Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

There is more evidence that B. Hussein Obama is a Muslim.

So, that's three posters in this thread who are confident in their ability to assess the evidence cited in a paper without actually having to read said paper.

Does Randi know about this remarkable ability that is apparently so widespread among members of the right?
 
So without having read the paper, you magically somehow know there's no evidence in it? Despite including voluminous citations and references to tobacco industry documents in the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, among its many other citations and references?
I'm having a discussion here in this forum, not in the "letters to the anti-smoking journal" pages. If you'd like to present the evidence you think supports your conclusion here, I'm willing to consider it. What you've presented so far has been that some groups which may or may not receive funding from tobacco companies may or may not have supported the Tea Party in some way. The most aggresive argument that might be made with such evidence is that the tobacco companies might be attempting to exert some influence on a grass-roots movement.

Whether or not the paper agrees with your claim, I'm not going to read it. I'm not going to pay to read something that is only marginally interesting to me, and that includes paying in the time and gas it would take to go to a library that might offer free access to it. You have not made the case here, and I dismiss your hollow appeal to authority as empty rhetoric with no facts to back it up. If you have facts, provide them. If you don't, don't.
 
So, that's three posters in this thread who are confident in their ability to assess the evidence cited in a paper without actually having to read said paper.

Does Randi know about this remarkable ability that is apparently so widespread among members of the right?

http://www.amazon.com/Betrayers-truth-William-Broad/dp/0671447696.

Medical research appears to account for 83% of scientific fraud.

Either those researchers are inherently more dishonest, or the peer review process there is less effective.
So I discount anything that has a wished-for conclusion.
 
If you'd like to present the evidence you think supports your conclusion here,

I did. I even gave everyone a link to it.

I'm willing to consider it.

No, you're not.

The most aggresive argument that might be made with such evidence is that the tobacco companies might be attempting to exert some influence on a grass-roots movement.

No, tobacco companies are one of the primary groups (and the group that is the focus of the paper) behind the political organizations that created and are directing the tea party movement, which is absolutely not a grass-roots movement. [EDIT: That's why, as the paper notes, tea party groups have been active in protesting smoking bans and other restrictions, despite the fact that more than 3/4 of tea-party-affiliated people support such anti-smoking measure, almost the same percentage as people who identified themselves as opposing the tea party].

You have not made the case here,

It's not my case. If you don't like what the paper says, you can explain what you think is incomplete or erroneous about it.

and I dismiss your hollow appeal to authority as empty rhetoric with no facts to back it up.

You do know the purpose of citations to academic research, right?

If you have facts, provide them. If you don't, don't.

I referenced a paper. You can read it, or not.
 
Last edited:

The last paragraph was funny:
The anti-smoking movement, fueled with billions of dollars a year in taxpayer dollars and grants from liberal foundations, also has Web sites devoted to attacking smokers. If you visit any anti-smoking sites, make a mental note to see how many of them link to pro-smoking sites. It should tell you something about their commitment to honest debate.

Funny because guess what was missing from their page? You got it -- links to sites with opposing views. Sweet, sweet, hypocrisy.

Honest debate is a rare and precious commodity.
 
I remember when the Tea Party was recruiting in my area, they had little tables set up in the parking lots with pictures of Obama sporting a Hitler mustache.

Now, it's possible that if I'd taken the time to have a conversation instead of simply capturing a "here's some crazies" moment with my cell phone, I'd have heard "He's trying to TAKE OUR SMOKES!!!" Somehow, I doubt it.

A Google search on "tea party smoking ban" returns plenty of results, like "New Indiana tea party group takes aim at smoking bans", "Tea Party Smoking Ban foe to run for Kentucky Sec. of State", ATL Tea Party's letter to the AJC about how "We all detest smokers, but you're missing the point, Atlanta. The movement to ban smoking in parks is another step in the direction of limiting personal freedom", the Spartanburg Tea Party calling a discussed smoking ban there "the nanny state idea that just won’t die", the Mass Tea Party posting "San Francisco Smoking Ban Would Prohibit Smoking In Public Places – But Smoking Weed Is Okay" (in the category "Nanny State"), the Outer Banks Tea Party posting "Nanny-in-Chief proposes full smoking ban in County", and the Parkersburg Tea Party posting "Smoking Ban Extends Outside In Grant County" on the West Virginia Tea Party site.
 
Guys, one of the rules of Rovian Rhetoric is "never engage, always deny".

That's why these guys are making up lies to discount this paper without even knowing what it says.
 
Interesting that the South Carolina Tea Party convention held last month was in a non-smoking venue, even though the state has no restrictions on smoking at the workplace, restaurants or bars.
 
Interesting that the South Carolina Tea Party convention held last month was in a non-smoking venue, even though the state has no restrictions on smoking at the workplace, restaurants or bars.

As I mentioned above, the paper points out that tea partiers generally are in favor of smoking bans on an individual level, but often oppose smoke-free laws on an organizational level.

It's an emblem of how the issues the tea party organizations protest are not really grass-roots issues arising from the concerns of the members, but instead tend to reflect the political advocacy priorities of the groups that fund and direct the overall tea party movement.

EDIT: And look who promoted that convention and was one of the featured speakers: Americans for Prosperity and its president. And last year, there were at least three featured speakers from FreedomWorks, including its president Matt Kibbe (who came up with the "tea party" faux-grassroots concept in 2007).
 
Last edited:
(marplots): "The last paragraph was funny:...
Funny because guess what was missing from their page? You got it -- links to sites with opposing views. Sweet, sweet, hypocrisy.
Honest debate is a rare and precious commodity.
"
(BenBurch): :D
(jj): "Guys, one of the rules of Rovian Rhetoric is 'never engage, always deny'. That's why these guys are making up lies to discount this paper without even knowing what it says."
Which guys? What lies? Please be specific.

(BenBurch: "Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick: "'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "C'mon. Cite =___?"
Cite=___?
 
As I mentioned above, the paper points out that tea partiers generally are in favor of smoking bans on an individual level, but often oppose smoke-free laws on an organizational level.

It's an emblem of how the issues the tea party organizations protest are not really grass-roots issues arising from the concerns of the members, but instead tend to reflect the political advocacy priorities of the groups that fund and direct the overall tea party movement.
What is a "smoking ban on an individual level"?

Seems to me, as with most human behaviors that some people find annoying, the tolerant policy toward drugs (e.g., tobacco) neither requires nor bans, but allows individuals to please themselves so long as they do no harm to others. The definition of "harm" will determine the limits of tolerance.
 
What is a "smoking ban on an individual level"?

I apologize if I wasn't clear.

When polled as individuals, tea partiers are in favor of smoke-free laws in almost the same proportion as those who are opposed to the tea party. It's only tea party organizations that seem to have a problem with those laws.
 
Last edited:
Malcolm Kirkpatrick;8997259"[I said:
'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?[/I]

So, you assert that people never state intentions? You assert that actions do not speak to intentions? Did you read the paper that was cited, rather than demanding another cite?

How about it. Show your homework.
 
(marplots): "The last paragraph was funny:...
Funny because guess what was missing from their page? You got it -- links to sites with opposing views. Sweet, sweet, hypocrisy.
Honest debate is a rare and precious commodity.
"
(BenBurch): :D
(jj): "Guys, one of the rules of Rovian Rhetoric is 'never engage, always deny'. That's why these guys are making up lies to discount this paper without even knowing what it says."
Which guys? What lies? Please be specific.

(BenBurch: "Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick: "'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "C'mon. Cite =___?"
Cite=___?

If you need a cite (BTW, Heartland not Heritage - all you GOPers look alike to me) then you really haven't been paying attention, or you forgot how to Google. Plus it makes me happy to not answer your questions.
 
If you need a cite (BTW, Heartland not Heritage - all you GOPers look alike to me) then you really haven't been paying attention, or you forgot how to Google. Plus it makes me happy to not answer your questions.

Koch's dad also helped start the lunatic conspiracy-mongering John Birch Society.
 
So, you assert that people never state intentions?
No.
You assert that actions do not speak to intentions?
People often assert intentions. Sometimes they even tell the truth. Certainly, observed actions will indicate whether some statement of intention is truthful. I'm asking Ben to show his homework, to support his assertion that the Koch "founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco".
Did you read the paper that was cited, rather than demanding another cite? How about it. Show your homework.
I'm asking Ben to show his homework, to support his assertion that the Koch "founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom