Pentagon Flyover Illusion

Ok, you wanted a professional magician.

Here I am. What do you want to know?

Welcome, Hannibal!

What I want to know is,

1. What have I gotten wrong so far, in talking about stage magic?

2. Given a budget sufficient to buy whatever you needed (aircraft, etc.) but not sufficient to develop whole new technologies (giant holograms, invisibility cloaks), how would you vanish a speeding jetliner in mid-air?

Let's get some imagination going here. How about an Asrah plane? A Pentagon-sized dove pan? (No, those wouldn't work, but something, anything...)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Anyone familiar with the 757 will understand why. "Distinct" doesn't even begin to describe the sound from those things. They're a hugely over-powered airliner.

That is true. I was just in one last month for the first time. I have been in 737's and Airbus' but the 757 was distinctive for the sound of the turbine wind up and the acelleration down the runway even for the full passenger load.
 
Great post and great guidelines!

Hopefully members will abide.

Yes, please all do. Read the OP, OK?

Now:

*snip*
3. The Pentagon is right next to Reagan National Airport and has air traffic going to and fro all day long every day right above the Pentagon. Any plane that flew over wouldn't stick out or necessarily seem out of place. Furthermore there are cover stories of other planes in the area that were not on the normal take-off/departure flight paths and were even "circling" the area before and after impact. Any of these planes would be diversions and if someone did happen to see and report the fly over plane they were simply told by the authorities that a plane flew into the building and that they must have seen one of these other planes in the area. There was even one that was reported as having "shadowed" the AA jet and that veered away over the Pentagon just after the explosion. These reports would instantly quash any accounts of a plane flying over the Pentagon since the authorities had already reported that AA77 flew into the building.

I disagree. For a plane to make a flyover that could be mistaken for a collision would require it to fly over at very low altitude. This is what the withnesses all report: A large plane flew VERY low towards the Pentagon, and an explosion occurred.

For the plane to make a pass-over, it would have to pass within a 100ft of the roof of the building (and I even think I'm being charitable here). such a low passage is NOT a normal sight. Notice that the first plane to hit the WTC was noticed by many people because it was unusually low (and it was much higher than 100ft).

To regain a more normal altitude after the pass-over, the plane would have to climb steeply, like after a take-off. This would be a very spectacular and noisy event, that would hardly be mistaken for the normal plane observations in the area.

Other refutation:

A fly-over would be very noticeable to the air traffic control of the nearby airport. So the ATC people would have to be in on the conspiracy.

Hans
 
I have one suggested change for the OP:

For this exercise, why don't we use a real sample of where the witnesses could have been. For the sample I suggest we use the current image presented by Google Earth. The image of the vicinity immediately surrounding the Pentagon is a very high resolution and even from roughly the right time of day. If someone builds a Sketch-up model of the Building and representative plane and fireball we could see and post the view of each visible witness.

That's a good idea, Dan. And I see you've made a start already. Is the view of the building really that clear from highway 110? What about trees, overpasses, embankments, etc.?

However, it appears (pending further comments from Lyte) that the topic is taking an unexpected turn. I expected to be talking about witness placements, angles, velocities, the position of the sun, and so forth. But now it looks like Lyte is not particularly concerned about whether or not the plane could have been seen. We seem to be going from an explanation based on staged illusion to one based primarily on a sort of, for want of a better term, mass suggestion.

An analgy might be, a stage magician calls for a volunteer from the audience, stabs him to death, then takes advantage of the audience's shock and disbelief to tell them that they've just seen an elephant magically appear on a fully lit bare stage. And the audience believes him, and no one tells the police.

I await further developments with interest.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Welcome, Hannibal!

What I want to know is,

1. What have I gotten wrong so far, in talking about stage magic?

2. Given a budget sufficient to buy whatever you needed (aircraft, etc.) but not sufficient to develop whole new technologies (giant holograms, invisibility cloaks), how would you vanish a speeding jetliner in mid-air?

Let's get some imagination going here. How about an Asrah plane? A Pentagon-sized dove pan? (No, those wouldn't work, but something, anything...)

Respectfully,
Myriad

1. Nothing. There are things you haven't taken into account, but nothing that faults the logic of your proposal, stage magic wise. fwiw, some magi DO work "in the round", but then the angle concern changes ... "in the round", the magician is much closer to the audience than on stage ... and this opens new opportunities and concerns.
The way the Pentagon is situated, large scale, surrounded (not to mention satelite coverage which must have been there that day (?) ... it would be nigh impossible to plan it as an illusion with any hope of success. (You honestly don't have any control over your audience, where they will be standing, what other events might happen at the "wrong" moment, etc.
The magician relies less on "direction of attention" than he does on "audience control".

2. My first thought would be a "fake toss'. Every play fetch with a dog, and fake throwing the ball? Ever had it done to you? You actually "see" the object in motion before it vanishes. Problem is, the object still exists and must be disposed of, somehow. I'll think on this.
 
Hey now! The CTists finally get around to a topic in which I have some experience and you want to come in here and steal my thunder? Fine! I'll just go home and mumble, grumble, never wanted to do this anyway...

I hope you don't. :) I really appreciate you and HannibalGroup taking part in the thread. Like so many experts at this forum, you probably would normally expect to get paid for this kind of consultation.

I'll address to you the same questions and requests as I made to Hannibal above.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Here's a good example of how obvious vortices in smoke would be... and bear in mind they are more profound at higher speeds:



-Gumboot
In particular, notice the duration of the vortice phenomenon. Iti s not just that great vortices would be there just after the pass, where everybody might not be so observant about details, but they would continue to twirl the smoke column for minutes after the fly-over. It would be a very weird and noticeable effect.

Hans
 
Let's get some imagination going here. How about an Asrah plane? A Pentagon-sized dove pan? (No, those wouldn't work, but something, anything...)

Respectfully,
Myriad
mirrors, lots of very large mirrors


or do you really think its a coincidence that all 5 sides of the pentagon look the same?
 
In particular, notice the duration of the vortice phenomenon. Iti s not just that great vortices would be there just after the pass, where everybody might not be so observant about details, but they would continue to twirl the smoke column for minutes after the fly-over. It would be a very weird and noticeable effect.

Hans

Also, the 757 is notorious for the size and duration of its wake vortices. The president of the In-N-Out hamburger chain was killed several years ago when his light jet crashed after flying through a 757's wake.
 
2. My first thought would be a "fake toss'. Every play fetch with a dog, and fake throwing the ball? Ever had it done to you? You actually "see" the object in motion before it vanishes. Problem is, the object still exists and must be disposed of, somehow. I'll think on this.

good analogy, as a youngster i was fascinated by the "wheel of death" dagger throwing type acts. years later i found out the illusion method and even taped and slowmo'ed a video to see the empty hand. however, lytes version of the trick would have us believe that the dagger is actually thrown at the wheel and the terrified blindfolded patsy. but somehow it (the dagger) spins up at an impossible angle over the target, defying all laws of physics, to disappear without anyone in the audience noticing.

the problem here is that, while trying to rationalise lytes convoluted distortions, he will, when disproved, resort to "tower of turtles" tactics. just like christophera this one will run and run and run and run..................

BV
 
Last edited:
That's a good idea, Dan. And I see you've made a start already. Is the view of the building really that clear from highway 110? What about trees, overpasses, embankments, etc.?

Yes, this is about exactly what it will look like. You can see the shadows of the trees and estimate their hight. There is one road sign ahead that might partially block the view of the approaching plane.

I've got to work on my taxes so I can't work on this for a while. But anybody that has a computer and internet can do this themselves. All you need is Google Earth (free software from Earth.Google.Com) and Google SketchUp (more free software from sketchup.google.com).

The two programs work together so you can import an image from google earth into SketchUp, trace an object and pull it into a 3-D shape then export it right back to the surface in Google Earth and fly around to view your creation from all angles. The previous shot took less time to put together than this post. If you want more accuracy, we could model the trees, bridges, signs and everything in a SketchUp model and place a camera at any point (including inside a car).
 
My understanding of large magic effects comes in part from the book Hiding the Elephant as well as those Secrets of Magic Revealed specials on FOX. Both of them talked about the absolute importance of perspective.

The brain receives only so much information from the eye, the rest it just makes up based on past experience. One cannot do magic for a baby primarily because the baby has no expectations as to what is supposed to occur. Using this quirk of cognition, the Statue of Liberty, an aircraft or Diamondhead can be made to disappear. However, and this is the important part, only from one particular angle.

The viewer needs to be in exactly the right spot to receive misleading information from the eye. The coast of New Jersey, the girls on the bagage trucks, the surfers in the ocean all must apear not to move as the audience actually is moved (sometimes rotated and sometimes pushed down a track several feet).

Incidentally, all the live audiences for all three of those tricks were in on the illusion. All three tricks were for the cameras only. The fact that the audience did not seem to move (because the camera was on the moving platform with them) was part of the illusion for the home viewer.

The upshot is simple: No such illusion can be constructed so that it appears equally realistic from all vantage points. An illusion might be possible but only for one particular perspective. Most other perspectives wouldn't even see what the illusion was supposed to be. Many other perspectives would instantly reveal to the audience the exact workings of the trick.

Find me a professional magician who disagrees.

(Missed this post, when catching up before.)

I can't see any way in which the "rotate/shift the audience" type of illusion (used for vanishing large immovable objects) could work.

The last one of those I watched on TV, I think it was Blaine, was a vanish of a parked airplane. It was set up in a large parking lot. I deliberately paid attention to the direction of the lines of the rows of parking spaces. I honestly expected the angle of the lines to stay the same after the vanish, because surely the magician would have anticipated that detail and repainted the lines in the "after" view area to match the "before" view area. But no, the lines were clearly going a different direction after "the airplane disappeared."

Which makes a devil's advocate point for Lyte -- how many people in the viewing audience do you think noticed that the stripes didn't stay in the same alignment? Clearly a trick doesn't have to be perfect in order to deceive a lot of people. (But then again, no one puts David Blaine in prison if they figure out it's just a trick...)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Here are some reasons why I believe the flyover illusion would be so effective:

here are some reasons why i believe the flyover illusion would not be very effective. in fact the flyover illusion must have been about as effective as farting on a bushfire.
count how many of these eye-witnesses saw the plane impact the pentagon. or are these people all "deep-cover" also?

didn't happen, couldn't happen, will never happen.

BV
 
My 0.02...

If, as is conjectured, the plane flew through/over the fireball, would we not see a large object somewhere overhead when viewing the explosion from the side, as has been captured by the security camera?
 
That's a good idea, Dan. And I see you've made a start already. Is the view of the building really that clear from highway 110? What about trees, overpasses, embankments, etc.?

You need to understand just how big the Pentagon is. It's huge and can be seen from pretty much anywhere in the vicinity. Absolutely clear view from Route 110, as well as from the massive Pentagon North parking lot. I have parked in the North lot numerous times, since it's where my running program met regularly in the summer. Also, there's the massive Pentagon South parking lot.

Also, clear view from outside the Pentagon metro station, and at the large and always busy Pentagon bus station/drop off point. There was major construction going on around the metro station and bus station, with numerous construction workers outside working there. They would definitely have seen the flyover.

650px-MEFaerial23MAY01fromsouth_web.jpg


650px-MEF26APR01SwingingHammer_web.jpg


Extremely clear view of the Pentagon can also be had from Interstate 395, coming over the 14th Street Bridge into Virginia.

The Pentagon can also be clearly seen from Pentagon city, from high rise apartment buildings there:
http://www.flickr.com/photo_zoom.gne?id=378027135&size=l

Also, from the numerous buildings in Crystal City, including the restaurant on the top level of the Doubletree
http://www.flickr.com/photo_zoom.gne?id=159029517&size=l

Pentagon can also be seen from the marina and LBJ Memorial Grove, across Boundary Channel Drive, as well as from the George Washington Parkway, the Mount Vernon Trail (popular with joggers, cyclists, rollerbladers, people walking dogs, and simply going for a walk, on a beautiful morning that 9/11 started out as).

As well, the view of the Pentagon from the Air Traffic Control tower at Washington Ronald Reagan National Airport is superb.

There are other locations in the vicinity which good views of the Pentagon in addition to these mentioned.
 
In keeping (trying) with the intent of this thread...

To me the only practical means of pulling off something like this would be to have it happen at night or in the evening or similar very low-light conditions. Limited number of observers and any observers who are present have limited visibility. The no cameras viewing the impact area would also become feasible for the poor images captured by the parking gate cameras would be even poorer under those light conditions.
With the limited capacity for observation, the jet just has to fly very low and does not even have to get low enough to actual hit the Pentagon. Put on the air brakes, cut engine power, and cut any lights to try and reduce the noise of the jet and use the pyrotechnics to interfere with the night vision of any observers and cover the transition from full power and high speed to low(er) power and slower speed.

People will make the proper connections in their mind. Low flying jet, explosion, it hit the Pentagon.

The biggest problem I see that seems unsurmountable is that it occurred in full daylight. That means reasonably good visibility for an awful lot of potential observers from all angles. Those observers will also be able to pick out details in realtime, something they would not necessarily be able to do if the event occurred at night or low-light. You can pull people's attention with the pyrotechnics, and those who are some distance away may not notice the airliner flying away NOE, but anyone who is closer in, especially in the immediate vicinity of the Pentagon, will definitely see, or at least hear, the airliner, whose flight signature might be reduced but not eliminated, and even if they assumed that there were two aircraft and one crashed they would almost certainly speak up and describe what they witnessed (even if they didn't see the actual impact).

Any presumption of only one aircraft would run into these (new) witnesses since they have something to report (presumably in real life, all they would be able to say is they heard AA77 and heard the crash/saw the fireball, which would not add much to the investigation).
 
anyone who is closer in, especially in the immediate vicinity of the Pentagon, will definitely see, or at least hear, the airliner, whose flight signature might be reduced but not eliminated

Even at night, you do see (they do have lights) and hear aircraft taking off. Only if it were extremely foggy with very low-level fog, might I not see it.

And the aircraft from the nearby airport follow a very regular pattern, coming from the airport. Depending on which runway, they will fly over the 14th Street Bridge and up the Potomac. On the other runway, they will appear to pass over the Pentagon from the airport heading over Arlington National Cemetery and over Rosslyn.

The flight path of AA77 is anything but routine and would stand out like a sore thumb. Aircraft never travel that way to/from the airport. Extremely obvious something is not right and the full speed it was travelling is not right. Anything out of the ordinary grabs one's attention.
 
People knew we were under deliberate attack. They knew that this attack involved flying planes into buildings. Their minds were already pre-conditioned to believe that this was what would happen.

I get shivers whenever a truther attempts to fancy himself psychologist.

2. The "big lie" syndrome. Since people were ready to accept the notion that a plane would fly into the building.....the notion that a perfectly timed explosion combined with a pyrotechnic fireball/smoke plume as the plane flew over the building would seem beyond ludicrous and not something they would initially believe as conceivable in any way shape or form. It was difficult for people to accept the fact that we were under attack at all but for them to instantly entertain the possibility that the attack was really a staged hoax designed from within is too outrageous of a scenario for people to even consider accepting. Even for any "CT'ers" that may have wintessed the event! This actually makes the illusion much easier to pull off then a standard magic show illusion where the "audience" understands they are being fooled and is even looking for clues as to how they are being fooled from the get go.

See what I mean ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom