Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Huh ? How does ANYTHING in biology make sense WITHOUT the idea of evolution ? If you say that macro-e doesn't exist because gunderscoredidit, then that's no answer at all.
Those statements mean to me that you seem irretrievably indoctrinated - just as you probably think I am so in an opposite way.

Again, you're assuming a number of things. You're assuming to know what I think. I'm not "overzealous". I'm not even "zealous". There is simply NO other explanation to evolution than darwinism as this time. If you think another theory fits the facts better or that darwinism is inadequate, then stop making vague claims or personnal attacks and be specific.
I don't see how it is a personal attack to make a collective reference to over-enthusiasm. I didn't say "John is overzealous".

Perhaps you'd care to make that experiment yourself.
I can imagine dropping sand through a template and would expect to see the shape of the template in the pile of sand. So why should I get all dirty and go to the trouble of running the experiment. this is equivalent to what his morphs are. I find Dawkins' programs, particularly "methinks it is a weasle" to be not astonishing, and I find that they obviously illustrate just the opposite of what he purports. They do not illustrate RM/NS, at best they illustrate RM/artificial selection. RM/AS is Intelligent Design by definition.

Let's stick to the point, shall we: biological organisms are extremely inneficient. Several points of designs lead us to conclude that, if there IS a designer, he doesn't know what he's doing.
Windows XP is designed, is inefficient, and makes $100Ms for Microsoft. It is inefficient, viable, profitable - YET DESIGNED. The whole interpretation of efficiency having anything to do with being a criterion for design is a non sequitir. I agree with you that the Designer is not Santy Clauss, though:rolleyes: .

Unfortunately that's YOUR theory indeed. Who the hell thinks that selection becomes neutral at ANY point in time ?
I guess I'll have to go find it for you. Its an evolutionary idea, and I understand why it was conjured - not my idea, though.


Let's not talk about atoms, shall we ? There's no evidence whatsoever that they are efficient or not, so there's no argument to be made there. However, I did read yesterday that, if my weight was converted into pure energy instantly, I could wipe out all forms of life on earth (1500 megatons, if I calculated properly.) To me, this makes fusion immensely inefficient. Again pointing to an incompetent designer. Can't even get his physical laws right.
I think you would have done better to follow your own advice "let's not talk about atoms..". Its obvious why you are uncomfortable with the premise of this thread. If you don't want to talk about this thread - why are you here? ..and yet you couldn't help yourself to make this nonsense about turning yourself into a fusion bomb. What laws are not right?
 
Let me get this straight. You believe that members of a species, over millions of years, may devellop into new species, but you don't think this can accumulate into huge differences over even longer time periods ? What's stopping it from doing so ?
Information theory.
 
Hmmm...do you think that Behe´s opinion on that should be taken as authoritative at face value? I suspect Behe does not read as much as he ought to (maybe he doesn´t have time?), especially for a scientist that uses the argument from personal incredulity as much as he does. By all means, have a look here and judge for yourself.
Yeh, I read that before. Behe would never be a good lawyer or politician. Good for him. But rather than point to credential, how many papers he wrote,etc, what about the point he made that I made reference to?

Except specifically in the evolution journals, why do not explanations of biochemical function and process include evolution? Or why is inclusion of evolution RARE in the explanations? Is it because evolution is not REALLY the guiding underpinning of understanding biology? You didn't say Behe was wrong about that.
 
Yeah, and if it doesn't work at the atomic level, what kind of theory is that?
Surely, if it worked at the biochemistry level, it would be a good theory. But the biochemistry specialists are silent on evolution when the write their papers and books. Atomic level? I thought it was repeatedly stated here by skeptics that pre-bio is out of scope for evolution. Didn't you know that chipmunk?
 
Let us say there is some protein that is a presumed pre-cursor to another protein. Let us say that there are minimally 256 bits of changes that have to be made along the path to the target. The synthesis of the target is presumed to take N steps, in 'evolving' from the precursor to the target protein. N could be 256 steps, one bit at a time; N could be one step, in one miraculous move; N could be more than 256 steps because of a circuitous path with meandering inefficient scrambling. I would think that the best approach to a credible proposition is that N is somewhere between 1 and say, 16. Each of these steps would have to be intermediate forms, defined by: they each provide useful function to the organism.
No. They merely have to be not invariably lethal.

If N=1 then the 256 bit change is one out of 10^77. That's why I called that a miracle.
That's because you have no understanding of evolution. Or rather, because you have an anti-understanding.

There is no set goal. Genetic changes happen. If they don't kill your offspring or render them sterile, they may propagate. And you end up with something different from what you started with.

If you make 256 one-bit changes to a particular protein coding, you will almost certainly end up with a different protein. The likelhood for this is 10^77 - 1 out of 10^77, or effectively, 1.

A 16 bit change is a manageable one out of ~10^5. What stretches my credulity is that there could be found 16 intermediate steps that could happen 'just so'. This is such an immense problem to prove. In the environment it is reasonable to say that most the intermediate proteins are gone or they are too hard to find. The amount of computation that would be required to 'find' intermediate proteins that fit the criteria would exceed what could be done in the lifetime of the universe, much less the lifetime of a human. So we can only wave our hands and say 'it could happen', or we must doubt. I doubt.
It's not a problem at all. It is, rather, unavoidable.

Why I get as you say 'so hung up': If there is no teleology to evolution, which is a priori to the theory (agree?), then why cannot an evolution-enthusiast express anything without teleological terms.
We do.
 
Surely, if it worked at the biochemistry level, it would be a good theory. But the biochemistry specialists are silent on evolution when the write their papers and books. Atomic level? I thought it was repeatedly stated here by skeptics that pre-bio is out of scope for evolution. Didn't you know that chipmunk?
Do you have no understanding at all of any field of science?

Evolution is biology is chemistry is physics. It's just a matter of the most useful level of abstraction for understanding a particular problem.

Evolution does work at the atomic level. Otherwise it wouldn't work at all.
 
Let us say there is some protein that is a presumed pre-cursor to another protein. Let us say that there are minimally 256 bits of changes that have to be made along the path to the target. The synthesis of the target is presumed to take N steps, in 'evolving' from the precursor to the target protein. N could be 256 steps, one bit at a time; N could be one step, in one miraculous move; N could be more than 256 steps because of a circuitous path with meandering inefficient scrambling.

Still, every form is an intermediate form. There is no "end" result. This is just an after-the-fact assumption.

In presenting above the changes to the pre-cursor molecule in steps toward the target model, do you not agree that some steps could be 'innocuous' but yield no extra function, and so that step is neutrally affected by NS because the yield provides no advantage at that step (but may in the future?)?

Hard to say without precise examples, but it's possible that some of the changes do NOT yield any result while some do. This doesn't prove your point.
 
Those statements mean to me that you seem irretrievably indoctrinated - just as you probably think I am so in an opposite way.

As I said, if you think another theory fits the facts better or that darwinism is inadequate, then stop making vague claims or personnal attacks and be specific.

Windows XP is designed, is inefficient, and makes $100Ms for Microsoft. It is inefficient, viable, profitable - YET DESIGNED. The whole interpretation of efficiency having anything to do with being a criterion for design is a non sequitir. I agree with you that the Designer is not Santy Clauss, though:rolleyes: .

How is it inefficient ? It allows us to do precisely what it was designed to do. It wasn't designed so much for speed and stability as it was for versatility. And that it is.

I guess I'll have to go find it for you. Its an evolutionary idea, and I understand why it was conjured - not my idea, though.

Still waiting.

I think you would have done better to follow your own advice "let's not talk about atoms..". Its obvious why you are uncomfortable with the premise of this thread. If you don't want to talk about this thread - why are you here? ..and yet you couldn't help yourself to make this nonsense about turning yourself into a fusion bomb. What laws are not right?

You're the one who asked about the carbon atom beign badly designed or not. I'm simply pointing out that the nuclear fusion process is inneficient compared to, not the fusion bomb, as you clearly didn't understand my post, but a total energy conversion, however THAT might be done. I'm saying that stars are inneficient and AGAIN this points to an incompetent designer. Your Microsoft example is inadequate, because Bill Gates did NOT create the LAWS OF PHYSICS themselves.
 
It is like an unsolved murder. We don't know 'who dunnit'. The cops have a perp captured who I don't think did it. You are the detective who thinks he DID do it. We both look at the same evidence but we interpret it differently.
I think it's more like an apparent heart-attack victim, and I'm the detective who can find no evidence to rule it a homicide, while you're the crazy conspiracy theorist who thinks the president had something to do with it.

I agree that small variations on pre-cursors can happen - probably do sometimes, here and there. I do not think RM/NS can happen on a small number of nucleotides at a time leading up to a long nucleotide sequence change. For me, the incredulity springs from doing a little arithmetic on the amount of possible permutations of a small sequence. I did this for myself years ago. In order to pick a sufficiently small sequence to make the amount of permutations small enough that it is credible that most of the combinations of these sequences readily occur with random mutation, those size sequences are very short. On the other extreme, picking the size of sequences such that it is more credible that they are long enough to code for something differentiable, they are so long that there is not enough time for a significant fraction of the combinations to have had a chance. It is like looking for "Leave it to Beaver" in a random sequence.


Let us say there is some protein that is a presumed pre-cursor to another protein. Let us say that there are minimally 256 bits of changes that have to be made along the path to the target. The synthesis of the target is presumed to take N steps, in 'evolving' from the precursor to the target protein. N could be 256 steps, one bit at a time; N could be one step, in one miraculous move; N could be more than 256 steps because of a circuitous path with meandering inefficient scrambling. I would think that the best approach to a credible proposition is that N is somewhere between 1 and say, 16. Each of these steps would have to be intermediate forms, defined by: they each provide useful function to the organism. So if one can theorize such a path, of on average 16 bits change at a time, each time producing a useful function and not losing the needed function that the pre-cursor provided, and do it 16 times, then that would be a model that could show how intermediate forms work in such an example.

If N=1 then the 256 bit change is one out of 10^77. That's why I called that a miracle. A 16 bit change is a manageable one out of ~10^5. What stretches my credulity is that there could be found 16 intermediate steps that could happen 'just so'. This is such an immense problem to prove. In the environment it is reasonable to say that most the intermediate proteins are gone or they are too hard to find. The amount of computation that would be required to 'find' intermediate proteins that fit the criteria would exceed what could be done in the lifetime of the universe, much less the lifetime of a human. So we can only wave our hands and say 'it could happen', or we must doubt. I doubt.
It's only a miracle if there's a target already in mind, if humanity was inevitable for instance. Now I see why you get hung up on teleological-sounding language used by evolutionists.



In presenting above the changes to the pre-cursor molecule in steps toward the target model, do you not agree that some steps could be 'innocuous' but yield no extra function, and so that step is neutrally affected by NS because the yield provides no advantage at that step (but may in the future?)?
Sure, it seems possible. But why would you assume that it's a necessary condition of "macro" change.


Why I get as you say 'so hung up': If there is no teleology to evolution, which is a priori to the theory (agree?), then why cannot an evolution-enthusiast express anything without teleological terms.
(Where is the teleological term in "the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce"?)

If it is mere anthropomorphizing, then challenge yourself to re-state without such terms. Can you do it? If you cannot, my point is that maybe you are blind to the notion that you, on some other level of thinking, DO attribute purpose. Here in this forum of skeptics, is it not heresy to attribute purpose? Your 'short hand' should be avoided if it always leads you to appear to attribute purpose when your creed is 'there is no purpose'.
(I thought I asked you not to misquote me.)

I think the best you can do is just say: that the mechanism of evolution appears teleological but it is not. The reason it is not is because we believe it is not. Disclaimer: any terms we use that imply purpose are merely shorthand and it is not intended to attribute 'purpose' to how evolution works.

Translation: it is impossible for us to describe what we believe without using words that represent what we do NOT believe.

Again, I'm pointing out "cognitive dissonance".
Just yesterday, I told a coworker: "My car didn't want to start this morning." Are you suggesting that this was some sort of Freudian slip, that somewhere deep in my subconscious I actually believe that my car is sentient and makes decisions, if I would only admit it to myself?

In everyday conversation we use purpose-driven language all the time. It's easy to insert into just about any topic because it comes naturally and it's easy to relate to. You seem to be the only person I've ever met who takes it literally, even when it's been clearly stated that it's not meant literally.

This zealous evolutionist who is determined to prove that life has no purpose and yet finds it impossible to express ideas about evolution without resorting to teleological language because deep down he believes that there is conscious intent behind life is a fantasy.
 
As I said, if you think another theory fits the facts better or that darwinism is inadequate, then stop making vague claims or personnal attacks and be specific.
He has been specific. He thinks programmers working somewhere outside the known laws of this simulation send viruses to earth on comets, viruses that carry genetic upgrades and are designed to find their way into specific genomes and install themselves. Or something. :cs:
 
But historically, I think it was the result of the Human Genome Project that presented the greatest exception - the quantity of genes was not predicted by the dogma.


Big deal. The Steelers' recent victory in the SuperBowl was not predicted by the central dogma, either. That doesn't invalidate either the Steelers' victor or the dogma, since the dogma is silent on the issue.

The dogma is similarly silent on the issue of how many genes humans -- or any given organism -- are supposed to have.
 
Recently it was discovered some genes produce huge amounts of proteins - I'm pretty sure I read 10,000s!

You read wrongly.

Parametric changes are easy for me to accept. the New Information i have a problem with is the code inside the loop, metaphorically. I should say 'sizeable new information' I doubt can be formed using the RM/NS model. If it worked, we would already be using it in digital simulation. Problem is that the NS component in such digital models is still really artificial selection (AS), so it isn't the same. Nevertheless, RM/AS makes an interesting tool for research.

How about doubling the amount of chromosomes in a single generation? That's been observed in plants. A single-generational jump to a new species, capable of reproducing with its own generation but not plants of its parents generation.

If that's not "sizeable new information", I don't know what is.

Also, it doesn't have to be a single large jump. What process stops the small changes from continuing to grow? That's what you haven't explained. There's no reason for the small changes not to continue to occur, and add up to something larger. Look up ring species, seriously. Ring species giove an excellent example of how small changes can add up without discontinuity. If you don't know, a ring species is where there are several different populations spread out geographically. Each population can interbreed with the populations near it. However, the populations say, on the two ends, can't interbreed. This can occur in time as well as geography, a species makes small changes, and those add up to a completely new species.
 
How about doubling the amount of chromosomes in a single generation? That's been observed in plants. A single-generational jump to a new species, capable of reproducing with its own generation but not plants of its parents generation.

If that's not "sizeable new information", I don't know what is.

Ooh, ooh. Can you tell me what species that was ? That's a very tasty bit of information, right there.
 
Belz:

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html#part5

Several listed, most involving hybridization, and most sterile, but at least one (maidenhair fern) produced 2N spores, which grew without fertilization(the genes didn't seperate in the spores). These plants then produced 4N offspring.

Check under section 5.2 for some speciation in plants that don't involve hybrids or polyploidization. They list some animal speciations as well.

In short, we've observed speciation under all the currently accepted definitions of speciation.
 
Belz:

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html#part5

Several listed, most involving hybridization, and most sterile, but at least one (maidenhair fern) produced 2N spores, which grew without fertilization(the genes didn't seperate in the spores). These plants then produced 4N offspring.

Check under section 5.2 for some speciation in plants that don't involve hybrids or polyploidization. They list some animal speciations as well.

In short, we've observed speciation under all the currently accepted definitions of speciation.

HA! Take THAT, creationists!
 
Recently it was discovered some genes produce huge amounts of proteins - I'm pretty sure I read 10,000s!

Please cite your source. I'd certainly be interested in reading such a paper. And if you cited your sources, it would give your argument more weight.
 
Do you have no understanding at all of any field of science?

Evolution is biology is chemistry is physics. It's just a matter of the most useful level of abstraction for understanding a particular problem.

Evolution does work at the atomic level. Otherwise it wouldn't work at all.
Naming disciplines of academia are only human fields of study: biology, chemistry, physics are only separate because of human limitations - human specialities. Nature doesn't care what we call it.

Evolution is NOT biology. Nature doesn't care what we call it but they are not equal. Your identity Evolution=biology is not supported at all by fact. Again I reference the noted LACK of evolutionary explanation in 99% of biological studies.

I don't know what you mean but -evolution does not work at the atomic level means to me that RM/NS did not work in the "origin of atoms". The scope of evolution is to living things and apparently only has credibility where there already existed huge volumes of DNA to begin work with. Evolution has NO theory about origin of DNA. Previous mumblings about clays are brief sentences of speculation. Self-catalyzing sets are mathematical models (Kauffman) and are not (yet?) part of the evolutionary theory.
 
(I thought I asked you not to misquote me.) .
Oh, now I see - please understand that I am doing the same thing that I recognize everyone tends to do here: I say 'you' when I would do better to say 'one'. I am not speaking necessarily specifically to you when I say 'you' being that I recognize there is an audience. Take it as a broadcast. Please do not take it personally.

Sure, it seems possible. But why would you assume that it's a necessary condition of "macro" change..
I am commenting on what I understand some evolutionists interpretation is with regard to how large changes can happen. I can see why they think it is necessary. Every mutation that passes down may not add advantage at that time but may contribute later. So NS must be neutral toward some of the intermediate changes. Someone help me - does someone know what I'm referring to - this isn't MY stuff. I don't think I should be called to defend it.

(Where is the teleological term in "the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce"?).
Chipmunk's non-telological statement: "the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce."

Did chipmunk mean: "[Natural Selection selects based upon] the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce." ?

For expediency I attempted to help your quote be a complete sentence. Not having been able to think of anything better, I had added the stuff in brackets. Is my addition satisfactory?

Does this say that NS is a sort of transfer function where, given inputs that represent the characteristics of the organism expressed by a given genome, the output function is to either delete that genome [through attrition] or sustain it [through reproduction]?

OK, that is a good start - an introduction. Now explain the internal workings of this function without being teleological nor anthropomorphic.

Just yesterday, I told a coworker: "My car didn't want to start this morning." Are you suggesting that this was some sort of Freudian slip, that somewhere deep in my subconscious I actually believe that my car is sentient and makes decisions, if I would only admit it to myself?

In everyday conversation we use purpose-driven language all the time. It's easy to insert into just about any topic because it comes naturally and it's easy to relate to. You seem to be the only person I've ever met who takes it literally, even when it's been clearly stated that it's not meant literally.
Of course. Anthropomorphism with your car not "wanting" is fine and could have been stated another way easily ("my car did not start"). But trying to describe how natural selection works without teleology, some of which is anthropomorphic, is where I am taking notice. I think that it is due to a lack of non-teleological terms that still say what you think you want to say. [Disclaimer: "You" means "one" -not specifically chipmunk]

If when speaking of evolution, which is a priori non-teleological, you cannot cast it in terms of teleology (which I have not proven is true - merely what I think I keep observing), then I ask "why is that?" Perhaps you can now proceed to define the internal workings of function NS() without using teleological terms?[Disclaimer: "You" means "one" -not specifically chipmunk]
 
Last edited:
Please cite your source. I'd certainly be interested in reading such a paper. And if you cited your sources, it would give your argument more weight.
I cannot cite my source right now because I can't remember where I read it. However, I quick search on the web produced this:

http://cmgm.stanford.edu/biochem118/Projects/2001/renteria.pdf#search='one%20gene%20thousands%20of%20proteins'

I don't know what credibility this paper has and I have not read it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom