacking, or it is denial, or what.
 
Last edited:
The lottery ticket that I have in my hand is 4663890014. The chance that I would have got exactly this ticket is minimal, but yet, there it is! However, this does not mean that the ticket is a winner.

More important to this discussion: if you happen to win, that's no indication that the lottery was created specifically for you to win.
 
Evolution doesn't explain origin either, only "descent with modification".
Correct.

I presented this scenario merely to prompt thought from those who have what I see as the mindset of so-called-skeptics.

Can you follow me on:
1. it is true that "skeptics" enjoy SF stories that entertain progression typified by #1 through say #8 or so, correct?
2. Beyond being SF story entertainment, it is in the minds of some that this is plausible?
If so, do you see that it might be interesting to me that those who proclaim non-existence of designers, do render plausibility in designers-just-not-yet? ...and so I point this out for your [not specifically chipmunk's] contemplation.

I'm just saying that simulation/ID is already in the plausibility domain in the paradigm of self-proclaimed skeptics - the argument is merely where we are on the time-line.

Please understand I was not presenting infinite loops of re-births as something I believe and therefore am not here to answer questions how that can be. Remember? ...it was only to make a point about mind-sets. You implied with your bouncy slobbering smilie that I was nuts [to paraphrase] and so I say it isn't any crazier than what some of you already find plausible. Gimme some feedback on if this post is or is not clear chipmunk. I've repeated this before and don't know if it is my explanation skills that are lacking, or it is denial, or what.
However plausible some might find the idea, there's still a lack of evidence. It's possible to accept that there may be evidence of some particular idea one day, but still reject the idea for the time being based on present lack of this evidence. Of course, I personally don't find the idea all that plausible, so maybe someone who does would be able to give a better answer.

The main problem that I see is that if you regard the existence of complex, intelligent lifeforms as evidence of design, then that means you regard design as necessary to the existence of complex, intelligent life. So under this assumption, if there was a lifeform complex and intelligent enough to design and implement other complex, intelligent lifeforms, then this designer also must have been designed, and so on ad infinitum.

This is why I believe that the default assumption must be lack of design, unless compelling evidence is discovered that points to design. And why I believe that our very existence doesn't count as evidence of design.

So to me it would seem somewhat more plausible that we're at #1/#10 on the nth iteration of a version of your re-birth loop scenario that has a definite first iteration than that we're at the same point on an infinite version. But since it's impossible to know (at least given the evidence on hand) if we're in this loop at all or where we are in it, then I have to assume (unless evidence suggesting otherwise arises) that if we're in it at all, then we're in the first iteration.

My take on any other somewhat plausible but impossible to prove scenarios would be similar.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom