Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

And the only response I got was from you DF! I'll paraphrase and throw it out again... Can anyone tell me why we should care about a simulator or any sort of less-than-perfect designer? If we have physical, non-evolutionary origins, won't that be shown by science? And if we have supernatural origins, doesn't a less-than-perfect designer (or simulator) just leave a bunch of unanswered questions?

Anyway, DF, we can have our own discussion! My anatomy grad-school friend claims that any anti-evo claim that evo is not supported by the fossil record is using 40-year-old data. Discuss.
I realize from what DF said that he is still waiting for my response on something 'iron-clad' he said about common ancestry of humans/apes.

I guess I will have to go back and find what DF said. I should tell DF that I believe it plausible that apes evolved from humans. I think I have a popular book making the case for chimps evolving from humans.

In ref to Jimbo's implication that there is good fossil evidence in the last 40 years, I guess we won't get it from him because it is heresay from his anatomy grad-school friend. I did some reading about it within the last 40 years and in that period of time we went from the Neandertal to Cro-Magnon model to a multi-hominid coexisting model. There is still a wide variation in opinion on first arrival of the hominid line - I think it ranges from 5M to a little more than 10MY. So to Jimbo and to DF I will say that I have not seen anything as a result from the digs that can give credence to the remains being ancestors to humans. I think that throughout the last thousands to millions of years that there were probably a much larger variety of simians. I think it is just as plausible that the bones were the remains of a tasty monkey dinner as they are that they are the remains of tool-making pre-humans. Wouldn't you find campfires and flint tools around a bunch of dinner bones? There are people in the world today who eat monkeys and monkey brains. Must taste pretty good. It would be only because I choose to believe the fossils are hominids that I find it probable that they are - but if I'm skeptical, I can see that the decision to classify them as hominids is arbitrary.
 
About what?
About what you just commented on :confused: . Go back and read it. I got blank stares from people when I told them about my idea that viruses exchange genetic material between species. ...and that this could be a major accelerator of evolution. It could even explain what was called 'convergent evolution'. I even called it horizontal or lateral gene transfer which is what they call it now. Only I had this idea almost 40 years ago. Turns out, I was right, blank stares from specialists, notwithstanding.
 
About what you just commented on :confused: . Go back and read it. I got blank stares from people when I told them about my idea that viruses exchange genetic material between species. ...and that this could be a major accelerator of evolution. It could even explain what was called 'convergent evolution'. I even called it horizontal or lateral gene transfer which is what they call it now. Only I had this idea almost 40 years ago. Turns out, I was right, blank stares from specialists, notwithstanding.
No.
 
I think it is just as plausible that the bones were the remains of a tasty monkey dinner as they are that they are the remains of tool-making pre-humans.
No.

And if you have to ask why, it just proves, again, that you have no idea what you are talking about.
 
Can anyone tell me why we should care about a simulator or any sort of less-than-perfect designer? If we have physical, non-evolutionary origins, won't that be shown by science? And if we have supernatural origins, doesn't a less-than-perfect designer (or simulator) just leave a bunch of unanswered questions?
Oh, and DF who is fond of the term 'incompetent designer' never answered my question:
" What is incompetent about the design of the carbon atom?"

I think the scientific evidence has been invalidating evolutionary theory since darwin first published "origin..". So you ask "won't that be shown by science?" - Yes - it already has.

All that I've read with regard to paleontologists et al discounting the evidence of evolution is stuff you guys can read, too. I don't need to be called to task to do your homework for you. You'd do better to do it yourself than to trust me anyway being you may have an Ad Hominem bias. I should stay closer to the thread on abiogenesis.

In the end, we all have a bunch of unanswered questions - alas. ..so how about that carbon atom drfrank?
 
No.....
you have no idea what you are talking about.
You get p***ed when I talk about your religion that way.

"In fact, evolution became in a sense a scientific religion; almost all scientists have accepted it and many are prepared to `bend' their observations to fit in with it."—H. Lipson, "A Physicist Looks at Evolution," Physics Bulletin, 31 (1980), p. 138.

"It is therefore of immediate concern to both biologists and layman that Darwinism is under attack. The theory of life that undermined nineteenth-century religion has virtually become a religion itself and, in its turn, is being threatened by fresh ideas. The attacks are certainly not limited to those of the creationists and religious fundamentalists who deny Darwinism for political and moral reason. The main thrust of the criticism comes from within science itself. The doubts about Darwinism represent a political revolt from within rather than a siege from without."—B. Leith, The Descent of Darwin: A Handbook of Doubts about Darwinism (1982), p. 11.

"The hold of the evolutionary paradigm [theoretical system] is so powerful that an idea which is more like a principle of medieval astrology than a serious twentieth century scientific theory has become a reality for evolutionary biologists."—Michael Denton, Evolution: A Theory in Crisis (1985), p. 306 [Australian molecular biologist].
 
I must trust that the PhDs in various biological sciences (anatomy, paleobiology, etc.) know their craft in the same manner that physicists know theirs. The arguments, in some cases, start to get pretty sophistimacated, and I can immediately see how a lay person would be misled. Scientific 'sounding' arguments can be overwhelming (hence the championing of Behe as an ID proponent). It's only when arguments start violating elementary physical principles that I'm back on home turf, but...
I wouldn't trust those desperate biologists and their 'interpretations' of the 'evidence'. A physicist could never get away with it - it'd be like cold fusion.

Not a single professor has told me where physical principles come from! There is a hole for ID... I'm not sure that it rests at biology. I'm also not sure that many of them would be satisfied by the simulation explanation.
I am probably the only one in the world claiming simulation and ID at the same time - but the world is a big place. I'll bet Fredkin, Zuse, Wolfram are all as, what shall I say, athiest-leaning(?) as self-claimed among some of you. My claiming simulation and that the IDers are programmers is enough to get me thrown out of any Christian circles, i would imagine. So i would suspect that 'simulation' is more plausible than ID to your professors. Perhaps there would be no more concern for who/what programmed the simulation than evolutionists worry about where physical laws came from.


Oh, and as for some sort of life engineer? I can confidently say, "they made us, because it's COOOL!" There's your meaning of life from imperfect designers... Us: Why did you make us? Them: Because it was cool... an engineer's creed :D .
I think so, too, Jimbo.

In the beginning was 10^43 lines of code, and it was good (but not perfect) - and it is soooooooooo cooooooooool :cool:
 
My 'fundamentalism' as it were, without knowing sweet squat about biology is that biology (and all other sciences) follow (through some as yet unravelled (and potentially unresolvable) paths) from physics. Put less assertively, anything which can be felt to be even loosely constrained by physical principle should be considered natural. In all other realms except the deity (see Randi's commentary), there appears to be a lack of evidence for interaction between the natural and supernatural. I make the 'faith-based' jump that then says, "the deity doesn't 'tweak' organisms, physically, as they go along.

So yes, my feeling is that Behe, Dembski, the Discovery Institute etc. are on the wrong path right from the start, right out of the gate. I have also asserted that simulation (imperfect creation) ideas are problematic, right from the underpinnings, so that even if I can't follow every biological argument (and so far I have...), those theorists still have some explaining to do.

But... how can mighty PhDs be so wrong about science, and I be right? My guess is that they're going for notoriety...
I see here you made the assumption again that the idea of simulation coupled with ID has some group of followers someplace. I'll say again here that I don't think so. At least not until I can rally up enough "believers". Anybody here want to join my new religion of "Simulation ID"?

As far as I can tell the few 'digital physics' guys out there are probably not on my side of the fence when it comes to ID. Also, I don't know of any IDers who have snapped to the idea of simulation but I think that is more likely than the former.

Now, how do you get tax exempt status?
 
You get p***ed when I talk about your religion that way.
I don't have a religion.

"In fact, evolution became in a sense a scientific religion; almost all scientists have accepted it and many are prepared to `bend' their observations to fit in with it."—H. Lipson, "A Physicist Looks at Evolution," Physics Bulletin, 31 (1980), p. 138.
No.

"It is therefore of immediate concern to both biologists and layman that Darwinism is under attack. The theory of life that undermined nineteenth-century religion has virtually become a religion itself and, in its turn, is being threatened by fresh ideas. The attacks are certainly not limited to those of the creationists and religious fundamentalists who deny Darwinism for political and moral reason. The main thrust of the criticism comes from within science itself. The doubts about Darwinism represent a political revolt from within rather than a siege from without."—B. Leith, The Descent of Darwin: A Handbook of Doubts about Darwinism (1982), p. 11.
No.

"The hold of the evolutionary paradigm [theoretical system] is so powerful that an idea which is more like a principle of medieval astrology than a serious twentieth century scientific theory has become a reality for evolutionary biologists."—Michael Denton, Evolution: A Theory in Crisis (1985), p. 306 [Australian molecular biologist].
No.

Any more baseless assertions you care to bestow upon us?
 
I think the scientific evidence has been invalidating evolutionary theory since darwin first published "origin..".
If that is so, you'll be able to provide us with an example.

Whenever you're ready.

All that I've read with regard to paleontologists et al discounting the evidence of evolution is stuff you guys can read, too.
We could read it, yes, if you would tell us what it is. Because I am not aware of any books or articles that make such claims that stand up under even the most cursory examination.

So... Whenever you're ready.
 
I wouldn't trust those desperate biologists and their 'interpretations' of the 'evidence'. A physicist could never get away with it - it'd be like cold fusion.
What desperate biologists? What interpretations?

I am probably the only one in the world claiming simulation and ID at the same time
I doubt it.

So i would suspect that 'simulation' is more plausible than ID to your professors.
Why would you suspect that? Why do you think the simulation idea is plausible at all?
 
VonNeumann, in all your critisism you constantly come back to the likes of "in my opinion", "i don't find the evidence convincing", "what I have seen" etc. You then refer to 25 year old books that support your case. For sake of the discussion you might consider presenting one particular piece of "evidence" that you don't find convincing and provide your alternative interpretation of it?

As it is, the discussion seem to get stuck in a dialogue of "A says: well I have read scientists who say ToL is a good theory. B: Well I've read many who think it's not. Hah!"
 
I could believe that the African and Asian elephants, while different species, could have descended one from the other. So mere intra-species is not sufficient. Let me come back later with a better definition, but that is semi-close for now.

Huh ? Isn't that exactly what evolution is about ?
 
Macro-e is hard to define. One definition could be 'that which is NOT micro-e' but evolutionists believe macro-e is simply an extrapolation of micro-e. I am astonished at that simplistic thinking because it is not very critical thinking to simply say that a bunch of micro-e over enough time produces macro-e. There are two points I would introduce for my scope of macro-e:
1. macro-e must result in significantly sizeable new information
2. natural selection must stay neutral during the micro-e process, only to become a stabilizer at the end of the macro-e process.

So item#1, that macro produces sizeable increases in the genome, representing new information, is based on my belief that there are no intermediate steps for some structures.

Let me get this straight. You believe that members of a species, over millions of years, may devellop into new species, but you don't think this can accumulate into huge differences over even longer time periods ? What's stopping it from doing so ?
 
Macro-e is hard to define. One definition could be 'that which is NOT micro-e' but evolutionists believe macro-e is simply an extrapolation of micro-e. I am astonished at that simplistic thinking because it is not very critical thinking to simply say that a bunch of micro-e over enough time produces macro-e. There are two points I would introduce for my scope of macro-e:
1. macro-e must result in significantly sizeable new information
2. natural selection must stay neutral during the micro-e process, only to become a stabilizer at the end of the macro-e process.
Number 1 is a start. "Significantly sizeable" could be determined in some pragmatic but otherwise arbitrary way that would give us a workable distinction between macro- and micro-ev, if it would serve a purpose to classify things that way. Not unlike "species", "genus", etc.

Number 2 is a ridiculous assumption.

So item#1, that macro produces sizeable increases in the genome, representing new information, is based on my belief that there are no intermediate steps for some structures. Take as an example chlorophyll, even though it may not be a good enough example. If there are no light-to-energy conversion molecules lesser than chlorophyll, there are no precursors. So chlorophyll had to be coded for completely at once. This would be macro evolution unless there was already a similar molecule for some other purpose, that could be changed by a micro-e process.
Why would the physical precursors of chlorophyll necessarily be required to also carry precursors to the light-to-energy conversion attribute of chlorophyll? As you suggest, it's a perfectly reasonable scenario to imagine that there may already have been a similar molecule for some other purpose, changed by a micro-ev process. Re-use appears to be a common "strategy" in evolution.

The test for macro-e is that a new sequence of significant size appears that RM would have to work on for too long a period of time in order to get in one fell swoop. It is not all that many nucleotides of a specific sequence that it would take more than 20 billion years to occur by chance. ...Even if the primordial soup filled the whole universe volume. Macro evolution is where 'there's not enough time' because the intermediate steps are too large to be micro-e. Natural selection must remain neutral during the intermediate steps that do not express some advantage. So in macro-e, it would be best if natural selection would look the other way for a while. Natural selection can not do anything but stay neutral to help along the intermediate steps. That is another characterisitic of macro-evolution - being where NS must be neutral while new information is forming.
Talk about simplistic thinking. This assumes that new complex structures are built piece-by-piece and that the intermediate steps confer no advantage. But we see numerous examples, and can imagine countless others, where complexity arises out of iterative refinement of an initially simple advantage (sight is a good example), where simple but highly specialized "irreducible" forms arise out of more complex "scaffolded" structures, where small-advantage or "neutral" features become critical when environment changes, and where small changes give new meaning to a structure and send it off on a new evolutionary tangent. I think you should reevaluate whose thinking is inside the box.
 
Chipmunk,

On Chlorophyl, it's also likely that precursor chemicals no longer exist. Fossils of single-celled organisms (which have been the most abundant lifeform since life stated, including today, and the only type of life for most of the time) generally give little information about chemical processes they carried out. It's quite likely that any precursor molecules to chlorophyl were less efficient in some way (assuming they were light-to-energy molecules) and were weeded out of the gene pool by more successful, chlorophyl using species. Much in the same way that almost all life on Earth uses DNA with a similar structure.

Oh, and VonNeumann:

More information does not mean adding to the genome. Again, you show a lack of understanding of the subject you pontificate about. The human genome contains about 25,000 genes. Corn contain 40,000. You'd be hard-pressed to prove corn more complex than humans, yet it has 60% more genes than humans do. So, how do you explain a lesser number of genes leading to a more complex organism that creates more and varied protiens?

P.S.-I know the answer, do you?
 
So to Jimbo and to DF I will say that I have not seen anything as a result from the digs that can give credence to the remains being ancestors to humans.
The claim is not that any given hominid is a direct ancestor to humans, as that's impossible to tell without DNA. However, the fact that plenty of intermediate stages between ape and human have been found is important. Couple that with the genetic evidence (high similarity vitamin C gene, chromosomal fusion etc.), and it's pretty indisputable.

Even if no hominid fossils had ever been found, the genetic evidence on its own would be very compelling.
I think that throughout the last thousands to millions of years that there were probably a much larger variety of simians. I think it is just as plausible that the bones were the remains of a tasty monkey dinner as they are that they are the remains of tool-making pre-humans. Wouldn't you find campfires and flint tools around a bunch of dinner bones? There are people in the world today who eat monkeys and monkey brains. Must taste pretty good.
A better question here would be: where are the skeletons from the full humans of this period who were eating this delectable monkey meal?

Oh wait, no fully human skeletons from these periods have ever been found :eek:

Odd, that :rolleyes:
It would be only because I choose to believe the fossils are hominids that I find it probable that they are - but if I'm skeptical, I can see that the decision to classify them as hominids is arbitrary.

No, you want to think that the decision is arbitrary because you have no idea how this evidence is put together, and you're all to eager to shoehorn your own conclusion onto the evidence, no matter how badly it fits.

That's because, I'm guessing, you know nothing about why they were classified as hominids.

Oh, and DF who is fond of the term 'incompetent designer' never answered my question:
" What is incompetent about the design of the carbon atom?"
That's because it's nonsensical. The carbon atom itself is not `designed' - it's just a direct result of the physical laws of the universe and, as explained previously, we have no evidence as to whether they could be any different.

In any case, my reference to Incompetent Design was in relation to biology, not cosmology.
 
Last edited:
VonNeumann, in all your critisism you constantly come back to the likes of "in my opinion", "i don't find the evidence convincing", "what I have seen" etc. You then refer to 25 year old books that support your case. For sake of the discussion you might consider presenting one particular piece of "evidence" that you don't find convincing and provide your alternative interpretation of it?
As it is, the discussion seem to get stuck in a dialogue of "A says: well I have read scientists who say ToL is a good theory. B: Well I've read many who think it's not. Hah!"

I think if one claims to be a skeptic, one should remain skeptical, but more 'omni-directionally'. I am a skeptic, but more globally, I think than what I've seen here. But I see that you so-called-skeptics have a strong bias toward evolution and do not exercise much skepticism there 'because its all we have' (which I think I saw one of you or two post - and that is an honest answer).

So you point out "the likes of 'in my opinion'" in reference to MY words about MY skepticism about evolution... don't be surprised that we should use some of the same words. We are talking about something for which the evidence is thin to say the least.

OK, I don't have time to do your homework but off the top of my head, lets take the avian digits II III IV vs the therapod I II III. I'll assume most of you have some awareness of this topic, but even if you do, go visit talkorigins and you will see such certitude where the evolutionist PZMeyers claims the discrepancy not a problem:
http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/dinosaur/bird_and_frog_development.html#claim1

PZMeyers is pretty tough on Sarfati, vascillating between 'he's utterly wrong' to 'its complicated and greater minds have been confused over it' [my paraphrase]. But where I see this differently than you may, is in the fact that the dinosaur embryology is NOT THERE for us to study. The assertion that dinosaur embryology SHOULD verify this if only we had it is implied in Meyers assuring choice of words. On the other hand he expresses himself in a much weaker way when he says "We don’t have fetal dinosaur hands to experiment on, but our growing knowledge about how limbs develop suggests that that might just be the case."

He said "suggests that that might just be the case." How is that different than "in my opinion", that you impune me for saying? It is my opinion that Meyers is stating an opinion. It is his opinion that Safarti is wrong. To you 'skeptics' Meyers is reading holy scripture.

See, so I don't have time to point out these things to all of you. Simply go yourself, and pump up your omni-directional skepticism, and research it yourself.

I think Michael Behe made a very good point - he being a micro-biologist: he points out a sort of "they talk the talk but they don't walk the walk" when it comes to the biologists' claim that modern biology could not have made the advances it has made without the underpinnings of the evolutionary theory. There are constant claims that evolution is the guiding light in understanding biology. OK. BUT, go look in biological journals and texts and try to find where the paradigm has actually helped discover how a mechanism works. I haven't read that many biological texts myself. Of course, we aren't talking about general texts for biology 101, but more specific works. I do remember reading a book called "Gene Expression" in the 70s. Being an evolutionist at the time, I remember searching through the book and seeing that there was no mention of evolution in the whole text, to help explain how it was a guiding light.

And Jocce, yes that was an old book (as you said I refer to 25 year old books - hehheh), but go look at some new books and see if you can find where evolution was the guiding paradigm that actually helped in understanding how something works. It SHOULD be prevalent, but it is rare.

As I have mentioned twice before now, the Central Dogma of DNA is an example of where evolution was a guiding light. THe guiding light led biologists for 40 years with the WRONG assumptions and it took 40 years to find that the Central Dogma was FALSE.

Many of you think of yourselves as some kinds of protectors of science, but science needs to be protected by this kind of 'wishful thinking' spawned by overzealousness toward darwinism.

...oh, and then you have the evolutionists who appear to me to be outright liars. I say "appear to be" because the example I am thinking of is from a very bright person for whom it is hard for me to believe he cannot see his folly. So I wonder if he is perpetrating a falsehood intentionally. I'm speaking of Dawkins and his computer generated something-morphs - what did he call them? JJEEEEZ! How stupid does he think his readers are that his silly program represents how evolution works?
 
No, you want to think that the decision is arbitrary because you have no idea how this evidence is put together, and you're all to eager to shoehorn your own conclusion onto the evidence, no matter how badly it fits.
Yes, that is a somewhat accurate assertion. Not that I have "no idea", I DO have an idea. My idea is that the paleoanthropologists are "all to eager to shoehorn [evolutionary] conclusions onto the evidence, no matter how badly it fits."

Your point that I am ignorant of the latest and greatest in how the evidence has been put together is true. I did keep up with some of it for quite a while until I lost interest in what seemed like a lot of unsettled issues. I assume it is still much the same.


The carbon atom itself is not `designed' - it's just a direct result of the physical laws of the universe and, as explained previously, we have no evidence as to whether they could be any different.

In any case, my reference to Incompetent Design was in relation to biology, not cosmology.
You mocked the idea of intelligent design DF and called it incompetent design. So, this implies you think that if there exists a designer, she is incompetent - right? Then if there exists a designer, and she is incompetent, then she did very well with her physical laws that they could form gigantic furnaces that could forge, through a few billion years, such things as carbon, oxygen, nitrogen etc., each atom identical to the next within an accuracy of at worst 1 part in 10^40.

Yes, exactly: 'we have no evidence as to whether [physical laws of the universe] could be any different.' How does that statement bolster your position? ...your position is that ID only has to do with biology because things are fuzzy enough and complex enough in biology that the argument is not so 'cut and dried' there? Well lets step back into the more crisp era of pre-bio. Where did the "undesigned" atoms come from? You say from the "undesigned" physical laws?

How do you know that the physical laws were not designed? You stated that as if you think you 'know'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom