PixyMisa
Persnickety Insect
Define what you mean by that, and I will answer the question.How well does pure math apply to reality, anyway? I don't know but, to me, it is a more fundamental question than the question that started this thread (let me say that question is "were physical laws designed?"). ..or more than that... the question of 'what is mathematics?' is pretty tough. Did we invent math or did we discover it?
They code for a significantly larger brain. Oh, and chimps can "fathom the number 4".How do a mere few million nucleotides in our DNA make us able to mentally cruise through a world of math while a chimp cannot fathom the number 4.
Tell me what the question means, and I will tell you the answer.Was mathematics here or somewhere before there was a human mind?
Why do you think minds are formal systems?What I made reference to tries to apply the concept of a formal system to something like the mind.
If it is purely algorithmic and its input is entirely deterministic, yes. Neither one is necessary, of course.I brought it up in context of a universal simulation (as a computer program) which would be a formal system by definition.
Ah, that. Penrose doesn't know what he is talking about.Also, I maybe got some ideas about it by reading Penrose's "Emperor's New Mind".
And why do you think that?What is it about minds? My personal thought is that 'mind' is not entirely Mechanism (as Lucas said for Godelian reasons) and that creation of new information must be done 'in a mind'.
It's not a question of "old school", it's a question of relevance. The Incompleteness Theorem points out a fundamental and inescapable limitation of formal systems. If minds were formal systems, then they are subject to the same limit. But they aren't.Of course, you are probably in good company if you dismiss Godellian relevance to any of this. It is probably 'old school'.
They're virtual photons. In a mathematical model.Bringing up QED again: when I say something about outside the universe, I think that there is some evidence, at least to my way of thinking. That is, light cannot even go through a pane of glass without virtual photons going an infinite number of paths, including those paths that go backward in time.
Not for virtual photons it doesn't.Going backward in time violates cause-and-effect.
Or it may simply be utter nonsense.Now it may be merely semantics to say that things that violate cause-and-effect happen 'outside this universe', or one could include such phenomena as part of this universe.
This universe is all we can speak of empirically; that is indeed the definition of universe.Of course, by many people's definition, universe means everything, so they don't know why I keep saying 'this universe'.
Yes.But science is about empirical stuff
Not necessarily. Science states that natural events have a natural cause (and indeed that all observable events are natural). It doesn't specify the direction of time; we worked that out afterwards.cause-before-effect.
No.So, could this mean that quantum physics has already poked a hole in science?
No.The evidence using cause and effect says that sometimes effect can come before cause?
They are wrong.Then there are those who think quantum computers will someday compute instantaneously. What do you think of that possibility Pix?
Quantum computation can produce approximations to extremely difficult combinatorial problems very quickly, but (a) they are approximations, and (b) the accuracy of the approximation is dependent on the processing time. So you may have a problem that would take a million years on a conventional supercomputer that could be calculated in a second on a small quantum computer... But the answer might be wrong.
They most certainly cannot process anything instantaneously.