Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

To me, this is neither a 'religion' nor 'merely entertainment'.

I don't have a religion. I used to, then I grew up.

What about posting here is entertaining to you? Trolling?
(Trolling? I don't get the fishing metaphor.). Btw, i also never understood what is "woo".

What is entertaining here? Being incognito while conversing - especially when the topic(s) are those where I may take a diametrically opposed viewpoint.

The emotional responses from you, for example, were interesting for me to observe. Admittedly, I might be accused of being too easily amused.
 
Plausible ? Where are your credentials to toss aside that theory so easily ? You remind me of my mother, always thinking that, from your lay position, you can judge all those pesky specialists and their data and their evidence and declare, because you can't accept it, that the theory on which theyhave spent the last 150 years is bunk.
Belz belz belz... always being reminded of your dear mother... that's quaint.

The reason I call you fellows "so-called-skeptics" is because I think you should be MORE skeptical. It is not very often, but occasionally these pesky specialists become quite pesky with their observation of the "data" and of the "evidence". Every once in a while there is a statement made about how the evidence does not support the theory or how the evidence is made to fit the theory. A salient difference between you and me is that I don't ignore it when a highly credentialed specialist admits this, while you do ignote it. The reaction amongst the darwin-faithers is as one would expect of a religious person, and is why I characterize darwin-faithers that way. They ignore the contra-evidence, close their eyes and BELEEEEEEEEEEEEEEIVE.

So i choose not to believe that baloney about macro-evolution. Microevolution - no prob. And I did not toss it aside easily as you suggest. It probably took more years for me to make the transition than you've been alive. I was very stubborn about it, just as you are.
 
Every once in a while there is a statement made about how the evidence does not support the theory or how the evidence is made to fit the theory.
This is true. It seems as though you have an example or two in mind? Care to share?

A salient difference between you and me is that I don't ignore it when a highly credentialed specialist admits this, while you do ignote it.
You don't know belz or me or anyone else who posts here well enough to back up this assertion. Name these specialists and their claims. Then we'll talk.

The reaction amongst the darwin-faithers is as one would expect of a religious person, and is why I characterize darwin-faithers that way.
And this is why you hear the word "straw-man" so often. You're arguing against a caricature, dude.

So i choose not to believe that baloney about macro-evolution. Microevolution - no prob.
These terms are often used by evolution-deniers*, but as far as I've been able to discern, there's no general consensus on what they really mean. So for the purposes of discussion, please outline a practical distinction between "macro-evolution" and "microevolution". Thanks.


*Something I've noticed that seems to be common among ID-proponents is the use of inflammatory language (e.g. "darwin-faithers") It's an ugly habit. Stick to the merits and the flaws.
 
....or that we live in a simulation (not unlike a simulation on a digital computer but I only say that because it would otherwise be hard to relate), and the IDers are 'outside the simulation' ...thereby getting around the godelian problem.
What [SIZE=-1]Gödelian problem?[/SIZE]
 
Damn. Iacchus II.
And yet the unnamed, unspecified, incompetent supernatural designer is more believable ?
I have no idea what is "iacchus ii", but i'm sure it's not to the point anywise.

Perhaps rather than "unnamed, unspecified, incompetent supernatural designer" I could just say "unknown programmer(s)".

Good question about "which is more believable?". I had previously made the point, i don't think many of you thought was fair argument, that whatever it is that you believe is at the kernel of macro-evolution, must be "making" all this living stuff.

I presented: "making", "designing", "creating", "programming", etc as possible verbs that this seminal kernel in the black box of evolution actually DOES.

Amusedly, someone suggested the expected verb "EVOLVING". This is circular. I ask what is it that is the mechanism of evolution - what does it do? Skeptic Survey says: it does the "evolving". I was also taught here, not at all unexpectedly, that when darwin-faithers use the term "design" or "purpose" or "function" when speaking of organs/organelles/systems that those terms are merely "andropromorphic".

OK, of course they are "andorpromorphic". But not like "the sea is angry" because in said phrase, many other alternative terms could be used such as "the sea was rough."

When I think of "design" in the sense of constructing something that has a purpose, through some process that goes on in the mind, I think of something that only a human can do. A waterfall may be said to design a hole, but that is an unnecessary anthropomorphistic use of the term because we are not forced to use the term for lack of another better term. A stream of electrons may make a hole in a foil for the same reason a waterfall makes a hole. If the stream were aimed for a purpose, then it would be "design", otherwise it would be the consequence of physical law. ...Reminding you here that the question of whether physical law is designed, is the origin of the top of this thread.

So the word "design" is used, not capriciously anthropomorphically, but rather out of necessity. Humans design. Human's tools design by direction of the human. But what ELSE designs? If you say nothing else (yet - just wait, though), then I believe you are saying that "life has no purpose."

So, "which should we believe?" That the designer of life is some un-named designer, out there somewhere? or the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution? You believe that the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution but you would not use the term "design". You would use the term that means "unfold". Well that implies that it was predestined to unfold and therefore had a purpose. Yet you deny "purpose". What is this purposeless "thing" that is at the center of evolution that does the evolving? All I've gotten is "chance" or "randomness" from some of you.

I know, I know. "Purpose" is an illusion. If we weren't here then we wouldn't be suffering from the illusion, but obviously, we are here, and since we are here, we ... Its like a bullseye drawn around the arrow after it...

Yes, I've backed off of believing that the idea of evolution has it. For source of new complexity, I think it is missing something so big that I'll join the club again when someone discovers that 'missing something'. I happen to believe it plausible that the missing something is NOT LOCAL.
 
So the word "design" is used, not capriciously anthropomorphically, but rather out of necessity. Humans design. Human's tools design by direction of the human. But what ELSE designs? If you say nothing else (yet - just wait, though), then I believe you are saying that "life has no purpose."

So, "which should we believe?" That the designer of life is some un-named designer, out there somewhere? or the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution? You believe that the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution but you would not use the term "design". You would use the term that means "unfold". Well that implies that it was predestined to unfold and therefore had a purpose. Yet you deny "purpose". What is this purposeless "thing" that is at the center of evolution that does the evolving? All I've gotten is "chance" or "randomness" from some of you.

I know, I know. "Purpose" is an illusion. If we weren't here then we wouldn't be suffering from the illusion, but obviously, we are here, and since we are here, we ... Its like a bullseye drawn around the arrow after it...

Yes, I've backed off of believing that the idea of evolution has it. For source of new complexity, I think it is missing something so big that I'll join the club again when someone discovers that 'missing something'. I happen to believe it plausible that the missing something is NOT LOCAL.
I totally sympathize with the empty feeling that accompanies the idea that there might not be a direction or plan that got us here and that is guiding us into the future.

We are purpose-driven creatures. We set goals and strive for them. We tell stories that have a coherent structure. We make stuff that does useful things. We plan strategies. To think that our very existence has purpose just seems right.

Problem is, when we use the best methods we've discovered and developed to uncover the story of the universe and of life, the story that appears to be coming together is one of purposeless, undirected self-organization, not a Plan developed by an outsider.

Don't get me wrong. I don't think life, that is our lives, are purposeless. We create purpose in our lives. And I'm rooting for a larger purpose. I would love to learn of strong evidence (but I mean evidence, not wishful conjectures and interpretations of evidence) of a grand mission or whatever for the earth, life, humanity. But until then, my life is filled with purpose, and that's enough.
 
Quantum Electrodynamics.
Yes indeed. Thanks for bringing it up. I have already tried to make the point that QED invokes virtual photons going backwards in time.

Your argument ostensibly is that: QED is a complete theory. I have made the point earlier that QED is one of the best theories we have because of the corroborative computer model evidence. But just because we can simulate virtual photons that go backward in time on a digital computer does not mean we know how the "universe does it". How the universe does it may be infinitely complex.

We have a valid and extremely accurate gravitational model of subatomic particles. Where do you get your ideas from? It's as though you read the headlines in New Scientist but never bothered to read any of the articles.
It must be your extreme positivism that allows you to believe how "valid and extremely accurate" are the gravitational models. If it were as you say, why is gravitational not unified with the rest?

You have some other concept of randomness than that taught in statistics? Non-random randomness, maybe?
Your reference to "non-random randomness":
"Anyone who considers arithmetical methods of producing random digits is, of course, in a state of sin." said John von Neumann. I'm not talking about pseudo-random or statistically random, but rather the "non-sinful" physically random. Statistics is pure math. It is impossible to accurately model physical randomness using mathematics, obviously.

Yes, the "concept of randomness" I am talking about is physical randomness. Is pi a normal distribution in the statistical sense? Presumably so (someone proved it I think). But could it satisfy the statistical definition of "normal distribution" yet never ever in its infinite digits contain one single sequence of numbers that has enough order to code something as complex as a simple genome? I don't think it would be too difficult to prove "Yes". You say if it is a "normal distribution" and if you search deep enough, you will find a whole "Leave it to Beaver" TV show that was never written, in standard American raster format. My concept is that it can satisfy "statistical normal distribution" and NEVER have "Leave it to Beaver".

My point about pi then is that, it may be a "statistically normal distribution" but it may not be useful as a pseudo-random ingredient to an RM/NS model. But pi is pseudo-random, not physically random.

What about a random sequence spewed forth from some natural physical source? What if we say "it looks like white noise" over some bandwidth. But it could be as spectrally flat as we could possibly measure and still not contain any useful complexity. We do not know if physical randomness, such as emission of a particle timing, is algorithmic or not.

Another algorithmically infinitely complex model is the M-set. It is random in that our intelligence cannot predict what exactly the M-set will look like in a given place without our computing it, yet we can recognize M-set-ness. I have a gut feel that no matter where you look in the M-set, you will never see a picture of a pussy cat. In its infinite complexity - no pussies. By the same token, we do not know if what we call physically random, does not also have a certain *-ness as the M-set has M-set-ness.

I'm sorry if the above did not drift well to my point - but here it is: regardless of what my concept is of physical randomness, I think that, were I still an evolutionist, I would have to believe, whether I tumbled to it or not, that the physical randomness at the kernel of evolution possesses some sort of "life-ness" to it.
 
I totally sympathize with the empty feeling that accompanies the idea that there might not be a direction or plan that got us here and that is guiding us into the future.

We are purpose-driven creatures. We set goals and strive for them. We tell stories that have a coherent structure. We make stuff that does useful things. We plan strategies. To think that our very existence has purpose just seems right.

Problem is, when we use the best methods we've discovered and developed to uncover the story of the universe and of life, the story that appears to be coming together is one of purposeless, undirected self-organization, not a Plan developed by an outsider.

Don't get me wrong. I don't think life, that is our lives, are purposeless. We create purpose in our lives. And I'm rooting for a larger purpose. I would love to learn of strong evidence (but I mean evidence, not wishful conjectures and interpretations of evidence) of a grand mission or whatever for the earth, life, humanity. But until then, my life is filled with purpose, and that's enough.
I think you stated that very well. I would only presume that we should insert some words as I show bracketed here:
"Problem is, when we use the best methods we've discovered and developed to uncover the story of the universe and of life, the story that appears [to strong materialists] to be coming together is one of purposeless, undirected self-organization, not a Plan developed by an outsider."

One thing I am not clear on is whether most of you would make the same sort of statement as you have. And if so, is it understood that being a "strong materialist" is what you volunteer to adhere to because thats the way we keep science from giving up to zeus as the cause of things. Is it further understood that, just because it is the rule of science, it does not mean it is the rule of "what really is." You see what I mean? I applaud that science must do what science must do. I just don't like it going beyond the evidence to make claims. To me, an example of a claim that goes beyond evidence is that this realm has no purpose.
 

So I choose not to believe that baloney about "gallons". Pints - no prob.
I cannot believe you could be so simple-minded. That's like saying, because I can jump over this puddle, I can jump over *. Let * be "the moon" or "the nearest supernova".

I would more liken the contrast of micro to macro-evolution by this:

Given a function: Function(P1, P2, P3, P4)

Given : the function is 10^3 bytes of code. Assume the calling parameters are one byte each and boundary checked within the function.

Now assume a mutation of each of the following types:
1. a change to a parametric value Pn.
2. a change somewhere in the 10^3 bytes of the function code.

I liken scenario #1 to micro-evolution. The function still performs as it was designed but produces a little more or less of pigment or metabolism or growth, etc.

I liken scenario #2 to be what would be required for macro evolution. The function itself would have to be greatly changed, not simple parametric change. Not only that, a single one byte change to the functional code would likely "kill" the function. The liklihood of benefit over harm is a quantitatively vanishingly small. ...and that is for only a one byte change to the code. A speciation change may require a whole new function - a whole new rewrite of this function. What is the likelihood of making multibyte changes without killing the function? Vanishingly small.

I think my metaphor is much closer to properly contrasting micro/macro evolution than would be the metaphor of pints and gallons. But you've revealed now how simple your thinking is - ASStonishing.
 
It must be your extreme positivism that allows you to believe how "valid and extremely accurate" are the gravitational models.
No. It's just that the theory is, in fact, valid and extremely accurate.

If it were as you say, why is gravitational not unified with the rest?
Because we haven't worked that out yet.

Your reference to "non-random randomness":
"Anyone who considers arithmetical methods of producing random digits is, of course, in a state of sin." said John von Neumann. I'm not talking about pseudo-random or statistically random, but rather the "non-sinful" physically random. Statistics is pure math. It is impossible to accurately model physical randomness using mathematics, obviously.
Wrong. It is perfectly possible; indeed, it is ubiquitous.

John Von Neumann was talking about the algorithmic generation of random numbers. He was right in that, but it is completely - completely - different to what you are claiming.

Yes, the "concept of randomness" I am talking about is physical randomness. Is pi a normal distribution in the statistical sense? Presumably so (someone proved it I think).
No, it has not yet been shown that pi is normal.

But could it satisfy the statistical definition of "normal distribution" yet never ever in its infinite digits contain one single sequence of numbers that has enough order to code something as complex as a simple genome?
No. If pi is normal, that is impossible.

I don't think it would be too difficult to prove "Yes". You say if it is a "normal distribution" and if you search deep enough, you will find a whole "Leave it to Beaver" TV show that was never written, in standard American raster format. My concept is that it can satisfy "statistical normal distribution" and NEVER have "Leave it to Beaver".
Sorry, but that is simply wrong.

The definition of a normal number is this:
A real number x is normal in base b if in its representation in base b all digits occur, in an asymptotic sense, equally often. In addition, for each m, the b^m different m-strings must occur equally often. In other words, lim n->infinity N(s,n)/n = b^-m for each m-string s, where N(s,n) is the number of occurrences of s in the first n base-b digits of x. A number that is normal in all bases is called normal.
So if pi is normal, then it necessarily contains both the human genome and every Leave it to Beaver episode ever made - for every possible encoding.

But pi is pseudo-random, not physically random.
If you can actually demonstrate this, you're a good candidate for the Fields Medal.

What about a random sequence spewed forth from some natural physical source? What if we say "it looks like white noise" over some bandwidth. But it could be as spectrally flat as we could possibly measure and still not contain any useful complexity. We do not know if physical randomness, such as emission of a particle timing, is algorithmic or not.
There is no possible source of such an algorithm.

I have a gut feel that no matter where you look in the M-set, you will never see a picture of a pussy cat.
A gut feel? Really? I'm sooo impressed. :rolleyes:

I'm sorry if the above did not drift well to my point - but here it is: regardless of what my concept is of physical randomness, I think that, were I still an evolutionist, I would have to believe, whether I tumbled to it or not, that the physical randomness at the kernel of evolution possesses some sort of "life-ness" to it.
No. You are talking complete twaddle.
 
Last edited:
I cannot believe you could be so simple-minded. That's like saying, because I can jump over this puddle, I can jump over *. Let * be "the moon" or "the nearest supernova".
No.

Implicit in that is the assumption that evolution is discontinuous. All the evidence shows that this is wrong.

It is, rather, like saying that because you can drive from New York to New Jersey, that you can drive from New York to Baltimore.

I would more liken the contrast of micro to macro-evolution by this:

Given a function: Function(P1, P2, P3, P4)

Given : the function is 10^3 bytes of code. Assume the calling parameters are one byte each and boundary checked within the function.

Now assume a mutation of each of the following types:
1. a change to a parametric value Pn.
2. a change somewhere in the 10^3 bytes of the function code.
How does this relate to evolution in any way?

The difference we see between species is entirely coded in their DNA. There is one source of change. One only.

I think my metaphor is much closer to properly contrasting micro/macro evolution than would be the metaphor of pints and gallons.
You're wrong. Hopelessly, utterly, hilariously wrong. You have assumed into being an entirely different mechanism for the origin of species which directly contradicts everything we have learned of biology, ever.

It does not happen the way you think it does.
 
This is true. It seems as though you have an example or two in mind? Care to share?
Yes, I'll have to go look up some of my old notes.

You don't know belz or me or anyone else who posts here well enough to back up this assertion.
You are correct that we don't know each other. I was making reference, though to where Belz implied that I do not believe specialists. It follows that he thinks he does believe the specialists. Since he does not know what I mean when I speak of contra-evidence, I assume he does as I alleged - ignores the credentialled specialists who have pointed out the poor/lack_of evidence. I will concede your point - I do not KNOW he ignores them. He may just be ignorant of them or dismiss them.

Name these specialists and their claims. Then we'll talk.
Excellent idea.

And this is why you hear the word "straw-man" so often. You're arguing against a caricature, dude.
These terms are often used by evolution-deniers*, but as far as I've been able to discern, there's no general consensus on what they really mean. So for the purposes of discussion, please outline a practical distinction between "macro-evolution" and "microevolution". Thanks.

*Something I've noticed that seems to be common among ID-proponents is the use of inflammatory language (e.g. "darwin-faithers") It's an ugly habit. Stick to the merits and the flaws.
When I speak of darwin-faithers, I would assume that a person who does not consider himself a darwin-faither to merely go 'he's not talking to me.' I apologize to anyone who has felt disrespected by my use of the term. I respect everyone here. I never thought it would be considered "inflammatory". I think darwin-faither is more illustrative than 'evolutionist'. I would not be insulted to be called an IDer or an ID-faither. I believe 'origins' is something taken on 'faith' not on 'evidence', in either case. Besides, how many times have I been called a 'creationist' here? Isn't that supposed to tick me off to put me in with 'church-lady'? My apology stands but methinks you are being too hard on me.

As far as Macro vs Micro evolution, I just posted an example in my previous post in response to pixy, who thinks the difference between micro and macro evolution is exactly 112 ounces:D .
 
What [SIZE=-1]Gödelian problem?[/SIZE]
"Gödel's theorem seems to me to prove that Mechanism is false, that is, that minds cannot be explained as machines. So also has it seemed to many other people: almost every mathematical logician I have put the matter to has confessed to similar thoughts, but has felt reluctant to commit himself definitely until he could see the whole argument set out, with all objections fully stated and properly met."

This was John Lucas' intro to his essay "Minds, Machines and Gödel".

I would characterize myself as having fallen all the way from strong AI down to "Mechanism is false". When I made the statement about the Programmer of a simulation having to be outside the Simulation, I said so because it seems to me to be a Gödelian type of question, to which the answer would be that He would have to be outside the System.

I have heard arguments that Gödel does not apply to AI. I don't think I've heard it argued one way or the other with regard to evolution. In fact I think I'll go look it up to see how Gödel has been applied to self-organization.
 
"Gödel's theorem seems to me to prove that Mechanism is false, that is, that minds cannot be explained as machines.
Why would this be true?

So also has it seemed to many other people: almost every mathematical logician I have put the matter to has confessed to similar thoughts, but has felt reluctant to commit himself definitely until he could see the whole argument set out, with all objections fully stated and properly met."
Well, as soon as one of them comes up with an argument rather than a feeling, perhaps it will probe worth discussing.

I would characterize myself as having fallen all the way from strong AI down to "Mechanism is false". When I made the statement about the Programmer of a simulation having to be outside the Simulation, I said so because it seems to me to be a Gödelian type of question, to which the answer would be that He would have to be outside the System.
What, again, is the [SIZE=-1]Gödelian problem? What is it about minds that you think is an issue?[/SIZE]

I have heard arguments that Gödel does not apply to AI. I don't think I've heard it argued one way or the other with regard to evolution. In fact I think I'll go look it up to see how Gödel has been applied to self-organization.
The Incompleteness Theorem applies to any consistent and sufficiently powerful formal system, regardless of where it came from. It does not apply to things that aren't formal systems, but it always applies to formal systems.

So where's the problem?
 
The difference we see between species is entirely coded in their DNA.
No.

Weren't you there when the pharmaceuticals crashed along with the dot coms? Perhaps you didn't notice the collapse of "the DNA theory". I have first hand hearsay;) that this collapse helped start the lack of confidence in parmaceutical stocks.

You're wrong. Hopelessly, utterly, hilariously wrong. You have assumed into being an entirely different mechanism for the origin of species which directly contradicts everything we have learned of biology, ever.

It does not happen the way you think it does.
"It does not happen the way you think it does," is exactly what you should have been learning of late.

If, as you said 'The difference we see between species is entirely coded in their DNA", then we humans wouldn't have fewer genes than a flower.

When DNA transcribes to RNA transcribes to protein, not all the information from the DNA was there that insures that the protein will be properly folded in the cell cytoplasm. The cytoplasm contains chaperone proteins that make sure that the protein gets properly folded. Where did the chaperone proteins come from? They were already there. What made sure the chaperone proteins were properly folded? Pre-existing chaperone proteins.

Ever hear of 'mad cow'? Prions are mal-folded proteins as those that cause those kinds of diseases. I'm sure you must already know this.

What we are learning is that much of the information has to already be in the cell that is not in the nucleus. Are there some proteins in the cell that are not coded in the DNA? At least it appears that we have lately learned that some genes can produce 10,000s of proteins (where dogma had it as one protein per gene up until recently), and that protein folding may not be coded explicitly in the DNA but instead rely on legacy protein chaperones that have procreated without the help of DNA, for millions of years.
 
No.

Weren't you there when the pharmaceuticals crashed along with the dot coms? Perhaps you didn't notice the collapse of "the DNA theory". I have first hand hearsay;) that this collapse helped start the lack of confidence in parmaceutical stocks.
What the hell are you talking about now?

If, as you said 'The difference we see between species is entirely coded in their DNA", then we humans wouldn't have fewer genes than a flower.
Why not?

When DNA transcribes to RNA transcribes to protein, not all the information from the DNA was there that insures that the protein will be properly folded in the cell cytoplasm. The cytoplasm contains chaperone proteins that make sure that the protein gets properly folded. Where did the chaperone proteins come from? They were already there.
What do you mean, "they were already there"? They were necessarily manufactured, otherwise they would have disappeared long since.

What made sure the chaperone proteins were properly folded? Pre-existing chaperone proteins.
Which poses no problems for evolution at all. Many proteins will fold "correctly" most of the time in most situations, requiring no chaperones. That some species have evolved proteins that require the assistance of other proteins to fold correctly in some situations is not an argument against evolution at all.

Ever hear of 'mad cow'? Prions are mal-folded proteins as those that cause those kinds of diseases. I'm sure you must already know this.
So?

What we are learning is that much of the information has to already be in the cell that is not in the nucleus.
There is DNA in mitochondria as well.

Are there some proteins in the cell that are not coded in the DNA?
Why are you asking me? This is your assertion; you're supposed to be providing evidence for it.

At least it appears that we have lately learned that some genes can produce 10,000s of proteins (where dogma had it as one protein per gene up until recently), and that protein folding may not be coded explicitly in the DNA but instead rely on legacy protein chaperones that have procreated without the help of DNA, for millions of years.
Why do you claim that the chaperone proteins are not encoded in DNA? Do you have actual evidence, or did you just make this up?
 
Why would this be true?

Well, as soon as one of them comes up with an argument rather than a feeling, perhaps it will probe worth discussing.

What, again, is the [SIZE=-1]Gödelian problem? What is it about minds that you think is an issue?[/SIZE]

The Incompleteness Theorem applies to any consistent and sufficiently powerful formal system, regardless of where it came from. It does not apply to things that aren't formal systems, but it always applies to formal systems.

So where's the problem?
How well does pure math apply to reality, anyway? I don't know but, to me, it is a more fundamental question than the question that started this thread (let me say that question is "were physical laws designed?"). ..or more than that... the question of 'what is mathematics?' is pretty tough. Did we invent math or did we discover it? How do a mere few million nucleotides in our DNA make us able to mentally cruise through a world of math while a chimp cannot fathom the number 4. Was mathematics here or somewhere before there was a human mind? Of course these are rhetorical but I noticed people give surprisingly different answers.

What I made reference to tries to apply the concept of a formal system to something like the mind. I brought it up in context of a universal simulation (as a computer program) which would be a formal system by definition. I am not educated in it so will refer you to read John Lucas' essay if you are interested. I have the ancient book here but maybe its on the web. Also, I maybe got some ideas about it by reading Penrose's "Emperor's New Mind".

What is it about minds? My personal thought is that 'mind' is not entirely Mechanism (as Lucas said for Godelian reasons) and that creation of new information must be done 'in a mind'.

Of course, you are probably in good company if you dismiss Godellian relevance to any of this. It is probably 'old school'.

Bringing up QED again: when I say something about outside the universe, I think that there is some evidence, at least to my way of thinking. That is, light cannot even go through a pane of glass without virtual photons going an infinite number of paths, including those paths that go backward in time. Going backward in time violates cause-and-effect. Now it may be merely semantics to say that things that violate cause-and-effect happen 'outside this universe', or one could include such phenomena as part of this universe. Of course, by many people's definition, universe means everything, so they don't know why I keep saying 'this universe'. But science is about empirical stuff: cause-before-effect. So, could this mean that quantum physics has already poked a hole in science? The evidence using cause and effect says that sometimes effect can come before cause?

Then there are those who think quantum computers will someday compute instantaneously. What do you think of that possibility Pix?
 
Hey VonNeumann, free education!

Go here.


It´s a little like the JREF challenge in that most prospective applicants only seem to come as far as making their claim along the lines: "...to demonstrate, in a double-blind setting, a complete non-understanding of the friggin´ rules already". But, why not surprise us all?

Come on, you´re itching for it. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom