Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

No.

You're talking about philosophy, not science.
Yes. You're starting to catch up.

So also is any idea about origins: it's philosophy or meta-physics - NOT science.

Particularly this thread: origin of physical laws. Philosophy. NOT science.
 
Yes, and when we genetically engineer such things, we could then remove all the crap from our DNA and correct our faulty vitamin C gene. Of course, the resulting genetic code will then cease to make any sense if viewed as the result of evolution, and enormous unexplainable discrepancies would become apparent by any future race who tried to study us as the result of such.
heheh. Yeh, it would look like a little bit of design had crept in. In fact, it already has ceased to make any sense if viewed as a result of descent that follows the taxonomological tree.
 
1. With your common design argument, why wouldn't the Incompetent Designer you describe just have bodged creatures together from a wide variety of genes?
Because that's not what we observe.

Creatures ARE made up from a wide variety of genes.
The thing is, the molecular and morphological and fossil and radiometric evidence all coincides with evolutionary theory, and not with a designed bodging something together.

drfrank, are you unaware of recent discovery that all mammals/birds are genetically equidistant from fish? Darwinism would predict a taxonomical relationship instead of equidistance.
Uh, what? What do you mean, "equidistant from fish"?

Why do we have some genes that are incredibly similar to those in the fly?
Because we evolved from a common ancestor.

The common ancestor of anthropods and vertabrates were cambrian
Pre-cambrian.

and so simple that the need for those genes in that common ancestor is unthinkable.
Argument from personal incredulity. Won't win you any points here.

There are a lot of processes that vertebrates share with invertebrates, so it's hardly suprising that they share genes.

If we land vertebrates had the mollusca design, ie the blood service from behind the retina, we would not have the blind spot, I presume you are saying.
Yes. It's a fairly common point.

It is amazing that we can see stars so incredibly far away with these annoyingly badly designed eyes ... and why do we need to see stars to survive?
What? What do stars have to do with anything?

Perhaps having eyes, so light sensitive, gave us an advantage. But apparently there was not so much attenuation of star light, looking through the capillaries.
What do stars have to do with anything?

If we had mollusc eyes, could we see stars even better?
What do stars have to do with anything?!

I don't know - do you? Would our retinas get burned by the excessive light in the daytime?
No. The cornea and lens block UV light anyway.

I don't know if anyone has answered the question of whether the attenuation of light by the capillaries is an advantage for land animals.
The capillaries are transparent and have nothing to do with the blind spot.

If so, that might indicate that ID would predict the blind spot as a trade-off against the needed attenuation.
No. Wrong. Completely and hopelessly wrong.

Another thing is that the difference in the two designs is rather trivial - at least I think so.
Unfortunately, the term Argument from ignorance already has a specific meaning.

And so nearly identical I doubt if it could have evolved twice.
That is close the the specific meaning, though. And utter nonsense, given the vast number of variations on the eye that we find.

I think I read that Gould believed this, too, that it couldn't have evolved twice.
Cite.

Now for some facts:

Not only the blood vessels but the nerves are connected to the wrong side of the retina. That is why we have a blind spot. It's where the optic nerve passes through the retina.

If the nerves where on the right side, not only would we not have a blind spot, but the retina would be securely attached and not be so easy to detach. Google for "detached retina" if you don't know what I mean.

I do not think of the designer as perfect nor do I believe the designer is incompetent. I believe the way genes got distributed was through viral infection. I think of it this way. Free genes, having to do with eye design, are let go on the planet. The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves. In the installation process, there may be some self revision that is designed into the mechanism that may cause slight differences in implementation. Some people believe viruses are primarily diseases and maybe some sort of proto-life. I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.
No.

Do you have any idea how many variations on the eye exist in nature? (Well, obviously not. It's a rhetorical question.)
 
Yes. You're starting to catch up.

So also is any idea about origins: it's philosophy or meta-physics - NOT science.
Origins of what? The Universe? I'll grant you that. Life? Not a chance. That's entirely within he purview of science.

Particularly this thread: origin of physical laws. Philosophy. NOT science.
No. The post was about using the Anthropic Principle as support for Intelligent Design. Doesn't work, of course, because Intelligent Design doesn't match the evidence. Doesn't matter what impressive-sounding philosophical arguments you muster to your side; it doesn't match the evidence.
 
You said "there is a process through which the universe can be created"- I believe that it may be impossible to create such complex things AS this universe, IN this universe.

The universe is complex ? Not really. What evolved "naturally" is far less complex than the things we've created since the dawn of civilization. Why would we assume that humans are unable to invent physical laws ? I can do that right now.

I believe you are talking about mathematical models. We do not know 'the laws of physics'. We just make up mathematical laws, or models, and test them against reality.

Now, now, Von. If our mathematical models represent the physical laws the way they work, why would you assume that these laws are in any way more complex than the model ?

Our models do not yet take care of 'randomness', thoug we have made some strides into turbulence.

Randomness is the simplest thing you can imagine, Von. That's the beauty of it. If it obeyed some form of law, then it wouldn't be random.

Not we humans. Our progeny in the evolutionary sense of the word. Go back to my post and you will see - sorry if I was unclear. I mean silicon intelligence or whatever that evolves from us - I'm not saying HUMANS would have omnipotence. Now if this is clear, do you agree that our evolved progeny (probably this progeny would evolve from our AI machines) might in the future be omnipotent, or nearly so?

No. Omnipotent means "can do anything". Within the confines of this universe, I don't see how one could do the physically impossible. Now, if you're asking about the physically possible, then whatever can be done, humans can do.
 
I merely said that the only intelligent design we have personal experience (out own) with is not perfect. I do not see incompetence in the design of so-called natural things - only in humanly designed things. I think our concept of 'perfection' is very subjective. But I don't understand your question anyway. Creatures ARE made up from a wide variety of genes.

Common creationist ploy. I assume you've been saying this because you've never been sick with some ridiculous human biological malfunction. If the design is perfect, how do you explain cancer, allergy, ingrown nails ? Those are simplistic, idiotic failures of what should be a perfect, god-designed organism. My computer crashes once in a while, but rebooting usually solves the problem in no time. No biological organism comes even close.

A third explanation which i cannot take seriously is that the same thing evolved a plurality of times. This is ridiculous from an information theory standpoint, but biologists apparently can't do the 'rithmatic.

I just love it when laypeople think they know better than specialists. My mother does that all the time. Funny thing, really.

If we land vertebrates had the mollusca design, ie the blood service from behind the retina, we would not have the blind spot, I presume you are saying. It is amazing that we can see stars so incredibly far away with these annoyingly badly designed eyes ... and why do we need to see stars to survive?

That wasn't the point. You ARE aware that the human eye has a blindspot, right ? That's due to the inexplicable fact, from a design standpoint, that the "wires" of the retina's cells pass in FRONT of the retina before bundling up and shooting THROUGH the retina to the brain. What kind of an idiotic designer would do this ? The wires should, obviously, pass BEHIND the retina so as to prevent this. This is perfectly explainable by natural selection but ridiculous if you assume design.
 
Yes. You're starting to catch up.

So also is any idea about origins: it's philosophy or meta-physics - NOT science.

Particularly this thread: origin of physical laws. Philosophy. NOT science.

Philosophy ? Science is doing a much better job of finding answers to the same questions. Philosophy, in my view, is obsolete.
 
I believe the way genes got distributed was through viral infection. I think of it this way. Free genes, having to do with eye design, are let go on the planet. The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves. In the installation process, there may be some self revision that is designed into the mechanism that may cause slight differences in implementation. Some people believe viruses are primarily diseases and maybe some sort of proto-life. I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.
......this is...did you just...what were you...sputter...ack........

There's approximately zero evidence to support this fanciful idea.
 
I believe the way genes got distributed was through viral infection. I think of it this way. Free genes, having to do with eye design, are let go on the planet. The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves. In the installation process, there may be some self revision that is designed into the mechanism that may cause slight differences in implementation. Some people believe viruses are primarily diseases and maybe some sort of proto-life. I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.

See ? This is what I was talking about. You just conjure up this idea, and expect it to stand the test of time, without evidence or research on your part... and yet you attack darwinism, which HAS stood the test of time by GATHERING evidence. You don't seem to know what evolution is at all.
 
2. Why don't we have some genes that are more similar to frogs, chickens or lizards than apes?

drfrank, are you unaware of recent discovery that all mammals/birds are genetically equidistant from fish? Darwinism would predict a taxonomical relationship instead of equidistance.

I often imagine a kind of pseudoscientific videogame, where you have to fight the forces of reason:

"Oh God, he's just thrown a Reasonable Question at me - press X+Y for an Evasion+Strawman counterattack!"

I'll respond properly a little later :D
 
drfrank, are you unaware of recent discovery that all mammals/birds are genetically equidistant from fish? Darwinism would predict a taxonomical relationship instead of equidistance.

No, it wouldn't. Where do you come up with this astonishing misrepresentation? Do you even know what a "taxonomical relationship" would look like?
 
Free genes, having to do with eye design, are let go on the planet. The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves. In the installation process, there may be some self revision that is designed into the mechanism that may cause slight differences in implementation. Some people believe viruses are primarily diseases and maybe some sort of proto-life. I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.

So, let me get this straight...

You believe the Designer releases genetic patches, in the form of retroviruses, in order to incrementally improve His creations?

Basically, you believe God is some kind of cosmic Microsoft? :whistling

Okiday.... care to present any positive evidence for this claim i.e. not a strawman critique of evolutionary theory?
 
I believe the way genes got distributed was through viral infection. I think of it this way. Free genes, having to do with eye design, are let go on the planet. The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves. In the installation process, there may be some self revision that is designed into the mechanism that may cause slight differences in implementation. Some people believe viruses are primarily diseases and maybe some sort of proto-life. I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.

Do you think that this is still ongoing? When should we expect the next upgrade to H. sap. 1.02.06 or whatever?
 
Do you think that this is still ongoing? When should we expect the next upgrade to H. sap. 1.02.06 or whatever?
I am just saying I think that it fits the evidence pretty well. I suppose it is plausible that it is ongoing, though probably infrequent. ...and soon we will probably be curing diseases and making 'improvements' through the same sort of delivery system ourselves. We may not be able to see the 'background' among our man-made 'upgrades'.
 
So, let me get this straight...

You believe the Designer releases genetic patches, in the form of retroviruses, in order to incrementally improve His creations?

Basically, you believe God is some kind of cosmic Microsoft? :whistling

Okiday.... care to present any positive evidence for this claim i.e. not a strawman critique of evolutionary theory?
I'm not taking credit for this idea. It belongs to Hoyle, Crick, and a few other high profile thinkers. Go see panspermia.org where Klyce Brigg has done an excellent job of presenting the idea.

Again, you so-called-skeptics seem sort of dry when it comes to thinking outside the box. The best science has come from the brave renegades. Don't let me make you feel defensive. You already know that is what you all dream of being able to do - come up with something truly revolutionary.

THAT is my best emotional plea to you about darwinism being a tired old idea. Let yourself release yourself from that bond. See? I'm not trying to tell you to go to church. That's your business.

BTW, if you think this idea is wild, maybe over a beer, I'll tell you what I really think...
 
I often imagine a kind of pseudoscientific videogame, where you have to fight the forces of reason:

"Oh God, he's just thrown a Reasonable Question at me - press X+Y for an Evasion+Strawman counterattack!"

I'll respond properly a little later :D
In the lexicon of the so-called-skeptics I find the word "strawman" too often and unhelpful. I am telling you what I think. I assume it may differ from what you think but I am not disingenous when I project to you an idea.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom