Pentagon Flyover Illusion

Are you referring to Russell Pickering? Yes, I read the melt down on the Loose Change Forum and then their own forum. I didn't know he was the originator of NoC, if that's who you mean.

No, it wasn't Russell Pickering. It was someone else who's name I don't recall. Pickering split with them because they were manipulating witnesses and the result was the meltdown you're speaking about.
 
It is. I didn't suggest there was any validity to their claims nor that their claims should be open for further discussion. They enjoyed a very small group of supporters even at their height, AFAICT, and other than a scattering of "flyover" trumpeters with little to know understanding of what their saying, CIT is all but dead and gone.

Yes, I understood your question and your viewpoint. Didn't mean to imply otherwise.

Now this I didn't actually know. Can you elaborate for me?

The photograph I recall most vividly was a couple of still shots from the video taken by the guy in the car as he traveled East around the Pentagon as the smoke was rising (Tribby Video). They arranged two stills from DIFFERENT perspectives, but pretended they were from the same perspective. It gave the distinct impression that the smoke was to the North of the actual impact point. Of course, the smoke column was always South of the impact point. As I recall it was an obvious attempt to show the flyover was well North of the actual impact point because it had been shown mathematically/aerodynamically that it was impossible for the aircraft to have made the turn from the Citgo Station to the actual impact point.

It was posted on their Web Site, at ATS and probably here, but I have no interest in searching for it now. All of this occurred after it was vividly shown that none of their flight paths North of the Citgo Service Station were aerodynamically possible.
 
No, it wasn't Russell Pickering. It was someone else who's name I don't recall. Pickering split with them because they were manipulating witnesses and the result was the meltdown you're speaking about.

Ok.

A very interesting read was that meltdown. Along with the one at PFFFTT between Dominick and Rob Balsamo!

[ducks to avoid a chair thrown by Reheat at the mention of that name!]

:D
 
Yes, I understood your question and your viewpoint. Didn't mean to imply otherwise.



The photograph I recall most vividly was a couple of still shots from the video taken by the guy in the car as he traveled East around the Pentagon as the smoke was rising (Tribby Video). They arranged two stills from DIFFERENT perspectives, but pretended they were from the same perspective. It gave the distinct impression that the smoke was to the North of the actual impact point. Of course, the smoke column was always South of the impact point. As I recall it was an obvious attempt to show the flyover was well North of the actual impact point because it had been shown mathematically/aerodynamically that it was impossible for the aircraft to have made the turn from the Citgo Station to the actual impact point.

It was posted on their Web Site, at ATS and probably here, but I have no interest in searching for it now. All of this occurred after it was vividly shown that none of their flight paths North of the Citgo Service Station were aerodynamically possible.

Ok, thanks for this. Very interesting! I hadn't come across that one before.

I'm beginning to change my viewpoint given the responses. I also forgot that they initially went to DC with Dylan Avery right around the height of Loose Change. I imagine it would be very easy to get up in the 9/11 cottage industry being so close to all that hype and internet adoration.

And no, I don't expect anyone to do any more digging on this than what they can reference from the top of their head. This is simply curiosity on my part, and not a need to rehash old arguments.

Thanks very much for your response Reheat.
 
The thing that still gets me about such clams is this: suppose I was an evil CIA/NSA/Illuminati/NASA/whatever conspirator, and I wanted people to believe an airliner hit the Pentagon... If any of my minions suggested such absurd and clunky plans as put forth by the no-planers, I would press the button that drops him into the piranha tank, stroke the fluffy white cat on my lap, and order another minion to, well, arrange for an airliner to fly into the building.
 
The thing that still gets me about such clams is this: suppose I was an evil CIA/NSA/Illuminati/NASA/whatever conspirator, and I wanted people to believe an airliner hit the Pentagon... If any of my minions suggested such absurd and clunky plans as put forth by the no-planers, I would press the button that drops him into the piranha tank, stroke the fluffy white cat on my lap, and order another minion to, well, arrange for an airliner to fly into the building.

I think RMackey had the definitive response in regards to CIT and their theory. Something along the lines that it was so dumb it wouldn't even be thought up to use in stress tests!

I haven't immersed myself in other conspiracy theories as much as 9/11, but I'm sure the same can be said for most if not all of them: 9/11 is so unbelievably complicated and unnecessary that it would never make it off the white board to be implemented as a plan.
 
No, it wasn't Russell Pickering. It was someone else who's name I don't recall. Pickering split with them because they were manipulating witnesses and the result was the meltdown you're speaking about.
Ahhh... good ole' Russ! One of the most reasonable of that cesspool known as LCF! Those were the days!
 
No, it wasn't Russell Pickering. It was someone else who's name I don't recall. Pickering split with them because they were manipulating witnesses and the result was the meltdown you're speaking about.

Not killtown, was it? The description of total loon fits but I don't recall him being with the CiT.
 
Can you believe my little thread is getting ready to start the third grade this September? They grow up so fast!!
 
Not killtown, was it? The description of total loon fits but I don't recall him being with the CiT.

No. Sorry I don't recall the guys name now. He started advocating no plane crap and then apparently dropped it. CIT picked up on the same later. Someone will come along who remembers the name eventually. He never was a big name in the BM, but he was the originator of the thought...
 
It kind of boggles my mind that I used to seriously debate those mad theories with those people. On the one hand it was such a waste of time, but on the other hand god damn I learned a lot about 9/11. If nothing else, the experience really revealed to me just how insanely well documented that event actually was. It's insane what you can find out about it from your own computer. That in itself completely dispels any CT because with such a mountain of information, if there was anything amiss about the event, it would be readily available.
 
It kind of boggles my mind that I used to seriously debate those mad theories with those people. On the one hand it was such a waste of time, but on the other hand god damn I learned a lot about 9/11. If nothing else, the experience really revealed to me just how insanely well documented that event actually was. It's insane what you can find out about it from your own computer. That in itself completely dispels any CT because with such a mountain of information, if there was anything amiss about the event, it would be readily available.

And on their side, IIRC, they had one witness (Legasse) who legitimately says the plane flew Noc.

One whole witness.

And even he says it hit the Pentagon.

And they actually had some people who bought this!

Boggles the mind for sure.
 
And on their side, IIRC, they had one witness (Legasse) who legitimately says the plane flew Noc.

This is no real mystery. Lagasse had to be reminded where and in what direction he was parked at the gas station! He obviously didn't remember. That would make a great deal of difference when referring to left and right of his position. They capitalized on those relative references and many loons bought it.

They also capitalized on the fact that it is difficult to near impossible for anyone (especially a layman) to determine the distance of an airborne object without comparative references for estimating that distance. This is vividly illustrated in that many folks identified it as a B-737 as opposed to a B-757. Distance make a great deal of difference in the apparent size.
 
This is no real mystery. Lagasse had to be reminded where and in what direction he was parked at the gas station! He obviously didn't remember. That would make a great deal of difference when referring to left and right of his position. They capitalized on those relative references and many loons bought it.

They also capitalized on the fact that it is difficult to near impossible for anyone (especially a layman) to determine the distance of an airborne object without comparative references for estimating that distance. This is vividly illustrated in that many folks identified it as a B-737 as opposed to a B-757. Distance make a great deal of difference in the apparent size.

Absolutely. I was referring to Craig and Aldo's spin on the other witnesses. Legasse, as far as I can tell, was the only witness who states the plane was NoC. Everyone else was CIT's interpretation of what they "meant".

There's an interesting thread on their forum about "another" flyover witness, Dewitt Roseborough, a name I hadn't come across before. It illustrates what I'm talking about perfectly. He was an eyewitness to the crash and had given an interview around the time. They take that interview and interpret fly over. They then call him, he repeatedly states he'd rather not talk about it, and they interpret he understands the implications of a fly over and is afraid to talk about it. Boom! Fly over witness! And then all the faitful jump in to pat Craig and Aldo on the back.

One admittedly confused police officer and that was the basis for their magic show and harrassing an old cab driver. Psychologically, it's amazing to watch.
 
And on their side, IIRC, they had one witness (Legasse) who legitimately says the plane flew Noc.

One whole witness.

And even he says it hit the Pentagon.

And they actually had some people who bought this!

Boggles the mind for sure.
Each supposed NoC witness who was also in a position to view the Pentagon says it hit the building. Exactly none of them say it flew over the building. None even opine that it hit an upper floor!
CiT then come up with fantastical excuses why this single point of agreement between all these witnesses, on the position of the aircraft, should be discarded. Boger didn't see it hit because he dove under the desk and lied about when he did that. The Arlington witnesses also ducked so they couldn't see what they said they saw. Etc., etc.,etc. ( BTW I keep the 'i' in CiT in lower case because while I cannot dispute their citizenship or that they form a team, I can dispute their investigatory prowess)
 
They also capitalized on the fact that it is difficult to near impossible for anyone (especially a layman) to determine the distance of an airborne object without comparative references for estimating that distance. This is vividly illustrated in that many folks identified it as a B-737 as opposed to a B-757. Distance make a great deal of difference in the apparent size.


Speed, also, tricks people. This was well illustrated to me earlier this year when a meteorite came over New Zealand one night. Hundreds of people all over the country reported it, and virtually all of them reported it hitting ground in their vicinity. Some of them were absolutely certain it had landed "just over those trees" or "up in that valley".

In reality the meteorite landed in the ocean, some 300 km east of New Zealand.

The reason for the confusion was that normal people simply aren't familiar with objects travelling at such huge speed, so if they see something go past that fast, they assume it's much, much closer than it actually is.

The same thing, to a lesser extent, happens with an aircraft flying over at very low speed. Most people aren't used to large objects flying over them at 600-800km/h, so they can't accurately judge how close or far away the object is.
 
The speed trickery is illustrated if you can watch a large a/c such as a 747, landing. As it approaches the ground it seems to almost be hanging in the air, barely moving. Then as it touches down one realizes its doing what would be considered fast for a car on a highway.
 
The speed trickery is illustrated if you can watch a large a/c such as a 747, landing. As it approaches the ground it seems to almost be hanging in the air, barely moving. Then as it touches down one realizes its doing what would be considered fast for a car on a highway.
This reminded me of the first few minutes of 'Fata Morgana'.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L1e_mlz8ZdY

The planes look as though they are moving straight down like flying saucers landing.
 
The speed trickery is illustrated if you can watch a large a/c such as a 747, landing. As it approaches the ground it seems to almost be hanging in the air, barely moving. Then as it touches down one realizes its doing what would be considered fast for a car on a highway.

It is doing more or less the same mph as a smaller plane BUT that translates into a lot less "aircraft lengths per second" - which is what perception/judgement tends to follow.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom