VonNeumann, in all your critisism you constantly come back to the likes of "in my opinion", "i don't find the evidence convincing", "what I have seen" etc. You then refer to 25 year old books that support your case. For sake of the discussion you might consider presenting one particular piece of "evidence" that you don't find convincing and provide your alternative interpretation of it?
As it is, the discussion seem to get stuck in a dialogue of "A says: well I have read scientists who say ToL is a good theory. B: Well I've read many who think it's not. Hah!"
I think if one claims to be a skeptic, one should remain skeptical, but more 'omni-directionally'. I am a skeptic, but more globally, I think than what I've seen here. But I see that you so-called-skeptics have a strong bias toward evolution and do not exercise much skepticism there 'because its all we have' (which I think I saw one of you or two post - and that is an honest answer).
So you point out "the likes of 'in my opinion'" in reference to MY words about MY skepticism about evolution... don't be surprised that we should use some of the same words. We are talking about something for which the evidence is thin to say the least.
OK, I don't have time to do your homework but off the top of my head, lets take the avian digits II III IV vs the therapod I II III. I'll assume most of you have some awareness of this topic, but even if you do, go visit talkorigins and you will see such certitude where the evolutionist PZMeyers claims the discrepancy not a problem:
http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/dinosaur/bird_and_frog_development.html#claim1
PZMeyers is pretty tough on Sarfati, vascillating between 'he's utterly wrong' to 'its complicated and greater minds have been confused over it' [my paraphrase]. But where I see this differently than you may, is in the fact that the dinosaur embryology is NOT THERE for us to study. The assertion that dinosaur embryology SHOULD verify this if only we had it is implied in Meyers assuring choice of words. On the other hand he expresses himself in a much weaker way when he says "We don’t have fetal dinosaur hands to experiment on, but our growing knowledge about how limbs develop suggests that that might just be the case."
He said "suggests that that might just be the case." How is that different than "in my opinion", that you impune me for saying? It is my opinion that Meyers is stating an opinion. It is his opinion that Safarti is wrong. To you 'skeptics' Meyers is reading holy scripture.
See, so I don't have time to point out these things to all of you. Simply go yourself, and pump up your omni-directional skepticism, and research it yourself.
I think Michael Behe made a very good point - he being a micro-biologist: he points out a sort of "they talk the talk but they don't walk the walk" when it comes to the biologists' claim that modern biology could not have made the advances it has made without the underpinnings of the evolutionary theory. There are constant claims that evolution is the guiding light in understanding biology. OK. BUT, go look in biological journals and texts and try to find where the paradigm has actually helped discover how a mechanism works. I haven't read that many biological texts myself. Of course, we aren't talking about general texts for biology 101, but more specific works. I do remember reading a book called "Gene Expression" in the 70s. Being an evolutionist at the time, I remember searching through the book and seeing that there was no mention of evolution in the whole text, to help explain how it was a guiding light.
And Jocce, yes that was an old book (as you said I refer to 25 year old books - hehheh), but go look at some new books and see if you can find where evolution was the guiding paradigm that actually helped in understanding how something works. It SHOULD be prevalent, but it is rare.
As I have mentioned twice before now, the Central Dogma of DNA is an example of where evolution was a guiding light. THe guiding light led biologists for 40 years with the WRONG assumptions and it took 40 years to find that the Central Dogma was FALSE.
Many of you think of yourselves as some kinds of protectors of science, but science needs to be protected by this kind of 'wishful thinking' spawned by overzealousness toward darwinism.
...oh, and then you have the evolutionists who appear to me to be outright liars. I say "appear to be" because the example I am thinking of is from a very bright person for whom it is hard for me to believe he cannot see his folly. So I wonder if he is perpetrating a falsehood intentionally. I'm speaking of Dawkins and his computer generated something-morphs - what did he call them? JJEEEEZ! How stupid does he think his readers are that his silly program represents how evolution works?