Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

So, rather than present evidence for the theory you have advanced, you now say "well, it wasn't really my idea." Evasion noted.



Emphasis mine. It may be true that much good science has come from "brave renegades". However, they all had one thing on their side that you lack: EVIDENCE!

Also, there were plenty of "brave renegades" who were plain wrong. Velikovsky, Pons and Fleischmann, etc., etc.



So you need alcohol to believe it? :p
Jon, that is unfair and you know it, with your accusation my motive was evasiveness. First, because I can type extremely fast I can say a lot in a short amount of time... but why should I attempt to explain here what is already so well explained, with references, at panspermia.org. Also, it may appear plageristic. I've given you the link. Go read.

Sure there were plenty who were wrong a la velikovsky et al. Yeh, its a problem, isn't it. Go out on a limb and embarrass yourself in front of your peers.

The euphemism about 'over the beer' is merely that I would say more with my comrades on a face to face basis.
 
VonNewmann - You would do better to think, read, and post seldom.

Your "huge amount" of posts betrays you.

You didn't have to say you believe in a god - that's all too apparent.

Grow up and think some before you post again. Please.
 
I think VonNeumann is more driving towards Space Aliens/Time Travellers From The Future (tm) rather a classical notion of God, in which case the idea of imperfection isn't unreasonable.
....or that we live in a simulation (not unlike a simulation on a digital computer but I only say that because it would otherwise be hard to relate), and the IDers are 'outside the simulation' ...thereby getting around the godelian problem.

Personally, I am not fond of space aliens nor of time travelers as serious ideas.
 
VonNewmann - You would do better to think, read, and post seldom.

Your "huge amount" of posts betrays you.

You didn't have to say you believe in a god - that's all too apparent.

Grow up and think some before you post again. Please.
I don't really care what you think. To me this is merely entertainment. To you it is your religion.
 
VonNewmann - You would do better to think, read, and post seldom.

Your "huge amount" of posts betrays you.

You didn't have to say you believe in a god - that's all too apparent.

Grow up and think some before you post again. Please.
Oh, and why so emotional, Complexity? Instead of what YOU think I SHOULD do, why don't you answer my question in that post:

"Is the carbon atom imperfect?"
 
Isn't that an oxymoron? Unless one believes in a pantheon of gods who were petty, scheming, bickering and all too human (much like the Roman, Greek, or Norse gods) doesn't belief in God pretty much require belief in that God's perfection?
Repeat after me: "intelligent designer". Why do you so-called-skeptics always frame everything in terms of a 'perfect God'?

But Yaksman, it is a good question you posted. It is at the crux of the argument. Western philosophy has always* presumed a purpose to 'our world' and sought answers because it is fundamental that the universe is 'understandable'. *"Always" that is, up until the last 100 years or so, where teleology has been expunged. So now it is believed that universe and nothing in it, has no purpose, yet it is still ultimately all understandable by human intellect?

Why would the universe be understandable and why would we, merely different from a chimp by a couple million nucleotides, be able to ponder and argue whether there is intrinsic purpose.
 
You created a strawman version of the theory of evolution where birds would be expected to be genetically closer to fish than we are, and then pointed out it was wrong, thus disproving evolution. Since birds have also been evolving all the time we have, equidistance of both our genetic structures from our common fish ancestor woulc be expected by Evolution. Perhaps you hear "strawman" so often because you use them so often ;)

Oh, and panspermia.org appears to regurgitate all the bog-standard Creationist anti-evolution arguments with a slightly different spin. The section on thermodynamics, while pointing out some of the misunderstandings between the different meanings of entropy, nevertheless trots out the old "complexity cannot increase" canard. Also, if most of your arguments have come from there, then the accuracy of the rest of the information is also pretty dubious. From another random page:

Nevertheless, computer scientists are confident that an unquestionable demonstration of evolutionary progress in artificial life is imminent, because they think they are only trying to model a phenomenon already proven in biology. Many biologists, on the other hand, are under the impression that computer models have already corroborated evolutionary progress in a closed system.

Sorry, but that's just Grade A bullcrap. Lies (and they are demonstrably lies) like that have been trotted out by Cretinists for years to try and make the evidence behind evolution seem shaky.

You may not be disingenuous, but all you've done so far in this discussion, correct me if I'm wrong, is make flawed arguments against evolution and then pose an arbitrary hypothesis with absolutely no supporting evidence. It may seem intriguing, but that does not make it right.

I have no problem with the basic panspermia idea, in which basic self-replicating life was originally arrived from outer space. I don't believe the evidence is in its favour, but it's not completely bonkers. The "strong" panspermia, stuff, is pretty blatantly flat-out pseudoscience, indicated by their tendency to use completely discredited arguments.

The case for Cosmic Ancestry is not yet proven, of course. At this point the best reason to notice it is that sustained evolutionary progress and the origin of life on Earth are not satisfactorily accounted for by Darwinism.

Bring on those good ol' Creationism arguments...

I am used to it now. Typically your attitude is 'either you're with us or against us' and that's why dissent from within the evolutionist club is quashed. What scientist wants to be called a 'creationist'?

OK - no progress on this front. Drfrank, I invite you to respond to:

"is the carbon atom imperfect?"
"what is plausible to you as possible seminal sources of things such as atoms and the physical laws that make their construction possible?"
 
Repeat after me: "intelligent designer". Why do you so-called-skeptics always frame everything in terms of a 'perfect God'?
We don't.

But that's what the IDists believe. This is documented in detail in the transcripts of the Dover Trial. ID is Creation Science is Creationism is Christian Fundamentalism.

So now it is believed that universe and nothing in it, has no purpose, yet it is still ultimately all understandable by human intellect?
It's not that we believe the Universe has no purpose, it's that we don't assume a purpose without evidence. And we only think it is understandable by human intellect because we've been so successful at it so far.

Why would the universe be understandable and why would we, merely different from a chimp by a couple million nucleotides, be able to ponder and argue whether there is intrinsic purpose.
Why? Who cares about why? Why should there even be a why?
 
I am used to it now. Typically your attitude is 'either you're with us or against us' and that's why dissent from within the evolutionist club is quashed.
No. We just want evidence. If you have no evidence, then stop bothering us until you get some.

It's not a question of quashing dissent; it's a question of fact. All the fact is on the side of evolution; none whatsoever on the side of Intelligent Design.
 
I am used to it now. Typically your attitude is 'either you're with us or against us' and that's why dissent from within the evolutionist club is quashed. What scientist wants to be called a 'creationist'?
Well, if the strong panspermia club were bringing up any plausible arguments then I'd be more than happy to acknowledge them. However, the "we don't really have any evidence so our best bet is to criticise evolution" tactic is all too familiar. They obviously aren't Creationists, but the fact that they steal discredited arguments from Creationists puts them on the same level of scientific respect.

Would I deserve respect if I tried to enter the JREF challenge with spoon-bending tricks I'd stolen from Uri Geller? :rolleyes:
"is the carbon atom imperfect?"
I think talking about perfection with relation to a carbon atom is meaningless. Is this piece of dust perfect? Is this brick perfect?
"what is plausible to you as possible seminal sources of things such as atoms and the physical laws that make their construction possible?"
That's a pretty oddly worded question. Personally, I don't know enough about physics to make any real statements on this and, to be honest, I doubt anyone does. However, our (well, more specifically my) current ignorance does not automatically mean that your simulation idea holds any water.

If this Universe were a simulation, there'd need to be some greater reality - how did that come into existence? How did the IDers come into being? Then you're faced with exactly the same problem as now apart from lifted into another reality whose existence you have no evidence for :S

Not exactly the most parsimonious of solutions, is it?
 
Oh, and why so emotional, Complexity? Instead of what YOU think I SHOULD do, why don't you answer my question in that post:

"Is the carbon atom imperfect?"

You idiot, your question has no meaning.

What does 'perfection' mean in this context?

It is what it is.
 
I don't really care what you think. To me this is merely entertainment. To you it is your religion.

To me, this is neither a 'religion' nor 'merely entertainment'.

I don't have a religion. I used to, then I grew up.

What about posting here is entertaining to you? Trolling?
 
In my huge amount of posts in just a matter of less than two weeks, you will notice if you look, that I've NEVER said I believe in God. The subject matter here, I thought was ID and that origin of natural laws is probably a better domain for pro-ID argument. That being said, and I have NOT read all the posts so maybe someone already answered "Is the carbon atom an imperfect design?".

Again, I ask. In short, you posit an intelligent, unspecified and incompetent designer, instead of a blind force that corresponds to our current knowledge of the universe ? Pray tell, then, what makes ID more "believable".
 
....or that we live in a simulation (not unlike a simulation on a digital computer but I only say that because it would otherwise be hard to relate), and the IDers are 'outside the simulation' ...thereby getting around the godelian problem.

Damn. Iacchus II.

Personally, I am not fond of space aliens nor of time travelers as serious ideas.

And yet the unnamed, unspecified, incompetent supernatural designer is more believable ?
 
How would you represent it?

Well, the three key topological aspects of neo-Darwinism are, first, that any two organisms have a common ancestor (the theory of common descent); second, that once two organisms speciate, they and their descendants can never interbreed (which is basically the definition of "species."); and third, that time uniformly moves forward (hence ancestors preceed descendants, and a number of other common-sense properties).

From these three properties, it can be proven that evolutionary relationships form a uniquely rooted, directed, acyclic graph -- what topologists and graph theorists call a "tree" for short -- and that all current species are separate leaves on the this tree.

Therefore, any two living species will be "distant cousins" of each other, both descended from a most recent common ancestor. And any more distant living species will share a most recent common ancestor with that common ancestor, and hence be equally related to the first two.

In other words, it predicts -- mathematically, and from first principles provably -- that fish should be equally related to birds and mammals. It similarly predicts that insects should be equally related to any and all vertebrates, that lizards should be equally related to cats and dogs, and that starfish are equally related to all primates.

Or more generally, the "surprising" genetic relationship you trumpeted turns out to have been predicted long ago. As a simple glance at the literature will confirm to you. The idea of a chain of life where fish are more closely related to amphibians are more closely related to reptiles are more closely related to mammals turns out to be an incorrect medieval conceit....
 
Or more generally, the "surprising" genetic relationship you trumpeted turns out to have been predicted long ago. As a simple glance at the literature will confirm to you. The idea of a chain of life where fish are more closely related to amphibians are more closely related to reptiles are more closely related to mammals turns out to be an incorrect medieval conceit....

I've just finished reading Gould's "Life's Grandeur" (or Full House in America), which does a particularly good job of addressing this sort of issue, and the tendency to assume that humans are somehow the most `highly evolved'. He postulates that evolution has no innate tendency to produce increasing complexity (which is sensible), and that we are simply the right tail on the distribution of complexity of life.

Oh, panspermia.org also makes a lot of the fact that evolutionary biologists argue over terms such as `higher' and `lower' lifeforms.
 
Or more generally, the "surprising" genetic relationship you trumpeted turns out to have been predicted long ago. As a simple glance at the literature will confirm to you. The idea of a chain of life where fish are more closely related to amphibians are more closely related to reptiles are more closely related to mammals turns out to be an incorrect medieval conceit....

Good post, kitten. I think that clears it up quite nicely.
 
I told everybody I knew about my idea that viruses were a transverse (horizontal rather than descent) mode of genetic transfer, a long time ago. But it was not my field and so I told a bunch of people who didn't care. I thought transverse genetic transfer would be a great accelerator to evolution. Years later, I finally read in my local newspaper that science had come up with the same idea. I would not be surprised if George Gamov et al had the same idea when viruses were first discovered to invade the reproductive machinery of the cell. Being highly unorthodox, and being non-darwinistic, I guess it took a long time to catch on. Finally, in the late 90s you start to see a lot of reference to transverse genetic transfer via viruses. So, at least this concept is already pretty established in science.
If it turns out that horizontal gene transfer has a large role in evolution, in no way would it bolster the idea of design, or undercut the neo-Darwinist model. Viruses reproduce and mutate rapidly, and so the lottery of life would be a perfectly adequate explanation.

And it absolutely wouldn't imply that: "The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves." [your quote, my emphasis] There is approximately zero evidence of purpose-driven viruses.

Francis Crick, who I think some of you may agree is a 'scientist', proposed that genes were pre-fabed some place far far away and propulsed here on purpose, to seed the earth. He called it 'directed panspermia'. His reasons were that he did not see sufficient evidence of darwinistic evolution on earth unless all the microbes were prefabed and everything sort of self-assembled from those initial ingredients. Fanciful? yes. I think Cricke's idea of what is the intelligent designer was some alien race. ...begs the question of where they came from, of course. But I think it is important to realize that the Father of DNA, Cricke, doubted RM/NS could be wholly responsible for life origins here on earth.
It's not especially important, no. Especially considering that a) if I recall correctly, Crick believed not in Cosmic Ancestry (the flavor of panspermia preferred by panspermia.org), but plain vanilla panspermia, which was originally proposed merely to explain life origins, but otherwise doesn't touch the evolutionary model; b) many great thinkers and contributors to science held beliefs that now seem out of sync with the work we associate them with: Newton's obsession with alchemy being a good, and by no means rare, example; and c) arguments from authority are fallacious.

Anyway, give it a chance... go delve into panspermia.org.
I started with their FAQ page. Here's my favorite quote:
Q. I think you're crazy.
A. I know.
 
If this Universe were a simulation, there'd need to be some greater reality - how did that come into existence? How did the IDers come into being? Then you're faced with exactly the same problem as now apart from lifted into another reality whose existence you have no evidence for :S

This was also in the "What's the Craziest..." thread.

VN: Let's assume for a moment that you are absolutely correct. Assume that we can disregard both God and aliens as our immediate creators, but that we ARE living in a simulation...

So what?

Or more precisely, now what? What prevents the IDers of the simulation from existing in an infinite stack of simulations? Do simulation and reality then have separate definitions? Is there a first simulator, rather than a first cause?

It seems that you, rather than the 'evolutionist fundamentalists,' are asking religious questions...

How have I misunderstood this issue?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom