Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

(BenBurch): "Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "C'mon. Cite =___?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "Cite=___?"
(BenBurch): "If you need a cite (BTW, Heartland not Heritage - all you GOPers look alike to me) then you really haven't been paying attention, or you forgot how to Google. Plus it makes me happy to not answer your questions."
Pride in ignorance and paranoia, huh? It's Heartland Institute and Heritage Foundation. C'mon. You made the assertion. Defend it, if it's so easy to do. Cite=___?
 
Last edited:
So, that's three posters in this thread who are confident in their ability to assess the evidence cited in a paper without actually having to read said paper.

So what does your reading of said paper indicate?
 
(BenBurch): "Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "C'mon. Cite =___?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "Cite=___?"
(BenBurch): "If you need a cite (BTW, Heartland not Heritage - all you GOPers look alike to me) then you really haven't been paying attention, or you forgot how to Google. Plus it makes me happy to not answer your questions."
Pride in ignorance and paranoia, huh? It's Heartland Institute and Heritage Foundation. C'mon. You made the assertion. Defend it, if it's so easy to do. Cite=___?

You bring joy to my day!
 
So what does your reading of said paper indicate?

Well, the evidence that the tea party movement wouldn't have even been a movement if it weren't for tobacco-industry-funded and -allied top-down political advocacy groups like AFP and especially FreedomWorks is pretty strong. They basically enticed people to start tea parties, funded and trained them, organized and promoted "grass roots protest rallies" for them to attend, and pretty much shepherded them and determined the direction they would take right from the beginning.
 
Last edited:
Again, a credible linking the baggers with undesirables. Already 'it' is linked to haters, racist, crazies, extremists and other, all under the transparent guise of conservatism. Just another marriage of extremists from both the left and thr right and very similar to Canada's shortlived Reform party.
 
"Merchants of Doubt", written by historians, Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway, talks extensively about the tobacco company 'scientists' whose political ideology led them to whore out their credentials with bad science propaganda.
In their new book, Merchants of Doubt, historians Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway explain how a loose–knit group of high-level scientists, with extensive political connections, ran effective campaigns to mislead the public and deny well-established scientific knowledge over four decades. In seven compelling chapters addressing tobacco, acid rain, the ozone hole, global warming, and DDT, Oreskes and Conway roll back the rug on this dark corner of the American scientific community, showing how the ideology of free market fundamentalism, aided by a too-compliant media, has skewed public understanding of some of the most pressing issues of our era. ...
The book sounds a bit like a conspiracy theory. Is it?
No. As far as we know, none of the players in our story did anything illegal, and it was all done quite openly. The men in our story had dedicated their lives to science and technology in the cause of defending the U.S. against the Soviet threat. When the Cold War ended just a few years later, they just couldn't lay down their arms. So they found a new threat in environmentalism, which they worried would lead to excessive government regulation of the marketplace, and put us on the slippery slope to socialism.

In light of having read the book, I find that paper fascinating, ANTPogo.
 
Ok, so the authors are American. Explain to me why I should place any value on an article in a pro tobacco control journal, even one that is peer reviewed (Are history or politics normal areas of expertise for physicians?), about the history of a political movement? An article behind a pay wall that doesn't even say in the abstract what the thread title states no less.



I ask again, shouldn't this be in the CT forum?
Maybe you should look at more than just the title before jumping on the 'dismiss this without looking' band wagon.
 
Well, the evidence that the tea party movement wouldn't have even been a movement if it weren't for tobacco-industry-funded and -allied top-down political advocacy groups like AFP and especially FreedomWorks is pretty strong. They basically enticed people to start tea parties, funded and trained them, organized and promoted "grass roots protest rallies" for them to attend, and pretty much shepherded them and determined the direction they would take right from the beginning.

And boy is it coming back to bite them.
 
Well, the evidence that the tea party movement wouldn't have even been a movement if it weren't for tobacco-industry-funded and -allied top-down political advocacy groups like AFP and especially FreedomWorks is pretty strong. They basically enticed people to start tea parties, funded and trained them, organized and promoted "grass roots protest rallies" for them to attend, and pretty much shepherded them and determined the direction they would take right from the beginning.
The evidence the TEA Party is really an astroturf movement is not new. Of course you can't tell followers that, they see themselves as grass roots.

And there are some grass roots followers in the TEA Party. But they take on an aura of being a larger, more significant political group inflated by the backing of a small number of billionaires.

Crooks and Liars weighs in. (sorry if it's been posted already)
Study: Kochs Tried To Start 'Grassroots' Tea Party In 2002...

A new academic study confirms that front groups with longstanding ties to the tobacco industry and the billionaire Koch brothers planned the formation of the Tea Party movement more than a decade before it exploded onto the U.S. political scene.

Far from a genuine grassroots uprising, this astroturf effort was curated by wealthy industrialists years in advance. Many of the anti-science operatives who defended cigarettes are currently deploying their tobacco-inspired playbook internationally to evade accountability for the fossil fuel industry's role in driving climate disruption.

The study, funded by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institute of Health, traces the roots of the Tea Party's anti-tax movement back to the early 1980s when tobacco companies began to invest in third party groups to fight excise taxes on cigarettes, as well as health studies finding a link between cancer and secondhand cigarette smoke.
 
Last edited:
Right because when one is trying to understand a U.S. political movement the best source of information is clearly a British M.A publication. Shouldn't this be in the CT forum?

We understand the teabaggers all too well. They are fools and tools and ignorant of both to boot.
 
We understand the teabaggers all too well. They are fools and tools and ignorant of both to boot.

Something that's been known since long before this study came out.

In July 2010, David Koch told New York magazine: "I've never been to a Tea Party event. No one representing the Tea Party has ever even approached me." But a fascinating new film – (Astro)Turf Wars, by Taki Oldham – tells a fuller story. Oldham infiltrated some of the movement's key organising events, including the 2009 Defending the American Dream summit, convened by a group called Americans for Prosperity (AFP). The film shows David Koch addressing the summit. "Five years ago," he explains, "my brother Charles and I provided the funds to start Americans for Prosperity. It's beyond my wildest dreams how AFP has grown into this enormous organisation."

A convener tells the crowd how AFP mobilised opposition to Barack Obama's healthcare reforms. "We hit the button and we started doing the Twittering and Facebook and the phonecalls and the emails, and you turned up!" Then a series of AFP organisers tell Mr Koch how they have set up dozens of Tea Party events in their home states. He nods and beams from the podium like a chief executive receiving rosy reports from his regional sales directors. Afterwards, the delegates crowd into AFP workshops, where they are told how to run further Tea Party events.

Americans for Prosperity is one of several groups set up by the Kochs to promote their politics. We know their foundations have given it at least $5m, but few such records are in the public domain and the total could be much higher. It has toured the country organising rallies against healthcare reform and the Democrats' attempts to tackle climate change. It provided the key organising tools that set the Tea Party running.

The movement began when CNBC's Rick Santelli called from the floor of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange for a bankers' revolt against the undeserving poor. (He proposed that the traders should hold a tea party to dump derivative securities in Lake Michigan to prevent Obama's plan to "subsidise the losers": by which he meant people whose mortgages had fallen into arrears.) On the same day, Americans for Prosperity set up a Tea Party Facebook page and started organising Tea Party events.

Oldham's film shows how AFP crafted the movement's messages and drafted its talking points. The New Yorker magazine, in the course of a remarkable exposure of the Koch brothers' funding networks, interviewed some of their former consultants. "The Koch brothers gave the money that founded [the Tea Party]," one of them explained. "It's like they put the seeds in the ground. Then the rainstorm comes, and the frogs come out of the mud – and they're our candidates!"
 
Koch's dad also helped start the lunatic conspiracy-mongering John Birch Society.
It's amazing how few people know about the JBS and the beyond-extreme-right wing views of the Koch family.

The JBS were seriously concerned about Nixon's and Reagan's communist ties. That's how far right wing the CTers we are talking about here are.

And lest you think the JBS has gone away, Sarah Palin reads their magazine.:p

Conservapedia conveniently leaves the Kochs out of their JBS info page.
The organization was founded by Robert Welch in 1958 to fight subversive infiltration of the United States.[4]
And of course we all know that 'infiltration' was a real threat.:rolleyes:

But even Conservapedia cannot deny how wacky the JBS was and still is:
Reagan was suspect because he picked for vice president the choice of the Illuminati, George H.W. Bush. Welch argued that the Illuminati was subversive of good government, destructive of religion, and used professional agitators and massive terror to destroy the good people, while manufacturing smears to destroy the brave souls who tried to expose it.[5]
However, it looks like they slipped that in for a couple reasons, one to give the piece some pseudo-objectiveness and two, so they could dismiss the wacky and actually make the JBS look reasonable and sane.
There are unofficial JBS chapters on many college campuses throughout the United States.
One survey in the early 1970s found the typical John Birch Society member was middle or upper-middle class, Republican and Protestant. He was also fairly young and well educated: the majority of the sample was under 40 at time of recruitment and had completed at least three years of college. A later survey in the mid 1980s found the membership then was disproportionately Southwesterners, young, urban, male, and Catholic. They were consistently conservative on secular issues, antigovernment, and negative toward communism. The evidence does not support liberal notions that irrationality, social strains, or status anxiety explained their beliefs.[13]
 
Rational Wiki writes about the JBS to a different drummer: (Again my apologies if this has been posted.)
Today

Their current whereabouts, alas, are unknown.[5] File them in the "where are they now" pile next to Spinal Tap and The Misadventures of Sheriff Lobo.

The John Birch Society does still exist. Today, they are most worried about threats to US sovereignty, most particularly the (never actually proposed) union between the US, Canada and Mexico. They are also adamantly opposed to free trade, immigration, and the United Nations.

Recently, they have morphed into been aligning themselves with the Tea Party movement, and are even co-sponsoring CPAC,[6] the largest conservative conference in the US.
 
Then why do you lose at every turn, eh?
Lose? Like underline your unsupported claim? If you juudged boxing, the winner would be the guy with the best view of the ceiling. If you judged shotput the winner would be the guy who put the shot closest to his own toes.
Cite=___?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom