Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Not sarcastically. Very seriously.

The situation you describe, by your own admission, we have no way of knowing. That makes it idle speculation, not a serious point. Not only is there no reason to believe this bit of speculation over any other bit of speculation, there can be no reason to believe this bit of speculation over any other. You say so yourself.

It is utterly pointless. This is not sarcasm, this is the simple truth.
Most of what this forum is about is in regard to things for which 'we have no way of knowing'. What this forum is about is mostly what people believe, isn't it?

Please, if you do not mind responding, do you believe that an intelligent designer of universe-creating-power could evolve in this universe in the future?
 
Most of what this forum is about is in regard to things for which 'we have no way of knowing'. What this forum is about is mostly what people believe, isn't it?
Not exactly. What this forum is about is what people believe either in the absence of evidence or contrary to evidence. You're one example of this.

Please, if you do not mind responding, do you believe that an intelligent designer of universe-creating-power could evolve in this universe in the future?
We can do this right now.
 
Let ME put it this way. Assuming that there is a God, and that he created the universe. Doesn't that mean there is a process through which the universe can be created ? If so, then it's conceivable that WE could replicate this process in the future. And, if so, it kinda makes God unnecessary, or at the very least, mundane.
You said "there is a process through which the universe can be created"- I believe that it may be impossible to create such complex things AS this universe, IN this universe. Sort of a Godellian viewpoint, you see. If this hypothesis happens to be correct, then a self-creating universe would not be possible in THIS universe. The design would have to come from outside the universe. So by definition, this is what science would call supernatural. But I believe that is by our current definition of what is 'natural'. This same pardigm would have some parts of our own mental functioning porting outside the realm of what we presently know as the physical universe. I'm not saying these are beliefs I hold high, these are just plausible ideas to me.



The laws of physics, actually, are the simplest things we know of. Making up rules is easy. Finding out what they are is another matter, but this does not mean that they are any harder to imagine.
I believe you are talking about mathematical models. We do not know 'the laws of physics'. We just make up mathematical laws, or models, and test them against reality. Our models do not yet take care of 'randomness', thoug we have made some strides into turbulence. I think you mean that physical laws are fundamental enough for we humans to feel like we have come real close to encapsulating some of them totally.


That's a sizeable army of strawmen you're building for yourself. What are you planning on invading with that ?
I do not know how to respond to this statement. What does it mean?



I don't think so. The term "God" with a capital "G" has come to describe something that is either physically or logically impossible. Such a thing cannot exist either in the past or in the future. That we could reach a level of technology required to understand the origin of the universe and replicate it is more probable, but it seems unlikely that we'd be able to mold chaos to our desires. More likely, we'd just trigger a random universe. I hardly call that "designing".
I am trying to relate. I keep talking about ID and I keep running into so-called-skeptics who love to keep bringing up God with a "G". That sort of confuses me, but OK. I'm not sure if you agree or disagree that randomness is the seminal source? Agree? ..or Disagree?



It only seems to be a serious point because you're still battling your impotent strawman. None of us here, I presume, would think that we will be omnipotent at ANY point in the future.
Not we humans. Our progeny in the evolutionary sense of the word. Go back to my post and you will see - sorry if I was unclear. I mean silicon intelligence or whatever that evolves from us - I'm not saying HUMANS would have omnipotence. Now if this is clear, do you agree that our evolved progeny (probably this progeny would evolve from our AI machines) might in the future be omnipotent, or nearly so?
 
You said "there is a process through which the universe can be created"- I believe that it may be impossible to create such complex things AS this universe, IN this universe.
What sort of complexity are you referring to? If you are simply referring to the number of bits of information, then this is obviously true. If you are referring to Kolmogorov complexity, then it is not at all clear that this is the case. That notwithstanding, the fact remains that we can indeed create other universes within this universe, and your argument regarding intelligence is destroyed.
 
Not exactly. What this forum is about is what people believe either in the absence of evidence or contrary to evidence. You're one example of this.
Yes, belief where 'evidence' is lacking is what this forum is about - quite obviously. You point at me? I'm a newcomer and am just joining in to what apparently was established here long before. Are you intrinsically belligerent, or is it what you do when you are frustrated?

We can do this right now.[/QUOTE]
Are you saying you think one or more of the many flavors of human artifact toy universes, so far created, has the potential of our physical universe?
 
Yes, belief where 'evidence' is lacking is what this forum is about - quite obviously. You point at me?
Yes.

I'm a newcomer and am just joining in to what apparently was established here long before.
Yes, you are part of a long history of people making claims unsupported by evidence or contrary to the evidence.

Are you intrinsically belligerent, or is it what you do when you are frustrated?
No.

Are you saying you think one or more of the many flavors of human artifact toy universes, so far created, has the potential of our physical universe?
What potential?
 
What sort of complexity are you referring to? If you are simply referring to the number of bits of information, then this is obviously true. If you are referring to Kolmogorov complexity, then it is not at all clear that this is the case. That notwithstanding, the fact remains that we can indeed create other universes within this universe, and your argument regarding intelligence is destroyed.
It is a fact that we can create other universes within this universe. I'm not arguing that when you loosen up the definition of universe. We are intelligent and our creative faculty may not be a physical mechanism. When you say "we can indeed create" you presume all of what 'we' are is 'in' this universe. ...again speaking about belief since it has not been proven/disproven one way or another. "Mechanism" remains a fundamental controversy in science.

But that, notwithstanding, is not the type of universe creating I have been speaking of. I mean a universe on the level of this one in question, at the start of this whole thread, about which has origin that allegedly is better ID argument material according to the original poster, than would be evolution.
 
It is a fact that we can create other universes within this universe. I'm not arguing that when you loosen up the definition of universe. We are intelligent and our creative faculty may not be a physical mechanism.
Piffle. Our creative faculty is obviously a physical mechanism. Every last shred of evidence on the matter tells us this.

When you say "we can indeed create" you presume all of what 'we' are is 'in' this universe.
Duh.

...again speaking about belief since it has not been proven/disproven one way or another.
Do you know anything about the universe, and how we establish knowledge about the universe? If so, why are you speaking of proof?

"Mechanism" remains a fundamental controversy in science.
No.

But that, notwithstanding, is not the type of universe creating I have been speaking of. I mean a universe on the level of this one in question, at the start of this whole thread, about which has origin that allegedly is better ID argument material according to the original poster, than would be evolution.
What's the difference?
 
This same pardigm would have some parts of our own mental functioning porting outside the realm of what we presently know as the physical universe.

yes, the paradigm does. Your 'no' merely means you don't subscribe to it.

Whether the mind can be synthesized with a digital computer, or equivalent, has been argued with substance, since the 1950s. It is still unresolved. I believe that if it were determined that it be impossible, then there may be some magic involved. Think about algorithms that can run an infinite number of cycles in a few seconds. If that were to be observed, we would suspect that we made a wrong measurement, or it could mean that the algorithm ran in some sort of timeless space. We already have seen weird stuff like information travelling backward in time implied in the QED theory, with virtual photons. Could virtual photons port out and back into our physical universe? If so, be careful that you do not make that be 'supernatural' and decided science should not get to the bottom of it.

As the strident defender of evidence you seem to project, do you consider Feynman et al abstracted QED from evidence?
 
Oh, that. Sure, no problem. I played that universe on my Amiga back in the late '80s. Can't remember what it was called though.
Surely you jest. Honestly, I presumed you knew what you were talking about. You are speaking of Conway's "Life".

Ulam suggested to John von Neumann that he work on a universal self-replicator or something like that. I dunno... I'm too lazy to look it up. In the late 40's von Neumann came up with a fascinating thing coined cellular automata. A mathematician named Conway perfected it and called his algorithm "life" back in the 1960s. The general term for such thing is now called 'artificial life', a subset of artificial universes or toy universes. I used to have a program, fashioned after James Gleick's book "Chaos" by Autodesk (same people who make autocad) that could synthesize toy universes. Much much beyond what you could do on your Amiga pixy. A very good book on this, though dated, was called "The Recursive Universe" by Poundstone.

The most prodigious work I've seen that covers this stuff is Steve Wolfram's "A New Kind of Science". I believe Wolfram made some excellent points. Still, he got a rather cold response to his fascinating work.
 
This same pardigm would have some parts of our own mental functioning porting outside the realm of what we presently know as the physical universe.

yes, the paradigm does. Your 'no' merely means you don't subscribe to it.
No. I'm saying that based on what you said, it's a non-sequitur.

Whether the mind can be synthesized with a digital computer, or equivalent, has been argued with substance, since the 1950s.
Yes. But all the coherent argument has been on one side - the affirmative.

It is still unresolved.
No. It remains to be done, and people who don't understand the question are still arguing about it, but it has been resolved by people who have reviewed the evidence and can sustain a logical position.

I believe that if it were determined that it be impossible, then there may be some magic involved.
Was that supposed to mean something?

Think about algorithms that can run an infinite number of cycles in a few seconds.
No.

If that were to be observed, we would suspect that we made a wrong measurement, or it could mean that the algorithm ran in some sort of timeless space.
No.

We already have seen weird stuff like information travelling backward in time implied in the QED theory, with virtual photons.
No.

Could virtual photons port out and back into our physical universe?
Out of where?

If so, be careful that you do not make that be 'supernatural' and decided science should not get to the bottom of it.
"I felt a great disturbance in my brain, as if a million neurons cried out in terror, and then were suddenly silenced."

As the strident defender of evidence you seem to project, do you consider Feynman et al abstracted QED from evidence?
Depends exactly what you mean by that. What they certainly didn't do was blithely construct their theories irregardless of the evidence.
 
Last edited:
Surely you jest. Honestly, I presumed you knew what you were talking about. You are speaking of Conway's "Life".
No.

It was a commercially marketed game that simulated the process of evolution.

I did write a version of Life using the Amiga's blitter rather than the CPU. Took 27 blitter passes per generation, though.
 
Last edited:
Hey, VonNeumann, I'm still interested in hearing your answers to the above :)
I will have to go back and read what you asked and what I responded with and add to it (but not now - need go night night).

Also, with your common design argument, why wouldn't the Incompetent Designer you describe just have bodged creatures together from a wide variety of genes? Why don't we have some genes that are more similar to frogs, chickens or lizards than apes? The genes responsible for the eyes in squid would be nice, as then we wouldn't have an annoying blind spot...

1. With your common design argument, why wouldn't the Incompetent Designer you describe just have bodged creatures together from a wide variety of genes?
I merely said that the only intelligent design we have personal experience (out own) with is not perfect. I do not see incompetence in the design of so-called natural things - only in humanly designed things. I think our concept of 'perfection' is very subjective. But I don't understand your question anyway. Creatures ARE made up from a wide variety of genes.

2. Why don't we have some genes that are more similar to frogs, chickens or lizards than apes?

drfrank, are you unaware of recent discovery that all mammals/birds are genetically equidistant from fish? Darwinism would predict a taxonomical relationship instead of equidistance. Why do we have some genes that are incredibly similar to those in the fly? The common ancestor of anthropods and vertabrates were cambrian and so simple that the need for those genes in that common ancestor is unthinkable. Two explanations come to mind. The first idea I came up with when I was a teen but has not become 'science' until fairly recently (too bad I didn't publish it), and that is that there is a lateral transfer of genes through inter-special (inter-family, inter-class) viral infection. Another explanation is that the common ancestor possessed the genes (but we can't test the long gone DNA for verification). A third explanation which i cannot take seriously is that the same thing evolved a plurality of times. This is ridiculous from an information theory standpoint, but biologists apparently can't do the 'rithmatic.
3. The genes responsible for the eyes in squid would be nice, as then we wouldn't have an annoying blind spot...
If we land vertebrates had the mollusca design, ie the blood service from behind the retina, we would not have the blind spot, I presume you are saying. It is amazing that we can see stars so incredibly far away with these annoyingly badly designed eyes ... and why do we need to see stars to survive? Perhaps having eyes, so light sensitive, gave us an advantage. But apparently there was not so much attenuation of star light, looking through the capillaries. If we had mollusc eyes, could we see stars even better? I don't know - do you? Would our retinas get burned by the excessive light in the daytime? I don't know if anyone has answered the question of whether the attenuation of light by the capillaries is an advantage for land animals. If so, that might indicate that ID would predict the blind spot as a trade-off against the needed attenuation. Another thing is that the difference in the two designs is rather trivial - at least I think so. And so nearly identical I doubt if it could have evolved twice. I think I read that Gould believed this, too, that it couldn't have evolved twice. I do not think of the designer as perfect nor do I believe the designer is incompetent. I believe the way genes got distributed was through viral infection. I think of it this way. Free genes, having to do with eye design, are let go on the planet. The genes are designed to find their way into the appropriate genomes and install themselves. In the installation process, there may be some self revision that is designed into the mechanism that may cause slight differences in implementation. Some people believe viruses are primarily diseases and maybe some sort of proto-life. I believe viruses are information broadcast media to the genomes, and that they primarily have that purpose.
 
Me. I know. And so do lots of programmers who develop computer simulations.

We do indeed have the intelligence to create the laws of nature.
Then do it and get the nobel prize.

Merely I'll ask as an aside, ...How plausible to you is it that we live in a simulation?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom