Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I posted a fairly airtight case of human and ape common ancestry earlier on in the thread without any acknowledgement that it was strong evidence supporting evolution, so I'm not holding my breath for a sensible discussion ;)

And the only response I got was from you DF! I'll paraphrase and throw it out again... Can anyone tell me why we should care about a simulator or any sort of less-than-perfect designer? If we have physical, non-evolutionary origins, won't that be shown by science? And if we have supernatural origins, doesn't a less-than-perfect designer (or simulator) just leave a bunch of unanswered questions?

Anyway, DF, we can have our own discussion! My anatomy grad-school friend claims that any anti-evo claim that evo is not supported by the fossil record is using 40-year-old data. Discuss.
 
Anyway, DF, we can have our own discussion! My anatomy grad-school friend claims that any anti-evo claim that evo is not supported by the fossil record is using 40-year-old data. Discuss.

Obviously untrue. See Answers in Genesis for a counterexample.

Instead, in true creationist fashion, they simply misinterpret the fossil record. E.g.

The first obvious inconsistency came to mind while looking at the evidence for feathers. Sinosauropterxy prima had what appears to be a dark fuzzy outline surrounding the bones, apparently interpreted as the trace of hair-like filaments. I must confess that it looked much like the shading artists will often do around pencil drawings to emphasize the outline of an important object. The guidebook describes these ‘proto-feathers’ as feather-like structures. It explains that they appear as impressions in the fine-grained matrix or as a halo of darker, fibrous-like areas, usually at right angles to the bones, although not always contacting them. Certainly this evidence is vague. Did some dinosaur have a furry coating, or is this ‘fuzz’ just an artefact of the preservation or recovery process?

Caudipteryx (‘Caudi’, as Dr Willis affectionately nicknamed it) showed some long fibrous-looking traces in the area of the tail, similar to fossils of thin reed-like plants. To claim that they are feathers is clearly a statement of faith in a worldview, not a scientific observation.
 
And the only response I got was from you DF! I'll paraphrase and throw it out again... Can anyone tell me why we should care about a simulator or any sort of less-than-perfect designer? If we have physical, non-evolutionary origins, won't that be shown by science? And if we have supernatural origins, doesn't a less-than-perfect designer (or simulator) just leave a bunch of unanswered questions?

Anyway, DF, we can have our own discussion! My anatomy grad-school friend claims that any anti-evo claim that evo is not supported by the fossil record is using 40-year-old data. Discuss.

Definitely - most of the anti-evolution claims are ones which were created by the Creationists in the 60s and never been updated, as who cares about evidence?

A good example of this is "all the hominid fossils found would fit in a shoebox": although this may have been true at the time, thousands of hominid fossils have since been collected.
 
Obviously untrue. See Answers in Genesis for a counterexample.

Instead, in true creationist fashion, they simply misinterpret the fossil record. E.g.

lol I like our completely polar reactions ;) OK, they do use some new material on occasion but they certainly love referring to age-old articles.

For my money, Answers in Genesis is probably the most sane Creation site around (a very relative term, obviously) - they're the only one I've ever seen point out errors in common Creationist arguments.
 
Instead, in true creationist fashion, they simply misinterpret the fossil record. E.g.

Frustrating to me is my complete and utter lack of knowledge in biology. Frankly, my knowledge of physics could be said to be limited, but not to the same degree. I can at least recognize the errors that first-year students might make (like the guy who claims that dt/dt = 1 proves that time travel can't happen by definition :boggled:, and that Einstein, Hawking et al are frauds :rolleyes: (posted on /. yesterday) ).

I must trust that the PhDs in various biological sciences (anatomy, paleobiology, etc.) know their craft in the same manner that physicists know theirs. The arguments, in some cases, start to get pretty sophistimacated, and I can immediately see how a lay person would be misled. Scientific 'sounding' arguments can be overwhelming (hence the championing of Behe as an ID proponent). It's only when arguments start violating elementary physical principles that I'm back on home turf, but...

Not a single professor has told me where physical principles come from! There is a hole for ID... I'm not sure that it rests at biology. I'm also not sure that many of them would be satisfied by the simulation explanation.

Oh, and as for some sort of life engineer? I can confidently say, "they made us, because it's COOOL!" There's your meaning of life from imperfect designers... Us: Why did you make us? Them: Because it was cool... an engineer's creed :D .
 
Jimbo07;1436709 Not a single professor has told me [i said:
where[/i] physical principles come from! There is a hole for ID... I'm not sure that it rests at biology. I'm also not sure that many of them would be satisfied by the simulation explanation.

I doubt they will ever be able to do this to the satisfaction of the creationists. The whole point of asking about "where something comes from" is to explain a phenomenon in terms of other, more fundamental phenomena. I can tell you what atoms are made of (protons and neutrons), but that simply poses another question about what those are made of (quarks), and what, in turn those are made of, and.... If I told you that quarks were made up of snarks and boojums, would that actually satisfy people looking for the Ultimate Answer?

However, if the only "hole" left for ID is truly in the fundamental principles -- exactly why Planck's constant is the value it is -- then there's really not much to ID in the sense in which Behe and Dembski promote it. After all, if you accept the Dover testimony -- even the testimony of the defendants -- the central claim of ID is the "sudden emergence" of fully-formed life forms ("fish with fins, birds with feathers") and that "evolution" (meaning mostly the theory of common descent) is false.

If the only evidence for God (or a cleverly unspecified "Designer") is really in the fundamental (and therefore by definition inexplicable, which means "Goddidit" doesn't really explain anything anyway) constants of the universe, then that directly implies that the theory of common descent, without involving God, is an accurate description of the universe.

Which means that Behe and Dembski are still wrong, and the IDers are barking up completely the wrong tree.

Not that that would surprise me much.
 
Which means that Behe and Dembski are still wrong, and the IDers are barking up completely the wrong tree.

Not that that would surprise me much.

My 'fundamentalism' as it were, without knowing sweet squat about biology is that biology (and all other sciences) follow (through some as yet unravelled (and potentially unresolvable) paths) from physics. Put less assertively, anything which can be felt to be even loosely constrained by physical principle should be considered natural. In all other realms except the deity (see Randi's commentary), there appears to be a lack of evidence for interaction between the natural and supernatural. I make the 'faith-based' jump that then says, "the deity doesn't 'tweak' organisms, physically, as they go along.

So yes, my feeling is that Behe, Dembski, the Discovery Institute etc. are on the wrong path right from the start, right out of the gate. I have also asserted that simulation (imperfect creation) ideas are problematic, right from the underpinnings, so that even if I can't follow every biological argument (and so far I have...), those theorists still have some explaining to do.

But... how can mighty PhDs be so wrong about science, and I be right? My guess is that they're going for notoriety...
 
But... how can mighty PhDs be so wrong about science, and I be right? My guess is that they're going for notoriety...

And also, they're often talking about areas outside of their expertise.

My understanding is that Behe, in particular, is -- or was at some point -- a competent biochemist. His work on molecular genetics from the late 1970s and early 1980s is quite good and includes papers in high-level journals such as Proc. NAS and J. Mol. Biol..

I suspect, however, that as a professional trombone player, he would suck.

And as an evolutionary biologist, he's no better than I or you. In fact, quite the reverse, as far as I can tell.

Dembski is a little different -- his primary training and specialization is in mathematics, and as far as I can tell it's incompetent in his primary field as well.
 
And also, they're often talking about areas outside of their expertise.

Agreed.

Even the conversation of senior undergrads and new grad students starts to evolve. The conversations tend to frame the world more-and-more in terms of what they 'know.'

* guilty *

:o
 
Define what you mean by that, and I will answer the question.
What do I mean by 'what is mathematics?' We all know what the term means academically. So what am I asking? I am asking what you surely have asked yourself, before, I would presume. I think Einstein said 'the old one is a mathematician'. There is immense order to the physical world and this faculty we have with modeling via the 'language' of math is maybe what we could say is 'fortunate'. But I am asking the question, beyond that we have this faculty of mathematics, this language, does it have an existence of its own? I would predict that you would say that it has no existence on its own. Perhaps you would say, as I have, that it only has existence in a 'mind'. Define 'mind'? For now, I'll say it is the thing we have where we do math. Do other things have 'minds'? If I will take ID seriously, which I have come to entertain, then the ID will have to be done in something similar to this thing we possess, called 'mind'. So what I am asking you, and I also ask you to interpret my question in a context of your own paradigm if you cannot make literal sense of it, 'besides its definition as a branch in academics, or as a formal system extrapolated upon basic logic, or as a 'language', is there a more fundamental existence for 'mathematics'? ...not a trick question - just a curious question.

Why do you think minds are formal systems?
Actually, that was John Lucas' argument - his premise. I will have to read the essay again (after many years) and see the whole argument again. Perhaps that is the counter-argument? ... and here I believe the system incompasses more than the mind but the whole reality - the argument would be that the physical universe (nor a human mind within the physical universe) is not a formal system?

Ah, that. Penrose doesn't know what he is talking about.
..seems a rather global condemnation, to me. What is it mainly about ENM about which you find he "doesn't know"?

It's not a question of "old school", it's a question of relevance. The Incompleteness Theorem points out a fundamental and inescapable limitation of formal systems. If minds were formal systems, then they are subject to the same limit. But they aren't.
A neural network model running on a digital computer is a formal system. I have come to understand that it is not uncommonly believed by Strong-AI-ers that a conscious mind may emerge from a sufficiently complex neural network synthesized in an digital computer. So where am I incorrect: that such synthesis would not be a formal system; or, that a conscious mind could never emerge from such a synthesis?

They're virtual photons. In a mathematical model.
I can understand that the virtual photons are so-called for the reason that they convey intra-particle information, but are not directly detected with humanly devised instruments (did I say that to your satisfaction?).

I need to read up on virtual photons. Are information-packets labeled virtual only when they are non-relativistic? Otherwise, they are labeled "photons"?


Quantum computation can produce approximations to extremely difficult combinatorial problems very quickly, but (a) they are approximations, and (b) the accuracy of the approximation is dependent on the processing time. So you may have a problem that would take a million years on a conventional supercomputer that could be calculated in a second on a small quantum computer... But the answer might be wrong.
What kind of problems could be solved with this? Could QC at least give us some ideas and then we could use more conventional ways to verify/falsify?


They most certainly cannot process anything instantaneously.
"Instantaneously" is an extreme boundary... OK, what if we say that the speed ratio K= 1MY/1s (from your preceding paragraph). That approximates to 10^14 times as fast as a supercomputer. Not instantaneous but a hell of an improvement. Maybe the computation time is infinitesmal but the transport time is finite (I/O bound):)
 
What do I mean by 'what is mathematics?'
No. What do you mean by "invent" and "discover" in the context of mathematics? What does "exist" mean in this context?

Actually, that was John Lucas' argument - his premise. I will have to read the essay again (after many years) and see the whole argument again. Perhaps that is the counter-argument? ... and here I believe the system incompasses more than the mind but the whole reality - the argument would be that the physical universe (nor a human mind within the physical universe) is not a formal system?
Yes.

..seems a rather global condemnation, to me.
Sorry, you are right. When Penrose is speaking of consciousness, he doesn't know what he is talking about. Geometry - sure. Mathematical physics - no worries. Consciousness he knows less about than the average Kalahari bushman.

What is it mainly about ENM about which you find he "doesn't know"?
It's an utter debasement of science.

Assumption: Consciousness is mystical.
Reasoning: Therefore it must have a mystical cause.
Counter: But I'm a scientist, so I can't just say that magic fairies did it.
Question: What else is sciency-sounding but mysterious?
Conclusion: Quantum gravity dunnit!

Utter baloney.

A neural network model running on a digital computer is a formal system.
Not exactly; it is an implementation of a formal system. This does mean that it has the same limitations as formal systems, of course.

I have come to understand that it is not uncommonly believed by Strong-AI-ers that a conscious mind may emerge from a sufficiently complex neural network synthesized in an digital computer.
Yes.

So where am I incorrect: that such synthesis would not be a formal system; or, that a conscious mind could never emerge from such a synthesis?
Neither.

Here's the point: The only examples of minds that we have a clearly not formal systems. But we have no reason to believe that minds cannot be formed from implementations of formal systems. In which case they would be subject to the Incompleteness Theorem.

The Incompleteness Theorem poses no problems whatsoever to the idea that minds are purely physical in origin, because we have no evidence whatsoever that minds are not subject to the Incompleteness Theorem.

I can understand that the virtual photons are so-called for the reason that they convey intra-particle information, but are not directly detected with humanly devised instruments (did I say that to your satisfaction?).
They're called virtual because they are not real.

I need to read up on virtual photons. Are information-packets labeled virtual only when they are non-relativistic? Otherwise, they are labeled "photons"?
Non-relativistic? :confused:

What kind of problems could be solved with this? Could QC at least give us some ideas and then we could use more conventional ways to verify/falsify?
Optimisation problems, like airline scheduling. And yes.

"Instantaneously" is an extreme boundary... OK, what if we say that the speed ratio K= 1MY/1s (from your preceding paragraph). That approximates to 10^14 times as fast as a supercomputer. Not instantaneous but a hell of an improvement. Maybe the computation time is infinitesmal but the transport time is finite (I/O bound):)
No.

Remember the other part: The accuracy is proportional to the time spent calculating the answer. The answer is only probabilistic, and if you spend only one second calculating it, it might very well be entirely wrong.
 
The Mandelbrot set is essentially recursive. Infinite in depth, yes, but certainly not normal in the way pi might be. But even that doesn't guarantee that there aren't recogniseable images of cats in the set.
Right - we could not verify 'no cats' without empirical infinite study. But we 'know' there are no cats. Never mind - doesn't matter. I get from everything you have said so far that whatever "chance" or "randomness" there exists as seminal and at the kernel of evolution, it is merely the simplest sort of randomness. You do not entertain that there is anything special about it?


I said:
"Then finally, how do we know that physical randomness, again, like particle emission, is not algorithmically generated."
Because that would be physically impossible.
Certainly the old deterministic universe idea is dead. The idea of "hidden variables" was discounted. But, do you believe it has been ruled out that the universe is not somehow 'numerical'? Before when I said the universe could be a simulation, not unlike our concept of a digital computer simulation, I'm sure that was too looney an idea to be taken seriously here. Ed Fredkin at MIT got a bit of notoriety (amongst others - more of late) from proposing these sorts of ideas. So did Frank Cantor of "Information Mechanics" get some (like almost zero) notice for thinking toward this paradigm. And, lately, Steve Wolfram, who I will guess is thinking the world is too stupid to understand his revelation, after coming out with his big fat magnus opus "A New Kind of Science" a couple years ago. So...I don't think I'm entirely alone, nor entirely on the fringe, to suggest that "real" randomness such as 'emission' (meaning the timing thereof) may have a hidden algorithmic source. You say it would be 'Physically impossible'. You have no model of what kind of mechanism could be at the source of the 'random timing' of the emission though, do you? No. So if you don't know what it IS, how can you be so certain of what it is NOT?
 
VonNeumann, A couple of comments and questions.

You're presenting the hypothesis that we're all part of a simulation created by an external programmer. What observations lead you to this hypothesis? The only thing I've seen so far is that the theory of evolution can't work on a macro level because unspecified specialists in the field say so. So then it must be a simulation? Please explain this somewhat farfetched conclusion.

In your argumentation the only references you give is to popularized literature so you're obviously a jack of all trades, specialist in none. Nothing wrong with that, I have shallow knowledge in many areas and that's the way I like it. It is a problem though when you fail to see that the knowledge you've gained from popularized science magazines and books doesn't enable you to dismiss and reject theories in specialized fields. It's like reading "A brief history of time" and claim to know how the universe came into being and how it works. If you want to be taken seriously here it would work better if you provide references to contemporary scientific articles that supports your case.

And this whole discussion would really fit better in Philosophy and religion. "Why" something works is a philosophical question. "How" it works is what science is trying to describe. Who knows, we're digging deeper and deeper into the fabric of space and time and eventually we might find that there is in fact a programmer, god or threeheaded unicorn that is making it all up. Come and mock me then.
The question: "Why" ...is philosophical, yes. But why not post "philosophy" here? This thread originated on the topic that origin of physical laws is a better domain for the pro-argument toward ID than origin of species. Is that Philosophy? Yes.

I might say I predict digging deeper into the fabric... we will find evidence that there is:
1. a numerical universe - we would call it a simulation.
2. programmer(s) of said simulation

Could be.

I don't think I am the only one, besides some science fiction writers, who have taken this idea to heart. The movie Matrix popularized the notion recently. I think the current younger generation will find this idea more palatable than the staid older ones because of all the RPG games etc etc.

I actually thought of the idea that "all there needs to be is information" when I was very young. It was a decade later before I found that others thought the same thing. I think I went through some sort of solipsistic theory of reality when I was only 9 years old. I've always been suspicious that things are much much stranger than they appear. At the same time I was a fossil collector and wanted to be a paleontologist - I was a darwin-faither from the time I was 8 years old and entirely from my own self-indoctrinatation, just from reading books. But when I was a little older, I realized physics and math are where you can actually do stuff and make stuff - so I abandoned the idea of being a paleontologist.

Now, that was just a bunch of unnecessary background. But where I used to believe that the universe was much as a computer, I did not think it needed a programmer. I thought that some sort of 'cellular automata' would self-organize. But somewhere along the way, I made the transition to doubting whether this 'simulation' had intrinsic capacity to self-organize.

I do have more. I think I have some unique ideas, some of which I have had for decades. Every time I saw a new book come out (like Kantor's "information mechanics" 1977), I would get it and look and see if anybody else had thought the same things. Now, of course, with the internet, this is easier to do. I see that some other people have some of the same ideas but I still have a few I have never seen anyone else come up with. I just don't think this forum is the place I want to debut my bottled up ideas.

So, your points are well taken. I probably should just get out of Dodge and go post my ideas in the form of Science Fiction, somewhere else.
 
Pixy, do you think Penrose ever recanted? I never read all of 'shadows of the mind' but thought he might be back peddling a little in that book.

By "Non-relativistic" I meant super-c velocity.
 
Right - we could not verify 'no cats' without empirical infinite study. But we 'know' there are no cats.
No we don't.

Never mind - doesn't matter. I get from everything you have said so far that whatever "chance" or "randomness" there exists as seminal and at the kernel of evolution, it is merely the simplest sort of randomness. You do not entertain that there is anything special about it?
Of course not.


I said:
"Then finally, how do we know that physical randomness, again, like particle emission, is not algorithmically generated."

...

You say it would be 'Physically impossible'. You have no model of what kind of mechanism could be at the source of the 'random timing' of the emission though, do you? No. So if you don't know what it IS, how can you be so certain of what it is NOT?
Because subatomic particles have no hair.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom