Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I think Michael Behe made a very good point - he being a micro-biologist:
Wrong there, Behe is not a microbiologist despite his use of the flagellum as an example of "irreproducible complexity". Behe is a biochemist, having worked mainly on protein and nucleic acid structure.
 
Oh, and VonNeumann:
More information does not mean adding to the genome. Again, you show a lack of understanding of the subject you pontificate about. The human genome contains about 25,000 genes. Corn contain 40,000. You'd be hard-pressed to prove corn more complex than humans, yet it has 60% more genes than humans do. So, how do you explain a lesser number of genes leading to a more complex organism that creates more and varied protiens?

P.S.-I know the answer, do you?
I have already talked about that a little in earlier posts I thought (or maybe that was on another forum?). The general answer is that one gene does not code for just one protein. One gene can actually code for 10,000s proteins. Is that what you were looking for?

Now, how does it do this? Mostly by direct transcription? ...or mostly by proteins manufacturing other proteins?
 
Wrong there, Behe is not a microbiologist despite his use of the flagellum as an example of "irreproducible complexity". Behe is a biochemist, having worked mainly on protein and nucleic acid structure.
Yeh, I was afraid I should have said biochemist when I was typing it but I was too lazy to go look. Have you observed what Behe said about the term 'evolution' mysteriously lacking in biological works?
 
Number 1 is a start. "Significantly sizeable" could be determined in some pragmatic but otherwise arbitrary way that would give us a workable distinction between macro- and micro-ev, if it would serve a purpose to classify things that way. Not unlike "species", "genus", etc.

Number 2 is a ridiculous assumption.

Why would the physical precursors of chlorophyll necessarily be required to also carry precursors to the light-to-energy conversion attribute of chlorophyll? As you suggest, it's a perfectly reasonable scenario to imagine that there may already have been a similar molecule for some other purpose, changed by a micro-ev process. Re-use appears to be a common "strategy" in evolution.

Talk about simplistic thinking. This assumes that new complex structures are built piece-by-piece and that the intermediate steps confer no advantage. But we see numerous examples, and can imagine countless others, where complexity arises out of iterative refinement of an initially simple advantage (sight is a good example), where simple but highly specialized "irreducible" forms arise out of more complex "scaffolded" structures, where small-advantage or "neutral" features become critical when environment changes, and where small changes give new meaning to a structure and send it off on a new evolutionary tangent. I think you should reevaluate whose thinking is inside the box.

Lets see... if the eye is a good example of intermediate steps, lets talk about the intermediate steps to produce a rod or a cone. The complexity of a retinal neuron is so much more than the simple and tired old macro models of the eye. This isn't 1859 anymore where all we could do is talk about 'light collimator/ lens" and "light sensitive spot".

I get the idea of scaffolding and re-use. One of the wonderful things if you are defending evolution is that you can always say that intermediate forms are 'long gone' just as would be predicted. So tell me how re-use of some other molecule could be used for photosynthesis. Do you have something in mind, or just "it could happen."?

That natural selection must be neutral for macro evolution IS a ridiculous idea. Of course, remember i believe micro-e - no prob. It is macro-e I have a prob with. One problem is the "neutral" problem. That's not MY ridiculous theory. See, you think macro-e is ridiculous, too.:jaw-dropp

Also, it seems you think evolution has a 'strategy'?:eek:
 
I'm not sure we were referring to atoms, but to structures and processes in the universe that are inherently inneficient or flawed.
Look. It takes atoms to make life. It takes laws to make atoms. Maybe you see flaws where the complexity is immense, but can't you see the perfection at the more granular level?

The reason you would not refer to atoms is because, as the thread started, it is where it is harder to argue against design.
 
Huh ? Isn't that exactly what evolution is about ?
Yes and no. It is a trick, intentioned or not. See, you think that because I believe a transcription error can result in another species (like my elephant example), that that's evolution and so I believe in evolution. True, if that's all it is. That's exactly what it is about but that is not ALL that it is. The rest of the story is that repeating that example enough times and maybe you can get chess playing elephants... or whales. That part is also evolution, and that part I do not buy.

I no longer find it convincing that a bunch of little random changes, edited by the deletions by natural selection, can build up kilobytes of new information within the time constraint we know is there.

If you get away from giraffe necks, faster gazelles, better eye macro structures, when talking about evolution, and stay strictly with the biochemistry, its hard as hell to talk about biochemistry in an evolutionary context. M. Behe made that point. But if it doesn't work at the biochemistry level - what kind of theory is that?
 
Yeh, I was afraid I should have said biochemist when I was typing it but I was too lazy to go look. Have you observed what Behe said about the term 'evolution' mysteriously lacking in biological works?
Hmmm...do you think that Behe´s opinion on that should be taken as authoritative at face value? I suspect Behe does not read as much as he ought to (maybe he doesn´t have time?), especially for a scientist that uses the argument from personal incredulity as much as he does. By all means, have a look here and judge for yourself.
 
I no longer find it convincing that a bunch of little random changes, edited by the deletions by natural selection, can build up kilobytes of new information within the time constraint we know is there.
We know you think this. We want to know why.

If you get away from giraffe necks, faster gazelles, better eye macro structures, when talking about evolution, and stay strictly with the biochemistry, its hard as hell to talk about biochemistry in an evolutionary context.
No it isn't.

M. Behe made that point. But if it doesn't work at the biochemistry level - what kind of theory is that?
One that Behe doesn't understand.
 
Lets see... if the eye is a good example of intermediate steps, lets talk about the intermediate steps to produce a rod or a cone. The complexity of a retinal neuron is so much more than the simple and tired old macro models of the eye. This isn't 1859 anymore where all we could do is talk about 'light collimator/ lens" and "light sensitive spot".
I don't know where rods and cones come from. But what's more likely: They're specialized from variations on precursor cells, or they came with full instructions delivered by a virus attached to a comet, originating somewhere outside of the known laws of the universe?

I get the idea of scaffolding and re-use. One of the wonderful things if you are defending evolution is that you can always say that intermediate forms are 'long gone' just as would be predicted. So tell me how re-use of some other molecule could be used for photosynthesis. Do you have something in mind, or just "it could happen."?
In your view, is there a difference between an intermediate form and a not-intermediate form?

I'm not sure I understand your question about re-use and photosynthesis. The point I was driving at was that it's entirely possible that an organism was producing a molecule similar to chlorophyl that did something other than photosynthesis, and at some point its progeny accidentally started producing chlorophyl instead, which gave it an immediate advantage. It could happen.

That natural selection must be neutral for macro evolution IS a ridiculous idea. Of course, remember i believe micro-e - no prob. It is macro-e I have a prob with. One problem is the "neutral" problem. That's not MY ridiculous theory. See, you think macro-e is ridiculous, too.
There is no "neutral" problem.

Also, it seems you think evolution has a 'strategy'?
Don't misquote me. I said "re-use appears to be a common 'strategy' in evolution." I don't know why you get so hung up on this. We talk about survival "strategies" as short-hand for the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce.
 
Last edited:
VonNeumann said:
I think if one claims to be a skeptic, one should remain skeptical, but more 'omni-directionally'. I am a skeptic, but more globally, I think than what I've seen here. But I see that you so-called-skeptics have a strong bias toward evolution and do not exercise much skepticism there 'because its all we have' (which I think I saw one of you or two post - and that is an honest answer).

You're not beign skeptical, Von. You're been close-minded.

There are constant claims that evolution is the guiding light in understanding biology. OK. BUT, go look in biological journals and texts and try to find where the paradigm has actually helped discover how a mechanism works. I haven't read that many biological texts myself. Of course, we aren't talking about general texts for biology 101, but more specific works. I do remember reading a book called "Gene Expression" in the 70s. Being an evolutionist at the time, I remember searching through the book and seeing that there was no mention of evolution in the whole text, to help explain how it was a guiding light.

Huh ? How does ANYTHING in biology make sense WITHOUT the idea of evolution ? If you say that macro-e doesn't exist because gunderscoredidit, then that's no answer at all.

As I have mentioned twice before now, the Central Dogma of DNA is an example of where evolution was a guiding light. THe guiding light led biologists for 40 years with the WRONG assumptions and it took 40 years to find that the Central Dogma was FALSE.

Could you elaborate on that. Some of us don't know what you're talking about.

Many of you think of yourselves as some kinds of protectors of science, but science needs to be protected by this kind of 'wishful thinking' spawned by overzealousness toward darwinism.

Again, you're assuming a number of things. You're assuming to know what I think. I'm not "overzealous". I'm not even "zealous". There is simply NO other explanation to evolution than darwinism as this time. If you think another theory fits the facts better or that darwinism is inadequate, then stop making vague claims or personnal attacks and be specific.

I'm speaking of Dawkins and his computer generated something-morphs - what did he call them? JJEEEEZ! How stupid does he think his readers are that his silly program represents how evolution works?

Perhaps you'd care to make that experiment yourself.

VonNeumann said:
Yes, that is a somewhat accurate assertion. Not that I have "no idea", I DO have an idea. My idea is that the paleoanthropologists are "all to eager to shoehorn [evolutionary] conclusions onto the evidence, no matter how badly it fits."

Then perhaps you'd care to watch their reaction when they notice something that goes against what they initially thought.

You mocked the idea of intelligent design DF and called it incompetent design. So, this implies you think that if there exists a designer, she is incompetent - right? Then if there exists a designer, and she is incompetent, then she did very well with her physical laws that they could form gigantic furnaces that could forge, through a few billion years, such things as carbon, oxygen, nitrogen etc., each atom identical to the next within an accuracy of at worst 1 part in 10^40.

Let's stick to the point, shall we: biological organisms are extremely inneficient. Several points of designs lead us to conclude that, if there IS a designer, he doesn't know what he's doing.

VonNeumann said:
I get the idea of scaffolding and re-use. One of the wonderful things if you are defending evolution is that you can always say that intermediate forms are 'long gone' just as would be predicted. So tell me how re-use of some other molecule could be used for photosynthesis. Do you have something in mind, or just "it could happen."?

If you had read what some people posted on this topic before, you'd already have your answer. Go back a page or two.

That natural selection must be neutral for macro evolution IS a ridiculous idea. Of course, remember i believe micro-e - no prob. It is macro-e I have a prob with. One problem is the "neutral" problem. That's not MY ridiculous theory. See, you think macro-e is ridiculous, too.:jaw-dropp

Unfortunately that's YOUR theory indeed. Who the hell thinks that selection becomes neutral at ANY point in time ?

VonNeumann said:
The reason you would not refer to atoms is because, as the thread started, it is where it is harder to argue against design.

Let's not talk about atoms, shall we ? There's no evidence whatsoever that they are efficient or not, so there's no argument to be made there. However, I did read yesterday that, if my weight was converted into pure energy instantly, I could wipe out all forms of life on earth (1500 megatons, if I calculated properly.) To me, this makes fusion immensely inefficient. Again pointing to an incompetent designer. Can't even get his physical laws right.
 
I have already talked about that a little in earlier posts I thought (or maybe that was on another forum?). The general answer is that one gene does not code for just one protein. One gene can actually code for 10,000s proteins. Is that what you were looking for?

Now, how does it do this? Mostly by direct transcription? ...or mostly by proteins manufacturing other proteins?

Actrually, I pointed this out earlier.

But no, we know of NO single gene that codes for 10,000 protiens. However, many can code for two, or three, or as many as seven.

This is not, however, done by "protiens creating protiens", although there are sometimes chemicals made to control, protien folding (as others have stated). It's done by parts of the DNA remaining zipped, so that certain base pairs are "skipped over", or by part of the DNA looping around to insert an extra few base pairs between others.

In any case, this is neither here nor there. But it is an example of how a simple, random change (one base pair not unzipping, or a looping during DNA transcription) can create new information in the form of new proteins. In other words, the argument that "random mutation can't create new information", which you posited earlier, is completely unfounded.
 
There is no "neutral" problem.
...in fact, doesn't it make sense that the rate of evolutionary modification would increase in rough proportion to increasing selection pressures; quite contradictory to what you suggest? "Micro-ev" examples suggest that this is true (artificial selection is an amped-up selection pressure, for example).

It would seem that the bigger the change, the less neutral the selection pressures.
 
Von said:
As I have mentioned twice before now, the Central Dogma of DNA is an example of where evolution was a guiding light. THe guiding light led biologists for 40 years with the WRONG assumptions and it took 40 years to find that the Central Dogma was FALSE.
Do you mean that it took 40 years to find an exception to the central dogma? Are you referring to prions?

~~ Paul
 
I don't know where rods and cones come from. But what's more likely: They're specialized from variations on precursor cells, or they came with full instructions delivered by a virus attached to a comet, originating somewhere outside of the known laws of the universe?
It is like an unsolved murder. We don't know 'who dunnit'. The cops have a perp captured who I don't think did it. You are the detective who thinks he DID do it. We both look at the same evidence but we interpret it differently.

I agree that small variations on pre-cursors can happen - probably do sometimes, here and there. I do not think RM/NS can happen on a small number of nucleotides at a time leading up to a long nucleotide sequence change. For me, the incredulity springs from doing a little arithmetic on the amount of possible permutations of a small sequence. I did this for myself years ago. In order to pick a sufficiently small sequence to make the amount of permutations small enough that it is credible that most of the combinations of these sequences readily occur with random mutation, those size sequences are very short. On the other extreme, picking the size of sequences such that it is more credible that they are long enough to code for something differentiable, they are so long that there is not enough time for a significant fraction of the combinations to have had a chance. It is like looking for "Leave it to Beaver" in a random sequence.

In your view, is there a difference between an intermediate form and a not-intermediate form?
Let us say there is some protein that is a presumed pre-cursor to another protein. Let us say that there are minimally 256 bits of changes that have to be made along the path to the target. The synthesis of the target is presumed to take N steps, in 'evolving' from the precursor to the target protein. N could be 256 steps, one bit at a time; N could be one step, in one miraculous move; N could be more than 256 steps because of a circuitous path with meandering inefficient scrambling. I would think that the best approach to a credible proposition is that N is somewhere between 1 and say, 16. Each of these steps would have to be intermediate forms, defined by: they each provide useful function to the organism. So if one can theorize such a path, of on average 16 bits change at a time, each time producing a useful function and not losing the needed function that the pre-cursor provided, and do it 16 times, then that would be a model that could show how intermediate forms work in such an example.

If N=1 then the 256 bit change is one out of 10^77. That's why I called that a miracle. A 16 bit change is a manageable one out of ~10^5. What stretches my credulity is that there could be found 16 intermediate steps that could happen 'just so'. This is such an immense problem to prove. In the environment it is reasonable to say that most the intermediate proteins are gone or they are too hard to find. The amount of computation that would be required to 'find' intermediate proteins that fit the criteria would exceed what could be done in the lifetime of the universe, much less the lifetime of a human. So we can only wave our hands and say 'it could happen', or we must doubt. I doubt.


There is no "neutral" problem.
In presenting above the changes to the pre-cursor molecule in steps toward the target model, do you not agree that some steps could be 'innocuous' but yield no extra function, and so that step is neutrally affected by NS because the yield provides no advantage at that step (but may in the future?)?

Don't misquote me. I said "re-use appears to be a common 'strategy' in evolution." I don't know why you get so hung up on this. We talk about survival "strategies" as short-hand for the attributes of a particular organism that increase the likelihood that it will reproduce.
Why I get as you say 'so hung up': If there is no teleology to evolution, which is a priori to the theory (agree?), then why cannot an evolution-enthusiast express anything without teleological terms. If it is mere anthropomorphizing, then challenge yourself to re-state without such terms. Can you do it? If you cannot, my point is that maybe you are blind to the notion that you, on some other level of thinking, DO attribute purpose. Here in this forum of skeptics, is it not heresy to attribute purpose? Your 'short hand' should be avoided if it always leads you to appear to attribute purpose when your creed is 'there is no purpose'.

I think the best you can do is just say: that the mechanism of evolution appears teleological but it is not. The reason it is not is because we believe it is not. Disclaimer: any terms we use that imply purpose are merely shorthand and it is not intended to attribute 'purpose' to how evolution works.

Translation: it is impossible for us to describe what we believe without using words that represent what we do NOT believe.

Again, I'm pointing out "cognitive dissonance".
 
Actrually, I pointed this out earlier.

But no, we know of NO single gene that codes for 10,000 protiens. However, many can code for two, or three, or as many as seven.

This is not, however, done by "protiens creating protiens", although there are sometimes chemicals made to control, protien folding (as others have stated). It's done by parts of the DNA remaining zipped, so that certain base pairs are "skipped over", or by part of the DNA looping around to insert an extra few base pairs between others.

In any case, this is neither here nor there. But it is an example of how a simple, random change (one base pair not unzipping, or a looping during DNA transcription) can create new information in the form of new proteins. In other words, the argument that "random mutation can't create new information", which you posited earlier, is completely unfounded.
Recently it was discovered some genes produce huge amounts of proteins - I'm pretty sure I read 10,000s!

I presented earlier that I thought simple parametric changes happen, and I called that micro-ev which I believe happens.

Metaphorically:
do i=0; i<N; i++
where RM affects parameter N can do many things like change pigment, size, quantity, etc, Iwould think.

Parametric changes are easy for me to accept. the New Information i have a problem with is the code inside the loop, metaphorically. I should say 'sizeable new information' I doubt can be formed using the RM/NS model. If it worked, we would already be using it in digital simulation. Problem is that the NS component in such digital models is still really artificial selection (AS), so it isn't the same. Nevertheless, RM/AS makes an interesting tool for research.
 
Do you mean that it took 40 years to find an exception to the central dogma? Are you referring to prions?

~~ Paul
Genetic engineering was sold to congress 15YA with ref to C D of DNA. Even then they knew about reverse transcriptase which violates the CD of DNA.

So I don't know why it wasn't already dead since exceptions had been found along the way. Just goes to show how long dogma can ride with contra-evidence - kinda like evolution:jaw-dropp .

Prions are an example of an exception since the folding is not explicitly coded in the DNA. So I guess thats an example. But historically, I think it was the result of the Human Genome Project that presented the greatest exception - the quantity of genes was not predicted by the dogma.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom