Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

How well does pure math apply to reality, anyway? I don't know but, to me, it is a more fundamental question than the question that started this thread (let me say that question is "were physical laws designed?"). ..or more than that... the question of 'what is mathematics?' is pretty tough. Did we invent math or did we discover it?
Define what you mean by that, and I will answer the question.

How do a mere few million nucleotides in our DNA make us able to mentally cruise through a world of math while a chimp cannot fathom the number 4.
They code for a significantly larger brain. Oh, and chimps can "fathom the number 4".

Was mathematics here or somewhere before there was a human mind?
Tell me what the question means, and I will tell you the answer.

What I made reference to tries to apply the concept of a formal system to something like the mind.
Why do you think minds are formal systems?

I brought it up in context of a universal simulation (as a computer program) which would be a formal system by definition.
If it is purely algorithmic and its input is entirely deterministic, yes. Neither one is necessary, of course.

Also, I maybe got some ideas about it by reading Penrose's "Emperor's New Mind".
Ah, that. Penrose doesn't know what he is talking about.

What is it about minds? My personal thought is that 'mind' is not entirely Mechanism (as Lucas said for Godelian reasons) and that creation of new information must be done 'in a mind'.
And why do you think that?

Of course, you are probably in good company if you dismiss Godellian relevance to any of this. It is probably 'old school'.
It's not a question of "old school", it's a question of relevance. The Incompleteness Theorem points out a fundamental and inescapable limitation of formal systems. If minds were formal systems, then they are subject to the same limit. But they aren't.

Bringing up QED again: when I say something about outside the universe, I think that there is some evidence, at least to my way of thinking. That is, light cannot even go through a pane of glass without virtual photons going an infinite number of paths, including those paths that go backward in time.
They're virtual photons. In a mathematical model.

Going backward in time violates cause-and-effect.
Not for virtual photons it doesn't.

Now it may be merely semantics to say that things that violate cause-and-effect happen 'outside this universe', or one could include such phenomena as part of this universe.
Or it may simply be utter nonsense.

Of course, by many people's definition, universe means everything, so they don't know why I keep saying 'this universe'.
This universe is all we can speak of empirically; that is indeed the definition of universe.

But science is about empirical stuff
Yes.

cause-before-effect.
Not necessarily. Science states that natural events have a natural cause (and indeed that all observable events are natural). It doesn't specify the direction of time; we worked that out afterwards.

So, could this mean that quantum physics has already poked a hole in science?
No.

The evidence using cause and effect says that sometimes effect can come before cause?
No.

Then there are those who think quantum computers will someday compute instantaneously. What do you think of that possibility Pix?
They are wrong.

Quantum computation can produce approximations to extremely difficult combinatorial problems very quickly, but (a) they are approximations, and (b) the accuracy of the approximation is dependent on the processing time. So you may have a problem that would take a million years on a conventional supercomputer that could be calculated in a second on a small quantum computer... But the answer might be wrong.

They most certainly cannot process anything instantaneously.
 
John Von Neumann was talking about the algorithmic generation of random numbers. He was right in that, but it is completely - completely - different to what you are claiming.
I don't know what you think I'm claiming but I'm saying that PRN generators are by definition, not the same as natural randomness. I'm not saying they cannot be made to be indistinguishable from natural sources of randomness.

If pi is normal, that is impossible.
Lets assume we have a number sequence that is given as normal. Now let us go through it and snip out every occurence of "0001020304050607...99" in base 10. Whatever that would do to the distribution, it would change it by only one part in 1x10^200. So for all practical purposes it would still be normal. I guess I'm just saying, in a round about way, that it is not practical to get information from randomness.

A gut feel? Really? I'm sooo impressed. :rolleyes:
I guess I need to use the smiley faces more. My point is that we know we cannot expect certain sequences to be expressed in the M-set, obviously. I brought up the M-set because it is an algorithmic set we can visualize. Likewise, other algorithmic sets, while intended to be pseudorandom, can be expected to not have certain sequences in them, just as no puddy-tats in M-set. Then finally, how do we know that physical randomness, again, like particle emission, is not algorithmically generated. From a practical standpoint, a physical random sequence could appear normal but we would never know that it really is. yeh, maybe you're right - complete twaddle....
 
I don't know what you think I'm claiming but I'm saying that PRN generators are by definition, not the same as natural randomness. I'm not saying they cannot be made to be indistinguishable from natural sources of randomness.
That has nothing to do with what you said. You said:
It is impossible to accurately model physical randomness using mathematics, obviously.
Which is hopelessly wrong.
Lets assume we have a number sequence that is given as normal. Now let us go through it and snip out every occurence of "0001020304050607...99" in base 10.
In which case, it is no longer normal.

Whatever that would do to the distribution, it would change it by only one part in 1x10^200. So for all practical purposes it would still be normal.
NO!

I guess I'm just saying, in a round about way, that it is not practical to get information from randomness.
Well, I guess I'm just saying that you are wrong.

I guess I need to use the smiley faces more. My point is that we know we cannot expect certain sequences to be expressed in the M-set, obviously.
Why?

I brought up the M-set because it is an algorithmic set we can visualize. Likewise, other algorithmic sets, while intended to be pseudorandom, can be expected to not have certain sequences in them, just as no puddy-tats in M-set.
The Mandelbrot set is essentially recursive. Infinite in depth, yes, but certainly not normal in the way pi might be. But even that doesn't guarantee that there aren't recogniseable images of cats in the set.

Then finally, how do we know that physical randomness, again, like particle emission, is not algorithmically generated.
Because that would be physically impossible.

From a practical standpoint, a physical random sequence could appear normal but we would never know that it really is. yeh, maybe you're right - complete twaddle....
Once again, that's not the point. You said:

I'm sorry if the above did not drift well to my point - but here it is: regardless of what my concept is of physical randomness, I think that, were I still an evolutionist, I would have to believe, whether I tumbled to it or not, that the physical randomness at the kernel of evolution possesses some sort of "life-ness" to it.
(My emphasis.)

That is, as I pointed out before, complete twaddle.
 
VonNeumann, A couple of comments and questions.

You're presenting the hypothesis that we're all part of a simulation created by an external programmer. What observations lead you to this hypothesis? The only thing I've seen so far is that the theory of evolution can't work on a macro level because unspecified specialists in the field say so. So then it must be a simulation? Please explain this somewhat farfetched conclusion.

In your argumentation the only references you give is to popularized literature so you're obviously a jack of all trades, specialist in none. Nothing wrong with that, I have shallow knowledge in many areas and that's the way I like it. It is a problem though when you fail to see that the knowledge you've gained from popularized science magazines and books doesn't enable you to dismiss and reject theories in specialized fields. It's like reading "A brief history of time" and claim to know how the universe came into being and how it works. If you want to be taken seriously here it would work better if you provide references to contemporary scientific articles that supports your case.

And this whole discussion would really fit better in Philosophy and religion. "Why" something works is a philosophical question. "How" it works is what science is trying to describe. Who knows, we're digging deeper and deeper into the fabric of space and time and eventually we might find that there is in fact a programmer, god or threeheaded unicorn that is making it all up. Come and mock me then.
 
As far as Macro vs Micro evolution, I just posted an example in my previous post in response to pixy, who thinks the difference between micro and macro evolution is exactly 112 ounces:D .
You posted a metaphor, not an example. An example would be: I agree that these two animals are related as explained through micro-evolution, but I disagree that these other two animals are related because that would be macro-evolution.

But I didn't ask for a metaphor or an example. I asked for a practical distinction, for the purposes of discussion. That is, the difference in attributes between micro-evolution and macro-evolution. I should be able to pick out any two organisms that are said to be related according to evolution and be able to identify them according to your distinction as being related through micro-evolution or macro-evolution.

If you can show me how your functions map to what we know about biology, fine. Otherwise, it's just a fuzzy metaphor with no practical value.
 
Last edited:
You posted a metaphor, not an example. An example would be: I agree that these two animals are related as explained through micro-evolution, but I disagree that these other two animals are related because that would be macro-evolution.

But I didn't ask for a metaphor or an example. I asked for a practical distinction, for the purposes of discussion. That is, the difference in attributes between micro-evolution and macro-evolution. I should be able to pick out any two organisms that are said to be related according to evolution and be able to identify them according to your distinction as being related through micro-evolution or macro-evolution.

If you can show me how your functions map to what we know about biology, fine. Otherwise, it's just a fuzzy metaphor with no practical value.

If no-one else is going to offer one then

from http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/macroevolution.html

In evolutionary biology today, macroevolution is used to refer to any evolutionary change at or above the level of species. It means the splitting of a species into two (speciation, or cladogenesis, from the Greek meaning "the origin of a branch") or the change of a species over time into another (anagenesis, not nowadays generally used). Any changes that occur at higher levels, such as the evolution of new families, phyla or genera, is also therefore macroevolution, but the term is not restricted to the origin of those higher taxa.

Microevolution refers to any evolutionary change below the level of species, and refers to changes in the frequency within a population or a species of its alleles (alternative genes) and their effects on the form, or phenotype, of organisms that make up that population or species.

Another way to state the difference is that macroevolution is between-species evolution of genes and microevolution is within-species evolution of genes.
 
Belz belz belz... always being reminded of your dear mother... that's quaint.

Maybe, but it's true.

The reason I call you fellows "so-called-skeptics" is because I think you should be MORE skeptical.

I don't accept anything without some modicrum of proof. Isn't that pretty much as skeptical as can be ?

It is not very often, but occasionally these pesky specialists become quite pesky with their observation of the "data" and of the "evidence". Every once in a while there is a statement made about how the evidence does not support the theory or how the evidence is made to fit the theory.

I think you meant to say: the theory is made to fit the evidence. This is something I don't understand. You people keep saying this about science, but completely ignore that science has brought us technology which, if the theory was NOT correct, COULD NOT POSSIBLY FUNCTION.

A salient difference between you and me is that I don't ignore it when a highly credentialed specialist admits this, while you do ignote it.

I don't know what you're babbling about. I called shenanigan when they started talking about cold fusion. I was skeptical of relativity until I read the relevant articles.

The reaction amongst the darwin-faithers is as one would expect of a religious person, and is why I characterize darwin-faithers that way. They ignore the contra-evidence, close their eyes and BELEEEEEEEEEEEEEEIVE.

Such a clever tactic, eh ? A tu quoque. I'm sorry, but not only does it not help your position in any way, but it also happens to be a strawman at the same time. While there ARE darwin-faithers who believe in the theory simply because it's been told to them enough times, most of us, here, "believe" in it simply because the facts support it.

In fact, instead of attacking the skeptic position, you'd do much better to present actual evidence AGAINST darwinism, which you haven't done. In fact, you haven't countered anything I've said about evolution beign fact. You just ignored me, which says a lot.

So i choose not to believe that baloney about macro-evolution. Microevolution - no prob. And I did not toss it aside easily as you suggest. It probably took more years for me to make the transition than you've been alive. I was very stubborn about it, just as you are.

Would you please elaborate as to WHY you distinguish the two (macro vs micro) so ?
 
Perhaps rather than "unnamed, unspecified, incompetent supernatural designer" I could just say "unknown programmer(s)".

You can use whatever term you want. The point is that NO evidence points to an intelligent cause to the universe or biological organisms. Quite the opposite. The gargantuan waste of energy in the universe is, itself, quite an indication that this came about from random processes.

I presented: "making", "designing", "creating", "programming", etc as possible verbs that this seminal kernel in the black box of evolution actually DOES.

Amusedly, someone suggested the expected verb "EVOLVING". This is circular. I ask what is it that is the mechanism of evolution - what does it do?

I talked about this before. This is the part you ignored. I'll say it again for your benefit:

1 - Is DNA responsible for your physical and psychological characteristics ?

I assume you'll say "YES, at least at first".

2 - Are genetic mutations real ?

I assume you won't deny that they exist, otherwise I know a number of cancer victims that'll disagree with you.

3 - Are genes passed down from parent to child ?

Again, that's a no brainer, otherwise HOW could you be born ?

4 - Does environmental conditions change in certain places over time ?

If you don't think so, I know a few million africans who'd like to have a word with you about deserts.

5 - Do specimens better adapted to their environment have a better chance to survive and reproduce ?

Well... again this seems like a no-brainer.

That's all evolution is. And we KNOW evolution happens because biological organisms change all the time. So the theory fits the facts. The only point of dispute is the actual process, but seeing as points 1-5 are pretty much established, genetic mutations and natural selection seem to be the most likely candidates. In fact, genetic experiments on flies and other life-forms have INDEED resulted in new species.

So what's so impossible about it ?

Skeptic Survey says: it does the "evolving". I was also taught here, not at all unexpectedly, that when darwin-faithers use the term "design" or "purpose" or "function" when speaking of organs/organelles/systems that those terms are merely "andropromorphic".

OK, of course they are "andorpromorphic". But not like "the sea is angry" because in said phrase, many other alternative terms could be used such as "the sea was rough."

Still, the terms do not imply design. But, if you want, we could INVENT words that describe these things better.

So the word "design" is used, not capriciously anthropomorphically, but rather out of necessity. Humans design. Human's tools design by direction of the human. But what ELSE designs? If you say nothing else (yet - just wait, though), then I believe you are saying that "life has no purpose."

You contradict yourself, Von.

So, "which should we believe?" That the designer of life is some un-named designer, out there somewhere? or the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution? You believe that the designer of life is at the kernel of evolution but you would not use the term "design".

Not true. Read the relevant litterature. No one believes there is a DESIGN per se.

You would use the term that means "unfold". Well that implies that it was predestined to unfold and therefore had a purpose. Yet you deny "purpose".

You're still inventing definitions. Yes, the universe does appear to be completely deterministic, but only because its laws are clockwork. From the moment the universe began having actual laws, everything was SET, because there is simply no other alternative, not because there's a master-plan.
 
What about a random sequence spewed forth from some natural physical source? What if we say "it looks like white noise" over some bandwidth. But it could be as spectrally flat as we could possibly measure and still not contain any useful complexity. We do not know if physical randomness, such as emission of a particle timing, is algorithmic or not.

Another algorithmically infinitely complex model is the M-set. It is random in that our intelligence cannot predict what exactly the M-set will look like in a given place without our computing it, yet we can recognize M-set-ness. I have a gut feel that no matter where you look in the M-set, you will never see a picture of a pussy cat. In its infinite complexity - no pussies. By the same token, we do not know if what we call physically random, does not also have a certain *-ness as the M-set has M-set-ness.

I'm sorry if the above did not drift well to my point - but here it is: regardless of what my concept is of physical randomness, I think that, were I still an evolutionist, I would have to believe, whether I tumbled to it or not, that the physical randomness at the kernel of evolution possesses some sort of "life-ness" to it.

Physical randomness is not random per se. It's called random because we have no way to tell the outcome simply because we don't have all the factors. However, there is no "random" in there. As far as I know, random only occurs at the quantum level, and then even...
 
I think you stated that very well. I would only presume that we should insert some words as I show bracketed here:
"Problem is, when we use the best methods we've discovered and developed to uncover the story of the universe and of life, the story that appears [to strong materialists] to be coming together is one of purposeless, undirected self-organization, not a Plan developed by an outsider."

One thing I am not clear on is whether most of you would make the same sort of statement as you have. And if so, is it understood that being a "strong materialist" is what you volunteer to adhere to because thats the way we keep science from giving up to zeus as the cause of things. Is it further understood that, just because it is the rule of science, it does not mean it is the rule of "what really is." You see what I mean?
I had a debate with an idealist (self-described) about whether or not the choice of monism (the basic, underlying stuff of this rule-based universe) between matter and ~matter was true and necessary or false and illusory. Part of the problem was, he was never able to delineate in any meaningful way the difference between matter and ~matter or what difference it would make which you choose. If that makes me a materialist, then I suppose I am one. I don't know, I've never had much use for philosophy--if anything I consider myself a pragmatist (if I understand the implications of that word correctly.)

As to "what really is": the best, most accurate tool we have to discover this is science. Science has had a vastly higher success rate than any other strategy for discovering the truth about things. I'll grant that science may never uncover what really is, but I'd lay odds in its favor when competing against philosophy, religion, or idle speculation.

I applaud that science must do what science must do. I just don't like it going beyond the evidence to make claims. To me, an example of a claim that goes beyond evidence is that this realm has no purpose.
Science doesn't make that claim. (Maybe my statement about "purposeless, undirected self-organization" wasn't phrased carefully enough.)

Saying "the evidence does not point to purpose" is not the same as saying "the evidence points to a lack of purpose." Purposelessness is, has to be, the default assumption unless evidence of purpose is uncovered.

If you feel the evidence points to purpose, please: what is this purpose?
 
When I speak of darwin-faithers, I would assume that a person who does not consider himself a darwin-faither to merely go 'he's not talking to me.' I apologize to anyone who has felt disrespected by my use of the term. I respect everyone here. I never thought it would be considered "inflammatory". I think darwin-faither is more illustrative than 'evolutionist'. I would not be insulted to be called an IDer or an ID-faither. I believe 'origins' is something taken on 'faith' not on 'evidence', in either case. Besides, how many times have I been called a 'creationist' here? Isn't that supposed to tick me off to put me in with 'church-lady'? My apology stands but methinks you are being too hard on me.
Isn't it possible that origins of species may be taken on faith based on evidence? Most of the people I've come across here feel very strongly about their views on evolution, and there is an element of faith involved, but that's true for most of the conclusions of science. I think most people here understand the concept that a theory, however strong, is always tentative. We take it on faith that an apple will fall to the ground when we release it from our grip. We can't prove that the laws of gravity won't change at any moment, so even though our faith is based on strong evidence and much experimentation, it may turn out to be wrong.

As to the "church-lady" thing. I did make a snide remark about you being a blue-haired church lady or something like that, but it was not unprovoked. You had just finished telling me that my enemy was not creationists but my own lack of research into evolution. I think this has been common to your interactions with some others in this thread. You start with the "darwin-faithers" and stump-speech rhetoric, and others follow suit. (Granted, there are people on my side of the debate who can just be pricks, too, though. You know who you are.)
 
If no-one else is going to offer one then

from http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/macroevolution.html

In evolutionary biology today, macroevolution is used to refer to any evolutionary change at or above the level of species. It means the splitting of a species into two (speciation, or cladogenesis, from the Greek meaning "the origin of a branch") or the change of a species over time into another (anagenesis, not nowadays generally used). Any changes that occur at higher levels, such as the evolution of new families, phyla or genera, is also therefore macroevolution, but the term is not restricted to the origin of those higher taxa.

Microevolution refers to any evolutionary change below the level of species, and refers to changes in the frequency within a population or a species of its alleles (alternative genes) and their effects on the form, or phenotype, of organisms that make up that population or species.

Another way to state the difference is that macroevolution is between-species evolution of genes and microevolution is within-species evolution of genes.
Thanks, sphenisc. So, VonNeumann, shall we go with the inter-species vs. intra-species distinction?
 
I posted a fairly airtight case of human and ape common ancestry earlier on in the thread without any acknowledgement that it was strong evidence supporting evolution, so I'm not holding my breath for a sensible discussion ;)
 
The Incompleteness Theorem applies to any consistent and sufficiently powerful formal system, regardless of where it came from. It does not apply to things that aren't formal systems, but it always applies to formal systems.

It should also be pointed out that human minds are known to be both incomplete and inconsistent.

Therefore, it's perfectly possible that human minds may be formal systems, and Godel says not a syllable against the possibility.
 
Belz...

If you're saying that it's not an issue with the number of genes, I agree.

If you're saying that we have more genes than less complex creatures, well...

Actually, we do have fewer genes than many less complex species. Corn, for instance, has more genes than humans.

However, current research shows that our DNA is not limited to simply unzipping and reading protiens left to right. Various chemical triggers, certain pieces of junk DNA, and other factors can modify the DNA so that, for example, the RNA is recorded backwards, or a certain base set is "skipped", or two are transposed, so that each gene can code anywhere from one to seven different protiens. Scientific American had an article about this a while back, I believe it was the same one I'd posted a link to earlier.

It's in the April 2005 issue of Scientific American. "The Alternative Genome" by Gil Ast, pg. 60. From the article:

Spring of 2000 found molecular biologists placing dollar bets, trying to predict the number of genes that would be found in the human genome when the sequence of its DNA nucleotides was completed. Estimates at the time ranged as high as 153,000. After all, many said, humans make some 90,000 different types of protein, so we should have at least as many genes to encode them. And given our complexity, we ought to have a bigger genetic assortment than the 1,000-cell roundworm, Caenorhabditis elegans, which has a 19,500-gene complement, or corn, with its 40,000 genes.
When a first draft of the human sequence was published the following summer, some observers were therefore shocked by the sequencing team's calculation of 30,000 to 35,000 protein-coding genes. The low number seemed almost embarrassing. In the years since, the human genome map has been finished and the gene estimate has been revised downward still further, to fewer than 25,000. During the same period, however, geneticists have come to understand that our low count might actually be viewed as a mark of our sophistication because humans make such incredibly versatile use of so few genes.

A second quote froma Summary box, also pg 60:
A gene's instructions can be edited by cellular machinery to convey multiple meanings, allowing a small pool of protein-coding genes to give rise to a much larger variety of proteins.

That such an alternative splicing of genetic messages is possible was long thought understood. But only when genome sequences of humans and other organisms became available for side-by-side comparison did geneticists see how widespread alternative splicing is in complex organisms and how much the mechanism contributes to differentiating creatures with similar genes.

Alternative splicing enables a minimal number of genes to produce and maintain highly complex organisms by orchestrating when, where, and what types of proteins they manufacture. Humans, in turn, may soon be able to regulate our own gene splicing to combat disease.

Of course, I would say this very feature of the gnenetic code that VonNuemann points to as some sort of evidence of design, is nothing of the sort. This simply shows how minor cahnges (not just in chaperones to fold protiens, but in the DNA signallers that control how it unzips) can cause large changes in a creature, all at once. OF course, speciation doesn't happen overnight, either (except in a few cases with plants, which we have some observed instances of). Current examples of ring species provide a good example of how speciation can occur without any single large jump between steps (simply comapre the two ends of those species seperated by space to the two ends of an evolutionary chain seperated by time).
 
It should also be pointed out that human minds are known to be both incomplete and inconsistent.

Therefore, it's perfectly possible that human minds may be formal systems, and Godel says not a syllable against the possibility.

What are the porperties of a formal system and how would it be possible to tell if a human mind had those properties?
 
It should also be pointed out that human minds are known to be both incomplete and inconsistent.

Therefore, it's perfectly possible that human minds may be formal systems, and Godel says not a syllable against the possibility.

Hell, I think demonstrating that you were completely consistent would probably qualify for the million in itself lol

Personally, I think the fact that humans are capable of holding so many contradictory beliefs simultaneously is more than adequate evidence that formal systems are not an adequate model of our minds ;)

Edit: by that I mean that our we have no predisposition to be logical, not that we're held together by magic dancing pixies
 
What are the porperties of a formal system

A formal system is a system of symbolic manipulation with an unambiguous and well-defined procedure for doing the manipulation.

A good example of that would be formal logic (in its myriad incarnations). Each version shares a well-defined set of "well-formed formulae" (wffs) and set of rules for legitimate transformations between them.

For example, under propositional logic, any 'atom' is a wff, as is any conjunction of atoms. So the symbols A and B are both atoms (and therfore wffs), and the conjunction A and B is therefore also a wff. Similarly, anything that does not fit these rules is not a wff.

A formal system also includes 'rules of inference' that describe how wffs can be truth-related to each other. For example, if the wff X is true, then so is the wff X and X. If the wffs X and if X then Y are both true, so is Y. And for any wff X, X or not-X is always true.


how would it be possible to tell if a human mind had those properties?

Well, Lucas argues (incorrectly), that we can determine that the human mind does not have those properties, because it has other properties that are provably not those of a formal system. In particular, Kurt Godel proved in the early 1930's that any sufficiently strong formal system must be either incomplete (meaning there are some true statements that cannot be demonstrated true following the rules of the system), or inconsistent (meaning that there are some false system that can nevertheless be demonstrated to be true within the rules, meaning the rules are broken). Lucas claims, incorrectly, that human beings are both complete and consistent -- but we have ample evidence that they are neither.

We could also demonstrate that the human mind was not a formal system through other ways. For example, the information contained in a formal system is always finite -- there are a finite set of axioms and a finite way of manipulating them. If the human mind had infinite capacity for information, it wouldn't be describable by a formal system.

Basically, the question of whether the human mind truly is a formal system remains an open question (and probably will remain open for some time to come).
 
Personally, I think the fact that humans are capable of holding so many contradictory beliefs simultaneously is more than adequate evidence that formal systems are not an adequate model of our minds.

Lots of "formal systems" aren't logical in the sense of "non-contradictory."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom