Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Well, useless DNA strands probably can mutate into useful ones eventually, but, a priori I'd say they don't do anything before that.

Well, I can't find the article now. I can't remember enough about it to get much for a search term beyond DNA (which gives a few too many hits).

I seem to recall that it was found that there are roles DNA plays beyond coding proteins; that some sections of the DNA responded to certain outside influences (various chemicals and such), and changed shape slightly to rearrange the way that a DNA strand was read. So that, under normal conditions, the strand might be read A, B, C, D, E to make protein A-E; under differing conditions, a change in a section might cause it to instead transcribe A,B,D,E,F.

It was an explanation for why humans have fewer genes than mice, even though humans are more complex creatures.

Aha! Found the article. It's in the April 2005 issue of Scientific American. "The Alternative Genome" by Gil Ast. From the article:
Spring of 2000 found molecular biologists placing dollar bets, trying to predict the number of genes that would be found in the human genome when the sequence of its DNA nucleotides was completed. Estimates at the time ranged as high as 153,000. After all, many said, humans make some 90,000 different types of protein, so we should have at least as many genes to encode them. And given our complexity, we ought to have a bigger genetic assortment than the 1,000-cell roundworm, Caenorhabditis elegans, which has a 19,500-gene complement, or corn, with its 40,000 genes.
When a first draft of the human sequence was published the following summer, some observers were therefore shocked by the sequencing team's calculation of 30,000 to 35,000 protein-coding genes. The low number seemed almost embarrassing. In the years since, the human genome map has been finished and the gene estimate has been revised downward still further, to fewer than 25,000. During the same period, however, geneticists have come to understand that our low count might actually be viewed as a mark of our sophistication because humans make such incredibly versatile use of so few genes.

This is only tangentially relevant, however. The second article is "The Unseen Genome:Gems among the Junk" by W. Wayt Gibbs, Scientific American November 2003. From the article intro:
Flecks of dark brown on an iris may be a telltale sign of the hidden genome at work. Certain traits are transmitted not through ordinary genes but rather through chemical modifications to the chromosomes, changes that are regulated by bits of "junk" DNA. Unlike genetic mutations, these heritable traits are often reversible and appear in some cells but not others.

Not that this makes VonNuemann's case at all (I completely disagree with his rather sophmoric view), but we do need to be careful when making declaritive statements :)

If you want to see the full article, you'll probably have to find a copy of SciAm or subscribe to the digital version. I don't think it would be within fair use for me to email you the pdf, but if any law-savvy peopl on here okay it, I can :) It's an interesting read.
 
It may not be, of course; it may only seem that way to us. :D
Should you choose to have faith you have no choice was one of the options.

BTW, I have 100% faith that choice -- free-will -- is available. That is a possibility idealists enjoy. If materialists/atheists choose to have faith their Master Contol Programs also allow libertarian free-will, who am I to argue?

I'm sure we can argue about the meaning of the word "free-will". :D


Do you choose by physically changing portions of your brain operation? By what mechanism do you make those changes? ;)
 
BTW, I have 100% faith that choice -- free-will -- is available. That is a possibility idealists enjoy. If materialists/atheists choose to have faith their Master Contol Programs also allow libertarian free-will, who am I to argue?

What about materialists/atheists who choose to follow the evidence and conclude that there IS no free will ?
 
Their choice, isn't it? Or, perhaps they lost the path in their attempt to follow the evidence?
 
Last edited:
Their choice, isn't it? Or, perhaps they lost the path in their attempt to follow the evidence?

You're assuming your conclusion here, Hammegk. Are you willing to consider the possibility of free-will beign non-existent ? Would it be inconsistent with what we know of reality ?
 
Despite your attempt to obfuscate, we are discussing this universe.
Sorry, hammy, one set of laws of nature per universe. It's the rule, even for you.

The point is that VonNeumann was claiming that humans are not "intelligent" enough to create the laws of nature. Clearly, we are intelligent enough to create laws of nature for other universes, so he's wrong. We can't create the laws of nature for this universe because it already has laws of nature. Intelligence has nothing to do with it. Intelligence has nothing to do with any of his arguments.
 
Last edited:
About the "junk" material in the genes, I recall a much older notice in SciAm where it was reported that a team om cryptographers had analysed the codes and found that even if they could not break it, a cryptographic analysis showed that it formed patterns that pointed to possible information content.

The term "junk" about certain DNA strands has simply been a most ill-chosen term, because, as was to be expected, life has simply, again, turned out to be more complicated than first thought, and the normal RNA->protein decoding cyclus is not the only mechanism at work in the cells.
 
How can you compare the two? If humans had had all the time and power in the multiverse, who knows if their intelligence would not be enough to create the natural laws and life itself? The advances we have made within a short time span surely indicates a capacity that so far has shown no limit?
Were you addressing me?

If humans, or their remote progeny, could be that powerful, what would they be? Be that progeny 'organic' or some future 'silicon intelligent artifact', you apparently believe it could be very powerful. I understand this well, having been 'reared' in the upbringing of science and science fiction. If our future capacity has no limit and you believe the plausibility of the top of the evolutionary ladder could be a, let me use a euphemism, "Creator" ...

.... see where I'm going? You believe in the plausibility of a god/God/gods/Gods or what do you want to call it? You believe in the plausibility of a designer who has the capacity to make things as complex as the most complex things we now know.

You, steenkh, believe in the existence of an ID agent, powerful enough to do all the things that the IDer in question is purported to be able to do. You just don't believe the IDer has evolved yet. Am I right? This is a point I have made in at least one earlier post to someone else, in general. Here, I believe you stepped right into it all by yourself, but any one of you could have done it.

It has been posted that a term I've used, 'cognitive dissonance', is disfavorable. ..but I am going to have to say that it is an interesting holding of opposing things in the mind simultaneously that you posted, steenkh. I believe many so-called-skeptics on this forum are able to hold these two opposing thoughts, namely: denial of the existence of an intelligent designer; the faith that an intelligent designer will show up on the scene some time in the future.

Of course, a salient difference in believing whether a god exists NOW versus a god that exists in the FUTURE is just that: the displacement on the time line. But philosophically, and that is an important point. However, I don't think it comes to the conscious level of the 'skeptic' that he considers himself "atheist" but believes the IDer could exist in the future, BECAUSE...

Here is the punchline: if it is plausible it could happen in the FUTURE, we have no way of knowing that it hasn't happened ALREADY, and that our universe and all that is in it are the designed product of that IDer you think is not yet here.

I think this is a serious point, but I know some will prefer to jab sarcastically at it rather than seriously give their deeper thoughts.
 
Here is the punchline: if it is plausible it could happen in the FUTURE, we have no way of knowing that it hasn't happened ALREADY, and that our universe and all that is in it are the designed product of that IDer you think is not yet here.

I think this is a serious point, but I know some will prefer to jab sarcastically at it rather than seriously give their deeper thoughts.
Not sarcastically. Very seriously.

The situation you describe, by your own admission, we have no way of knowing. That makes it idle speculation, not a serious point. Not only is there no reason to believe this bit of speculation over any other bit of speculation, there can be no reason to believe this bit of speculation over any other. You say so yourself.

It is utterly pointless. This is not sarcasm, this is the simple truth.
 
If humans, or their remote progeny, could be that powerful, what would they be? Be that progeny 'organic' or some future 'silicon intelligent artifact', you apparently believe it could be very powerful. I understand this well, having been 'reared' in the upbringing of science and science fiction. If our future capacity has no limit and you believe the plausibility of the top of the evolutionary ladder could be a, let me use a euphemism, "Creator" ...

Let ME put it this way. Assuming that there is a God, and that he created the universe. Doesn't that mean there is a process through which the universe can be created ? If so, then it's conceivable that WE could replicate this process in the future. And, if so, it kinda makes God unnecessary, or at the very least, mundane.

.... see where I'm going? You believe in the plausibility of a god/God/gods/Gods or what do you want to call it? You believe in the plausibility of a designer who has the capacity to make things as complex as the most complex things we now know.

The laws of physics, actually, are the simplest things we know of. Making up rules is easy. Finding out what they are is another matter, but this does not mean that they are any harder to imagine.

I believe many so-called-skeptics on this forum are able to hold these two opposing thoughts, namely: denial of the existence of an intelligent designer; the faith that an intelligent designer will show up on the scene some time in the future.

That's a sizeable army of strawmen you're building for yourself. What are you planning on invading with that ?

Of course, a salient difference in believing whether a god exists NOW versus a god that exists in the FUTURE is just that: the displacement on the time line. But philosophically, and that is an important point. However, I don't think it comes to the conscious level of the 'skeptic' that he considers himself "atheist" but believes the IDer could exist in the future, BECAUSE...

I don't think so. The term "God" with a capital "G" has come to describe something that is either physically or logically impossible. Such a thing cannot exist either in the past or in the future. That we could reach a level of technology required to understand the origin of the universe and replicate it is more probable, but it seems unlikely that we'd be able to mold chaos to our desires. More likely, we'd just trigger a random universe. I hardly call that "designing".

I think this is a serious point, but I know some will prefer to jab sarcastically at it rather than seriously give their deeper thoughts.

It only seems to be a serious point because you're still battling your impotent strawman. None of us here, I presume, would think that we will be omnipotent at ANY point in the future.
 
You, steenkh, believe in the existence of an ID agent, powerful enough to do all the things that the IDer in question is purported to be able to do. You just don't believe the IDer has evolved yet. Am I right? This is a point I have made in at least one earlier post to someone else, in general. Here, I believe you stepped right into it all by yourself, but any one of you could have done it.
No, actually I do not believe in an ID agent. I see no sign of intelligent design anywhere. There might be, but I do not see the signs, and in any case it is something that cannot be proven, and accordingly is just speculation. Let us discuss it again when there is found signs of design.

I responded to your comparison between human intelligence and RM/NS. I could not see anything there that humans could not do given enough time. As others have said, it is quite mundane and not signs of something so important that the term "creator" needs to be assigned to it.
 
I've yet to hear a critique of why the evidence for ape/human common ancestry isn't compelling
...snip...
Remember, any theory that would replace evolution would also need to explain the evidence I described at least as well as the Theory of Evolution.

Let's look at your common design argument - is there any piece of evidence that couldn't be retrofitted to something that vague? Of course there isn't! No piece of evidence could ever show it wrong, which makes it completely pointless.

Hey, VonNeumann, I'm still interested in hearing your answers to the above :)

Also, with your common design argument, why wouldn't the Incompetent Designer you describe just have bodged creatures together from a wide variety of genes? Why don't we have some genes that are more similar to frogs, chickens or lizards than apes? The genes responsible for the eyes in squid would be nice, as then we wouldn't have an annoying blind spot...
 
Or it could be observed that the Incompetent Designer has managed to provide at least one working model that -- assuming we don't destroy ourselves -- in not too many more years will be able to reverse engineer rna/dna lifeforms and fix any glaring discrepancies noted in analyzing the original design. :)
 
Or it could be observed that the Incompetent Designer has managed to provide at least one working model that -- assuming we don't destroy ourselves -- in not too many more years will be able to reverse engineer rna/dna lifeforms and fix any glaring discrepancies noted in analyzing the original design. :)

Original design ? I'd like to see the blueprints he made for that... and then slap him upside the head.
 
Interesting comments, although I suggest we are a long way from unraveling the complete rationale for rna/dna coding. I.E. How sure are y'all your tinkering may not have "unexpected consequences", and not necessarily good ones?
 
Interesting comments, although I suggest we are a long way from unraveling the complete rationale for rna/dna coding. I.E. How sure are y'all your tinkering may not have "unexpected consequences", and not necessarily good ones?
You are probably right that we still have a long and interesting way to go.

Our tinkering may have unexpected consequences, but we can hardly do worse than any possible original creator who apparently has had to use several mass extinctions before he reached Adam and Eve who reportedly looks like himself.
 
Or it could be observed that the Incompetent Designer has managed to provide at least one working model that -- assuming we don't destroy ourselves -- in not too many more years will be able to reverse engineer rna/dna lifeforms and fix any glaring discrepancies noted in analyzing the original design. :)

Yes, and when we genetically engineer such things, we could then remove all the crap from our DNA and correct our faulty vitamin C gene. Of course, the resulting genetic code will then cease to make any sense if viewed as the result of evolution, and enormous unexplainable discrepancies would become apparent by any future race who tried to study us as the result of such.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom