Pentagon Flyover Illusion

Lyte's response will be that they were either:
1. Mistaken
2. Plants, in on the plot

Exactly. God forbid he says "well, these witnesses are contrary to my position. I guess I'll need to investigate more before I come to a definite conclusion", you know, like real investigators would.
 
This witness Mike Walter describes the planes wings folding up as it entered the building. Who was closer to the building? Your witnesses or him? are you calling Mike Walter a lier?

Great find there Smithie. Hopefully more 9/11 witnesses who's originally statements were misconstrued make similar clarifications.
 
Great find there Smithie. Hopefully more 9/11 witnesses who's originally statements were misconstrued make similar clarifications.


Thanks BUT that was Totovaders find on the Mike Walter thread he started. I just cross posted it here as another pentagon hit witness.
 
God forbid he [Lyte] says "well, these witnesses are contrary to my position. I guess I'll need to investigate more before I come to a definite conclusion", you know, like real investigators would.

He has made no effort to interview any of the first responders who saw the bodies and aircraft wreckage at the Pentagon. I told him firefighters are nice folks and you don't even need an appointment...just go up to any firehouse in Fairfax County, Montgomery County or D.C. Metro.

He choose not to.
 
He has made no effort to interview any of the first responders who saw the bodies and aircraft wreckage at the Pentagon. I told him firefighters are nice folks and you don't even need an appointment...just go up to any firehouse in Fairfax County, Montgomery County or D.C. Metro.

It appears that Lyte's game is to claim that because of his interpretation of a couple rogue witness's accounts the official explanation, no matter how supported by evidence, cannot have taken place.

Therefore, all the evidence MUST be bogus; there's no need to explain or prove anything at all. Obviously, all the first responders are lying or in on it and all the evidence planted because by God a couple rogue witnesses were confused. Why the need to talk to them?

This is the mindset we are dealing with. This is the crack Pentagon investigation team. These are the people who accuse innocent people of mass murder on the most TENUOUS of evidence.

weird.
 
Even at night, you do see (they do have lights) and hear aircraft taking off. Only if it were extremely foggy with very low-level fog, might I not see it.

And the aircraft from the nearby airport follow a very regular pattern, coming from the airport. Depending on which runway, they will fly over the 14th Street Bridge and up the Potomac. On the other runway, they will appear to pass over the Pentagon from the airport heading over Arlington National Cemetery and over Rosslyn.

The flight path of AA77 is anything but routine and would stand out like a sore thumb. Aircraft never travel that way to/from the airport. Extremely obvious something is not right and the full speed it was travelling is not right. Anything out of the ordinary grabs one's attention.

That would certainly be true, but the aircraft would not be using its landing lights, just its navigational lights, and would switch them off at or as it crossed the imaginary line that says, "CRASH HERE". At night without other references (i.e. the lights are off), I think that where the aircraft noise is actually coming from, except for someone who is in the near flight path, would be kind of hard to pin down.

I would think that the point, initially, is to draw attention to the Pentagon area where the pyrotechnics would then light it up and divert attention from the possibly camoflage colored aircraft. So being out of the ordinary would draw attention to the intended location but not necessarily assist in sorting out that the aircraft didn't actually crash. You don't even need to use a 757 unless the sound characteristics are so distinctive that it would be recognized by sound alone.

At this point, post psuedo crash, it becomes a gamble, but then you move from the mechanics of how to do it to the issue of the stakes involved. If something was really, really important and vital, and something like this was the only possible way to achieve that something, it may be worth the gamble. But it has to be remembered that it is a pretty big gamble with a real possibility (many would say probability) of not working or being detected.
 
Here is a quick view from the south...

Sorry for the confusion. The view I showed was from the north on Washington Boulevard looking south. (See the compass in the top right corner) I also got the building too tall. I guessed 90 feet but it should be a little over 77 feet.

I've got some time to play with this now so I'll build a better model and try to make a plane to go with it.
 
On the possibility of using arresting cables to land American Airlines flight 77 "inside" the pentagon:

Arresting cables are used to bring an airplane to a quick stop on a very short runway. They are most often used on aircraft carriers although some military airfields have such systems.

The largest aircraft ever to land on an aircraft carrier was a C-130 Hercules on the deck of the USS Forrestal in October 1963. 44 years later, it still holds the record. Fully loaded and with a gross weight of 121,00 lbs., the C-130 came to a stop in 460 feet. The carrier sped away from the landing aircraft against the wind to give the C-130 a relative 40 to 50 knot wind on its nose. I have no idea how fast the Herculese was going when it landed but, as the pilots were trying to land safely, I'd have to assume it was far less than its full speed. Here's my source which includes a video of the thing landing.

In any case, the C-130's maximum speed was 329 kts, or 379 mph. (source)

American Airlines flight 77 was a 757-223. The 757-200 series has an operational empty weight of 127,000 lbs. This is already more than the maximum weight of the C-130 tested. However, that doesn't include the passengers and luggage; it doesn't include fuel; it doesn't even include seats. It generally takes off weighing 220,000 lbs. This is almost 100,00 lbs. more than the C-130. (source).

The 757-200 has a maximum cruising speed of 493 knots but typically cruises at 460 kts. Ibid. AA77 has been determined to have been traveling at 400 mph. (source). This is faster than the C-130's maximum speed of 379 mph and probably far faster than the C-130's relative speed to the carier on landing.

Someone who knows engineering and force and numbers and stuff is going to have to draw the conclusions. It would appear that the forces necessary to stop a 757 going 400 mph with arresting cables would dwarf those required for the largest aircraft ever to land on a carrier.
 
The plane had already pulled up over the highway as Robert Turcios saw:

Once again with a minority account Lyte?

Robert is the sole witness who claims he saw the plane rise. Robert was running up an embankment when he witnessed this. His perception appears to have been affected by his changing perspective as he moved.

How can you take the one and only account that has the plane rising and create a flyover from that?

All of your winesses (including Robert) and every other witness who observed the plane all the way to the Pentagon say it hit the building. Several accounts have it banked slightly to port with the port engine or wing contacting the ground just as it impacts or a fraction of a second before impact. Physical evidence shows that indeed a curb had a chunk taken out of it along the path of the port engine. You make everyone of these witnesses wrong or liars (including Robert) by contending that Robert's sole account of the aircraft rising means that it actually flew not into the ground floor but over the roof. The roof is 77 feet above ground level. How did every single witness, every last one understand that the plane hit the Pentagon, several even describing it as occuring 80 or so feet below where you say it really was?
How did no one, no one at all notice a very large, very fast, very loud aircraft scream by on the other side of the Pentagon especially when there has been a giant fireworks display set off to draw all eyes in that direction?(this would be the polar opposite of 'misdirection').
I have worked at airports Lyte. I have stood next to the runway button when aircraft were landing, and next to the localizer array during take-offs, and there is no way anyone would confuse a plane at 100 feet (as it flies over the Pentagon) for one at 10 feet (or less).

Yes there are other aircraft that are technically low near the Pentagon. However an aircraft at a couple of thousand feet or even several hundred feet, is never going to be characterized as being at several dozen feet by anyone.
 
Can you guys please keep your thread topic irrelevant comments in the other threads that involve me?

Myriad represents a truly logical, respectful, critical thinking mentality better than most here so the least you could do is honor his request of following the guidelines set up in the OP.
 
Can you guys please keep your thread topic irrelevant comments in the other threads that involve me?

Myriad represents a truly logical, respectful, critical thinking mentality better than most here so the least you could do is honor his request of following the guidelines set up in the OP.

After the OP is debunked, exactly what is there to do subsequently?
 
This witness Mike Walter describes the planes wings folding up as it entered the building. Who was closer to the building? Your witnesses or him? are you calling Mike Walter a lier?



the parting shot from him: "keep an open mind, but always try and get the facts"
good advice there mike. have to applaud this guy for fighting his corner so effectively. it's a pity all the others (oft misquoted and cherry picked by people like lye and co) haven't had the opportunity to do the same.

BV
 
Don't say debunked until you've examined every possibility.

I found a picture of the actual plane and now I see how it could seam to have disappeared in the flyover. Notice the metalic "sky blue" color of the top? All that's needed is to execute a half barrel roll while flying over the Pentagon. When it emerges on the other side it will all but disappear in the cloudless sky. If the pilot were to cut power to the engines and let the plane climb using only it's momentum it would not be heard either.

Do we have any pilots willing to try this high speed un-powered maneuver less than 200 feet above witnesses?
 
Also, clear view from outside the Pentagon metro station, and at the large and always busy Pentagon bus station/drop off point. There was major construction going on around the metro station and bus station, with numerous construction workers outside working there. They would definitely have seen the flyover.

[qimg]http://www.debunk911myths.org/topics/images/thumb/a/a1/MEFaerial23MAY01fromsouth_web.jpg/650px-MEFaerial23MAY01fromsouth_web.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.debunk911myths.org/topics/images/thumb/8/87/MEF26APR01SwingingHammer_web.jpg/650px-MEF26APR01SwingingHammer_web.jpg[/qimg]
Those construction workers would have definitely seen a flyover, especially with Lyte's proposed flight path. The plane would be at such a low altitude that it would be an unforgettable event, even with the other horrors of the day. And before Lyte claims that they were just told that it was the plane shadowing the flight, is there a way to get a hold of these guys to see if they even saw a low altitude flyover? If it happened most, if not all, of them would remember it. If none of them remember, or even one or two rogue witnesses out of the whole lot of them, it would be safe to assume that it did not happen.
 
Last edited:
Of course. That's where the fireball and smoke plume come into play. Not only does it serve to conceal the plane but it also acts as an incredible diversion. Naturally the same tactic is used in stage show illusions. A puff of smoke and the girl disappears.

I want to focus on this statement because I think it's the crux of the problem with your illusion hypothesis. Quite simply (and, I hope, obviously), a puff of smoke does not make the girl disappear. The girl has to go somewhere out of sight in order to disappear.

The best the puff of smoke can do is conceal exactly what the girl does in order to get out of sight, such as being lowered down a stage lift, or have her outer costume pulled off to disguise her as one of the circle of audience members who have conveniently been called to the stage to "observe" the effect.

And even then, this will only work if the puff of smoke actually physically conceals the event from the audience. It's not enough to set off the puff of smoke somewhere else on the stage, to "distract" or "misdirect" the audience. It simply wouldn't work. If the smoke weren't between them and the girl, they would see the girl dropping down the lift; they would see her outer costume coming off.

Most people have a very wrong idea of what "misdirection" in stage magic is all about. They think that misdirection means tricking the audience into not seeing something that's happening in plain sight, because they're looking somehwere else. Why do most people have this idea? Because it's what (some) magicians tell them! And why do magicians tell them that? Because it makes the magician's task easier and often makes the effects more impressive, if people have wrong ideas about how they're accomplished.

The real misdirection in stage magic is misdirection about the significance of actions that everyone in the audience sees perfectly well. For instance, reaching into a pocket to take something out is often misdirection for putting something that's in his hand into the pocket, which you don't even know is in his hand because he's holding it in a such a way that it can't be seen, and also because you think it's still over there on the table, under the handkerchief.

A lot of that type of misdirection amounts to creating a mistaken impression of when something happens. Misdirection in time is much more common (and effective) than "hey, look over there!" misdirection in place. Whenever a magician says "watch carefully...", you can bet that whatever you're supposed to be carefully watching happen, has already happened, and that when the magician pretends to be making it happen (perhaps even punctuated by a puff of smoke), he's really only revealing that it's already happened. You think he's about to make the egg disappear from under the handkerchief, he's waving his magic wand at it, and you're thinking that he's just doing that to try to misdirect you from what his other hand is doing, so you watch the other hand thinking you might catch him grabbing the egg... but you will see nothing, because the egg is already in his pocket, and has been for the past two minutes.

So, the puff of smoke when the girl disappears might have nothing to do with making the girl disappear at all! Its only purpose might be to create a false impression that the girl disappeared (from inside a box, perhaps) at the precise moment when the smoke went off and the box fell apart, when actually she was waiting in the back of the auditorium by then.

When something that the audience isn't supposed to be able to see is visible to the audience (such as a palmed object), regardless of how briefly it's visible or how distracted elsewhere the audience's attention might be, magicians (when talking to one another) call it a "flash." As in, "Pretty good presentation, but you flashed the egg during the steal." It's not supposed to happen. Magicians practice for years to make it not happen. I'm sure some of them wish that all it took to render a suspicious move invisible to audiences were to set off some flash powder on the other side of the stage. But it doesn't work that way. It never works that way. I'm not aware of any trick that truly depends on "making the audience look the other way" or "transfixing the audience's attention" on something else, to completely hide an otherwise visible event. It can help hide the significance of an event -- the audience is less likely to think too much about why the magician might be wiping his brow at just that moment if they have something else to focus on -- but it's not ever going to cover grabbing the egg out from under the handkerchief, or the girl jumping into a trapdoor or getting out of the box and running off the stage.

Which means, you cannot use stage magic as a precedent for the claim that people's minds would have been so "focused" or "transfixed" on the fireball that they wouldn't notice the plane right next to, beyond, or above that same fireball.

I have never claimed the illusion would have or did work for absolutely everyone. It didn't have to.

Once again; it did not have to be concealed from everyone. The illusion would work best for people with the best and only view of the alleged impact and that was people at the citgo and for a less than 1/4 mile stretch on route 27 south of the light poles.

But that 1/4 mile stretch represents a range of view angles to the fireball of at least 40 degrees. Assuming an optimally positioned 100 meter fireball (much larger than in any photo, but the photos might not have captured it at its maximum size), the plane would have had to become fully visible again, for some viewpoints along that span, while the plane was less than half a mile from the highway and less than a second from when it cleared the southwest wall of the building. (Even less, if it followed your northern route.) At half a mile distance, the 124-foot wingspan of the plan spans a view angle of 2.7 degrees, five times the diameter of a full moon. Not exactly a small dot in the distance.

If the plane stayed very low it might have remained hidden from observers on the road by the wall. That's assuming that having successfully pulled up over the wall, it could level off quickly enough to get below the line of sight between the highway and the top of the southwest wall. To stay under that line of sight, it would have had to be below 200 feet as it emerged on the east side of the building, in full view of people on all those bridges, highways, jogging trails, parking lots, and Pentagon entrances. That would have been noticed and remembered even if (or especially if) it was inconsistent with what news reporters were reporting. People at ground level east of the Pentagon would have seen the plane first, before being able to see the smoke plume!

They [planes] most certainly do [fly over/near the Pentagon]. You can even see planes flying over the Pentagon DURING the interviews in our film.

At what altitude? Surely not 200 feet, or anywhere close.

I live a few miles from a naval air base, and all kinds of aircraft come and go all the time. Planes coming in for a landing or practicing low-level passes for air shows are well inside the air base boundaries by the time they descend below 200 feet, and planes taking off clear 200 feet well before leaving those same boundaries. Any kind of plane, passing anywhere in or near my community at 200 feet, would attract attention and be the subject of discussion, as it would most likely indicate an emergency of some kind. A large jet aircraft, even more so. Plus it would make an incredible noise. I have trees on my property over 100 feet tall, so an airplane at 200 feet would, from beneath, look like it was close to treetop height.

Some consipracy theorists like to cite Sherlock Holmes's adage about eliminating the impossible. But there's another one that applies here: the dogs that didn't bark in the nighttime. Meaning, in this case, the people east of the Pentagon who, to a man, did not report a low-flying plane.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Very well put Myriad. Nice explanation on stage magic as well.

Some people are simply delusional. Others are simply greedy slimeballs who will stop at nothing to make a buck.
 
What ticks me off about your theory Lyte, is that you use a rather ridiculous version of the phrase "We all remember where we were". True, 9/11 is a day we will never forget, and the images are put in our brains forever, but the way you are trying to take it is just, stupid.

Yes, we all remember where we were, but when a 757 flies over your head at 400MPH, smashing into the building, you are not going to be too accurate on the exact flight path, mearly the stuff that is really out of the ordinary. Like a plane impacting a building.

What annoys me too Lyte, is that you seem to go for some emotional appeal as well. The part on the film in which whoever that is says "Lets hear what these two fine officers saw" was frankly embarassing. I know you also interviewed that woman who saw no plane parts in the pentagon. However, for old and vulnerable men like Llyod England, you seem to think that because he is simply a working class taxi driver, you can pass off his story (Which confirms the official one by 100%) in one foul swoop.

What enrages me about you lot is that you have all the video evidence you have right there, right on that day, from the people who saw it happen, their minds were the cameras.

More people saw the plane hit it from the official side. People who were closer. Nobody saw it fly over the pentagon. Llyod England has both physical and mental evidence. Your cherry picked witnesses dont.

Get over it, grow up, move on.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom