Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Wrong question.

What do you think?
Wrong question? ...what a useful comment you've made there.

What do I think about whether RM/NS is "intelligent"? I'm not real confident in my thoughts on it but I think it is an interesting idea. Let's try this:

I think a case could be made for it depending upon the acceptance of a logical definition of intelligence. Put simply: humans possess intelligence and it is due to their intelligence that they are able to create tools and things that have a purpose to fulfill; but humans lack sufficient intelligence to create some very complex things we can see around us; humans cannot and did not create the natural laws, the elements, chemistry that abstracts therefrom, special complexities such as proteins, rna, dna, species; it appears that some process did create these things because evidence indicates that these various objects instantiated in sequence over a long period of time; specifically, some theorize a mechanism of RM/NS that is solely responsible for the origin-of-species end of this sequence; RM/NS ostensibly can make things that humans are not intelligent enough to make; so if RM/NS solely responsible for speciation of life, RM/NS is more intelligent than humans; therefore, RM/NS is intelligent.

Note the conclusion is actually that RM/NS is MORE intelligent than humans.

If you think this is weak, think about this. Are you familiar about the famous Turing Test for AI? Do you think it is weak? If the Turing test is plausible for testing machine intelligence, then is this test be plausible for testing RM/NS intelligence?
 
How can you compare the two? If humans had had all the time and power in the multiverse, who knows if their intelligence would not be enough to create the natural laws and life itself? The advances we have made within a short time span surely indicates a capacity that so far has shown no limit?
 
Wrong question? ...what a useful comment you've made there.
You're welcome.

What do I think about whether RM/NS is "intelligent"? I'm not real confident in my thoughts on it but I think it is an interesting idea.
I'm confident in my thoughts. I think you're going to redefine "intelligent" and wave your hands a lot.

I think a case could be made for it depending upon the acceptance of a logical definition of intelligence. Put simply: humans possess intelligence and it is due to their intelligence that they are able to create tools and things that have a purpose to fulfill
Okay, we're going for deliberately vague, are we?

but humans lack sufficient intelligence to create some very complex things we can see around us
Such as?

humans cannot and did not create the natural laws, the elements, chemistry that abstracts therefrom, special complexities such as proteins, rna, dna, species
Yes we can.

We can and do create all these things.

it appears that some process did create these things because evidence indicates that these various objects instantiated in sequence over a long period of time
You don't mean "instantiated". You mean "evolved".

specifically, some theorize a mechanism of RM/NS that is solely responsible for the origin-of-species end of this sequence;
This is correct, but misleading. Where you say "some" you should say "all competent biologists".

RM/NS ostensibly can make things that humans are not intelligent enough to make
Unsupported assertion, false description of process, and false-to-fact.

so if RM/NS solely responsible for speciation of life, RM/NS is more intelligent than humans; therefore, RM/NS is intelligent.
Non-sequitur. Even if you had established that evolution could do something that humans cannot - which you have entirely failed to do - you would still not have shown that this required intelligence.

Note the conclusion is actually that RM/NS is MORE intelligent than humans.
No such conclusion can be drawn from this argument.

If you think this is weak, think about this.
I don't think it is "weak", I think it is nonsense.

Are you familiar about the famous Turing Test for AI? Do you think it is weak?
Yes, it is weak as a test. It is useful as a way to think about how we think about intelligence.

If the Turing test is plausible for testing machine intelligence, then is this test be plausible for testing RM/NS intelligence?
No.
 
How can you compare the two? If humans had had all the time and power in the multiverse, who knows if their intelligence would not be enough to create the natural laws and life itself? The advances we have made within a short time span surely indicates a capacity that so far has shown no limit?
Me. I know. And so do lots of programmers who develop computer simulations.

We do indeed have the intelligence to create the laws of nature.
 
Wrong question? ...what a useful comment you've made there.

What do I think about whether RM/NS is "intelligent"? I'm not real confident in my thoughts on it but I think it is an interesting idea. Let's try this:

I think a case could be made for it depending upon the acceptance of a logical definition of intelligence. Put simply: humans possess intelligence and it is due to their intelligence that they are able to create tools and things that have a purpose to fulfill; but humans lack sufficient intelligence to create some very complex things we can see around us; humans cannot and did not create the natural laws, the elements, chemistry that abstracts therefrom, special complexities such as proteins, rna, dna, species; it appears that some process did create these things because evidence indicates that these various objects instantiated in sequence over a long period of time; specifically, some theorize a mechanism of RM/NS that is solely responsible for the origin-of-species end of this sequence; RM/NS ostensibly can make things that humans are not intelligent enough to make; so if RM/NS solely responsible for speciation of life, RM/NS is more intelligent than humans; therefore, RM/NS is intelligent.

Note the conclusion is actually that RM/NS is MORE intelligent than humans.

If you think this is weak, think about this. Are you familiar about the famous Turing Test for AI? Do you think it is weak? If the Turing test is plausible for testing machine intelligence, then is this test be plausible for testing RM/NS intelligence?

If I follow your argument correctly, does the exist of the Solar System, which humans are not intelligent enough to make, demonstrate that gravity is more intelligent than humans?
 
If I follow your argument correctly, does the exist of the Solar System, which humans are not intelligent enough to make, demonstrate that gravity is more intelligent than humans?
Yes, just as the existence of the ocean proves that water is more intelligent than humans, and the existence of babies proves that humans are more intelligent than humans.
 
Yes, just as the existence of the ocean proves that water is more intelligent than humans, and the existence of babies proves that humans are more intelligent than humans.

:jaw-dropp

You see, I phrased my comment as a question because I wanted VN's opinion, and then you go and through that into the mix. Are you just trying to outwoo VN?:rolleyes:

BTW I'd like a new law of nature where quantum uncertainty applies to macroscopic objects, there's so many times it would be useful to be in two places at once! As soon as you've created this for me, get ot touch... though you might want to apply for the JREF challenge first. :D

[No, I haven't taken you seriously, but feel free to use a smilie in future. Sometimes it's hard to tell... CCHEEECH.]
 
You see, I phrased my comment as a question because I wanted VN's opinion, and then you go and through that into the mix. Are you just trying to outwoo VN?
Sorry, I thought it was rhetorical. :o

BTW I'd like a new law of nature where quantum uncertainty applies to macroscopic objects, there's so many times it would be useful to be in two places at once! As soon as you've created this for me, get ot touch... though you might want to apply for the JREF challenge first. :D
No problem. Would you like your law of nature for Windows or Linux?

[No, I haven't taken you seriously, but feel free to use a smilie in future. Sometimes it's hard to tell... CCHEEECH.]
Well, I was serious about the laws of nature. We just can't create them for this universe. Because it already has laws, y'see. One set of laws of nature per universe, them's union rules, more than my job is worth etc etc. :)
 
Durn! You're right.
I got Y, Y, Y, Y, N just like you said.
....er. Never mind everybody! I'm an evolutionist afterall!

If you REALLY got those answers and still don't accept evolution... then you don't know what it is. Perhaps you'd care to know what you're talking about before you say you don't believe in it.

VonNeumann said:
Did you ever debug something Belz? Ever puzzled for a few hours, days, over a bug? You think it has to do with the framis is discombobulated with the poinsot elipsoid and you can't find one thing wrong with the framis? ..you been there? Finally, you prove to yourself there is indeed NOTHING to the idea of the cause originating in the framis.

What happens next? You look at other alternatives that previously you would not allow yourself to consider. You can finally fix the thing because you had a shift in your consciousness - in your attention - in your acceptance of what is real. As long as your debugger is stuck on the framis, Belz, you won't look outside of that domain.

I repeat: if the code doesn't do anything because there's a REM in front of it, then it's useless.

You said "...then they are useless, or don't you know what genes do ?" Perhaps YOU don't know what genes do.

What a delightful defense. Reminds me of my mother. Every time you point out one of her flaws she claims you have it too. Very mature.

Neither of us know much even if we are the world's "experts" on genes. Big daddy Francis Crick? You know him? He was WRONG. Google "Central Dogma of DNA".

DNA is used to encode other molecules. It doesn't really do anything else. That's what I was talking about.

Good design / bad design: its still very distinguishable from a chimp's attempt at programming.

Barely. If we assume that the universe is the result of "chance", then you'd expect it to be inneficient and poorly organised as it is. Now, I'm not saying it's not wonderful and amazing and fascinating. I'm just saying that, if an intelligent designer was involved, I'd expect better results, especially if we assume this guy is perfect and omniscient and omnipotent. Hell, he'd know his mistakes in advance and correct them as he goes along.

But that's not what we see, is it ?

What do you think, Belz... if RM/NS can make new DNA that code for complex proteins that function as intercellular machines that have needed function, the question is: does RM/NS "create"? "design"?

In the broadest sense, yes. Just like a waterfall designs a hole in the ground.

What terms are allowed/disallowed here, according to you?

None. Just know your definitions before you use the word.

Further: is RM/NS 'intelligent'?

Nope.
 
To be fair, there is some suggestive evidence that the "junk DNA" may play a non-coding role (more of a regulatory function, IIRC), and also provides a source for the development of new traits (through..transcriptions, I think? Where parts of the strand rearrange...a segment comes out of the dna at one point and fits in at another).

SciAm had an article on this sometime last year, I'll see if I can get a reference.

Well, useless DNA strands probably can mutate into useful ones eventually, but, a priori I'd say they don't do anything before that.
 
I think a case could be made for it depending upon the acceptance of a logical definition of intelligence. Put simply: humans possess intelligence and it is due to their intelligence that they are able to create tools and things that have a purpose to fulfill; but humans lack sufficient intelligence to create some very complex things we can see around us; humans cannot and did not create the natural laws, the elements, chemistry that abstracts therefrom, special complexities such as proteins, rna, dna, species;

That's ridiculous. Those laws are simple in the extreme. Much simpler than, say, a computer. The problem here is power, not wits. "Nature" did not create the laws of the universe as you understand it. But then if you researched into big bang physics you'd know that by now.

it appears that some process did create these things because evidence indicates that these various objects instantiated in sequence over a long period of time; specifically, some theorize a mechanism of RM/NS that is solely responsible for the origin-of-species end of this sequence; RM/NS ostensibly can make things that humans are not intelligent enough to make; so if RM/NS solely responsible for speciation of life, RM/NS is more intelligent than humans; therefore, RM/NS is intelligent.

Again, ridiculous. You are re-defining intelligence to fit your beliefs. As I said: know the definition of the word before you use it.

If you think this is weak, think about this. Are you familiar about the famous Turing Test for AI? Do you think it is weak? If the Turing test is plausible for testing machine intelligence, then is this test be plausible for testing RM/NS intelligence?

There are no intelligent machines, per se. Artificial "intelligence" is a misnomer, if you believe it should mean "aware" and "creative".
 
Ok. I understand your objection. I'd really like to tease this apart a little if you please. I had not really thought about this that much yet. Let me tell you first that I would love to have a theory of how to make a black box that would make new code (write programs) - think Genetic Algorithms for instance. Wouldn't you? Could we 'can' RM/NS so that it would...
Multiple choice Mercutio:
1. Make
2. Write
3. Create
4. Build
5. Design
6. help me! YOU give it a word: ______
... new useful programs.

What does RM/NS do if it does not make something, create something, design something. What does it do?
Your framing of the question is wrong. "so that it would _____" implies active agency. Words 1-5 reinforce this false assumption, and 6 does nothing to improve it. The "random" part of RM/NS is incompatible with active agency. The process results in ...new useful features, where "useful" is defined very narrowly, as reproductive fitness is. RM/NS results in features such as intelligence--but not always (unless you redefine intelligence so that it applies to bacteria), and unless environmental conditions were conducive to intelligence being reproductively advantageous, there is no reason to suspect that RM/NS would result in intelligence at all.

It is, quite simply, not design.
 
If a specific existent can choose, at miminum, to 'do' or 'not do', is it intelligent? If not, what is it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom