Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

See ? This is what I was talking about. You just conjure up this idea, and expect it to stand the test of time, without evidence or research on your part... and yet you attack darwinism, which HAS stood the test of time by GATHERING evidence. You don't seem to know what evolution is at all.
See previous post about panspermia.org. I cannot take credit for all the conjuring (actually I would allow "conjecturing" if you please). I know what the idea of evolution is, and I've moved on to more plausible ideas, thank you.
 
Origins of what? The Universe? I'll grant you that. Life? Not a chance. That's entirely within he purview of science.


No. The post was about using the Anthropic Principle as support for Intelligent Design. Doesn't work, of course, because Intelligent Design doesn't match the evidence. Doesn't matter what impressive-sounding philosophical arguments you muster to your side; it doesn't match the evidence.
I well understand Pixy that you have darwin-faith. Evolution is extremely political and you have faith about evolution being "entirely within [t]he purview of science." You and I disagree on whether origins of life are such as you say. Since we may have common ground on the point that origins of pre-biotic matter and natural laws have no 'scientific' theory, what kinds of things do you think about with regard to that?

BTW, you misunderstood a few things about what I said in previous discussion with drfrank about eyes. I hope to have time to respond more to you soon. For now I'll comment: I do not misunderstand the blind spot. I was saying there may be advantage to the vertebrata eye design that you and I may not have thought of - I proposed attenuation. Also, I brought up stars because single photons from stars can be detected by the retina. Not bad for what drfrank says is incompetent design. That was the drift on stars. In that post you seemed to have started with quoting drfrank and rebutting him (see word "bodged") where you thought it was my quote?

Oh, and you think my philosophical arguments are "impressive sounding"? Why, thank you pixy. But I still feel like you are ... like.... mad at me. ...The way you just say "No" to a sentence where I'm proposing a thought experiment. When I say to consider thinking about such and such... the choice is yours ... you can ignore it, but I'm amused the way you "just say no".
 
Philosophy ? Science is doing a much better job of finding answers to the same questions. Philosophy, in my view, is obsolete.

Science = the philosophy of science. Science is a subset of philosophy. Doesn't matter - it's academic.

OK Belz, I understand why you believe what you believe. Read John Hogan's "The End of Science". Mr. Hogan used to be editor of SciAm. It is an excellent read just from the interviews with the big guns - really good. ...though you can draw your own conclusions. Hogan, who is a journalist BTW, not a scientist, makes the point that science has reduced to being like literary critique (read "subjective"). BTW, Hogan is probably a so-called-skeptic.

Science can only find answers for 'natural' things. If all things are natural things then OK. But if you are sure all things are natural, then you take that on faith.

In mathematics, there are:
Provable truths.
Unprovable truths.
Provable falsehoods.
Unprovable falsehoods.

In science, we have the same thing but substitute something for "provable" with something like "testible".

Do you disagree with this or do you consider untestible things to 'not exist'?
 
Well, there is a Bill Gates/God similarity...you know, the desire to control everything and crush all competition...

:D
Interesting. What if there are competing intelligent designers? Multiple intelligent designers is not at all implausible to me.
 
The universe is complex ? Not really. What evolved "naturally" is far less complex than the things we've created since the dawn of civilization. Why would we assume that humans are unable to invent physical laws ? I can do that right now.
You say "[the universe is] not really [complex]". Belz, you must be the Intelligent Designer yourself.

Your physical laws you "invented" are "mathematical", not physical. If you can invent new physical laws, put your money where your mouth is and write the paper. Name one thing that you think evolved naturally that is less complex than anything a human has created. Do you think an electron is less complex than Windows XP? Prove it! Do we have a complete math model for a molecule as simple as h20? I don't think so. Maybe we have an electronic model for an hydrogen atom that is very good, but by the time you add two more atoms how accurate do you think it represents reality? Also, do we have a complete model of the nucleus? Maybe for the weak nuclear force we have a pretty good model, but for the strong nuclear? Now, of course the toughest part... the gravitational model of the subatomic particles! ZIP!



Now, now, Von. If our mathematical models represent the physical laws the way they work, why would you assume that these laws are in any way more complex than the model ?
Our math models represent our THEORY of how things work. Perhaps one of you grad physicists can tell us what is the most complete theory we have. The derivation of the fine structure constant by QED theory is impressive. Our supercomputers can calculate it beyond what we can test in the lab so how do we know if it is complete? Yes, I assume the models we have are generally incomplete. I assume you believe at least SOME of them are incomplete, right?



Randomness is the simplest thing you can imagine, Von. That's the beauty of it. If it obeyed some form of law, then it wouldn't be random.
If I were pixy, I would slam you for saying the things you say. But I will be polite. Randomness is not the simplest thing, it is the most complex - a random string of symbols contains infinite information - by definition of 'information'. Now maybe some will argue what is the definition of 'complex' - OK. But surely random means max info.

You say randomness doesn't obey some form of law? Hmmmmm. I'd say the most classic physical example of pure randomness is subatomic particle emission. Like ..the isotope of X has a half-life of Y - OK? If I get lots of isotope X, it emits the expected particle with a half-life of Y. Predictable as all get out. You can bank on it. So isotope X doesn't have the equivalent of some algorithm? .. some set of gears, pulleys, or some vibrating string in dimension n? How do you propose that it is predictable without any underlying law? I'm confused how can you utter such extreme positivism on one hand and be so non-determinist on the other?

Perhaps you are only familiar with an ideal concept of randomness that you learned in statistics 101?

No. Omnipotent means "can do anything". Within the confines of this universe, I don't see how one could do the physically impossible. Now, if you're asking about the physically possible, then whatever can be done, humans can do.
OK. I used the term omnipotent only because some so-called-skeptic used the term. I agree - so I retract the term. But you aren't at all of the mindset I could relate to. I was speaking of something that evolved from humans having great power, not humans themselves - I thought you darwin-faithers believed in obsolesence of h.sapiens. Sorry - I stereotyped you as I find everyone is fond of doing with me, on this forum. So I'll try to remember that Belz doesn't believe that man will have to evolve to be god-like; Belz believes man is already, with no upgrades, able to figure all this stuff out and do anything that is possible in this universe - someday. I have it right?
 
Common creationist ploy. I assume you've been saying this because you've never been sick with some ridiculous human biological malfunction. If the design is perfect, how do you explain cancer, allergy, ingrown nails ? Those are simplistic, idiotic failures of what should be a perfect, god-designed organism. My computer crashes once in a while, but rebooting usually solves the problem in no time. No biological organism comes even close.
JEEEZ Belz, go back and read what I said. I didn't say design is perfect. I said just the opposite. If I wasn't clear enough, let me try again: My point is that, speaking for myself, I can believe that things are designed, and that said things are not all perfect. I likened it to human design which is not perfect. But I thought 'incompetent' is severe. Are the natural laws incompetently designed? Is the carbon atom imperfect? How would you know?

I just love it when laypeople think they know better than specialists. My mother does that all the time. Funny thing, really.
Blez, if you haven't picked your major yet, I propose mathematics for you.

That wasn't the point. You ARE aware that the human eye has a blindspot, right ? That's due to the inexplicable fact, from a design standpoint, that the "wires" of the retina's cells pass in FRONT of the retina before bundling up and shooting THROUGH the retina to the brain. What kind of an idiotic designer would do this ? The wires should, obviously, pass BEHIND the retina so as to prevent this. This is perfectly explainable by natural selection but ridiculous if you assume design.
The blood service is in front as well as the nerves, yes. This is sophomoric. Why do so-called-skeptics think this stuff is so hard to understand and that those who disagree don't have the facts. ITS BECAUSE I DISAGREE WITH YOUR INTERPRETATION (in upper case so you don't miss it). You do not KNOW that it is a ridiculous design, Blez.

BUT, on the otherhand, it does not shatter my own concept of intelligent design if the vertebrate eye has no advantage due to its 'backward' retina. I have some really backwards code that I wrote that works so well that I've never gone back to change it. Also, nobody ever said my design was idiotic, either.

So, why does the IDer have to be PERFECT? I don't believe the IDer has to be perfect. As Heisenberg is alleged to have said on his death bed "I'm going to ask God two questions: why relativity, and why turbulence. I think he might have an answer for the first question."

Perhaps relativity and turbulence ARE perfect and we are too dumb to see it. Perhaps the vertebrate eye is perfect and we are too dumb to realize it.
 
......this is...did you just...what were you...sputter...ack........There's approximately zero evidence to support this fanciful idea.
I told everybody I knew about my idea that viruses were a transverse (horizontal rather than descent) mode of genetic transfer, a long time ago. But it was not my field and so I told a bunch of people who didn't care. I thought transverse genetic transfer would be a great accelerator to evolution. Years later, I finally read in my local newspaper that science had come up with the same idea. I would not be surprised if George Gamov et al had the same idea when viruses were first discovered to invade the reproductive machinery of the cell. Being highly unorthodox, and being non-darwinistic, I guess it took a long time to catch on. Finally, in the late 90s you start to see a lot of reference to transverse genetic transfer via viruses. So, at least this concept is already pretty established in science.

Francis Crick, who I think some of you may agree is a 'scientist', proposed that genes were pre-fabed some place far far away and propulsed here on purpose, to seed the earth. He called it 'directed panspermia'. His reasons were that he did not see sufficient evidence of darwinistic evolution on earth unless all the microbes were prefabed and everything sort of self-assembled from those initial ingredients. Fanciful? yes. I think Cricke's idea of what is the intelligent designer was some alien race. ...begs the question of where they came from, of course. But I think it is important to realize that the Father of DNA, Cricke, doubted RM/NS could be wholly responsible for life origins here on earth.

Anyway, give it a chance... go delve into panspermia.org.
 
I well understand Pixy that you have darwin-faith.
No.

Evolution is extremely political
No.

and you have faith about evolution being "entirely within [t]he purview of science."
No. It's not a question of faith, it's a question of definitions. The origin of life is within the purview of science.

You and I disagree on whether origins of life are such as you say.
So?

Since we may have common ground on the point that origins of pre-biotic matter and natural laws have no 'scientific' theory
No.

what kinds of things do you think about with regard to that?
Eh? Ask something meaningful and I'll answer.

BTW, you misunderstood a few things about what I said in previous discussion with drfrank about eyes. I hope to have time to respond more to you soon. For now I'll comment: I do not misunderstand the blind spot.
Well, I'd hope not, now that so many people have explained it to you.

I was saying there may be advantage to the vertebrata eye design that you and I may not have thought of - I proposed attenuation.
Which is in and of itself baloney. UV rays can damage the retina, but UV rays are blocked by the cornea and the lens. Your argument is without merit.

Also, I brought up stars because single photons from stars can be detected by the retina. Not bad for what drfrank says is incompetent design.
It has no bearing on the problems with the eye.

That was the drift on stars. In that post you seemed to have started with quoting drfrank and rebutting him (see word "bodged") where you thought it was my quote?
Right. Learn to quote.

Oh, and you think my philosophical arguments are "impressive sounding"?
Yours? Ha! :) Other people's may sound impressive. They are largely without merit, though. Yours sound absurd, and are without merit.

Why, thank you pixy. But I still feel like you are ... like.... mad at me.
Oh, no, not at all. This is me being nice.

...The way you just say "No" to a sentence where I'm proposing a thought experiment.
Yep.

That's shorthand for "What you have said is only wrong where it manages to be coherent. It contradicts itself where it does not stumble into meaninglessness. It ignores all prior argument, and misses facts that are obvious to every five-year-old. The spelling and grammar are atrocious, the formatting... unique. Grown philosophers clutch at their heads in despair when you enter a debate."

You can see why I just say "No".

When I say to consider thinking about such and such... the choice is yours ... you can ignore it, but I'm amused the way you "just say no".
No.
 
I'm not taking credit for this idea. It belongs to Hoyle, Crick, and a few other high profile thinkers. Go see panspermia.org where Klyce Brigg has done an excellent job of presenting the idea.
This has been around for decades, yes. And there is no evidence supporting it. None whatsoever. Zip. Zero. Zilch.

Again, you so-called-skeptics seem sort of dry when it comes to thinking outside the box.
No.

The best science has come from the brave renegades.
No.

Don't let me make you feel defensive.
Oh, you needn't worry about that.

You already know that is what you all dream of being able to do - come up with something truly revolutionary.
No. We want to be right. Anyone can be revolutionary and wrong; that's easy.

THAT is my best emotional plea to you about darwinism being a tired old idea.
It's neither tired nor old, but that is irrelevant anyway. The point is that it is correct. New ideas full of vim and vigour are no good to us when they are wrong.

Let yourself release yourself from that bond.
Bond? You mean, our demand for evidence?

See? I'm not trying to tell you to go to church. That's your business.
:rolleyes:

BTW, if you think this idea is wild, maybe over a beer, I'll tell you what I really think...
It's not wild. It's just wrong.
 
Your physical laws you "invented" are "mathematical", not physical. If you can invent new physical laws, put your money where your mouth is and write the paper. Name one thing that you think evolved naturally that is less complex than anything a human has created. Do you think an electron is less complex than Windows XP? Prove it!
Quantum Electrodynamics.

Do we have a complete math model for a molecule as simple as h20? I don't think so.
You don't think so?

Maybe we have an electronic model for an hydrogen atom that is very good, but by the time you add two more atoms how accurate do you think it represents reality?
Extremely accurately.

Also, do we have a complete model of the nucleus? Maybe for the weak nuclear force we have a pretty good model, but for the strong nuclear?
Yes.

Now, of course the toughest part... the gravitational model of the subatomic particles! ZIP!
Completely wrong. We have a valid and extremely accurate gravitational model of subatomic particles. Where do you get your ideas from? It's as though you read the headlines in New Scientist but never bothered to read any of the articles.

Yes, I assume the models we have are generally incomplete. I assume you believe at least SOME of them are incomplete, right?
Yes. And?

If I were pixy, I would slam you for saying the things you say. But I will be polite. Randomness is not the simplest thing, it is the most complex - a random string of symbols contains infinite information - by definition of 'information'. Now maybe some will argue what is the definition of 'complex' - OK. But surely random means max info.
No.

You say randomness doesn't obey some form of law? Hmmmmm. I'd say the most classic physical example of pure randomness is subatomic particle emission. Like ..the isotope of X has a half-life of Y - OK? If I get lots of isotope X, it emits the expected particle with a half-life of Y. Predictable as all get out. You can bank on it. So isotope X doesn't have the equivalent of some algorithm?
No.

some set of gears, pulleys, or some vibrating string in dimension n?
:rolleyes: Your lack of understanding disturbs me.

How do you propose that it is predictable without any underlying law?
Simple: It isn't.

I'm confused how can you utter such extreme positivism on one hand and be so non-determinist on the other?
Because that's the way things are.

Perhaps you are only familiar with an ideal concept of randomness that you learned in statistics 101?
:confused:

You have some other concept of randomness than that taught in statistics? Non-random randomness, maybe?
 
I well understand Pixy that you have darwin-faith. Evolution is extremely political and you have faith about evolution being "entirely within [t]he purview of science."

You got that entirely bass ackwards.
Understanding evolution has nothing to do with faith.
Evolution is entirely non-political. Anti-evolutionoids - creationists/IDers - are pushing the discussion into the political arena.
Your claim of 'well understanding' is disproved within the same sentence.
 
In the lexicon of the so-called-skeptics I find the word "strawman" too often and unhelpful. I am telling you what I think. I assume it may differ from what you think but I am not disingenous when I project to you an idea.

You created a strawman version of the theory of evolution where birds would be expected to be genetically closer to fish than we are, and then pointed out it was wrong, thus disproving evolution. Since birds have also been evolving all the time we have, equidistance of both our genetic structures from our common fish ancestor woulc be expected by Evolution. Perhaps you hear "strawman" so often because you use them so often ;)

Oh, and panspermia.org appears to regurgitate all the bog-standard Creationist anti-evolution arguments with a slightly different spin. The section on thermodynamics, while pointing out some of the misunderstandings between the different meanings of entropy, nevertheless trots out the old "complexity cannot increase" canard. Also, if most of your arguments have come from there, then the accuracy of the rest of the information is also pretty dubious. From another random page:

Nevertheless, computer scientists are confident that an unquestionable demonstration of evolutionary progress in artificial life is imminent, because they think they are only trying to model a phenomenon already proven in biology. Many biologists, on the other hand, are under the impression that computer models have already corroborated evolutionary progress in a closed system.

Sorry, but that's just Grade A bullcrap. Lies (and they are demonstrably lies) like that have been trotted out by Cretinists for years to try and make the evidence behind evolution seem shaky.

You may not be disingenuous, but all you've done so far in this discussion, correct me if I'm wrong, is make flawed arguments against evolution and then pose an arbitrary hypothesis with absolutely no supporting evidence. It may seem intriguing, but that does not make it right.

I have no problem with the basic panspermia idea, in which basic self-replicating life was originally arrived from outer space. I don't believe the evidence is in its favour, but it's not completely bonkers. The "strong" panspermia, stuff, is pretty blatantly flat-out pseudoscience, indicated by their tendency to use completely discredited arguments.

The case for Cosmic Ancestry is not yet proven, of course. At this point the best reason to notice it is that sustained evolutionary progress and the origin of life on Earth are not satisfactorily accounted for by Darwinism.

Bring on those good ol' Creationism arguments...
 
Last edited:
See previous post about panspermia.org. I cannot take credit for all the conjuring (actually I would allow "conjecturing" if you please). I know what the idea of evolution is, and I've moved on to more plausible ideas, thank you.

Plausible ? Where are your credentials to toss aside that theory so easily ? You remind me of my mother, always thinking that, from your lay position, you can judge all those pesky specialists and their data and their evidence and declare, because you can't accept it, that the theory on which theyhave spent the last 150 years is bunk.
 
Science can only find answers for 'natural' things. If all things are natural things then OK. But if you are sure all things are natural, then you take that on faith.

Wrong. Science ASSUMES that all things are natural. So far, it's been correct. There is no extant, known event that does not fit into the realm of the natural.

And don't presume to know WHY I "believe" in science or evolution. The only reason why I side with any theory or hypothesis is EVIDENCE, a word you should be familiar with.
 
Your physical laws you "invented" are "mathematical", not physical. If you can invent new physical laws, put your money where your mouth is and write the paper.

Pfft. I've invented THREE different fantasy settings so far, Von. I know of at least ONE from JRR Tolkien and ONE from George Lucas... etc. People can invent worlds and their physical laws. That's all I'm saying. The point was that you claimed that this was impossible. It clearly isn't.

Name one thing that you think evolved naturally that is less complex than anything a human has created.

Let's see. A photon vs a disposable facial tissue. There, I win. The tissue contains photons.

Do you think an electron is less complex than Windows XP? Prove it!

That's ridiculous and immature of you. first off, and electron is, basically, mass, charge and spin. Do you REALLY want me to enumerate the functions of Windows XP ?

Now... I'm sure you're going to say that we have no idea how complex electrons are, but really this defeats your purpose, because it would assume that electrons are composed of other and, of course, SIMPLER particles.

Do we have a complete math model for a molecule as simple as h20? I don't think so. Maybe we have an electronic model for an hydrogen atom that is very good, but by the time you add two more atoms how accurate do you think it represents reality? Also, do we have a complete model of the nucleus? Maybe for the weak nuclear force we have a pretty good model, but for the strong nuclear? Now, of course the toughest part... the gravitational model of the subatomic particles! ZIP!

Arguments from incredility and ignorance. No points there, Von.

Allright, Pixy, please tell Von what he DIDN'T win.

If I were pixy, I would slam you for saying the things you say. But I will be polite. Randomness is not the simplest thing, it is the most complex - a random string of symbols contains infinite information - by definition of 'information'. Now maybe some will argue what is the definition of 'complex' - OK. But surely random means max info.

Who said anything about an infinitely long random string of symbols ? I was talking about a singularity: something with no mass, no energy per se, no laws, no form, no dimension. Now, aside from NOTHING, what could POSSIBLY be simpler ? I don't think you're aware of what complexity means.

You say randomness doesn't obey some form of law? Hmmmmm. I'd say the most classic physical example of pure randomness is subatomic particle emission. Like ..the isotope of X has a half-life of Y - OK? If I get lots of isotope X, it emits the expected particle with a half-life of Y. Predictable as all get out. You can bank on it.

We're not talking about the same random. You're talking about the practically random, I'm talking about true, absolute chaos. Read up on singularities and quantum foam fluctuations, please.

I thought you darwin-faithers believed in obsolesence of h.sapiens. Sorry - I stereotyped you as I find everyone is fond of doing with me, on this forum. So I'll try to remember that Belz doesn't believe that man will have to evolve to be god-like; Belz believes man is already, with no upgrades, able to figure all this stuff out and do anything that is possible in this universe - someday. I have it right?

The laws of physics are FINITE. It's no stretch of the imagination to think our little technological tools will be able to utilise them fully some time in the future. Not humans, per se, mind you. Their tools.

Then again, I'm not omniscient. But then again, that doesn't give you the right to posit some god-of-the-gaps to fill the holes in my knowledge.
 
Blez, if you haven't picked your major yet, I propose mathematics for you.

Speaking my name in reverse does not make me dissapear, like in "the warlock".

The blood service is in front as well as the nerves, yes. This is sophomoric. Why do so-called-skeptics think this stuff is so hard to understand and that those who disagree don't have the facts. ITS BECAUSE I DISAGREE WITH YOUR INTERPRETATION (in upper case so you don't miss it).

So... let me get this straight. You admit that, if designed, the human eye is POORLY designed, and yet you claim that, although it is perfectly understandable from an evolution standpoint that such a flawed design would exist, an invisible, supernatural Incompetent Designer made it anyway ? You're digging a deeper hole for yourself by the minute.

You do not KNOW that it is a ridiculous design, Blez.

It won't work even if you say it three times, like in "Beetlejuice."

BUT, on the otherhand, it does not shatter my own concept of intelligent design if the vertebrate eye has no advantage due to its 'backward' retina. I have some really backwards code that I wrote that works so well that I've never gone back to change it. Also, nobody ever said my design was idiotic, either.

Maybe not, but if EVERYTHING you did exhibited this level of competence, we'd be justified in saying you're not a very good designer.

So, why does the IDer have to be PERFECT? I don't believe the IDer has to be perfect. As Heisenberg is alleged to have said on his death bed "I'm going to ask God two questions: why relativity, and why turbulence. I think he might have an answer for the first question."

So... you believe in an imperfect God ?
 
So... you believe in an imperfect God ?
Isn't that an oxymoron? Unless one believes in a pantheon of gods who were petty, scheming, bickering and all too human (much like the Roman, Greek, or Norse gods) doesn't belief in God pretty much require belief in that God's perfection?
 
Isn't that an oxymoron? Unless one believes in a pantheon of gods who were petty, scheming, bickering and all too human (much like the Roman, Greek, or Norse gods) doesn't belief in God pretty much require belief in that God's perfection?

I think VonNeumann is more driving towards Space Aliens/Time Travellers From The Future (tm) rather a classical notion of God, in which case the idea of imperfection isn't unreasonable.
 
[C]are to present any positive evidence for this claim i.e. not a strawman critique of evolutionary theory?
I'm not taking credit for this idea. It belongs to Hoyle, Crick, and a few other high profile thinkers. Go see panspermia.org where Klyce Brigg has done an excellent job of presenting the idea.

So, rather than present evidence for the theory you have advanced, you now say "well, it wasn't really my idea." Evasion noted.

Again, you so-called-skeptics seem sort of dry when it comes to thinking outside the box. The best science has come from the brave renegades. Don't let me make you feel defensive. You already know that is what you all dream of being able to do - come up with something truly revolutionary.

Emphasis mine. It may be true that much good science has come from "brave renegades". However, they all had one thing on their side that you lack: EVIDENCE!

Also, there were plenty of "brave renegades" who were plain wrong. Velikovsky, Pons and Fleischmann, etc., etc.

THAT is my best emotional plea to you about darwinism being a tired old idea. Let yourself release yourself from that bond. See? I'm not trying to tell you to go to church. That's your business.

BTW, if you think this idea is wild, maybe over a beer, I'll tell you what I really think...

So you need alcohol to believe it? :p
 
Speaking my name in reverse does not make me dissapear, like in "the warlock".



So... let me get this straight. You admit that, if designed, the human eye is POORLY designed, and yet you claim that, although it is perfectly understandable from an evolution standpoint that such a flawed design would exist, an invisible, supernatural Incompetent Designer made it anyway ? You're digging a deeper hole for yourself by the minute.



It won't work even if you say it three times, like in "Beetlejuice."



Maybe not, but if EVERYTHING you did exhibited this level of competence, we'd be justified in saying you're not a very good designer.



So... you believe in an imperfect God ?

In my huge amount of posts in just a matter of less than two weeks, you will notice if you look, that I've NEVER said I believe in God. The subject matter here, I thought was ID and that origin of natural laws is probably a better domain for pro-ID argument. That being said, and I have NOT read all the posts so maybe someone already answered "Is the carbon atom an imperfect design?".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom