Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Interesting Ian said:
One could of course complain that the hypothesis of a huge number of Universes (whether "presently" existing or having existed), all wholly devoid of life, is somewhat metaphysically extravagant.

Well, there ARE billions of stars. Presumably, very few of them have life-supporting planets. Doesn't that seem extravagant ? From the nine planets we know, only one supports life. Doesn't that seem like a waste ? Physics usually don't care about efficiency. Otherwise the human eye wouldn't be so damn flawed.

Interesting Ian said:
I don't think so. It seems my instinctive understanding of it far surpasses those skeptics on here who have actually studied it.

Ah! I forgot that the subjective is superior to the objective. :rolleyes:
 
VonNeumann - You've got a lot of nerve using that user name. You don't appear to have any of the qualities that the actual von Neumann had.
Neurologically, I am a mere worm compared to my great uncle - alas.

So are you really extraordinarily 'Complex', Complexity?
 
Something that you may not know, is that chimps and humans not only share the vast majority of their DNA, but also their USELESS DNA bits, which points even more to common ancestry. Otherwise, why would we share the same vestigial code ?
Nowhere ? I submit ... never mind.
As an aside: don't be so sure that 'junk dna' et al are useless. To the point, I think, as I've already posted in response to someone, that design predicts such things as useless info. If you already have concluded common descent, then you will fit evidence to what you presume. If you ask, what explanation is there for similar designs with differences and snips and patches and redundancy and dead wood, etc., design may fit the evidence better than common ancestry.

I can't remember the name of the book but it was written by a zoologist. Something like "Why Creationism Sucks" - no, that wasn't it. the dude's last name started with a B. Maybe someone knows... Anyway, it was funny that he decided to give an illustration of how evolution works. He gave as an example, albeit metaphoric example if you will, how a '58 corvette looks like a '57 corvette except for some changes in the body style etc. When I read this I couldn't believe it - the idiot gave an example from DESIGN to illustrate non-teleological 'descent with modification'.

A few years later I was reading one of the Philip Johnson books and saw that he had spotted it, too. Johnson had a name for it - something like "B---'s Folly".

How did such folly get past Dr. B---'s peers, reviewers, etc??? I think it reveals the hole in the thinking that runs through like minds who find evolution most plausible.
 
Neurologically, I am a mere worm compared to my great uncle - alas.

So are you really extraordinarily 'Complex', Complexity?

My field of research involves the design of algorithms for intractable problems and some other areas of complexity theory.

If you truly are related to J. von Neumann, you should grow and mature before you start using his name.

Reading your posts with that honored name as the author results in severe cognitive dissonance.
 
(emphasis mine)

I love the use of the word "therefore" here.

Remember that your logical conclusion is sound only if your premises are. But, to borrow a line I thought I only had to use for Iacchus, you are quite simply wrong. Your understanding of RM/NS is fundamentally flawed if you meaningfully ascribe "intelligence" to it. To call it a "creative power" is even a stretch, although I can accept it as a metaphor. You also conflate two uses of the word "design"--even while properly saying that scientists use it descriptively, you then stretch that into a causal version of design. The two uses are worlds apart.

I submit that your two premises--that RM/NS is "intelligent", and that descriptive and causal "design" can be interchanged, are baseless. Therefore, your conclusion is incorrect.
Ok. I understand your objection. I'd really like to tease this apart a little if you please. I had not really thought about this that much yet. Let me tell you first that I would love to have a theory of how to make a black box that would make new code (write programs) - think Genetic Algorithms for instance. Wouldn't you? Could we 'can' RM/NS so that it would...
Multiple choice Mercutio:
1. Make
2. Write
3. Create
4. Build
5. Design
6. help me! YOU give it a word: ______
... new useful programs.

What does RM/NS do if it does not make something, create something, design something. What does it do?
 
As an aside: don't be so sure that 'junk dna' et al are useless.

Well, I'm no geneticist, but show me a bit of useless computer code and I'll point it out to ya.

To the point, I think, as I've already posted in response to someone, that design predicts such things as useless info.

Bad design, you mean.

If you already have concluded common descent, then you will fit evidence to what you presume. If you ask, what explanation is there for similar designs with differences and snips and patches and redundancy and dead wood, etc., design may fit the evidence better than common ancestry.

We're not talking about redundancy, here. We're talking about genes that simply CANNOT result in the creation of proteins. If they can't produce anything, then they are useless, or don't you know what genes do ?

He gave as an example, albeit metaphoric example if you will, how a '58 corvette looks like a '57 corvette except for some changes in the body style etc. When I read this I couldn't believe it - the idiot gave an example from DESIGN to illustrate non-teleological 'descent with modification'.

His analogy is not without merit, however. Gradual modification, selection. Yes, the chevy IS designed, but it's still a valid comparison. The point is, knowing what we know of the universe, how could evolution NOT occur ?

A few years later I was reading one of the Philip Johnson books and saw that he had spotted it, too. Johnson had a name for it - something like "B---'s Folly".

How did such folly get past Dr. B---'s peers, reviewers, etc??? I think it reveals the hole in the thinking that runs through like minds who find evolution most plausible.

That's because you're stuck on the "designed" part of his analogy. Besides, before ID, creationism was somewhat less based on the idea of design than on the word of the bibble.
 
What does RM/NS do if it does not make something, create something, design something. What does it do?

I'm going to ask this a second time, just to be sure you haven't missed it: given what we know of the universe, how could evolution possibly NOT work ? You can break down your answer by responding to the following:

1- Do you admit that DNA exists ?
2- Does DNA affect both physical attributes and behaviour ?
3- Do you admit that genetic mutations occur ?
4- Do environmental factors change over time ?
5- Could organisms survive in a changing environment to which they are no longer adapted ?

If you've answered: yes, yes, yes, yes, and no, then you believe in evolution. Otherwise, please elaborate on your answers.
 
Life needs to adapt to its surroundings to survive. Its not too surprising that life then is well suited to the physical laws of this particular universe, but if those laws were a little different, it would make such life impossible. There is nothing miraculous or even really lucky about it.
 
My field of research involves the design of algorithms for intractable problems and some other areas of complexity theory.

If you truly are related to J. von Neumann, you should grow and mature before you start using his name.

Reading your posts with that honored name as the author results in severe cognitive dissonance.
I predicted it would bother some people such as you.

Is there something you would like to say to me with regard to complexity, being that is your field? I have something for you.

We have seen the astonishing complexity in the M-set, and others. It is remarkable that mere modulo arithmetic can produce recognizable (i mean recognizable signature thereof) complexity. Something I wish I knew more about, that maybe you do know a lot about, is about random and pseudorandom sequences, and sets that are products of other recursive arithmetic, such as the fractal sets (misnomer?).

For instance, I think someone proved that pi is a normal distribution. What if you went through pi and removed every occurence of, say, coded in ASCII, "This is the piece of pi I am removing". It should be in there an infinite number of times, right? But if I take it out, is the distribution or the remainder still theoretically normal, or is it now not considered to be normal?

Is the M-set considered to be infinitely complex? Is there more than one measure for how 'complex' something is - as there are different 'infinities'?
 
For instance, I think someone proved that pi is a normal distribution. What if you went through pi and removed every occurence of, say, coded in ASCII, "This is the piece of pi I am removing". It should be in there an infinite number of times, right? But if I take it out, is the distribution or the remainder still theoretically normal, or is it now not considered to be normal?

Is the M-set considered to be infinitely complex? Is there more than one measure for how 'complex' something is - as there are different 'infinities'?

Damn, Von. 18 posts and you're already right up there with the woo-kings.
 
Well, I'm no geneticist, but show me a bit of useless computer code and I'll point it out to ya.
Bad design, you mean.

We're not talking about redundancy, here. We're talking about genes that simply CANNOT result in the creation of proteins. If they can't produce anything, then they are useless, or don't you know what genes do ?

His analogy is not without merit, however. Gradual modification, selection. Yes, the chevy IS designed, but it's still a valid comparison. The point is, knowing what we know of the universe, how could evolution NOT occur ?

That's because you're stuck on the "designed" part of his analogy. Besides, before ID, creationism was somewhat less based on the idea of design than on the word of the bibble.
Did you ever debug something Belz? Ever puzzled for a few hours, days, over a bug? You think it has to do with the framis is discombobulated with the poinsot elipsoid and you can't find one thing wrong with the framis? ..you been there? Finally, you prove to yourself there is indeed NOTHING to the idea of the cause originating in the framis.

What happens next? You look at other alternatives that previously you would not allow yourself to consider. You can finally fix the thing because you had a shift in your consciousness - in your attention - in your acceptance of what is real. As long as your debugger is stuck on the framis, Belz, you won't look outside of that domain.

You said "...then they are useless, or don't you know what genes do ?" Perhaps YOU don't know what genes do. Neither of us know much even if we are the world's "experts" on genes. Big daddy Francis Crick? You know him? He was WRONG. Google "Central Dogma of DNA".

Good design / bad design: its still very distinguishable from a chimp's attempt at programming.

What do you think, Belz... if RM/NS can make new DNA that code for complex proteins that function as intercellular machines that have needed function, the question is: does RM/NS "create"? "design"? What terms are allowed/disallowed here, according to you? Further: is RM/NS 'intelligent'?
 
I'm going to ask this a second time, just to be sure you haven't missed it: given what we know of the universe, how could evolution possibly NOT work ? You can break down your answer by responding to the following:

1- Do you admit that DNA exists ?
2- Does DNA affect both physical attributes and behaviour ?
3- Do you admit that genetic mutations occur ?
4- Do environmental factors change over time ?
5- Could organisms survive in a changing environment to which they are no longer adapted ?

If you've answered: yes, yes, yes, yes, and no, then you believe in evolution. Otherwise, please elaborate on your answers.

Durn! You're right.
I got Y, Y, Y, Y, N just like you said.
....er. Never mind everybody! I'm an evolutionist afterall!
 
Ok. I understand your objection. I'd really like to tease this apart a little if you please. I had not really thought about this that much yet. Let me tell you first that I would love to have a theory of how to make a black box that would make new code (write programs) - think Genetic Algorithms for instance. Wouldn't you? Could we 'can' RM/NS so that it would...
Multiple choice Mercutio:
1. Make
2. Write
3. Create
4. Build
5. Design
6. help me! YOU give it a word: ______
... new useful programs.

What does RM/NS do if it does not make something, create something, design something. What does it do?

How about Evolve new, useful programs?
 
To be fair, there is some suggestive evidence that the "junk DNA" may play a non-coding role (more of a regulatory function, IIRC), and also provides a source for the development of new traits (through..transcriptions, I think? Where parts of the strand rearrange...a segment comes out of the dna at one point and fits in at another).

SciAm had an article on this sometime last year, I'll see if I can get a reference.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom