This thread is for discussion of the "stage magic" aspect of Lyte Trip's Pentagon flyover hypothesis. The question in contention is whether an illusion, that could have actually deceived all the witnesses, of the effect described in the flyover hypothesis, is achieveable. I'd like to debate this by means of discussing and disputing how such an illusion might be done effectively.
The flyover illusion hypothesis, as I understand it, includes the following claims:
- The aircraft that witnesses observed flying toward and then crashing into the Pentagon on 9/11 did not actually crash into the Pentagon, but pulled up and flew over it instead.
- The explosion, fireball, and smoke plume were not caused by an aircraft hitting the Pentagon, but by some other means. These phenomena played a part in concealing the flyover maneuver and creating instead the illusion that a collision occurred.
- The illusion did not just come about by a juxtaposition of events, however improbable. It was deliberately "staged" to fool witnesses.
- Other evidence of a collision, such as the downed light poles and the debris on the lawn, were also deliberately created to maintain the illusion after the explosion/flyover itself.
- Other aircraft in the vicinity may have played a role in creating the illusion and/or maintaining it after the fact.
I invite Lyte Trip (who has expressed an interest in participating in a thread on this topic) to fill in a more complete and precise description of the hypothesized course of events, and to correct any inadvertent errors and significant omissions I may have made in the above description.
The goalpost I want to set for this discussion is for Lyte and other proponents of the flyover hypothesis to make a convincing case that such an illusion could have happened, that is, that it's possible under the actual conditions that existed at the time. I expect that this would involve showing (and answering claims to the contrary) that the actions he hypothesizes (such as the necessary maneuvers of the aircraft) are physically possible and that they would likely be successful in fooling all of the witnesses in all of the locations that witnesses actually were present.
This is a challenging enough task. I do not ask Lyte to prove that the exact means he hypothesizes actually happened. The whole idea of an illusion is that what actually happened is not apparent to witnesses or later investigators. Think of this in the spirit of Randi's demonstrations that he can duplicate the "powers" of psychics by non-psychic means. He does not, in general, claim that the psychics use exactly the same method he does for any given feat. Only that non-psychic means are sufficient to explain the observed phenomena.
In this case, the only burden of proof that I ask Lyte Trip to take on is that a faked crash and flyover could have fooled the witnesses, not that the specific method(s) he proposes were the actual methods used. Similarly, the hypothesized illusion only has to "work" for witnesses in the actual locations witnesses are known or can logically be deduced (based on weekday pedestrian traffic patterns, etc.) to have been present. Arguing that a proposed illusion would not have fooled someone viewing from a certain special vantage point, if no convincing case can be made that there was in fact an objective witness at that vantage point at that moment, I would regard as unfair moving of the goalposts. Again similarly, there are many threads where the question "why would conspirators go to so much trouble, when they could just crash the actual plane?" can be asked. For this one, Occam's Razor is suspended.
On the other side of that coin, I'm not interested in evidence of why Lyte or others believe that the flyover took place or in evidence that a flyover "must have" taken place because evidence of a crash is lacking. There are other threads to discuss those arguments, and in any case, neither how well (or how poorly) a successful flyover illusion would have furthered the aims of some conspiracy, nor how necessary a flyover illusion might seem to be to explain other evidence, is relevant to the question of whether or not a flyover illusion is possible. So, for instance, please don't introduce arguments of whether the plane flew north or south of the Citgo station, unless the direction of the approach is somehow directly relevant to making the hypothesized illusion work.
Second, let's limit the hypothesizing of deliberately lying witnesses to a minimum (such as, only people in special or unusual positions such as those who were piloting aircraft in the area), or omit them altogether. While some stage magic tricks do involve assistants who are "in on it" pretending to be members of the audience (they're called confederates or stooges), it would make for neither a credible theory nor an interesting discussion if we have to make assumptions such as every witness on one entire side of the building being "in on it" or induced to lie.
Third, I hope Lyte will keep in mind that if he does put the ball through the uprights of this goalpost, if he arrives at a convincing scenario for how a flyover illusion could be accomplished, that's 3 points, not the whole game. Occam's razor, the other rules of logical reasoning, and honest analysis of all available evidence must still apply to the larger question of whether a flyover actually occurred. If he convinces some number of JREFers that a flyover illusion was feasible, he can of course add that to his body of evidence, but it would be dishonest of him to inflate that outcome into claims such as "JREF is convinced of a flyover" or "JREF couldn't disprove a flyover" or "JREF supports The PentaCON." On the opposing side, it should not be necessary for me to point out that failure to invent a convincing scenario, while contributing to the evidence against the flyover hypothesis, would not "disprove" it or "put the last nail in the coffin." (This shouldn't matter to those who believe the coffin's already pretty firmly nailed.) I doubt that even professional illusionists can figure out every detail of how every other illusionist's illusions work.
Speaking now to both sides, I'll ask participants not to argue by analogy with stage magic, unless you can cite a specific stage illusion effect and state a hypothesis of how the effect is actually peformed. That you once saw a girl disappear in a puff of smoke from a raised platform in a Vegas show will not be a convincing argument for a flyover illusion unless you can show that the method is applicable to an airplane over the Pentagon on a clear sunny day. If you believe the method is that the girl jumps down from the platform and runs off the stage while the audience is "blinded" or "distracted" by the flash and smoke, then make your case, but people who know that sucn an illusion actually requires trapdoors and mirrors under the platform might ask you to account for those elements' presence at the Pentagon.
This discussion will (or at least, it should) therefore involve "the discussion of secrets" of stage magic. While that's prohibited in the Conjurer's Corner forum here at JREF, I see no such rule for the forums in general. I would advise anyone who does not wish to learn about general principles and possibly specific methods used in stage magic not to read the thread.
Not that I have a great deal of expertise in that area myself. I am not a magician, not even a practicing hobbyist. What knowledge I have comes from books on the subject (which are available by the hundreds to anyone with a credit -- or library -- card), discussions with practicing hobbyist friends, working (not always expert) technical knowledge of many peripherally related fields including mechanics, electronics, fire science, optics, and stage lighting, and critical appreciation of illusions in performance. I hope others with greater expertise will weigh in.
Finally, I acknowledge that I am not a moderator here, and (even if I were) I cannot enforce all the guidelines I just described. If Lyte Trip or his critics want to turn this thread into another clone of the same arguments from half a dozen other threads, I can't stop that. So, in addition to everything else, this thread is an experiment in discourse. I'm hoping for courtesy, civility, open-mindedness, and perhaps some fun. Skeptics might even enjoy the challenge of attempting to conceive a method for such an elaborate and seemingly "impossible" illusion.
I'll follow up shortly with my own initial comments on the actual topic. (Personally, as I've already told Lyte, I'm more than a little skeptical of the feasibility of this illusion.) In the meantime, feel free to jump in.
Respectfully,
Myriad
The flyover illusion hypothesis, as I understand it, includes the following claims:
- The aircraft that witnesses observed flying toward and then crashing into the Pentagon on 9/11 did not actually crash into the Pentagon, but pulled up and flew over it instead.
- The explosion, fireball, and smoke plume were not caused by an aircraft hitting the Pentagon, but by some other means. These phenomena played a part in concealing the flyover maneuver and creating instead the illusion that a collision occurred.
- The illusion did not just come about by a juxtaposition of events, however improbable. It was deliberately "staged" to fool witnesses.
- Other evidence of a collision, such as the downed light poles and the debris on the lawn, were also deliberately created to maintain the illusion after the explosion/flyover itself.
- Other aircraft in the vicinity may have played a role in creating the illusion and/or maintaining it after the fact.
I invite Lyte Trip (who has expressed an interest in participating in a thread on this topic) to fill in a more complete and precise description of the hypothesized course of events, and to correct any inadvertent errors and significant omissions I may have made in the above description.
The goalpost I want to set for this discussion is for Lyte and other proponents of the flyover hypothesis to make a convincing case that such an illusion could have happened, that is, that it's possible under the actual conditions that existed at the time. I expect that this would involve showing (and answering claims to the contrary) that the actions he hypothesizes (such as the necessary maneuvers of the aircraft) are physically possible and that they would likely be successful in fooling all of the witnesses in all of the locations that witnesses actually were present.
This is a challenging enough task. I do not ask Lyte to prove that the exact means he hypothesizes actually happened. The whole idea of an illusion is that what actually happened is not apparent to witnesses or later investigators. Think of this in the spirit of Randi's demonstrations that he can duplicate the "powers" of psychics by non-psychic means. He does not, in general, claim that the psychics use exactly the same method he does for any given feat. Only that non-psychic means are sufficient to explain the observed phenomena.
In this case, the only burden of proof that I ask Lyte Trip to take on is that a faked crash and flyover could have fooled the witnesses, not that the specific method(s) he proposes were the actual methods used. Similarly, the hypothesized illusion only has to "work" for witnesses in the actual locations witnesses are known or can logically be deduced (based on weekday pedestrian traffic patterns, etc.) to have been present. Arguing that a proposed illusion would not have fooled someone viewing from a certain special vantage point, if no convincing case can be made that there was in fact an objective witness at that vantage point at that moment, I would regard as unfair moving of the goalposts. Again similarly, there are many threads where the question "why would conspirators go to so much trouble, when they could just crash the actual plane?" can be asked. For this one, Occam's Razor is suspended.
On the other side of that coin, I'm not interested in evidence of why Lyte or others believe that the flyover took place or in evidence that a flyover "must have" taken place because evidence of a crash is lacking. There are other threads to discuss those arguments, and in any case, neither how well (or how poorly) a successful flyover illusion would have furthered the aims of some conspiracy, nor how necessary a flyover illusion might seem to be to explain other evidence, is relevant to the question of whether or not a flyover illusion is possible. So, for instance, please don't introduce arguments of whether the plane flew north or south of the Citgo station, unless the direction of the approach is somehow directly relevant to making the hypothesized illusion work.
Second, let's limit the hypothesizing of deliberately lying witnesses to a minimum (such as, only people in special or unusual positions such as those who were piloting aircraft in the area), or omit them altogether. While some stage magic tricks do involve assistants who are "in on it" pretending to be members of the audience (they're called confederates or stooges), it would make for neither a credible theory nor an interesting discussion if we have to make assumptions such as every witness on one entire side of the building being "in on it" or induced to lie.
Third, I hope Lyte will keep in mind that if he does put the ball through the uprights of this goalpost, if he arrives at a convincing scenario for how a flyover illusion could be accomplished, that's 3 points, not the whole game. Occam's razor, the other rules of logical reasoning, and honest analysis of all available evidence must still apply to the larger question of whether a flyover actually occurred. If he convinces some number of JREFers that a flyover illusion was feasible, he can of course add that to his body of evidence, but it would be dishonest of him to inflate that outcome into claims such as "JREF is convinced of a flyover" or "JREF couldn't disprove a flyover" or "JREF supports The PentaCON." On the opposing side, it should not be necessary for me to point out that failure to invent a convincing scenario, while contributing to the evidence against the flyover hypothesis, would not "disprove" it or "put the last nail in the coffin." (This shouldn't matter to those who believe the coffin's already pretty firmly nailed.) I doubt that even professional illusionists can figure out every detail of how every other illusionist's illusions work.
Speaking now to both sides, I'll ask participants not to argue by analogy with stage magic, unless you can cite a specific stage illusion effect and state a hypothesis of how the effect is actually peformed. That you once saw a girl disappear in a puff of smoke from a raised platform in a Vegas show will not be a convincing argument for a flyover illusion unless you can show that the method is applicable to an airplane over the Pentagon on a clear sunny day. If you believe the method is that the girl jumps down from the platform and runs off the stage while the audience is "blinded" or "distracted" by the flash and smoke, then make your case, but people who know that sucn an illusion actually requires trapdoors and mirrors under the platform might ask you to account for those elements' presence at the Pentagon.
This discussion will (or at least, it should) therefore involve "the discussion of secrets" of stage magic. While that's prohibited in the Conjurer's Corner forum here at JREF, I see no such rule for the forums in general. I would advise anyone who does not wish to learn about general principles and possibly specific methods used in stage magic not to read the thread.
Not that I have a great deal of expertise in that area myself. I am not a magician, not even a practicing hobbyist. What knowledge I have comes from books on the subject (which are available by the hundreds to anyone with a credit -- or library -- card), discussions with practicing hobbyist friends, working (not always expert) technical knowledge of many peripherally related fields including mechanics, electronics, fire science, optics, and stage lighting, and critical appreciation of illusions in performance. I hope others with greater expertise will weigh in.
Finally, I acknowledge that I am not a moderator here, and (even if I were) I cannot enforce all the guidelines I just described. If Lyte Trip or his critics want to turn this thread into another clone of the same arguments from half a dozen other threads, I can't stop that. So, in addition to everything else, this thread is an experiment in discourse. I'm hoping for courtesy, civility, open-mindedness, and perhaps some fun. Skeptics might even enjoy the challenge of attempting to conceive a method for such an elaborate and seemingly "impossible" illusion.
I'll follow up shortly with my own initial comments on the actual topic. (Personally, as I've already told Lyte, I'm more than a little skeptical of the feasibility of this illusion.) In the meantime, feel free to jump in.
Respectfully,
Myriad