Great post and great guidelines!
Hopefully members will abide.
I hope so too. I'm sure you understand that I don't have any powers to enforce that. On some boards, the culture gives the opening poster a kind of unofficial moderating responsibility to keep the thread on topic. This is not one of those boards, so even by writing such guidelines I'm going against the local culture. Given that the moderators don't seem very happy about the current culture of this forum in particular, I think the experiment is worthwhile.
Here are some reasons why I believe the flyover illusion would be so effective:
1. Virtually everyone was aware of the planes that had hit buildings in New York earlier that morning.
People knew we were under deliberate attack. They knew that this attack involved flying planes into buildings. Their minds were already pre-conditioned to believe that this was what would happen. Many of the witnesses we talked to on the street went so far as to say that as soon as they saw the low flying passenger jet at tree-top level headed straight for the Pentagon, they already "knew" what was going to happen before the alleged impact took place.
I'm willing to grant you this one (though I see that others want to dispute how aware of the NYC events the witnesses were). Given the number of people who seem the types to follow the morning news -- press people, military, and government employees, for instance -- on the highways I think it's likely that most were aware; even more so the pedestrians outside the building, who would talk to each other.
It's also true that putting people in the frame of mind to accept an illusion is a part of stage magic. Books on showmanship for magicians (such as Darwin Ortiz
Strong Magic, one of my favorites) emphasize this. In older times magicians would create elaborate personas (Chinese mystic, warlock, etc.) that they would maintain even off-stage, and while those styles have changed and become more subtle, the rule that everything a magician does on and offstage should support their illusions remains good advice. Similarly, the best illusionists use stage setting, lighting, music, lobby decor, and other elements to set the right mood even before a show starts. Foreshadowing and suspense, knowing what's coming, is integral to many illusions. Ortiz has a whole chapter on balancing the contrary goals of suspense versus surprise.
That said, even if you have the audience in the perfect frame of mind, the visual illusion still has to happen. You still have to make the girl in the skimpy costume disappear. And a really strong illlusion can impress even an audience in the "wrong" frame of mind (such as a TV audience). So the awareness factor might have contributed but you'd agree, wouldn't you, that that alone isn't sufficient to hide the overflying plane from view?
2. The "big lie" syndrome. Since people were ready to accept the notion that a plane would fly into the building.....the notion that a perfectly timed explosion combined with a pyrotechnic fireball/smoke plume as the plane flew over the building would seem beyond ludicrous and not something they would initially believe as conceivable in any way shape or form. It was difficult for people to accept the fact that we were under attack at all but for them to instantly entertain the possibility that the attack was really a staged hoax designed from within is too outrageous of a scenario for people to even consider accepting. Even for any "CT'ers" that may have wintessed the event! This actually makes the illusion much easier to pull off then a standard magic show illusion where the "audience" understands they are being fooled and is even looking for clues as to how they are being fooled from the get go.
Here my opinion is that you're pushing the idea a bit too far. What you seem to be implying is that (1) seeing an overflying plane would immediately suggest a hoax, and (2) the idea of a hoax would be so cognitively dissonant that it would actually blind people from seeing or remembering the plane flying over. Psychological studies might be able to shed light on the plausibility of (2), but I have a problem right at (1). Which is that assuming I were aware of being under attack by aircraft as you say (and I'm willing to grant) that the witnesses were, seeing the explosion at the Pentagon wall and an overflying plane would not suggest a hoaxed fake plane crash to me at all. It would suggest, instantly, that the
plane had dropped a bomb.
That would guarantee that I woudn't take my eyes off the plane. What kind of plane was it? A military plane, attacking? Where was it going next?
Was it going to drop more bombs? If I were driving on one of those highways, I'd swerve onto the shoulder and jam on the brakes and risk a moderate car crash just so I could keep watching the plane. And I'd certainly tell reporters and investigators that I'd thought I'd seen a plane drop a bomb, and about what I'd observed the plane do afterward, even if told that the plane that caused the explosion had crashed.
The Pentagon is right next to Reagan National Airport and has air traffic going to and fro all day long every day right above the Pentagon. Any plane that flew over wouldn't stick out or necessarily seem out of place. Furthermore there are cover stories of other planes in the area that were not on the normal take-off/departure flight paths and were even "circling" the area before and after impact. Any of these planes would be diversions and if someone did happen to see and report the fly over plane they were simply told by the authorities that a plane flew into the building and that they must have seen one of these other planes in the area. There was even one that was reported as having "shadowed" the AA jet and that veered away over the Pentagon just after the explosion. These reports would instantly quash any accounts of a plane flying over the Pentagon since the authorities had already reported that AA77 flew into the building.
Okay, maybe. But you still have to hide the flyover plane from view (and hearing) for sufficient time and distance for it not to be immediately and obviously connected to the explosion that everyone is going to be looking at. Other air traffic in the area could help to confuse accounts later, and could be very effective at causing people to remember a plane that wasn't really there. But I don't see it helping to conceal a plane flying low over the Pentagon, or making a spectacular climb above the Pentagon, in the immediate vicinity of the explosion.
The idea that Reagan Airport traffic makes low-flying planes near the building a common, easy to overlook occurrence should be easy to demonstrate. People who worked there at the time would know this. Photographs and videos taken of the building should frequently include low-flying aircraft.
4. There isn't much on the other side of the Pentagon until you cross over the Potomac river into DC.
...
So as you can see people on that side wouldn't have a very detailed view anyway. Again....they may have seen other planes flying and there is no reason they would be alerted to the attack until after the fact. By then any plane that flew over would be long gone or blended in the landscape or blended with the other planes that were in the area at that time.
Several likely witness locations concern me:
1. People on foot near the Mall, River, Concourse, and South Parking entrances on practically all sides of the building. Do you know which entrances are most used? (The River entrance probably doesn't have much traffic.)
2. Drivers on highway 110 going north and south, to the east of the building.
3. Westbound drivers, heading directly toward the Pentagon, on the 395 bridge.
Now as far as me "proving" that the plane had the capability to fly over the building......I don't see how there could possibly be a question in this regard since planes are designed to maneuver. Some of you have doubted whether or not it could perform the necessary bank after crossing over Columbia Pike and the north of the citgo station but Myriad was very clear that this is not what we are discussing in this thread.
Right, the only maneuver absolutely necessary for the illusion as described so far is the pull-up, which seems to be just within the airframe's capabilities (as long as it is not too low or too close to the building -- though this is a problem as witnesses did see it low and close to the building before the explosion, and no one describes it gaining altitude while it was in view, so making the plane appear lower or close than it actually could have been is another effect the illusion would have to include). The high speed at low altitude should give the plane plenty of lift to pull off a sudden climb; the limiting factor appears to be the g forces relative to what the plane could survive.
I'm glad some people with more expertise have weighed in (though I haven't gotten to respond to their posts yet). Like them, I see problems with the angles. I did a rough calculation that the plane, assuming it could survive flying through the fireball -- let's assume that some elegant pyrotechnics could create a soap-bubble fireball with fire only on the outside and just smoke or something else inside -- could only be totally inside the fireball for one quarter second, and could only be partially inside the fireball for three quarters of a second. Of course it could be "behind" the fireball for longer, but that's where the angles become a problem.
The quarter-second figure reminds me of some stage magic tricks, such as Metamorphosis, where a sheet or a flag is rapidly passed between the audience and the performers, and that's enough time for something dramatic to happen, such as a vanish or an appear of a person. (In Metamorphosis, it's both.) The cover isn't the vanish, though. It only conceals how the vanish is done. A vanish invariably involves putting the vanished person or thing inside or behind or beneath something, or disguising it as something else.
My favorite (in terms of being the most impressively clever design) vanish illusion is Maskelyne's "Moth" vanish. On a bare stage, in only moderately dim lighting, a woman dances in a strange moth-like caped costume. Despite the costume, it's obvious that it must be a real person, not a mannequin or puppet or automaton. As she dances near the magician, she slows down and then freezes in place for just a moment -- and then vanishes in a fraction of a second, seemingly drawn into the magician's hand. The magician takes a bow, obviously not concealing a live adult woman anywhere on his person.
Now that's some damn fine magic. No big box, no shimmery back curtain, no lying down and being covered by a sheet and then levitating until the sheet is yanked away, no strobe lights or flash powder. Just a bare stage and -- poof -- gone.
The way it works is that the costume contains an internal framework of thin flexible wire that allows it to stand on stage in a certain shape, without the woman inside. The dance ends in that shape (and the woman's face turned away, hidden by the elaborate collar), and during the brief moment of the "freeze", the woman is dropped out of the costume down a trapdoor lift while the costume is left standing. Hidden by the magician's body, a tube about four feet high has been raised from under the stage; the magician engages a hook in the costume with a hook at the end of a wire running through the tube, and stagehands below the stage pull the costume through the tube, making it appear to vanish into the magician's hand. The tube itself is then rapidly pulled down. All this happens in successive fractions of a second.
If you had showed me this illusion and asked me how it was done, I don't think I would have been able to imagine it. But if you had asked me, "where does the woman go," I'd have had to conclude, correctly, that she ends up under the stage. Because the vanished thing has to go somewhere. Even if the vanished thing isn't as substantial as you think it is, like a large bouquet of flowers made of feathers that can fit inside the thickness of a magic wand, it still has to go inside, behind, underneath something.
In the flyover illusion, right now it looks like you have a trick with everything except the actual vanish. You have the mental preparation, you have an extraordinarily dramatic set-up as the plane flies right at the wall, you have the momentary cover of the fireball, but then... the plane is still there. If it were nighttime and the plane could turn off its lights, drop and self-destruct its engines (the only way to silence jet engines instantly), and glide quietly away, I might believe it. If there were a fog bank for it to fly into. If the plane flew into one end of a big colorfully decorated tube and didn't come out the other end. Anything. But what you have is broad daylight, clear sky, and witnesses on all sides. No wonder the professionals are daunted.
Respectfully,
Myriad