I'm willing to grant you this one (though I see that others want to dispute how aware of the NYC events the witnesses were). Given the number of people who seem the types to follow the morning news -- press people, military, and government employees, for instance -- on the highways I think it's likely that most were aware; even more so the pedestrians outside the building, who would talk to each other.
It's also true that putting people in the frame of mind to accept an illusion is a part of stage magic. Books on showmanship for magicians (such as Darwin Ortiz Strong Magic, one of my favorites) emphasize this. In older times magicians would create elaborate personas (Chinese mystic, warlock, etc.) that they would maintain even off-stage, and while those styles have changed and become more subtle, the rule that everything a magician does on and offstage should support their illusions remains good advice. Similarly, the best illusionists use stage setting, lighting, music, lobby decor, and other elements to set the right mood even before a show starts. Foreshadowing and suspense, knowing what's coming, is integral to many illusions. Ortiz has a whole chapter on balancing the contrary goals of suspense versus surprise.
Ok so 2 important things that work in favor of the illusion.
That said, even if you have the audience in the perfect frame of mind, the visual illusion still has to happen. You still have to make the girl in the skimpy costume disappear. And a really strong illlusion can impress even an audience in the "wrong" frame of mind (such as a TV audience). So the awareness factor might have contributed but you'd agree, wouldn't you, that that alone isn't sufficient to hide the overflying plane from view?
Of course. That's where the fireball and smoke plume come into play. Not only does it serve to conceal the plane but it also acts as an incredible diversion. Naturally the same tactic is used in stage show illusions. A puff of smoke and the girl disappears.
Here my opinion is that you're pushing the idea a bit too far. What you seem to be implying is that (1) seeing an overflying plane would immediately suggest a hoax, and (2) the idea of a hoax would be so cognitively dissonant that it would actually blind people from seeing or remembering the plane flying over. Psychological studies might be able to shed light on the plausibility of (2), but I have a problem right at (1). Which is that assuming I were aware of being under attack by aircraft as you say (and I'm willing to grant) that the witnesses were, seeing the explosion at the Pentagon wall and an overflying plane would not suggest a hoaxed fake plane crash to me at all. It would suggest, instantly, that the plane had dropped a bomb.
But remember.....their minds would be focused on the massive fireball and wouldn't necessarily see the plane fly on. And again.....I don't doubt that MANY people saw a plane flying over and were confused about it and may have even thought it dropped a bomb.
"What just happened? Did that plane fly over the building? Did it drop a bomb?". But the news reports told them that AA77 hit the building. Even if they were confused about what they saw in relation to this report they might dig deeper and find reports of a "2nd plane" that "shadowed" the AA jet and veered off just after the explosion. This would satisfy them that what they saw was not the plane that allegedly hit the building because......it did not hit the building AND because it looked different. Most of the witnesses we talked to described a white passenger jet. We do not believe it looked like an AA jet.
That would guarantee that I woudn't take my eyes off the plane. What kind of plane was it? A military plane, attacking? Where was it going next? Was it going to drop more bombs? If I were driving on one of those highways, I'd swerve onto the shoulder and jam on the brakes and risk a moderate car crash just so I could keep watching the plane. And I'd certainly tell reporters and investigators that I'd thought I'd seen a plane drop a bomb, and about what I'd observed the plane do afterward, even if told that the plane that caused the explosion had crashed.
Again.....this may have and probably
did happen. They were simply TOLD that a plane hit the building and that what they saw was a different plane. Reports that got published would be in regards to what the official story said happened. There WAS a lot of confusion initially and a lot of people made all kinds of different reports. Regardless of the many confusing and contradictory reports......the media reported mostly what the propaganda machine had set up for them to report and most conflicting accounts would have been discounted as incorrect. Remember: for the sake of discussion you have to hypothetically consider the implications of what it would happen IF this WAS an illusion.
I have never claimed the illusion would have or did work for absolutely everyone. It didn't have to.
Okay, maybe. But you still have to hide the flyover plane from view (and hearing) for sufficient time and distance for it not to be immediately and obviously connected to the explosion that everyone is going to be looking at. Other air traffic in the area could help to confuse accounts later, and could be very effective at causing people to remember a plane that wasn't really there. But I don't see it helping to conceal a plane flying low over the Pentagon, or making a spectacular climb above the Pentagon, in the immediate vicinity of the explosion.
Once again; it did not have to be concealed from everyone. The illusion would work best for people with the best and only view of the alleged impact and that was people at the citgo and for a less than 1/4 mile stretch on route 27 south of the light poles.
The idea that Reagan Airport traffic makes low-flying planes near the building a common, easy to overlook occurrence should be easy to demonstrate. People who worked there at the time would know this. Photographs and videos taken of the building should frequently include low-flying aircraft.
They most certainly do. You can even see planes flying over the Pentagon DURING the interviews in our film.
Several likely witness locations concern me:
1. People on foot near the Mall, River, Concourse, and South Parking entrances on practically all sides of the building. Do you know which entrances are most used? (The River entrance probably doesn't have much traffic.)
2. Drivers on highway 110 going north and south, to the east of the building.
3. Westbound drivers, heading directly toward the Pentagon, on the 395 bridge.
Sure. Realize though that most people, particularly Pentagon workers, were already in their offices at 9:30. I hung out in the parking lots at the Pentagon looking for people to talk to and there is a massive influx of people walking from the parking lots to the building until about 8:00 when it dies down because they are already at work.
Right, the only maneuver absolutely necessary for the illusion as described so far is the pull-up, which seems to be just within the airframe's capabilities (as long as it is not too low or too close to the building -- though this is a problem as witnesses did see it low and close to the building before the explosion, and no one describes it gaining altitude while it was in view, so making the plane appear lower or close than it actually could have been is another effect the illusion would have to include). The high speed at low altitude should give the plane plenty of lift to pull off a sudden climb; the limiting factor appears to be the g forces relative to what the plane could survive.
A plane that large being treetop level appears low no matter how you slice it because it is low. The witnesses did not necessarily see or report the plane as being at or near ground level. In the past Lagasse had claimed the plane made a steady descent and met the building at ground level even this contradicts the security video which has the plane traveling level to the ground.
I'm glad some people with more expertise have weighed in (though I haven't gotten to respond to their posts yet). Like them, I see problems with the angles. I did a rough calculation that the plane, assuming it could survive flying through the fireball -- let's assume that some elegant pyrotechnics could create a soap-bubble fireball with fire only on the outside and just smoke or something else inside -- could only be totally inside the fireball for one quarter second, and could only be partially inside the fireball for three quarters of a second. Of course it could be "behind" the fireball for longer, but that's where the angles become a problem.
I don't think the plane had to really touch the fireball at all. It would have been going fast enough that if the fireball was triggered as the plane nose past the facade of the building....the plane would have been past the facade as the fireball rose. This is why the vortices wouldn't have had much effect on the smoke either (although there may have been some effect). The plane would have already been gone.
The quarter-second figure reminds me of some stage magic tricks, such as Metamorphosis, where a sheet or a flag is rapidly passed between the audience and the performers, and that's enough time for something dramatic to happen, such as a vanish or an appear of a person. (In Metamorphosis, it's both.) The cover isn't the vanish, though. It only conceals how the vanish is done. A vanish invariably involves putting the vanished person or thing inside or behind or beneath something, or disguising it as something else.
Yes well again the illusion did not need to fool everyone.
In the flyover illusion, right now it looks like you have a trick with everything except the actual vanish. You have the mental preparation, you have an extraordinarily dramatic set-up as the plane flies right at the wall, you have the momentary cover of the fireball, but then... the plane is still there. If it were nighttime and the plane could turn off its lights, drop and self-destruct its engines (the only way to silence jet engines instantly), and glide quietly away, I might believe it. If there were a fog bank for it to fly into. If the plane flew into one end of a big colorfully decorated tube and didn't come out the other end. Anything. But what you have is broad daylight, clear sky, and witnesses on all sides. No wonder the professionals are daunted.
Respectfully,
Myriad
But the people who had the best vantage point of the "impact" (i.e. on route 27 or at the citgo) had the worst vantage point of the "fly over" so their vantage point was such that the plane DID vanish behind the Pentagon.
Conversely the people who had the best vantage point of the flyover (i.e. people on 395 or in the crystal city highrises) didn't really have a vantage point at all of the alleged impact therefore they were the ones that had to be fooled by the cover story and other planes in the area.
This is an extremely important point because it is easy to say that 100's saw the plane which is quite true.....and sure 100's REPORTED the impact. But how many could have actually SEEN the "impact"? Not many at all. And there are certainly not 100's that claim that they did literally see it.
This is a myth. I can point many out in the published witness lists that were not in a position to see the Pentagon at all let alone the alleged impact.
Most saw the plane and either heard or saw the explosion and therefore deduced the impact.