(I thought I asked you not to misquote me.) .
Oh, now I see - please understand that I am doing the same thing that I recognize everyone tends to do here: I say 'you' when I would do better to say 'one'. I am not speaking necessarily specifically to you when I say 'you' being that I recognize there is an audience. Take it as a broadcast. Please do not take it personally.
Sure, it seems possible. But why would you assume that it's a necessary condition of "macro" change..
I am commenting on what I understand some evolutionists interpretation is with regard to how large changes can happen. I can see why they think it is necessary. Every mutation that passes down may not add advantage at that time but may contribute later. So NS must be neutral toward some of the intermediate changes. Someone help me - does someone know what I'm referring to - this isn't MY stuff. I don't think I should be called to defend it.
(Where is the teleological term in "the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce"?).
Chipmunk's non-telological statement: "the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce."
Did chipmunk mean: "[Natural Selection selects based upon] the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce." ?
For expediency I attempted to help your quote be a complete sentence. Not having been able to think of anything better, I had added the stuff in brackets. Is my addition satisfactory?
Does this say that NS is a sort of transfer function where, given inputs that represent the characteristics of the organism expressed by a given genome, the output function is to either delete that genome [through attrition] or sustain it [through reproduction]?
OK, that is a good start - an introduction. Now explain the internal workings of this function without being teleological nor anthropomorphic.
Just yesterday, I told a coworker: "My car didn't want to start this morning." Are you suggesting that this was some sort of Freudian slip, that somewhere deep in my subconscious I actually believe that my car is sentient and makes decisions, if I would only admit it to myself?
In everyday conversation we use purpose-driven language all the time. It's easy to insert into just about any topic because it comes naturally and it's easy to relate to. You seem to be the only person I've ever met who takes it literally, even when it's been clearly stated that it's not meant literally.
Of course. Anthropomorphism with your car not "wanting" is fine and could have been stated another way easily ("my car did not start"). But trying to describe how natural selection works without teleology, some of which is anthropomorphic, is where I am taking notice. I think that it is due to a lack of non-teleological terms that still say what you think you want to say. [Disclaimer: "You" means "one" -not specifically chipmunk]
If when speaking of evolution, which is
a priori non-teleological, you cannot cast it in terms of teleology (which I have not proven is true - merely what I think I keep observing), then I ask "why is that?" Perhaps you can now proceed to define the internal workings of
function NS() without using teleological terms?[Disclaimer: "You" means "one" -not specifically chipmunk]