Damn. Iacchus II.
And yet the unnamed, unspecified, incompetent supernatural designer is more believable ?
I have no idea what is "iacchus ii", but i'm sure it's not to the point anywise.
Perhaps rather than "unnamed, unspecified, incompetent supernatural designer" I could just say "unknown programmer(s)".
Good question about "which is more believable?". I had previously made the point, i don't think many of you thought was fair argument, that whatever it is that you believe is at the kernel of macro-evolution, must be "making" all this living stuff.
I presented: "making", "designing", "creating", "programming", etc as possible verbs that this seminal kernel in the black box of evolution actually DOES.
Amusedly, someone suggested the expected verb "EVOLVING". This is circular. I ask what is it that is the mechanism of evolution - what does it do? Skeptic Survey says: it does the "evolving". I was also taught here, not at all unexpectedly, that when darwin-faithers use the term "design" or "purpose" or "function" when speaking of organs/organelles/systems that those terms are merely "andropromorphic".
OK, of course they are "andorpromorphic". But not like "the sea is angry" because in said phrase, many other alternative terms could be used such as "the sea was rough."
When I think of "design" in the sense of constructing something that has a purpose, through some process that goes on in the mind, I think of something that only a human can do. A waterfall may be said to design a hole, but that is an unnecessary anthropomorphistic use of the term because we are not forced to use the term for lack of another better term. A stream of electrons may make a hole in a foil for the same reason a waterfall makes a hole. If the stream were aimed for a purpose, then it would be "design", otherwise it would be the consequence of physical law. ...Reminding you here that the question of whether physical law is designed, is the origin of the top of this thread.
So the word "design" is used, not capriciously anthropomorphically, but rather out of necessity. Humans design. Human's tools design by direction of the human. But what ELSE designs? If you say nothing else (yet - just wait, though), then I believe you are saying that "life has no purpose."
So, "which should we believe?" That the designer of life is some un-named designer, out there somewhere? or the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution? You believe that the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution but you would not use the term "design". You would use the term that means "unfold". Well that implies that it was predestined to unfold and therefore had a purpose. Yet you deny "purpose". What is this purposeless "thing" that is at the center of evolution that does the evolving? All I've gotten is "chance" or "randomness" from some of you.
I know, I know. "Purpose" is an illusion. If we weren't here then we wouldn't be suffering from the illusion, but obviously, we are here, and since we are here, we ... Its like a bullseye drawn around the arrow after it...
Yes, I've backed off of believing that the idea of evolution has it. For source of new complexity, I think it is missing something so big that I'll join the club again when someone discovers that 'missing something'. I happen to believe it plausible that the missing something is NOT LOCAL.